Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that home education should mean one parent has no requirement to work under UC?

210 replies

Homeeducationproblems · 25/09/2023 08:11

I home educate but I’m in receipt of carers allowance so I don’t have to worry but many of the parents in the groups we attend have children with difficulties who couldn’t manage school and because they don’t get dla or are waiting for a dla claim (it takes months) they are under extreme pressure.

I know that some people plan to home educate and yes if its a choice for NT dc from age 4 then I can see why they’d be expected to fund that/work alongside but there’s a huge groups of parents struggling to home educate children with difficulties and it seems as if they aren’t recognised and supported ?

AIBU to think that if you’ve had to de register for a child who can’t manage school and you are engaging with your LA home education department (a lot of home educators refuse to engage so there should be something in place where UC have it verified ?) that you should be able to get UC with no requirement to work?

OP posts:
drspouse · 26/09/2023 07:22

Spikeyball · 25/09/2023 08:42

"The last thing we want to do is to create an incentive whereby allowing children to be so badly behaved to be excluded multiple times means that the parent has 'no option' but to home educate."

If a child is excluded then the LA has a duty to provide education. For most children this would be in an alternative provision.

They have a duty but they don't always bother doing anything about it.

Spendonsend · 26/09/2023 07:17

I think pp might mean the per pupil funding which is around 6kish.

BoobsOnTheMoon · 26/09/2023 06:29

autienotnaughty · 26/09/2023 03:33

If you choose to home educate the 6k funding that goes to the school should be accessed for tutors/resources/exams. Home schooling should be regulated to a degree (although how it would work I don't know)

If you mean the "notional" mythical £6k that schools spend on children on the SEN register - I've got news for you. That £6k doesn't actually exist. It's the made-up sum that schools are expected to spend, from their existing resources, to meet each child's SEN before top-up funding is given. There isn't a £6k funding pot actually provided or made available for children with SEN. It's just a figure pulled from a politicians arse without the actual ring fenced funding attached to it, that schools have been told to find before asking for more.

There is no £6k.

Then imagine that a 3 form entry school has 10 kids in every year group on the SEN register (that's only about 3 per class, maybe even a low guesstimate) - that's £360,000 every year to be spent on those children but without any actual extra funding, just expected to be "found" within the existing inadequate budget!

autienotnaughty · 26/09/2023 03:33

If you choose to home educate the 6k funding that goes to the school should be accessed for tutors/resources/exams. Home schooling should be regulated to a degree (although how it would work I don't know)

PandaExpress · 26/09/2023 01:00

The issue around funding and money is separate to all the previous points you have made.
We don't claim UC or any other benefit (not even child benefit) We are financially secure and our children are afforded every opportunity. This is the case for most HE families I know.
Like in every walk of life, we hear most from those who are struggling. HE families who are forced to HE because of lack of provision for their SEN child or other school related trauma, are less likely to have financially planned for HE. Do they need financial support? Perhaps. But I don't know how that would be best implemented.
It is ignorant to form your whole opinion on home education, based on what you know from families who are forced into HE through lack of choice. Again, I would look at the failings of the school system/government to why those families are in that position.

DietrichandDiMaggio · 26/09/2023 00:48

I don't understand the link between children with SEN being educated at home and claiming DLA? If a child's needs mean they qualify for DLA, where they are educated is irrelevant. If a parent feels the LA cannot meet the child's educational needs in school and therefore the child is taken out of school, their eligibility for benefits is no different.

PandaExpress · 26/09/2023 00:24

Oh I am living in a sort of bubble. Happily. It's a bubble in which my young DD is protected from the horrors of social media bullying, from sexualisation and from hearing or seeing distressing scenes in a school environment, which is happening in schools all too often. Because, that's what home ed gives us. The choice in how much they are subjected too and at appropriate ages. Are there home ed families who don't have this in the forefront of their minds and allow their children to access it? Most certainly. However, a huge portion of us, who I personally know, see this protection as a huge advantage of home ed life.
Our children do get to experience life and all that it brings with it, but the recent vile parts do not need to be experienced at a young age. People concerning themselves about safeguarding for the home ed community, need to concern themselves more with the children in the school environment, because it is an underfunded and overwhelmed shitshow.

Goldenbear · 26/09/2023 00:17

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 22:42

You keep insisting that home ed children are not engaged with any of the 'normal' teenage rights of passage. Such as risk taking. Is your children's only chance for social development during the times they are in school? When they are supposed to be learning from all of these subject experts you speak of? That doesn't give them much time to develop. Or perhaps they develop socially outside of school....Home ed kids spend a lot of time with each other too. They learn together, play together and grow together. Just like school kids. The difference being, if there is a particularly nasty child or a bully, they don't have to be subjected to it. Social media has brought with it horrific trends, such as children telling each other to kill themselves! This is real and it is happening. You're living in a bubble if you think its not!
HE kids don't have to hear or see highly inappropriate behaviour before their teen years or even then. Why would any normal person want them subjected to that, in the name of freedom of choice? Home ed kids are out in the world, living and experiencing. They aren't stuck at home, cut off from friends. They have ample chances to make mistakes and negotiate difficult situations. It's almost amusing to see people who obviously know nothing about home ed, argue against it.

I am not a 'normal person', what for wanting my teens to go to college and school? It is not exactly an irregular aspiration. Do I want to micro manage their every decision in navigating the teen years - no I don't, you know why, because it is stifiling to creativity, something I'm sure certain home education advocates are entirely convinced they are the champions of- unschooling for the benefit of creativity!

The main issue is that both members of the family have to be earning good money to afford their children certain opportunities, one on UC is not going to provide enough money, what are they supposed to do with no options, put up with a second rate education. The money needs to go on reforming and bettering the system for all not just a few that HE.

KeepTheTempo · 25/09/2023 23:48

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 22:42

You keep insisting that home ed children are not engaged with any of the 'normal' teenage rights of passage. Such as risk taking. Is your children's only chance for social development during the times they are in school? When they are supposed to be learning from all of these subject experts you speak of? That doesn't give them much time to develop. Or perhaps they develop socially outside of school....Home ed kids spend a lot of time with each other too. They learn together, play together and grow together. Just like school kids. The difference being, if there is a particularly nasty child or a bully, they don't have to be subjected to it. Social media has brought with it horrific trends, such as children telling each other to kill themselves! This is real and it is happening. You're living in a bubble if you think its not!
HE kids don't have to hear or see highly inappropriate behaviour before their teen years or even then. Why would any normal person want them subjected to that, in the name of freedom of choice? Home ed kids are out in the world, living and experiencing. They aren't stuck at home, cut off from friends. They have ample chances to make mistakes and negotiate difficult situations. It's almost amusing to see people who obviously know nothing about home ed, argue against it.

This is demonstrably untrue though. There are many arguments to support home ed for some children, in some circumstances.

You're the one living in a bubble if you don't think that home ed kids aren't aware of the same social media trends as kids in school. In some cases (though certainly not all), home ed kids actually have a lot more unsupervised internet use, given their need for more self-directed research and the fact that many home ed parents also have to make time for paid work, while many others are not engaged in their children's education very much at all.

That's not the case for the home ed parents I see posting on MN, who are generally doing this with great effort and skill as a family choice, or with reluctance but absolute best endeavours for a child who is not able to access suitable school provision. But unfortunately many of the kids being pulled or pushed out of school are not in either of these situations

And that's the biggest issue with funding parents to stay home. Ther are a decent number of home ed families where unfortunately home ed has been a way to keep unacceptable situations under wraps - things that would be spotted and likely acted on in a school - or to avoid the challenges involved in supporting a reluctant child to go to school or access alternative provisions at home, college or elsewhere.

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 22:42

You keep insisting that home ed children are not engaged with any of the 'normal' teenage rights of passage. Such as risk taking. Is your children's only chance for social development during the times they are in school? When they are supposed to be learning from all of these subject experts you speak of? That doesn't give them much time to develop. Or perhaps they develop socially outside of school....Home ed kids spend a lot of time with each other too. They learn together, play together and grow together. Just like school kids. The difference being, if there is a particularly nasty child or a bully, they don't have to be subjected to it. Social media has brought with it horrific trends, such as children telling each other to kill themselves! This is real and it is happening. You're living in a bubble if you think its not!
HE kids don't have to hear or see highly inappropriate behaviour before their teen years or even then. Why would any normal person want them subjected to that, in the name of freedom of choice? Home ed kids are out in the world, living and experiencing. They aren't stuck at home, cut off from friends. They have ample chances to make mistakes and negotiate difficult situations. It's almost amusing to see people who obviously know nothing about home ed, argue against it.

cansu · 25/09/2023 21:44

LA cannot afford to set up departments ro monitor home education in the way that would be required for such a system. Many parents would refuse to follow any instructions anyway. Many home educators follow an unschooling approach where there are few expectations if children if any. There are also many patents who would mess around and engage minimally.

Goldenbear · 25/09/2023 21:38

dimorphism · 25/09/2023 19:48

I also hate this idea that life is so utterly crap in this country that children need to 'get used to' things like drug taking and sex when they're 12.

Are we really so beaten down THIS is what we want for our children?

I think this is falling for the right wing press headlines and many children at 12 are not doing any of these things. Life as an older teenager/younger person is sometimes impulsive and risk taking it doesn't mean that young person is beyond redemption, or that they are correspondingly not doing well. I don't think it's the parents right to take that freedom of choice away from teenagers as you are denying a creativity of thought, you are prohibiting that development.

dimorphism · 25/09/2023 19:48

I also hate this idea that life is so utterly crap in this country that children need to 'get used to' things like drug taking and sex when they're 12.

Are we really so beaten down THIS is what we want for our children?

dimorphism · 25/09/2023 19:45

The main problem is that school funding has been cut to the bone whilst all sorts of costs have gone up. So it costs more to get an educational psychologist assessment etc but the funding available hasn't gone up. There's also a teacher retention and recruitment crisis. CAMHS waiting lists are a few YEARS in many places, which would be a failure for adults but when you think this will be a significant chunk of a child's childhood it's just totally and utterly broken.

Schools just aren't funded to properly support SEND students. And, partly as a result ,more and more parents are homeschooling not really out of choice but out of desperation and out of fear of what will happen to their child if they don't.

I work in an education related field and I've NEVER seen so many parents homeschooling and the increase is largely not among those who ideologically want to, it's parents on their knees after a year or two with a struggling child, trying to get them into school, trying to get them help, and being blamed and fined for non attendance (I know not all schools / Local Authorities do this, but some do). It's really, really sad.

I also know quite a few families who are DESPERATE for help from the LA and just don't get any. One mother said to me she'd called and called and emailed and no-one had got back to her. She was at the end of her tether.

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 19:44

When teachers are crying out that classrooms are in such a bad state, it's impossible to keep saying that school is best and home ed is a failure. I don't want my DD subjected to the things going on in schools. She is fully integrated into society. Meeting and befriending a variety of people, SEN kids included. But she, at such an impressionable age, does not have to deal with the things that are going on in schools at the moment.
I would read this thread and come back to tell us how home ed kids should be subjected to this if they want to live in society.
www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4903231-inclusion-policies-are-not-working

ketchup07070 · 25/09/2023 19:36

@Goldenbear I see what you are saying about living in a bubble, and I certainly hope other secondaries don't have these problems. To me 11 year olds being taught how to vape, take drugs etc is utterly tragic, and I don't believe they are ready to be exposed to this kind of variety. Learning that not everybody is nice happens quite naturally, from the grumpy neighbours to the child who hits you on every play date, no need to be exposed to drugs to find that out, imo. I may be off topic, but I was just agreeing that schools could considerably improve so that less parents feel forced into home education as their only option.

Goldenbear · 25/09/2023 19:20

ketchup07070 · 25/09/2023 18:27

The state secondary schools near me are a nightmare for SEN children, quite possibly NT children too. As well as being noisy and chaotic, there is a culture of vaping, drugs and underage sex. I don't know if many state secondary schools suffer from these issues, but they certainly are not being addressed. Though strangely, they are very quick to issue detentions for homework and uniform issues.

Edited

I don't think all state schools are like that but to some degree you are going to get some children that aren't very well behaved as the school population is so vast. I think it does teach you how to deal with all sorts of people though before you reach adulthood. Living in a bubble where everyone is nice is not reality.

Goldenbear · 25/09/2023 19:17

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 18:27

Schooled children don't have the monopoly on the things you have listed either. Why would you think that home ed children don't have the opportunities to hang out with friends or belong to a community consisting of their peers? Of course they do!
As for being in a place of learning, everywhere is a place of learning and libraries are free to use. My DD began her Spanish GCSE at that age because she loves it and asked to do it. She has every intention of going to University and these institutions look very favourably on home educated children who have gained qualifications and are self motivated.
I have one child in school, as was their choice and one home ed. I more than understand the pros and cons for each. As somebody with real experience of both, I know which one I think is better.

I've outlined that passion for a subject can be from a conventional setting and is not just the outcome of an alternative education which is what you appeared to be implying.

MiddleOfHere · 25/09/2023 19:07

No. Not if you are electively home educating. And I say that as someone who has home educated for years.

Babyroobs · 25/09/2023 18:40

I'm pretty sure if a child did have genuine needs and reasons why they couldn't attend school and they were waiting for a DLA award then a Uc work coach does have the discretion to reduce or turn off work search commitments.

Pinkglobelamp · 25/09/2023 18:31

Home education has always been protected as a right under benefits rules, so for example a single parent home educator isn't obliged to look for work during home educating times.

However, the laws are increasingly draconian and home education increasingly a luxury for the rich rather than a right.

ketchup07070 · 25/09/2023 18:27

The state secondary schools near me are a nightmare for SEN children, quite possibly NT children too. As well as being noisy and chaotic, there is a culture of vaping, drugs and underage sex. I don't know if many state secondary schools suffer from these issues, but they certainly are not being addressed. Though strangely, they are very quick to issue detentions for homework and uniform issues.

PandaExpress · 25/09/2023 18:27

Schooled children don't have the monopoly on the things you have listed either. Why would you think that home ed children don't have the opportunities to hang out with friends or belong to a community consisting of their peers? Of course they do!
As for being in a place of learning, everywhere is a place of learning and libraries are free to use. My DD began her Spanish GCSE at that age because she loves it and asked to do it. She has every intention of going to University and these institutions look very favourably on home educated children who have gained qualifications and are self motivated.
I have one child in school, as was their choice and one home ed. I more than understand the pros and cons for each. As somebody with real experience of both, I know which one I think is better.

FrancisSeaton · 25/09/2023 18:16

Sorry I'm not funding your desire to stay home with your kids

Goldenbear · 25/09/2023 18:13

cutegorilla · 25/09/2023 18:04

I'd rather all DC were provided with an education that suits their needs so that parents weren't pushed into home educating out of desperation.

Yes, I agree and on the back of this I have a good friend who is trying to get her DD in to a special needs school when she turns 11 and it is a complete nightmare. My friend would like to go back to a career of sorts but doesn't have that option when there is no availability or provisions made, by default she can see she may have to home school.