Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants us to move to Utah!

615 replies

Frenchcroissant · 16/09/2023 21:03

So, my husband has been offered an opportunity to move to Utah and work there 1 to 3 years. He's very excited about it. Me and two DDS ( 7 and 12) to and fro, sometimes excited sometimes nervous/reluctant. I'm freaking out!! We've literally just bought a house in May. I won't be able to work there. Is it an adventure/opportunity or a complete mad move? I haven't told anyone in real life, but I'm quite nervous/anxious about it. AIBU to freak out??

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
ihadamarveloustime · 17/09/2023 11:31

If you don't have citizenship of the country you're leaving 'temporarily', you may not be able to return to it. The UK only allows you to live elsewhere for up to 6 months I believe? You can lose your 'unlimited leave to remain' if you're not actually remaining in the UK...

KVick · 17/09/2023 12:10

The top 5 richest U.S. states by GDP per capita are: New York, Massachusetts, Washington, California, Connecticut. Utah’s at 22 (source: US Bureau of Economic Analysis. https://www.bea.gov/data/gdp/gdp-state).

I’m from Massachusetts – so yes, I’m biased - and have lived in a number of cities in the U.S. and abroad. Utah is undoubtedly a beautiful state to visit, especially for an outdoorsy-sort of person, due to their wealth of national parks. But living there and raising kids in their school system is another matter entirely.

In L.A., New York, Boston, a cosmopolitan European couple would fit right in, with the cities' mix of arts, culture, cuisine, population demographics. But Park City, Utah? That's going to be a [lack of] culture shock. Op is originally from Spain. I guarantee you that if she mentions to Utah locals that she's Spanish, many will not comprehend that she's European, not Mexican.

Italiangreyhound · 17/09/2023 12:28

I agree with Takeabreather23 "So you didn’t sit down as a couple and talk about the “job offer “ it was just wife we are moving the family to Utah! ?

How about you say you want to talk about wether you actually move and uproot everyone’s lives before he makes a decision . How would husband take that ?

Honestly I’d be staying putmyself with the kids before I would be stuck in another country with no financial independence and no way out."

and ihadamarveloustime "If your relationship breaks down while you're there over this, he could stop you from leaving to come back to the UK with the children."

Please read up on this aspect of law. you will have no job and no independent income. He will be even more in charge than he appears to be in the UK. This would be my issue, not Utah or Mormons.

Phineyj · 17/09/2023 12:39

UK religion is very different in my experience because there's not much pressure to recruit (exception being Jehovahs of course). Hence the falling numbers.

I mean, we are a family mostly of atheists who have somehow produced a BIL who is a CofE vicar. His church is evangelical but he's never tried to recruit the rest of us and I find it hard to imagine him doing so.

I visited Salt Lake City as a student and although I'm not a very persuadable person, I am polite and when approached by a couple of Mormons (who did not identify themselves as such) we were pretty close to being signed up to the East Grinstead temple mailing list before we could extricate ourselves. Quote impressive from a marketing point of view!

It is easy to be seduced by the gorgeous landscapes, nice quality of life, polite, friendly people, shared language etc and to forget that you are dealing with a very different culture outside the large coastal cities.

Great for a visit. Not if you risk educational and residency complications down the line. Risky if your relationship isn't 100% solid.

Zwellers · 17/09/2023 12:40

I love how people are just like go it will be wonderful. What if you hate the heat, aren't an outdoors family or at all religious?. What are the schools like, how will the children fit into uk education when you come back, will they be behind. What if your dh doesn't want to come back are you stuck. Are you OK with not working. What if your dc get indoctrinated?.

Onthisproject · 17/09/2023 12:42

bananasplitwithcherry · 17/09/2023 08:36

I did a 2 year stint in the US a fair while ago but had no kids at the time.
There is no way in hell that I would disrupt the education of a twelve year old and risk bringing them back to the UK mid-GCSE, not to mention the social disruption of losing their friendship group twice in 2-3 years. You're setting your 12 year old up to fail academically and socially.

Totally agree

JaneIntheBox · 17/09/2023 13:06

Italiangreyhound · 17/09/2023 12:28

I agree with Takeabreather23 "So you didn’t sit down as a couple and talk about the “job offer “ it was just wife we are moving the family to Utah! ?

How about you say you want to talk about wether you actually move and uproot everyone’s lives before he makes a decision . How would husband take that ?

Honestly I’d be staying putmyself with the kids before I would be stuck in another country with no financial independence and no way out."

and ihadamarveloustime "If your relationship breaks down while you're there over this, he could stop you from leaving to come back to the UK with the children."

Please read up on this aspect of law. you will have no job and no independent income. He will be even more in charge than he appears to be in the UK. This would be my issue, not Utah or Mormons.

Exactly!
I also made this point but I can't believe so many PP are ignoring it in favour of a US vs UK bunfight.
Even if it was a 100% 'wonderful utopia' like one of the Nordic countries the lack of joint discussion is still alarming.
Moving abroad takes a toll on even the healthiest of marriages but a controlling, uneven one like this? More dangerous. What happens if they break up, on a dependent visa the OP might get little or no help. If she's got no job, no access to money, can she just take the kids back and leave?
Especially with a 12 year-old might be disruptive to their exams in a couple of years.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 17/09/2023 13:11

Have you or your husband been sterilized? Unless you want another child be very careful. If you are pregnant and there is a complication your life won't be prioritized

SomeCatFromJapan · 17/09/2023 13:41

*It's one thing to move to wealthy "blue" states like New York, Massachusetts, California, Colorado.... but moving to any of the poor "red" states - Utah, for ex - is like moving to a third world country. And the schools are terrible!

You'll be miserable there - though, I suppose it's only a 2 hour flight to L.A. so you could take weekend trips there to come up for air and check in with civilization.*

Yes a fun weekend watching people abuse drugs in tent cities, if she gets bored of the lovely scenery and outdoor activities.

PaperDoves · 17/09/2023 13:52

JaneIntheBox · 17/09/2023 13:06

Exactly!
I also made this point but I can't believe so many PP are ignoring it in favour of a US vs UK bunfight.
Even if it was a 100% 'wonderful utopia' like one of the Nordic countries the lack of joint discussion is still alarming.
Moving abroad takes a toll on even the healthiest of marriages but a controlling, uneven one like this? More dangerous. What happens if they break up, on a dependent visa the OP might get little or no help. If she's got no job, no access to money, can she just take the kids back and leave?
Especially with a 12 year-old might be disruptive to their exams in a couple of years.

I agree with you but it's hard to sit on our hands when people say things like "Utah is a third-world country" and "have you and your husband been sterilised?" Grin

Wakintoblueskies · 17/09/2023 14:16

I love how people are just like go it will be wonderful. What if you hate the heat, aren't an outdoors family or at all religious?. What are the schools like, how will the children fit into uk education when you come back, will they be behind. What if your dh doesn't want to come back are you stuck. Are you OK with not working. What if your dc get

And what if she loves it?
What if she is too scared to try something new?
What if it’s the best decision ever made?
She won’t know unless she tries?

JaneIntheBox · 17/09/2023 14:36

Wakintoblueskies · 17/09/2023 14:16

I love how people are just like go it will be wonderful. What if you hate the heat, aren't an outdoors family or at all religious?. What are the schools like, how will the children fit into uk education when you come back, will they be behind. What if your dh doesn't want to come back are you stuck. Are you OK with not working. What if your dc get

And what if she loves it?
What if she is too scared to try something new?
What if it’s the best decision ever made?
She won’t know unless she tries?

But she doesn't need to know. That's the point.
Why is 'trying something new' always inherently a good thing? Not everyone wants adventure. Not everyone wants to uproot themselves from the life they have built.
If the OP is perfectly happy where she is, why should she change it because her husband and the rest of you think it's a fabulous idea?

You're ignoring all the practicalities pointed out by PP in favour of chasing a dream, that's fine if it's your personality but it may not be the OP's. Especially if she's stuck with all the shitwork because she's unemployed.

Unlike trying a new flavour of jam or even a new career this is NOT something you can 'try' just to figure out whether you like it or not, it has major repercussions for all of their lives and deserves careful thought not 'rah rah see if you love it you can always come back'

Especially with them having just bought a house and the current environment being hostile for LL's, managing the house alone will be a load of work and it only takes one nightmare tenant for them to face large losses.

Wakintoblueskies · 17/09/2023 14:41

JaneIntheBox · 17/09/2023 14:36

But she doesn't need to know. That's the point.
Why is 'trying something new' always inherently a good thing? Not everyone wants adventure. Not everyone wants to uproot themselves from the life they have built.
If the OP is perfectly happy where she is, why should she change it because her husband and the rest of you think it's a fabulous idea?

You're ignoring all the practicalities pointed out by PP in favour of chasing a dream, that's fine if it's your personality but it may not be the OP's. Especially if she's stuck with all the shitwork because she's unemployed.

Unlike trying a new flavour of jam or even a new career this is NOT something you can 'try' just to figure out whether you like it or not, it has major repercussions for all of their lives and deserves careful thought not 'rah rah see if you love it you can always come back'

Especially with them having just bought a house and the current environment being hostile for LL's, managing the house alone will be a load of work and it only takes one nightmare tenant for them to face large losses.

Edited

Well yes some people are happy doing the same thing. My ninety year old father would absolutely agree with you. There is no need to travel, to try new things or move out of your lane.

But many would say life is for living and trying new things and having new experiences.

We have one life. It’s up to us to make the most of it and seize opportunities .
We regret more the things we don’t do.

nearlywinteragain · 17/09/2023 14:57

I absolutely agree that it needs to be a joint decision. Even the best moves put huge strain on relationships.
We did two international moves but decided to stick in our last country once dc were 12 so we didn't mess up their education.
It is harder for young teens to move I think.

JaneIntheBox · 17/09/2023 15:05

Wakintoblueskies · 17/09/2023 14:41

Well yes some people are happy doing the same thing. My ninety year old father would absolutely agree with you. There is no need to travel, to try new things or move out of your lane.

But many would say life is for living and trying new things and having new experiences.

We have one life. It’s up to us to make the most of it and seize opportunities .
We regret more the things we don’t do.

That sounds nice on an inspirational poster, but isn't the reality. Life is far too complex to have one general principle.

I know many people constantly trying new things, new experiences but they're deeply unhappy. Constantly chasing a variety of things to fill the emotional void. They can never be content until they work out what brings them real happiness.
Others who are not adventurous but extremely happy.
Still, there are others who are both adventurous AND happy! Because they have the type of personality that thrives on change. They're not doing it out of FOMO or because they don't know what they want.

We are all different people. Who would've thought?

Life isn't about 'trying new things'. It's about happiness and contentment. You have to decide what brings you happiness. Which may or may not be trying new things.

If staying in the U.K and her life here is what brings OP happiness. It's extremely presumptuous of anybody to ride roughshod over that and declare that actually, she's wrong, she MUST move abroad because it 'could' be the best thing ever. Especially if this is the logic her husband is using to shut her down.

Also it shouldn't be relevant as an argument but if your 90 year old father has lived this long and happily there's nothing wrong with his perspective is there? It worked for him. If it doesn't work for you, you're just different people. I live in a different country but my parents are still in the town they were born and raised in. We're all happy with our choices and I don't look down on them for not being 'rah rah new experiences otherwise I'm wasting my life'.

PostBoxErgoProperBox · 17/09/2023 15:06

If OP is Spanish and living in Dorset, that doesn't suggest that she's someone who is scared to travel or try new things. However, the fact that she apparently has no say in this potential move to America is a good reason for her not to entertain it. How would her husband react if she told him she had a great job offer in Spain and was thinking of taking a unilateral decision to move the family there for 1-3 years, possibly longer?

Wakintoblueskies · 17/09/2023 15:14

JaneIntheBox · 17/09/2023 15:05

That sounds nice on an inspirational poster, but isn't the reality. Life is far too complex to have one general principle.

I know many people constantly trying new things, new experiences but they're deeply unhappy. Constantly chasing a variety of things to fill the emotional void. They can never be content until they work out what brings them real happiness.
Others who are not adventurous but extremely happy.
Still, there are others who are both adventurous AND happy! Because they have the type of personality that thrives on change. They're not doing it out of FOMO or because they don't know what they want.

We are all different people. Who would've thought?

Life isn't about 'trying new things'. It's about happiness and contentment. You have to decide what brings you happiness. Which may or may not be trying new things.

If staying in the U.K and her life here is what brings OP happiness. It's extremely presumptuous of anybody to ride roughshod over that and declare that actually, she's wrong, she MUST move abroad because it 'could' be the best thing ever. Especially if this is the logic her husband is using to shut her down.

Also it shouldn't be relevant as an argument but if your 90 year old father has lived this long and happily there's nothing wrong with his perspective is there? It worked for him. If it doesn't work for you, you're just different people. I live in a different country but my parents are still in the town they were born and raised in. We're all happy with our choices and I don't look down on them for not being 'rah rah new experiences otherwise I'm wasting my life'.

Edited

I could not disagree more.

It is so lacking in ambition.
Fear holds some of us back. Being happy with your lot is ok advice when there aren’t new opportunities to try. Few of us are lucky enough to be given such opportunities.

JaneIntheBox · 17/09/2023 15:39

Wakintoblueskies · 17/09/2023 15:14

I could not disagree more.

It is so lacking in ambition.
Fear holds some of us back. Being happy with your lot is ok advice when there aren’t new opportunities to try. Few of us are lucky enough to be given such opportunities.

Well actually most people who want to move abroad or try new things IME have done so. You needing it to be 'given' is what's lacking in ambition. Maybe it's because you're not that capable you see this as something rare and golden to be grabbed with both hands, while other people are ambitious and competent enough to create opportunity when the need arises as plenty of immigrants do, especially non-EU ones. If you want to move abroad you make the correct choices, not just sit and hope that 'following your passion' will magically allow you to achieve your goals. Or, some have different backgrounds that give them more mobility.

Like in this case. As @PostBoxErgoProperBox pointed out the OP has already moved once, to the U.K so she isn't scared of moving. Furthermore, the OP is Spanish, and probably possesses an EU passport that allows her to move to almost any country in the European continent. Most of these offer a great life, social welfare, etc etc.

OP has opportunities aplenty. She doesn't need to move to the U.S if she doesn't want to. She could literally move out of the U.K tomorrow, take a plane to an EU country and rent a property with nothing to stop her.

poetryandwine · 17/09/2023 15:46

@KvotheTheBloodless your comments about health care are misleading and do not suggest personal experience.

All American insurance and HMO care covers out of network emergency care. The only way I can fathom you would accidentally end up out of network is for emergency care.

It is true that at A&E they will look for your insurance card upon intake. They will liaise with your service provider concerning the need for admission. They will try to transfer you to network care as soon as you are stable for further procedures. But the insurers have reciprocal policies for this out of network care, and some lucky people with unrestricted insurance don’t even have networks.

Health care sadly is a major historical cause of bankruptcy amongst Americans, but that is amongst the uninsured and the minimally insured.

There are poor insurance schemes, of course. That’s why we are keen to know if the DH has been offered a good one. For example in Park City one might hope to find good HMOs with local primary, dental, paediatric , dermatology, gynaecology and MH provisions amongst others and further specialisms at the University of Utah Medical Center in Salt Lake, all organised by the University. And with just a small copay at point of use.

QS90 · 17/09/2023 15:51

Imo, life before children can be about "trying new things", but after children, it's about stability and putting the children first, so they can have their own adventures if they want, when they are older. Moving continent (and then back again once they are finally settled) isn't putting them first.

As for Mormons and their influence on the culture... a friend of mine in Salt Lake had a pamphlet dropped in his letterbox one winter that said "It's cold outside, but don't keep warm with premarital sex, or the fires of hell will keep you warm for all of eternity". Aside from the clunkiness, is this the message you want your children hearing as they go through puberty and form attitudes about sex and relationships (as you yourself aren't religious)? Mormons might be polite to visitors, but it's another thing to have children grow up in a community which believes this.

poetryandwine · 17/09/2023 16:01

Newsflash! Much to my own surprise, as someone with liberal politics,

Utah ranks No 1 overall in the 2023 US News and World Report ranking of states, including No1 for economy, No 5 for education and No 7 for health care.

I wasn’t a doomsayer; I said earlier that in the OP’s place I would consider Park City. But I never thought it would come rank this highly on objective measures. I went looking for data because the massive wall of ignorant comments about education and health care was just so boring. I hope we’ve all learnt something.

cakecoffeecakecoffee · 17/09/2023 16:05

I would definitely go, I’d take any chance to experience a different way of life for a couple of years.

but Yanbu for feeling anxious about it.

Lastchancechica · 17/09/2023 16:09

poetryandwine · 17/09/2023 16:01

Newsflash! Much to my own surprise, as someone with liberal politics,

Utah ranks No 1 overall in the 2023 US News and World Report ranking of states, including No1 for economy, No 5 for education and No 7 for health care.

I wasn’t a doomsayer; I said earlier that in the OP’s place I would consider Park City. But I never thought it would come rank this highly on objective measures. I went looking for data because the massive wall of ignorant comments about education and health care was just so boring. I hope we’ve all learnt something.

Fuck me! Patronising or what?
Liberal politics?
WE have all learnt something?

What we have learnt is the bar might be somewhat low if it’s No1 in the US for anything.

poetryandwine · 17/09/2023 16:39

I included myself ss amongst those surprised by the data, @Lastchancechica
(because of my own beliefs)
Sounds like you are, too.

Biased, much?

poetryandwine · 17/09/2023 16:49

To clarify, I was bored by the comments with no nuance or data backing up the belief that Utah would fare poorly on education, maternal health, etc. I expected it to rank perhaps at 30 or 35 in education. Not at the bottom, because I knew that there isn’t a lot of poverty.

So the statistics were quite a surprise.