Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants us to move to Utah!

615 replies

Frenchcroissant · 16/09/2023 21:03

So, my husband has been offered an opportunity to move to Utah and work there 1 to 3 years. He's very excited about it. Me and two DDS ( 7 and 12) to and fro, sometimes excited sometimes nervous/reluctant. I'm freaking out!! We've literally just bought a house in May. I won't be able to work there. Is it an adventure/opportunity or a complete mad move? I haven't told anyone in real life, but I'm quite nervous/anxious about it. AIBU to freak out??

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
sunglassesonthetable · 18/09/2023 08:05

Dear me some of the actual nonsense on here.

Croissantsandpistachio · 18/09/2023 07:10

There's a good Facebook group called 2 Fat Expats it would be worth asking or searching on. They have quite a lot of people who've had some time in Utah (and are not Mormon!). I mean I've lived in plenty of other majority religion countries and that bit is really fine.

The standard things to ask are:

  • what's the Healthcare package? Look very closely at the copay.
-schools- are your kids going to be in international school or the local system? What's the plan for the oldest on return (kids are more flexible than people think on shifting between school systems but GCSE years are a worry- could she either repeat a year or go into an American school in the UK for the rest of high school?) -What will you do all day? -Flights home every year

Also getting a house ready to rent in the UK can be a lot of work, so take that into account. Or if you can afford it and will be back a lot you could hang onto it, or air bnb it (there are agencies that do this).

I'd really recommend asking on an expat forum, as there tends to be a lot less panic at the idea of moving kids!

jeaux90 · 18/09/2023 06:36

I don't know OP. I've been to Utah loads for work and it's pretty but very boring.

And I would have a concern taking a 12 year old away a couple of years before GCSEs start.

PaperDoves · 18/09/2023 05:30

This misconception that American schools are terrible - where does it come from?

Much like anything relating to the US, we only hear the bad news and never the good news. It's easy to think an entire education system is failing if you only hear about exceptional cases, especially if your experience of schools is in the UK where there's a central department making decisions for state schools all over (most of) the country.

It doesn't work like that in America, at all. States as well as individual school districts have so much power over the curriculum.

Case in point for my own bias: my sister moved to Texas and said she was taking her son out of private and putting him into the local elementary school. My reaction was based solely off the news (they don't even teach evolution! Texas schools are in the gutter!!) Actually, no, Texas broadly but her area specifically has some of the top public schools in the nation. My nephew gets an amazing education and has far more choice in his classes than my kids do at their good UK schools. (He also has hours of homework every night, which I would personally hate having to monitor but tradeoffs, eh?)

PaperDoves · 18/09/2023 05:15

knitnerd90 · 17/09/2023 22:04

I'd pick North Dakota, I think. Kansas actually has some pretty bits, and Arkansas has the Ozarks. North Dakota is nothing but cold flat treeless prairie.

I've never been to North Dakota (or South Dakota for that matter) - I didn't realise it was completely flat!

I clearly haven't been to the good bits of Arkansas, either. No fond memories of the state.

Notpooryet · 18/09/2023 00:20

Wakintoblueskies · 17/09/2023 18:32

They could go to Grimsby for the day for that.

This is exactly what my 90 year old father would say and has said to me!

He's 90 so what he says must be rubbish?

Ageist as well as unable to understand that not everyone thinks like you or wants the same things...

mathanxiety · 18/09/2023 00:12

Ivebeentogeorgia · 17/09/2023 09:30

I would if your kids were younger. 3 years in America would affect your 12 year old when they come back home to do GCSEs. So for that reason, I wouldn’t do it.

also, I think it would be hard going at 12 friendship wise. To go to a whole new country with different religious views, make friends and settle and then after all that go back home and try and fit back in with friends who will have moved on or make brand new friends once again.

Between age 12 and 15 friendships are in a state of constant flux. There is no guarantee whatsoever that the kids a 12 year old is friends with will even be speaking to her next week.

mathanxiety · 18/09/2023 00:10

ihadamarveloustime · 17/09/2023 10:38

It would be a hard no for me in your position: you won't be able to work, medical care is very expensive, even with his benefits package, your children will be surrounded by religious families in schools, there will be guns drills to deal with in schools and you'll have to wade through the 'they keep guns at home' minefield if they're invited to their friends' homes.

Visit? Sure. Live there? No.

Such a parochial pov.

You realise there are guns on most British farms, right?
You realise that kids do lockdown drills in many British schools, right?
inews.co.uk/opinion/giving-children-in-the-uk-school-shooting-drills-is-a-foolish-and-dangerous-idea-1660796

The reasons to do these drills include preparation for such incidents as escaped prisoners roaming in the neighbourhood, people with restraining orders or prohibited steps orders forbidding them access to certain children seen near a school, and suspects fleeing the scene of another crime roaming in the neighbourhood.

Do you think people living in a place where there are snakes and bears shouldn't have a gun handy?

How do you feel about fire drills and tornado drills? Fires and tornadoes are both scary and unpleasant, and speaking from personal observation, these drills cause a lot of distress in young children.

You clearly know nothing about healthcare in the US.

Your anti-religious bigotry gives the lie to the unspoken assertion that the UK is a beacon of tolerance.

mathanxiety · 17/09/2023 23:52

SomeCatFromJapan · 17/09/2023 13:41

*It's one thing to move to wealthy "blue" states like New York, Massachusetts, California, Colorado.... but moving to any of the poor "red" states - Utah, for ex - is like moving to a third world country. And the schools are terrible!

You'll be miserable there - though, I suppose it's only a 2 hour flight to L.A. so you could take weekend trips there to come up for air and check in with civilization.*

Yes a fun weekend watching people abuse drugs in tent cities, if she gets bored of the lovely scenery and outdoor activities.

What a load of codswallop.

For starters, not all schools in 'wealthy blue states' are good.

And secondly, Utah is not a 'poor red state'.

Schools in inner cities tend to be poor. Schools in poor rural parts of a great many states tend to be poor. The rest are fine. Some are tremendous. There are ordinary state schools in the US that would put the leading British private schools to shame.

This misconception that American schools are terrible - where does it come from? A place of deep ignorance and bogotry for sure, but it is trotted out so often here it's almost like a script has been passed around and hundreds of people here have fallen for it.

TiredRetired · 17/09/2023 22:54

I’ve some experience of Utah. My ex husbands son lived there. Park City is probably the most cosmopolitan area in the state.

My husband worked in Texas for 6 months, we had flights for me and kids over school holidays built in. A move was on the cards if we wanted it, the housing compared to the U.K. was amazing and very tempting but our children were older, coming up to exams and loved their friends so for that and a variety of reasons we decided against it.
Go to church ( not the Mormon one) at least a few times if you can. Lots of social life based around that in US. They’re friendly but it is a very different culture which is unsettling at first.

porridgeisbae · 17/09/2023 22:27

I don't have a say in the way that's it's more money, so therefore better for us as a family

Money isn't everything, at all. I know some people who were really psychologically damaged by a house move away from all their friends etc as a child. I mean, eating disorders for life etc.

If you just moved in May, your husband sounds very feckless/fickle. You'dve thought he'd be committed to where you all decided to move.

porridgeisbae · 17/09/2023 22:21

@Frenchcroissant I absolutely wouldn't do it. Imagine your DC having to leave where they're settled. Sad

And your husband doesn't sound particularly nice. x

knitnerd90 · 17/09/2023 22:04

PaperDoves · 17/09/2023 19:11

@Ruthietuthie don't pick on Idaho! It has some lovely landscapes. If I had to pick a most boring state it would be somewhere flat, like Kansas. Maybe Arkansas... no offense to anyone from those places. It takes all types of landscapes to make a country.

Utah really is stunning though. The Moab area is mind blowing.

I'd pick North Dakota, I think. Kansas actually has some pretty bits, and Arkansas has the Ozarks. North Dakota is nothing but cold flat treeless prairie.

givemeasunnyday · 17/09/2023 20:58

Itick8outof10boxes · 17/09/2023 18:27

I know someone who knows Utah well and calls it 'the most boring state in America' .I'd stay put with the dc if it was me and plan visits both ways.

Unbelievable 😞😧

Lizzieregina · 17/09/2023 20:53

@givemeasunnyday once upon a time I did have to choose between the UK and the US and it was an easy choice for me.

Now choosing between the US and Ireland was extremely difficult.

If I could convince my kids to live in Ireland it’d be easier!

givemeasunnyday · 17/09/2023 20:48

roarrfeckingroar · 17/09/2023 10:46

I don't understand the hate for America on Mumsnet. It's extreme.

Not just America, any country which isn't the UK comes in for criticism. Apparently the UK is some sort of utopia, and everyone in the rest of the world wants to live there!

I don't live in either part of the world, but if I had to pick one to live in for a few years I wouldn't have to think about it for more than a second - and it wouldn't be the UK.

PaperDoves · 17/09/2023 19:11

@Ruthietuthie don't pick on Idaho! It has some lovely landscapes. If I had to pick a most boring state it would be somewhere flat, like Kansas. Maybe Arkansas... no offense to anyone from those places. It takes all types of landscapes to make a country.

Utah really is stunning though. The Moab area is mind blowing.

Ruthietuthie · 17/09/2023 18:54

@knitnerd90's post is excellent. Yes, there are several factors that make this a complicated decision - the education issues for the eldest, plus potential interruption of the OP's career - but discount the inaccurate stereotypes, OP.
And comments from the friend of a friend of @Itick8outof10boxes, are just silly. Honestly, Utah's mountains and national parks are incredible. If that's "most boring state" well, that person has clearly never driven through Idaho...

knitnerd90 · 17/09/2023 18:48

But you're saying provably false things, so no, your memories aren't just as valid.

I didn't need to google the name of the clinic by the way! I happened to know that because it was actually fairly big news in the US as Wyoming had no clinics until this year.

The problem with every moving to the US thread is that it becomes about false stereotypes like roving bands of Mormon missionaries rather than the particulars & practicalities of THIS move. I don't think moving countries is ever as simple as "it'll be fun, just pick up and try it!" There's loads of reasons not to! But make your decision based on proper facts and what's relevant to your situation. For example, on a time limited work visa, OP wouldn't be at risk of being trapped here -- she wouldn't be considered a resident of the US for custody purposes. It's not as simple as "wherever you happen to be living at the time". In THIS case OP should consider:

  • eldest's education as returning to UK would be at a difficult time (returning in primary is fine even if a child is slightly behind curriculum wise; unless they have SEN, they will catch up in a year or so)
  • does she have a career she would be giving up on here as she would not be legal to work in USA
  • details of husband's package: with currency differences, COL, etc the numbers you need to live in USA/Canada are quite shocking even before you account for US healthcare costs
  • Risks to her ILR with extended absences.
Ruthietuthie · 17/09/2023 18:48

@verdantverdure, don't be silly. Not all opinions are equally valid, particularly when they include opinions that are factually completely inaccurate.

verdantverdure · 17/09/2023 18:37

Ruthietuthie · 17/09/2023 17:57

@verdantverdure, it's far less Mormon that almost any other city in Utah, and less than many in Idaho, Colorado, and other surrounding states... In fact, there are parts of Nevada (in the suburbs of Las Vegas) that have a higher proportion of Mormons than Park City does.
And your imaginings of what gender relations might be like for the OP, plus your other imaginings, well, you clearly have a good imagination!!! How does just making things up from a dimly remembered short trip help the OP?

It wasn't that long ago.

I don't have dementia.

My opinions formed from having spent time there are at least as valid as anyone else's.

OhCrumbsWhereNow · 17/09/2023 18:35

Even if it was a 100% 'wonderful utopia' like one of the Nordic countries

Weirdly nobody ever seems to mention the gun laws and how many there are knocking around in Nordic countries...

Finland: mass school shootings in 2007 and 2008, 1.5 million registered small firearms for a population of 5.6 million. 32.4 guns per 100 population.

Norway: 1.3 million firearms with 28.8 guns per 100 population. 98.3% of licence applications are approved. Mass shootings in 2011 and 2022.

Sweden: 60 shooting deaths in 2022. Sweden sits among the world’s top countries with the highest guns owned per capita at about 23 per 100 population.

Wakintoblueskies · 17/09/2023 18:32

They could go to Grimsby for the day for that.

This is exactly what my 90 year old father would say and has said to me!

poetryandwine · 17/09/2023 18:32

OP,

I have no idea whether you should go or not. I certainly think you should have an equal say in the decision.

But as someone (liberal) who moved to America for 15 years and was generally no fan of Utah but loved visiting Park City, I am angered by the large number of factually false statements on this thread. I looked up the State Rankings because I thought we all needed data and yes, I was genuinely surprised. BTW, most of the top states are progressive so the data aren’t skewed to favour conservative states.

I hope you can speak up within your marriage and I hope you can decide based on your own values and the facts, rather than some of the bias and nonsense here.

Best wishes

Itick8outof10boxes · 17/09/2023 18:27

I know someone who knows Utah well and calls it 'the most boring state in America' .I'd stay put with the dc if it was me and plan visits both ways.

Swipe left for the next trending thread