Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

teacher DH needs to leave his job.

106 replies

greenteaandchai · 21/09/2023 20:08

DH is a Maths teacher (A Level). A very good one. He is head of something and many other things I can't remember, he's also SLT.

DH HATES his job. Every day is the anger, the stress, the cries of how much he 'can't do it anymore'.

DH also privately tutors, in fact, he has built such a reputation that he runs a successful company doing it. He earns more privately tutoring than his teacher salary. It helps that I am an accountant so I can do his finances easily.

I've produced cash flows, projections, financial models. I've proved he can quit. I have proved his business could be a massive success. I also have said, if you quit then you can always apply for another job if this fails, there's enough of them. I also earn more than double DH so we can easily survive on my salary.

Up until recently he'd say 'I want to quit' and I'd say 'are you sure? really?' and i'd console, I was the therapist, the ear, the teacher, but all just got angry responses of 'you don't get it'. So now I am saying QUIT. Stop moaning or quit.

AIBU to say that he can easily survive without this job right now and he needs to sort his mental health out? At the moment he is juggling everything well enough but with a lot of stress and occasional mood swings. However, we are TTC and I am clear that he can't juggle when/if we are successful because he is never home at the moment.

Would like to get opinions.

YABU - teaching is security, do it, keep it up
YANBU - do the other business idea, sort your mental health out.

Would be very interested to hear from teachers who have left the profession too.

OP posts:
ScotchPine · 22/09/2023 14:00

I wonder if what the OP means is that, based on what he makes at the moment, he has the same/higher earning potential if he were to rely solely on his tuition business? Of course, as others have said, that would depend on a regular income stream which is not guaranteed. And it’s likely to include evening and weekend work, which is definitely not ideal with a new baby,

OP, so sorry to hear you’re in this position. It sounds horrible and unsustainable for both of you. I was the teacher in this situation and I fully admit that when I was burning out it became ‘all about me’ and I absolutely wasn’t present for my husband in the way that I should have been.

I hope this doesn’t sound patronising, but has your DH taken time to break down, maybe with a mind map or something, exactly what it is that’s keeping him stuck? Maybe that would help with the way forward. For example, is he struggling with losing his seniority after working so hard to progress? Is it fear of the unknown? Does he feel able to share his feelings with his line manager and could any support be put in place? Like many teachers, are there things he still enjoys about the job that are keeping him invested like actually being with the kids in the classroom. If so, is there something he could do to retain the parts of the role he enjoys whilst removing some of the stressors? Like, part time hours topped up by tuition, stepping back down to a non senior role? Or, if it’s a school culture problem, a different school/type of school. Like the previous poster said, I’ve known people make the transition to private schools and enjoy a better work life balance. It’s not always the case, though. I worked in both state and private and found the private equally stressful in its own way - lots of pressure to maintain their reputation and the obligation to do extras in your lunch hour, after school and weekend/holidays, to ensure you were providing all of the extra bells and whistles the parents were paying for. And a LOT of parental contact. Mind you, I was earlier in my career and still working on mastering the core teaching element of the job. I would imagine that isn’t an issue for your DH!

Would he maybe benefit from a career coaching session or perhaps a short course of counselling to help him explore everything and alleviate some of the emotional burden on you?

Best of luck in what you decide and with TTC.

EnidSpyton · 21/09/2023 23:49

When you say he earns more tutoring than he does being SLT in a school, do you mean per hour? Because I don’t see that he can possibly outearn a full time annual leadership scale salary by doing a bit of extra tutoring in the evenings. Something’s not quite right there.

Teaching is fabulous (I’m a secondary teacher) if you’re in the right school.

I teach in an independent school. I earn 60k as a classroom teacher. We have a five period day - I never teach more than three periods per day and I never take any work home after 4.30pm. It’s not stressful - I have small classes of well behaved children, a supportive SLT and great colleagues. I used to be a head of faculty and stepping back to classroom teaching has been fabulous - so much less stress and I can just focus on my work in the classroom rather than admin, targets and endless meetings and emails about pupil progress.

If your husband enjoys the actual teaching part of the job, I’d recommend he moves to the independent sector for better pay and work life balance.

Tutoring is all very well but it’s not a steady income, the pension is shit and the hours are concentrated after school and into the early evening, or on weekends, and he’ll have hardly any work during school holidays. You mentioned trying for a baby - him being a tutor won’t be conducive to family life if he’s working between 4 and 8pm and you’re trying to get children fed, bathed and put to bed by yourself.

You need to think a bit more flexibly here I think. In the right school your husband could be much happier. Running a tutoring business won’t be a walk in the park either and comes with its own stresses when you factor in an unreliable income, a need to generate your own clients, and unsociable
working hours.

JFDIYOLO · 21/09/2023 23:21

Employee and sole trader/own business owner here.

This is about change, which is scary.

Absolutely go part time or somehow reduce hours, maybe go back to being teacher rather than head of - reduce, reduce.

This gives energy, time, headspace to devote to the business, nurture and grow it.

Lose some of the shittiness around the full time full on role, spending money, time and care on the thing he loves.

Earn more money doing that.

Be your own boss.

Make sure you have a private pension too, tho.

Nanny0gg · 21/09/2023 23:08

cardibach · 21/09/2023 20:27

He earns more privately tutoring than his teacher salary.
Sorry @greenteaandchai this isn’t possible. The lowest SLT pay is £47k. At £30 an hour for A level tutoring that’s 30 students per week, every week, all year. Even if he does the tutoring in groups it’s not possible.

But if he's employing others?

RandomButtons · 21/09/2023 22:47

I voted YABU because I think your options are too polar, there are other options available.

What does he want to do? Does he actually want to quit teaching? Could he change schools?

Anyone would be burnt out doing two full time jobs.

Milkand2sugarsplease · 21/09/2023 22:46

Quitting teaching was the best thing me and my husband have done. He's gone over to the DfE and I've moved into the school office to keep my term time hours. We have so much more time together and as a family. Neither of us is sitting down to work at 9pm after the children have gone to bed. Neither of us switches our laptop on at weekend any more. It's bloody awesome!!

Hankunamatata · 21/09/2023 22:45

Does he actually want to quit or just he just need an offload of emotional build up at the end of the day and a sympathetic ear?

Mischance · 21/09/2023 22:44

My late OH hated being a GP - it was making him ill. I said well just quit - you only have one life and we will all rally round and play our part. He went on to do locums instead which was more manageable. I am glad I did - he became ill when he got to retirement age and died relatively young - so at least he did not spend what life he had being miserable.

PyongyangKipperbang · 21/09/2023 22:41

I agree that the tutoring may become an issue when you have a baby. Maternity leave, not so much but when you go back to work, you will be walking in as he is walking out at the very least.

Is there another business plan that could perhaps include a subscription to online tutoring for specific age groups or exams so his in person tutoring wouldnt eat into what will be your family time so much? Or maybe group tutoring...like "private school lite" so maybe ten students at a time for a couple of hours but focussing on one particular age group.....say Mondays is Primary, Tuesdays is the GCSE group, Wednesday is Senior group, Thursdays is the A Level group for example? The kids get good tutoring but its cheaper than paying for 121 and he is teaching without actually being a teacher in the school sense.

Namechangedtoanswerthisone · 21/09/2023 22:35

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 21/09/2023 20:30

There's something not right here. How on earth would someone with a ft senior teaching job have time to tutor at all (in term time), never mind tutor enough to make more money than his SLT salary?! It's not possible!

Indeed

Maray1967 · 21/09/2023 22:17

cardibach · 21/09/2023 20:27

He earns more privately tutoring than his teacher salary.
Sorry @greenteaandchai this isn’t possible. The lowest SLT pay is £47k. At £30 an hour for A level tutoring that’s 30 students per week, every week, all year. Even if he does the tutoring in groups it’s not possible.

I pay £35 an hour for maths aGCSE tuition in Liverpool. A level is £40. I paid £40 for A level physics in 2017.

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 21/09/2023 21:58

Years ago I had this problem with my DH. I finally said after 3 years that he could do something about it, eg quit, or stop moaning to me about it, that I'd offered enough listening ears and solutions, both. Now it was his issue.

It also occurred to me that we talked a lot about him and never about me, as a result of that job, and I pointed that out too.

Quornflakegirl · 21/09/2023 21:41

I left teaching 13 years ago and never looked back, I hated every part of it.

dc have a 11plus tutor who is making over 100k, she work hard but compared to being the classroom, she says it’s a doddle.

FitAt50 · 21/09/2023 21:39

My husband was an Assistant head on £59k. 15 years of teaching and he couldn't take anymore. We sold our house, moved to Glasgow and bought a lovely flat with tiny little mortgage. He now earns £30k working as a civil servant. He is so so happy now and we love our simple life.

menopausalmare · 21/09/2023 21:39

The pension is good as are the holidays. Suggest he steps down from responsibility and becomes a standard classroom teacher with tutoring on the side.

mikado1 · 21/09/2023 21:39

Leeds2 · 21/09/2023 20:16

I think a half way house suggestion is a good idea. I would worry that there wouldn't be enough tutoring hours during school hours (maybe home schooled children, if he can get into that market), and that any out of school hours tutoring would be done in the evenings and at weekends when I would want him to be home.
But I would be very unimpressed at continual moaning but not actually doing anything about it, when it sounds as though he is in the fortunate position that he could do so if he wanted to.

The last paragraph here is the crux of it!

I'm very grateful that teaching in Ireland is not the same job at all. It sounds awful in the UK tbh, and I teach in a top tier disadvantaged school so I'm well aware of the challenges.

BCBird · 21/09/2023 21:39

I don't know how he is managing to fo two jobs. If u can mamage on ur wage then yes I would say go for it. As for those who say part time, I bin there and u can, as I did, use yiurvday off to work to kerp.ahead. For me it meant keeping weekends free. Teaching can zap you of your energy, particularly when you are constantly on the roulette wheel.of changes

hiredandsqueak · 21/09/2023 21:37

cardibach · 21/09/2023 21:33

In which case he has to pay all the tutors so it needs even more sessions a week.

If he's supplying tutors to meet LA funded EOTAS programmes though in our LA they pay the agency £95ph.

cardibach · 21/09/2023 21:33

Mistressanne · 21/09/2023 21:30

He runs a company, presumably he’s not the only tutor.

In which case he has to pay all the tutors so it needs even more sessions a week.

JaneIntheBox · 21/09/2023 21:31

YANBU!
As you said he can walk back into a job at any time. He can even teach supply if he so desires, there's such a shortage of Maths teachers.
At the same time, there can be a psychological block.. leaving the profession you trained for.. it's not easy to just 'quit'. It's not, how do I put it entirely rational and when he says you 'don't understand' even he may not be able to put into words. Is it fear of being self-employed? Guilt at leaving his students?
With such a high salary surely you could afford some counselling to help him see the light?

Of course this may result in him quitting the tutoring instead but let's be clear he can't really carry on like this. Especially not with kids. That way madness lies

hiredandsqueak · 21/09/2023 21:30

As a parent with an EOTAS programme fully funded by the LA and friends with many others in the same position our experience is that LA's are crying out for tutors and tutor agencies. Our LA prefers agencies because they don't want to add individuals to the pay roll.I would say that as more CYP struggle to attend school and more parents secure EOTAS then there is a real gap in the market. Our LA pay £95ph to secure tutors through an agency to give you an idea of what they pay, materials and exams funded on top.

Mistressanne · 21/09/2023 21:30

cardibach · 21/09/2023 20:27

He earns more privately tutoring than his teacher salary.
Sorry @greenteaandchai this isn’t possible. The lowest SLT pay is £47k. At £30 an hour for A level tutoring that’s 30 students per week, every week, all year. Even if he does the tutoring in groups it’s not possible.

He runs a company, presumably he’s not the only tutor.

Abeli · 21/09/2023 21:29

Could it be that running a successful tutoring company that earns more than teaching is contributing to his stress? He's basically doing two jobs. Teaching is a pretty full on job on it's own.

Either way he could quit and do supply if necessary, he'd never be short of work as a maths teacher.

HappiDaze · 21/09/2023 21:29

If he's tutoring and teaching in a school then no wonder he's worn out