Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
CarrotsAndCheese · 26/09/2023 14:42

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 13:53

Well of course she didn't read them all by herself; I read them to her and she gives me reactions like she understands

😂 Erm, that's not reading!

And calling a 12 month old mature is ridiculous!

FWIW, I was the youngest in my year. I was actually ahead academically throughout school. I found it hard to socialise but I think that was for other reasons than my age. For example, I didn't go to nursery, so missed out on joining the friendship groups that were formed there. So I'm not convinced that deferring would help with socialisation and might make it worse.

I also think that personality is a big factor in how easily children settle in and make friends.

Personally, I would have been annoyed if I'd been held back as I was ready to do more academically challenging work. I would hope that good teachers would be able to set tasks that can be differentiated according to different abilities within the class, thereby stretching the most able while supporting the least able to catch up. That's what happens in secondary schools, at least.

Are you 100% sure that the primary schools near you will allow you to defer and still enter Reception? Our local primary school will allow you to defer but then your child absolutely must enter Year 1.

Fair enough, defer if you think it is best for your child (without comparing to siblings) but do it based on a sound reason such as the ASD you mentioned and be as sure as you can be that the extra year will actually make it easier for them.

Namechangenoidea · 26/09/2023 14:41

I actually think if you held your eldest back you are doing them a disservice in life and taking away a whole year from them. A whole year of making money/building their career.

HowcanIhelp123 · 26/09/2023 14:37

Also consider all aspects. Socially I know in my year kids knowing you were a year older would get you bullied for 'being so dumb' they kept you back a year. Kids can be cruel and we haven't been deferring long enough for kids to get to the age where that becomes a problem yet. School sports teams usually have age cut offs based on birthdays aligning with the usual school year. Will holding them back keep them out of teams with their year?

Potentialscroogeincognito · 26/09/2023 14:35

I can’t believe what I’m reading. I think you need to stop comparing your children and saying “it’s not fair”.
Treat them as individuals and assess their readiness for school as such, rather than it being “fair” in comparison to a sibling. Simply bonkers.

OhYeahOhYeah · 26/09/2023 14:33

Both my girls are summer babies (Mid July and the other end August)

We never considered this as both bright and also had friends who would be starting and they’d have been split up by a whole school year.

They both adapted just fine and there has never been a difference in terms of maturity, achievement etc since day one (they’re now in years 3 and 9.)

humpty74 · 26/09/2023 14:32

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 13:57

Nursery thinks that dd1 is academically able to go straight to yr 1 but is not near ready socially.
We won't lose our 15 or 30 nursey hours during our "extra year". The extra year of schooling is financially viable.
She doesnt have any friends at nursery, as she only plays alone.

If nursery think that another year with them will make the transition and settling at school easier then listen to them. Glad to hear you won't lose the free hours, when we looked at it a few years ago we were told it stopped when they were old enough to go into reception (and we decided not to defer and stopped researching so no idea if that was correct information. It wasn't the deciding factor for us)

All the stories about summer born kids doing well is brilliant but not very helpful. If your daughter is likely to struggle with any aspect of school then deferring is wise.
Check your local council application info, you may need to apply in her "expected" entry year and get agreement from the school to defer. You can speak to the schools you're considering as well and find out how they work with more able students throughout the school to make sure they're equipped to challenge her.

Fundays12 · 26/09/2023 14:29

Personally I would always defer younger kids as they are generally at a disadvantage to older peers. The youngest in dc1 and dc2 years are the ones who are struggling the most in all areas unfortunately.

The child in dc2 year family refused to even consider deferring there dd as she was "so advanced, much smarter and well ahead of all the other kids" her mum and grandparents words when it was suggested to them. She is now really behind academically and struggling socially. An extra year would have made her school experience much better.

BrawnWild · 26/09/2023 14:27

@Hankunamatata I'd be interested in whether the studies say whether poorer achievement was down to ability or being easier led? I know two very bright children, one a summer born, the other put up a year group, both ultimately got poor academic results and both fell in with the "naughty" kids first before grades dropped.

Rinoachicken · 26/09/2023 14:24

An ‘extra year’ isn’t going to give her time to ‘grow out’ of her ASD related social difficulties. How ridiculous.

You’ve said she’s academically able - so put her in the appropriate year for her age so she can have the self esteem
boost of being appropriately challenged and achieving academically and YOU SUPPORT her socially if she struggles there.

Don’t hold her back academically just to try and compensate for social difficulties. That’s just bizarre.

BrawnWild · 26/09/2023 14:22

Does she have friends? I think she will be sad seeing them going to school and perceiving herself as left behind. She will also have to make a load of new friends and see her original friends in Year 1.

She will also be the oldest in a nursery setting and may want more/older/adult engagement, which they cant be expected to do whilst looking after lots of small ones.

When she is older she might have friends asking why she was kept behind or speculating about why shes older than the rest of the class.

I think you are creating a lot of additional transition periods for her and need to really carefully weigh that up.

Gillstuck · 26/09/2023 14:14

A bright summer born can do well being stretched educationally in class. Done well it can increase their determination and resilience. The September/ October borns can be ones who coast and be lazy buggers later in their school life!

ChristopherTalken · 26/09/2023 14:13

Yes, you absolutely can delay your child to CSA start. People will always use their own anecdotal evidence that their 3 minute old baby was ready for school etc, but only you know your child.

We are delaying our July born child. Its not a process for the faint-hearted and not without risk. It can be an administrative nightmare to get approval for them to start reception out of cohort. For us, we know the extra work and stress is worth it, as DD will not be ready - not just for reception age 4 and 6 weeks, but for Year 1 when shes only 5 and two weeks.

TheaBrandt · 26/09/2023 14:09

Yeah you are into a loser trying to smooth the way to make everything “fair” between siblings - life is not fair! Some people are cleverer / prettier / more confident- luck of the draw

sleepyscientist · 26/09/2023 14:09

Someone will always be the youngest also be aware some schools just start them in year 1 so they are actually further behind

TheNumberfaker · 26/09/2023 14:08

There is a lot of wrong information on here. The law changed between my DDs starting school. I would have deferred DD1 if she could have started Reception at just 5, but the law at the time said she could defer but would go straight to Y1 at age 5+ 3 weeks. Now, as the OP states, summer borns can defer properly to start Reception at age 5.
Lots of anecdotal information too about how it never did me/my kids any harm. I’ll add to that, but with 5 years of working in Y6: you could still tell most of the summer borns from the autumn borns. Not always because there will always be outliers. Out of over 300 children, I can only think of 2 summer borns who would have suffered from being deferred as they were top of the class. The vast majority of summer borns would have benefited from starting later, including my own daughter.

The report referred to above shows it still has an effect at GCSE and beyond.
In your situation OP, especially considering the ASD, definitely look into deferred entry.

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 14:07

PinkRoses1245 · 26/09/2023 14:05

I’d consider based on if you think DD is ready. Definitely do not compare to siblings, that js a very slippery slope as they grow up. And July birthday, I wouldn’t delay unless premature or really not seeming ready.

dd1 was born at 36 weeks due in August

OP posts:
useitorlose · 26/09/2023 14:06

You are being ridiculous. For context, DC1 was born 31 August and DC2 3 October two years later, so I get it, but you're still being ridiculous.

PinkRoses1245 · 26/09/2023 14:05

I’d consider based on if you think DD is ready. Definitely do not compare to siblings, that js a very slippery slope as they grow up. And July birthday, I wouldn’t delay unless premature or really not seeming ready.

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 14:04

Tribevibes · 26/09/2023 13:56

As an August baby I was top of the class. I would have been really bored if I was deferred.

Honestly, why do this? It’s fine. I have three kids who are September, February and August born so at all ends of the spectrum. They’ve all been fine.

In the case of my shy ASD child it may reduce her social impediments

OP posts:
Regholdsworthswaterbed · 26/09/2023 14:04

Hankunamatata · 26/09/2023 13:59

Er no. There are loads of studies that have proven statistically the educational achievements of summer born is lower than those born other times of the year. Just Google it and loads come up

Yes statistically I'm sure that is the case but I'm speaking from my own experience and I have an October born and and August born. I think it should be a case by case basis and knowing your own child. My son was totally ready for primary school.

Hankunamatata · 26/09/2023 13:59

Regholdsworthswaterbed · 26/09/2023 13:15

What bollocks. Just because your children weren't ready it doesn't mean others aren't.

Er no. There are loads of studies that have proven statistically the educational achievements of summer born is lower than those born other times of the year. Just Google it and loads come up

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 13:57

humpty74 · 26/09/2023 13:09

What does nursery think?

You lose your 15 or 30 nursery hours once they're old enough to go to school, so you might need to think about whether it's financially viable.

Some summer kids do benefit from deferral and some autumn ones from early entry. That said, if she prefers to play alone a more structured environment might suit her more than the free-flow type play they have in most nursery environments.

Does she have friends at nursery that will be going to school at the same time? Being left behind might be hard for her if she does and you do defer.

Nursery thinks that dd1 is academically able to go straight to yr 1 but is not near ready socially.
We won't lose our 15 or 30 nursey hours during our "extra year". The extra year of schooling is financially viable.
She doesnt have any friends at nursery, as she only plays alone.

OP posts:
Tribevibes · 26/09/2023 13:56

As an August baby I was top of the class. I would have been really bored if I was deferred.

Honestly, why do this? It’s fine. I have three kids who are September, February and August born so at all ends of the spectrum. They’ve all been fine.

Rooroo42 · 26/09/2023 13:53

My first is one of the youngest in her class, would never of occurred to me to defer her. She’s 15 now and has consistently in the upper levels of what would be expected at her level. My other daughter whose birthday falls in spring struggled much more in first few years of school but then caught up, they all handle it differently. I also think you need to consider the effects of deferring for a year on your child as they get older, kids can be very cruel and and at some point someone will notice that they are a year older than other July born kids - prime bullying material I would say.

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 13:53

nokidshere · 26/09/2023 13:36

My 1yo reads and understands nursery books

I've been a childcare professional for over 40yrs. The number of 1yr olds that I've come across as being able to read is, strangely enough, 0

Well of course she didn't read them all by herself; I read them to her and she gives me reactions like she understands

OP posts: