Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants us to move to Utah!

615 replies

Frenchcroissant · 16/09/2023 21:03

So, my husband has been offered an opportunity to move to Utah and work there 1 to 3 years. He's very excited about it. Me and two DDS ( 7 and 12) to and fro, sometimes excited sometimes nervous/reluctant. I'm freaking out!! We've literally just bought a house in May. I won't be able to work there. Is it an adventure/opportunity or a complete mad move? I haven't told anyone in real life, but I'm quite nervous/anxious about it. AIBU to freak out??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
RiderofRohan · 25/09/2023 10:51

I'm sure there are atheists and non-religious people and communities in Utah. It's meant to be gorgeous. I would go and enjoy a nice big house, the natural beauty and being a real housewife for a while.

Mikimoto · 25/09/2023 10:28

wotanarse · 20/09/2023 20:50

Utah sounds like a great place for a three-week holiday, not so much as a place to live.

So...a bit like Scotland or Yorkshire*?

(*if you change "3-week" to "3-day")

wotanarse · 20/09/2023 20:50

Utah sounds like a great place for a three-week holiday, not so much as a place to live.

Laguera · 20/09/2023 17:05

And my 12 year old does shooting drills at her school, so how would it be different? Does Utah has a history of school shootings?

The whole of the US has a massive problem with shootings, in schools and out, yes including Utah. It’s very different from Dorset (I’m in Dorset).

That is personally something I would be very concerned about, it is really becoming an everyday occurrence over there. I think Utah is an open carry state too so you will see people walking around with guns which definitely changes the environment IMO.

knitnerd90 · 20/09/2023 07:43

Health insurance is so individual and specific that it can be difficult to advise without plan details. Depending on the company's offer, it can be amazing or it can be terribly expensive. However I can correct a few things:

  • Diabetes is covered, period (I have it). The issue with having to see an endocrinologist is simply that the endocrinologist insists on seeing you to keep prescribing. I am not insulin-dependent, so I don't need to see a specialist. You never have to see the doctor for the insurance to cover something; it's a question of continuing to be a patient with that doctor.
  • Contraceptive services are covered at no cost to the patient thanks to the Affordable Care Act. A friend of mine actually had to have her IUD removed in hospital under anaesthesia as it was embedded in the endometrium -- she paid nothing.
  • pre-approvals are an issue however the doctor will usually sort it all for you, the thing is to check and make sure it was properly received!
  • Annual visits to your doctor for preventative care are recommended and free, as is an annual visit to the gynaecologist. Anything on the list of preventative services is at no cost to the patient. That includes the annual well-child visit for children and all recommended vaccines for children and adults. I do love having a paediatrician, mine has been gold and has helped all 3 of my children get proper diagnoses for different things including autism.

On college: yes you can get into one with just GCSEs but not the good ones, generally speaking (a few colleges are very idiosyncratic and will take students without typical qualifications, who are leaving school early, etc). The American degree is actually based on the Scottish system. All degrees have you take things outside your major, but some are much more intense than others. For example in engineering you do not spend 2 years just taking liberal arts!

sashh · 20/09/2023 04:38

BlueKaftan · 17/09/2023 09:14

The educational curriculum in the U.S. might be behind the U.K. but what does it cost the children who suffer through the stress of GCSEs and A levels? And for what? A place at “uni” from whence they will go on to be just as average as the American person the same age.

But they don't.

You can go to uni in the states with GCSEs, 5 is equivalent to a HSD. A Levels give you advanced placement.

US, "4 year degrees" are often 'liberal arts' with specialism much later so things like law and medicine are post graduate courses.

OP

As well as the bad timing for your 12 year old, she could also lose her status as a 'home' student in terms of uni fees / access to loans.

Also really really check out any health insurance. I watch a lot of 'Americans living in Europe' and healthcare comes up again and again. Others who have actually lived in the states can probably tell me what the realities are but this is what comes up a lot.

One woman who is diabetic has to have two appointments a year with an endocrinologist in order for her diabetes to be covered by insurance.

The in network / out of network is a real issue because you might get regular check ups at hospital A but then you need to see a different specialist, so you go to hospital A, unfortunately the department physically in the hospital is actually part of a different network.

You also need preapproval from the insurance company for a lot of treatments.

You might need to have an annual visit to a gynaecologist.

I'd also look into contraceptive services for yourself and your DDs if either of them has bad periods while you are there.

Also you may lose access to the NHS when you come back.

PaperDoves · 19/09/2023 20:46

knitnerd90 · 19/09/2023 20:11

The gun violence issue is significant but the discussions bother me because they completely ignore all the disparities in gun violence by region, class, and race and what we get are well off white people acting like they're going to be the ones at risk. You are not. Try being poor, Black, and living somewhere like Baton Rouge or Memphis. "Mass shootings" don't just mean the ones you hear about like the Aurora cinema or the Pulse or schools. They happen at parties where people get too drunk and get into fights. Gun violence is an absolutely horrible, horrible social problem in the USA and the people who can do something about it either won't or can't.

The conversation bothers me in both directions because it is a real issue, it is horrible, it shouldn't happen. But it's also weaponised as a reason that expats should fear for their lives and not visit or come here.

That's the real burden of living in the USA -- the knowledge that economic or racial privilege will make all the difference in your life. You either have to be able to deal with it, in whatever fashion, or you become the kind of conservative who denies the statistics.

Really well said.

Lastchancechica · 19/09/2023 20:13

knitnerd90 · 19/09/2023 20:11

The gun violence issue is significant but the discussions bother me because they completely ignore all the disparities in gun violence by region, class, and race and what we get are well off white people acting like they're going to be the ones at risk. You are not. Try being poor, Black, and living somewhere like Baton Rouge or Memphis. "Mass shootings" don't just mean the ones you hear about like the Aurora cinema or the Pulse or schools. They happen at parties where people get too drunk and get into fights. Gun violence is an absolutely horrible, horrible social problem in the USA and the people who can do something about it either won't or can't.

The conversation bothers me in both directions because it is a real issue, it is horrible, it shouldn't happen. But it's also weaponised as a reason that expats should fear for their lives and not visit or come here.

That's the real burden of living in the USA -- the knowledge that economic or racial privilege will make all the difference in your life. You either have to be able to deal with it, in whatever fashion, or you become the kind of conservative who denies the statistics.

Well said I completely agree.

knitnerd90 · 19/09/2023 20:11

The gun violence issue is significant but the discussions bother me because they completely ignore all the disparities in gun violence by region, class, and race and what we get are well off white people acting like they're going to be the ones at risk. You are not. Try being poor, Black, and living somewhere like Baton Rouge or Memphis. "Mass shootings" don't just mean the ones you hear about like the Aurora cinema or the Pulse or schools. They happen at parties where people get too drunk and get into fights. Gun violence is an absolutely horrible, horrible social problem in the USA and the people who can do something about it either won't or can't.

The conversation bothers me in both directions because it is a real issue, it is horrible, it shouldn't happen. But it's also weaponised as a reason that expats should fear for their lives and not visit or come here.

That's the real burden of living in the USA -- the knowledge that economic or racial privilege will make all the difference in your life. You either have to be able to deal with it, in whatever fashion, or you become the kind of conservative who denies the statistics.

Delatron · 19/09/2023 19:08

The risk may be low but it’s still a risk. And one that we don’t have here. I personally couldn’t live in a country where children get shot in their classrooms and there are mass shootings every day. Where gun deaths amongst children and teenagers are rising every year and nothing is done. Whether the risk to me personally and my family was tiny or not.

OP may well be fine with that. I’d end up getting in to arguments (as seen on here) with people who downplay that specific horror.

I’m sure the parents of those children that get killed every year thought their risk was low too. The point is this could all be avoided if you had stricter gun controls.

Anyway, I’m aware I’m derailing the thread. Hope the OP comes to a decision.

Delatron · 19/09/2023 18:32

There’s nothing to get! I’d rather live here than the U.S for many, many reasons. Nothing you have said is convincing me otherwise.

Delatron · 19/09/2023 18:31

It’s quite shocking how you play down the gun ownership and gun violence issue. Maybe you have to to be able to live there who knows.

Nobody is saying the UK is amazing. I’d rather live somewhere like Sweden. But I’d rather live here than worry about my child getting shot when they go to school. But good that most people over there don’t worry about that. Or see it as an issue.

mathanxiety · 19/09/2023 18:23

Delatron · 19/09/2023 17:02

I guess we all have different experiences. I had breast cancer and had months of chemo, a double mastectomy, all the drugs and obviously did not pay a penny (apart from in taxes). Yes we can all criticise the NHS, especially at the moment but I read stories on US cancer boards about women not having the private healthcare cover to have lifesaving mastectomies and treatment. Awful.

So far this year you have had 484 mass shootings. We’ve had zero.
Great that you get used to that and you don’t think about it on a daily basis. I would so couldn’t live there. We’re all different.

I suspect there's quite a lot of confirmation bias going on here. I doubt you read stories of women on Medicaid getting timely, first class treatment for cancer without paying a cent.

The UK continues to struggle with five year survival rates relative to other OECD countries for several common cancers.
www.nuffieldtrust.org.uk/resource/cancer-survival-rates
The reasons suggested include delays accessing treatment. People have been aware of problems in the NHS for years now but continue to resist the obvious solution of throwing more taxpayer money at it. It seems a great many people have made their peace with the idea that the system isn't great and focus on other priorities when voting.

All the figures prove is that there is no perfect place to get cancer, but obv some places are better than others.

Delatron · 19/09/2023 18:08

’A sensational piece of news’ so our media really overegg young children getting shot in their classrooms? They really need to play that down. Nothing to see here.

Though to be fair I think our media have stopped reporting the U.S school shootings since they happen so often. And nobody in your country seems able to stop them.

And gun crime is increasing year on year and poor children and teens are getting shot in the thousands. But you’re all just so used to it it barely registers.

Nice place to live.

mathanxiety · 19/09/2023 17:52

PrimitivePerson · 19/09/2023 09:26

Yeah, the chance of getting shot in a school should be a big fat zero. Obviously you can't prevent everything, but since Dunblane we took all the actions we could, and your chances of being shot in a British school are infinitesimally small. However "statistically insignificant" school shooting deaths are in the US, the chances of it happening are FAR higher than they are here, and no-one really seems to care about stopping it. It's hardly surprising British parents consider it a major problem.

It is a sensational piece of news whenever it happens, and that's why British parents think they're justified in considering it a major problem.

But a statistically insignificant risk is a really, really small risk, even if it is higher than that risk in the UK, so turning it into a reason not to want to live in the US for a few years isn't a rational response.

Your chances of being bitten by some venomous snake are also higher by a long shot in the US than in the UK, but that risk is also statistically insignificant.

mathanxiety · 19/09/2023 17:47

ZadocPDederick · 19/09/2023 17:22

I actually think an over focus on the school shootings that I abhor as much as anyone is a cheap way of feeling superior. America is generally more complex than many here seem willing to admit. I am not sure where any feeling of superiority realistically comes from.

It's not a matter of feeling superior, though it's interesting that you read it that way. It's simply a matter of feeling afraid. Plus, of course, no-one is naive enough to believe that the risk is confined to school. As the stats quoted by @Delphinium20 demonstrate, the risk is considerably greater in the world outside.

The feeling of fear is not shared by the vast majority of Americans going about their daily lives. It's a feeling encouraged or engendered by distance therefore, and unfamiliarity.

There are dangers everywhere. Traffic, flying, riding a bike, train crashes - all dangerous. Do people cheerfully hop into cars and drive to work every day? Do they let their children walk to school and back? Ride bikes? Do people fly to holiday destinations? Do they swim in lakes, rivers, and the sea?

Regardless of where we live, we all put up with a certain degree of risk. Just because a risk statistic exists doesn't mean the dangerous thing is going to happen to me today.

MartinChuzzlewit · 19/09/2023 17:28

Rubyupbeat · 19/09/2023 16:44

Oh for goodness sake. There is abuse in every religion and non religion!

Oh well that’s ok then

ZadocPDederick · 19/09/2023 17:22

I actually think an over focus on the school shootings that I abhor as much as anyone is a cheap way of feeling superior. America is generally more complex than many here seem willing to admit. I am not sure where any feeling of superiority realistically comes from.

It's not a matter of feeling superior, though it's interesting that you read it that way. It's simply a matter of feeling afraid. Plus, of course, no-one is naive enough to believe that the risk is confined to school. As the stats quoted by @Delphinium20 demonstrate, the risk is considerably greater in the world outside.

Phineyj · 19/09/2023 17:15

There is an armed police division in the UK and while it's not common, it's not unusual to see armed police at times/locations of high alert.

For example I saw three armed police patrolling Bluewater Shopping Centre in Kent one weekend a couple of years ago.

I assume there had been a credible threat.

Delphinium20 · 19/09/2023 17:11

I cant believe the idiotic comparison to bee stings. Schools have lowered gun risks for children BECAUSE they are locked, have metal detectors and have staff who are aware of the risks. It's outside school where most of our children are dying from guns in the US. Walking to school, in the home, at a bday party, at a park, etc.

5,590 deaths of children by guns in 2021.

www.pewresearch.org/short-reads/2023/04/06/gun-deaths-among-us-kids-rose-50-percent-in-two-years/

Delatron · 19/09/2023 17:02

I guess we all have different experiences. I had breast cancer and had months of chemo, a double mastectomy, all the drugs and obviously did not pay a penny (apart from in taxes). Yes we can all criticise the NHS, especially at the moment but I read stories on US cancer boards about women not having the private healthcare cover to have lifesaving mastectomies and treatment. Awful.

So far this year you have had 484 mass shootings. We’ve had zero.
Great that you get used to that and you don’t think about it on a daily basis. I would so couldn’t live there. We’re all different.

Rubyupbeat · 19/09/2023 16:44

MartinChuzzlewit · 16/09/2023 21:19

Mormon isn’t a race 🤣

Are you aware of the abuse scandals in the Mormon church?

Oh for goodness sake. There is abuse in every religion and non religion!

ACynicalDad · 19/09/2023 16:16

1-3 years of your life is nothing, it's a great adventure, I live abroad for a few years and am richer for the experience and your kids will be too, my fear would be school shootings, they don't happen in every state, have there been any/many in Utah. Mormons may actually make it a safer place.

Rubyupbeat · 19/09/2023 16:13

Utah is lovely , I lived there for 18 months when my boys were small, the scenery is amazing, the schools seemed good, mine were too young to go, but went pre school and they loved it. Yes, there is a majority of Mormons, they are kind, friendly and helpful and don't try to push the religion on you at all, Its one of the only places I felt truly safe.