Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Why didn't they go to the police? (TW)

136 replies

CynicalUsee · 17/09/2023 09:37

I am sick of hearing this being trotted out in relation to victims of sexual assault. The only person the victim is responsible for is themselves and their own recovery, that is it. No one else. They aren't responsible for potential future victims, they aren't responsible for the rapist. If they choose not to report the crime that is 100% ok if they choose to go to the police that is 100% ok.

What anyone chooses to do with their recovery is their choice. For a group of people who have suffered due to having choice removed from them why are people so hellbent on creating more trauma by laying on guilt and removing more choice away from them?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
NeunundneunzigHorseBallonz · 17/09/2023 12:53

I meant to add that a journalist knows to say “I believe you.” ALL current justice systems in the Western World involve proving that you weren’t “asking for it.”

PartTimeLove · 17/09/2023 12:45

100% agree OP.

There are so many ways the police and courts let women down.

I'm grateful to any woman who speaks out in whatever way she feels she can.

colourwheelofortune · 17/09/2023 12:40

So many reasons, all good ones, why women don't report to the police. Luckily I have not been in this position, but I would think twice. The only thing I would say is the woman assaulted by the Wests and was ridiculed for reporting them and backing out, later said if she had stuck with it, they may have been stopped from murdering young women. Very very brave of anyone who reports anything other than a stranger attack on a deserted street.

GolgafrinchamB · 17/09/2023 12:40

It's not "trial by media" for god's sake. It's 3-year investigative journalism into a serial abuser of women too powerful to be stopped by any of his victims reporting it.

They didn't "go to the media", investigative journalists came to them, and their stories reinforce one another.

Also, Channel 4 is not a mono-culture. The people hiring Brand in the first decade of the 21st century aren't the same people as the Dispatches investigative team.

There is no "media agenda" beyond exposing his abuses. Just like the investigative team who exposed Harvey Weinstein.

Any survivor of rape or sexual assault who does report her assailant to the police is brave beyond words. I didn't and I wouldn't, for all the reasons PP have given.

OvaHere · 17/09/2023 12:39

LakieLady · 17/09/2023 12:10

Having supported a friend through the committal and trial of her rapist, I can entirely understand why some women don't report.

It was a long time ago (1980s), so hopefully things are different now, but she had to give evidence at both the committal and the trial. By the time the trial took place, the rapist had opted to represent himself, so she was cross-examined by the bastard that had put her through the worst experience of her life.

He got 7 years. She was utterly broken by the whole process, became an alcoholic and died 20 years later. She bitterly regretted reporting it, and found the legal proceedings more traumatic than the crime.

I wonder if the situation now is even worse because women will have the entire contents of their phone and any social media presence poured over by the defence. If you ever flirted or engaged in any sexual correspondence with any man at any time then the man who abused has a better than good chance of being found not guilty.

The system is stacked against us and deliberately so. Let's face it if every man who had ever committed VAWG including rape and abuse served the prison time they deserve then I reckon we would need in the region of 2 prisons per medium sized town.

KitsyWitsy · 17/09/2023 12:33

When me and my friend were raped by two guys when we were 15 we never told anyone. We were shell-shocked and didn’t want our parents knowing about it, or anyone else for that matter. I can totally understand why people take decades sometimes to gather the strength to speak out. We blamed ourselves at the time for putting ourselves in that position.

Tryingmybestadhd · 17/09/2023 12:31

The reason they didn’t go to the police ( the first woman talking did get help ) , is people like you . Most women will never see their rapist convicted , they knew from day one the chances of RB being convicted were nil . People will forever doubt them . But the same people would be the ones attacking them if they went to the police , the same people attacking them now

tinytemper66 · 17/09/2023 12:30

Absolutely

Lifeomars · 17/09/2023 12:29

Thank you for clearly articulating the truth. When I was young I was beaten and sexually assaulted by a man who I met in a night club, he attacked me when he walked me home after dragging me into an alleyway and trying to make me have sex with him. I did not report it because I had been drinking, I had danced with him at the club and had willingly let him walk me home. Imagine what his defence would have made of that if it had ever reached court. Many years later I was seriously sexually assaulted by a stranger who grabbed me in the street when I was walking home from work, so essentially I was the "blameless victim" (for clarity I believe that all victims are blameless). He was caught and it all went to trial and even in those circumstances I went through hell, this was due to multiple errors by the police, the CPS and the Witness Care service. My support worker from the local Rape Crisis said that they had never seen a case with so many mistakes and that was so badly handled. The night before the court case (he pleaded not guilty despite the attack being witnessed and there being DNA evidence and photographic proof of one of my injuries) I honestly felt that I could not go on and the Police had to do a welfare check on me. He did get a long jail term and that helped me to recover, but if I as someone who was attacked by a total stranger went through all this, I can't bear to think how it is for people who know their attacker, who may have been in a relationship with them, who have been out drinking and socialsing with them? I would never report again, the process was almost as bad as the attack. And don't even get me started on the process of claiming compensation from the Criminal Injuries Compensation Authority, that is a whole other level of hell.

henlee · 17/09/2023 12:28

I think the water is muddied when there is consensual sex intermingled with non consensual sex, sexual coercion, pushing of boundaries and emotional abuse.

If your sexual partner asks you to stop, or indicates they want you to stop, and you ignore this and carry on, it is rape.

It doesn't matter if you are married, have been having sex for months, willingly went over to their house, initiated the sex act - there is no context that changes this from rape to something that is ok.

A well adjusted person does not want to continue having sex with someone if it becomes clear they're no longer enjoying themselves.

DoDoDoD · 17/09/2023 12:27

Thewizardbinbag · 17/09/2023 11:21

I went to the police. I was pregnant at the time. Spoken to by 2 officers, one male and one female. The male officer didn’t believe me, as it was a friend who did it. All his questions were framed around did I start if, lead the guy on, why would a friend do this to me etc etc. Female officer stayed silent. After about an hour of defending myself, I said I wanted to leave and didn’t want to take it further. He then said they’d have to have a psychologist speak to me to see if I was fit to parent the child I was pregnant with, as making false reports about that sort of thing was a red flag. That’s when the female office spoke up and said enough and let me leave.

So I went to the police and he threatened to try and have my unborn child removed from my care.

That is absolutely horrific, so sorry this happened you

DoDoDoD · 17/09/2023 12:26

fitch568 · 17/09/2023 10:02

I agree I really do but genuine question, why would you go the media instead? Surely opening yourself up to a whole load of abuse from the perpetrator's 'fanbase' is as/more daunting..? And what's the media's agenda in gathering this case now? Why didn't they gather it all 10/5 years ago? Why him..why not a whole host of comedians (if the rumours are true) & really make it a 'me too' for the comedy sector? The way this programme just dropped - wasn't pre-scheduled before- is unusual. I find the whole 'process' odd & unsettling for some reason I can't put my finger on because there's no doubt the allegations are horrific & in retrospect, even without them, his act should never have been given the platform it was, utterly misogynistic. The broadcasters enabled and celebrated this style of comedy in the 90s in the way they did racist comedy in the decades before.

But the interviewees were anonymous, not being cross-examined in a court in front of other people.

RudsyFarmer · 17/09/2023 12:25

If we are talking about the recent news stories I think the water is muddied when there is consensual sex intermingled with non consensual sex, sexual coercion, pushing of boundaries and emotional abuse.

if you walked into the relationship willingly then the likelihood of a conviction is massively lowered. Also add in a celebrity and incredibly expensive lawyers and you don’t stand a cat in hells chance.

CynicalUsee · 17/09/2023 12:22

Im so sorry to read what everyone on here has gone through. I wish I could say I'm shocked by the number of people it affects, but I'm not.

I am shocked at the number of people who reply solely to a title of a thread and not read an OP though

OP posts:
wednesdayatone · 17/09/2023 12:22

If I see the sentence "trial by media" one more time. Ill combust

Cosmosforbreakfast · 17/09/2023 12:12

Because the victim is put on trial.

The tolerance for violent crimes against women in particularly high in Scotland.

Can't blame women for not wanting to put themselves through a trial where they have to sit in front of their rapist, being interrogated and every aspect of their private life pulled apart and dragged out in front of everyone in the courtroom. In some cases they are forced to refer to their attacker as 'she' because their attacker is now identifying as a woman. Then more than likely they will watch their rapist get a laughable sentence or walk out of court a free man grinning for the press pics. And that is if it even gets to court.

LakieLady · 17/09/2023 12:10

Having supported a friend through the committal and trial of her rapist, I can entirely understand why some women don't report.

It was a long time ago (1980s), so hopefully things are different now, but she had to give evidence at both the committal and the trial. By the time the trial took place, the rapist had opted to represent himself, so she was cross-examined by the bastard that had put her through the worst experience of her life.

He got 7 years. She was utterly broken by the whole process, became an alcoholic and died 20 years later. She bitterly regretted reporting it, and found the legal proceedings more traumatic than the crime.

Amara123 · 17/09/2023 12:05

There is real value in the media exposing this. It gives an opportunity for other victims to come forward and for more evidence (although god knows there's already enough) to be brought to bear. None of these women who have come forward knew each other so the media has enabled them to come together as a group.

The justice system would most likely have ignored them/not progressed the case as individuals. That we know statistically.

pinkred · 17/09/2023 12:02

For those concerned about where this general view on MN supporting perpertators and blaming sexual assault victims is coming from, there's a thread here: https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/sitestuff/4897781-troll-registering-to-post-rape-denial-comments

Maybe this does represent what the majority of MN users now think, who knows. But I do think it's something that needs to be looked in to because there's been a massive influx of what can only be described as Andrew Tate conspiracy theory fans in the last couple of days.

I am sorry those who are sharing their stories and can only imagine how they are feeling Flowers These threads do not represent what the majority of women think.

EDIT: please share link on other threads that crop up, if relevant.

PineNeedler · 17/09/2023 12:01

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

2023forme · 17/09/2023 12:00

@CynicalUsee - YANBU. When I read the title of your thread, I nearly screamed as I thought you were going to agree with the 'why didn't they go to the police' narrative. I have just spent a good part of this morning explaining this to my early 20s DS and thankfully he is now appreciating just why women don't report SA and questioning some of what he originally thought.

I am also absolutely disgusted that his shows are still selling out - what does it take for some people to just not be completely and utterly vile. Shame on them.

changedusernameforthis1 · 17/09/2023 11:58

Unfortunately most people won't understand unless they've been through it themselves. I was sexually abused throughout my childhood by a family member. My Sister is 10 years older than me, and it happened to her too. She never told anyone, and the amount of times I hear "so it's her fault it happened to you then?" When I open up about what happened is awful. I could never blame her.

heistgeist · 17/09/2023 11:58

How do we know victims haven't reported to the police?

How likely would the police be to take any action?

BonnieLisbon · 17/09/2023 11:58

Going to the police and going to court would be extremely traumatic especially as the perpetrator will likely get away with it anyway. They've already been traumatised enough by the assault.
It doesn't mean they don't want to speak out and protect others though, so I can see why they go to the media.

JillyBoel22 · 17/09/2023 11:55

@Soontobe60 here here. a rape crisis charity told me once that you could be lying naked on a bed in a room and still the only person responsible for the rape is the rapist. Really resonated with me. Victims should never have to feel like they are responsible for what happens next, it just adds to the trauma