Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband wants us to move to Utah!

615 replies

Frenchcroissant · 16/09/2023 21:03

So, my husband has been offered an opportunity to move to Utah and work there 1 to 3 years. He's very excited about it. Me and two DDS ( 7 and 12) to and fro, sometimes excited sometimes nervous/reluctant. I'm freaking out!! We've literally just bought a house in May. I won't be able to work there. Is it an adventure/opportunity or a complete mad move? I haven't told anyone in real life, but I'm quite nervous/anxious about it. AIBU to freak out??

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
PrimitivePerson · 19/09/2023 15:56

But that's the thing - even our police officers don't carry guns.

Delatron · 19/09/2023 15:41

Sure. But for those not used to it the worry would always be there. Hence I couldn’t live over there. I don’t want to worry about sending my child to school every day.

Bored1000 · 19/09/2023 15:34

I would go, it’s a great opportunity to expose the children to a different culture / life etc
But I would want the option to be able stay for at least 2 years as It’s a big move and a lot of admin/ organising involved

pinkyredrose · 19/09/2023 15:09

RhiWrites · 16/09/2023 21:06

That is alarming. Utah is alarming. It is full of Mormons. I would not go there.

Mormon's are people you know.

Delatron · 19/09/2023 10:56

PrimitivePerson · 19/09/2023 10:50

@Wallaw Oh, I appreciate perspective is needed. I'm just pointing out that gun crime in the UK is so incredibly low that it's hardly surprising British people obsess about it when thinking about moving to America.

And they are desensitised to it in the U.S. hence children continue to get shot at school every year.

Delatron · 19/09/2023 10:55

I hate it when people downplay the gun problems in the U.S. Children should be safe in school - not doing shooter drills. It’s horrific that children are shot every year at school.

Then there’s the lack of laws around guns in the home. Than the abortion laws. You couldn’t pay me to live there.

PrimitivePerson · 19/09/2023 10:50

@Wallaw Oh, I appreciate perspective is needed. I'm just pointing out that gun crime in the UK is so incredibly low that it's hardly surprising British people obsess about it when thinking about moving to America.

poetryandwine · 19/09/2023 10:50

For clarification its the bee sting number that is about 75

poetryandwine · 19/09/2023 10:29

Who is blase about school shootings? Not me.

The points about trauma and sampling size are partially fair (sampling is complex) but do not affect the basic issue of scale. Perhaps it is more easily imagined when you realise that about 3 times as many people die from bee and wasp stings in America every year as the school shooting average.. This number is about 75 by the way.

Is my horror at the shootings less than yours? Highly doubtful. Nor is that of many Americans.

Many, many wrongs that children face in this world should not exist @PrimitivePerson . A barely detectable chance of being involved in a school shooting is not nearly the highest thing on my list. Children who are murdered in the family home after being overlooked by Social Services seems to be a much bigger problem here than in America and personally I find that worse, because the whole of their young lives has been an unheeded call for help.

I actually think an over focus on the school shootings that I abhor as much as anyone is a cheap way of feeling superior. America is generally more complex than many here seem willing to admit. I am not sure where any feeling of superiority realistically comes from.

Lastchancechica · 19/09/2023 10:04

Gemst199 · 19/09/2023 09:43

I'm LDS/Mormon. I've not read everything, but I did want to address the concerns about abuse. Like any other group there's always going to be bad people and mistakes in dealing with that, but the church is working really hard at preventing abuse.
In the UK over the last few years they've added windows into all the doors of our chapels (accept the toilets) so that there's no 'behind closed doors'. If an adult is talking to a child either another trusted adult must be in the room, or if the child asks for privacy they will stand outside but still in sight.
Anyone who works with children must do mandatory safeguarding training, which among other things makes it clear that any concerns must be reported to the police not just church authorities. And they've just made it mandatory that anyone working with children or vulnerable adults has a current CRB check.
Like I said, we aren't perfect no one is, but your children will not be in more danger living in a community with a high proportion of LDS.

It’s taken them this long to do that? The mind boggles.

Gemst199 · 19/09/2023 09:43

I'm LDS/Mormon. I've not read everything, but I did want to address the concerns about abuse. Like any other group there's always going to be bad people and mistakes in dealing with that, but the church is working really hard at preventing abuse.
In the UK over the last few years they've added windows into all the doors of our chapels (accept the toilets) so that there's no 'behind closed doors'. If an adult is talking to a child either another trusted adult must be in the room, or if the child asks for privacy they will stand outside but still in sight.
Anyone who works with children must do mandatory safeguarding training, which among other things makes it clear that any concerns must be reported to the police not just church authorities. And they've just made it mandatory that anyone working with children or vulnerable adults has a current CRB check.
Like I said, we aren't perfect no one is, but your children will not be in more danger living in a community with a high proportion of LDS.

PrimitivePerson · 19/09/2023 09:26

ZadocPDederick · 19/09/2023 08:53

Your comparator fairly obviously should not be the entire population but the school population. You also don't mention any statistics for pupils who aren't physically injured but who are mentally traumatised by school shootings.

In the UK, we still view one school shooting 27 years ago involving the killing of 17 people with utter horror. It is therefore somewhat difficult to be blasé about 25 people being killed in schools every year. And that is, of course, before you also take into account the horrific statistics for gun deaths and injuries overall.

Yeah, the chance of getting shot in a school should be a big fat zero. Obviously you can't prevent everything, but since Dunblane we took all the actions we could, and your chances of being shot in a British school are infinitesimally small. However "statistically insignificant" school shooting deaths are in the US, the chances of it happening are FAR higher than they are here, and no-one really seems to care about stopping it. It's hardly surprising British parents consider it a major problem.

PrimitivePerson · 19/09/2023 09:21

Gun related deaths per head of population are over 50 times lower in the UK than the US. This is why British people think it's a big deal. We just aren't used to guns at all over here. If you're a law abiding citizen in an average town, you'll never see one in everyday life.

ZadocPDederick · 19/09/2023 08:53

poetryandwine · 18/09/2023 20:05

Actually @Lastchancechica the data prove you wrong. The US Naval Postgraduate School has been keeping statistics.

I bow to no one in my horror of even one shooting death at a school. But from 1999 to earlier this year (24 years) the data in total were

440 people in total dead in school shootings. That includes perpetrators and police

Just under 1250 injured

Again this is a horror. But in a country of 350,000,000 people over a period of 24 years anything that kills fewer than 25 people per year on average is not a statistically significant killer.

Your comparator fairly obviously should not be the entire population but the school population. You also don't mention any statistics for pupils who aren't physically injured but who are mentally traumatised by school shootings.

In the UK, we still view one school shooting 27 years ago involving the killing of 17 people with utter horror. It is therefore somewhat difficult to be blasé about 25 people being killed in schools every year. And that is, of course, before you also take into account the horrific statistics for gun deaths and injuries overall.

Lastchancechica · 19/09/2023 08:38

poetryandwine · 18/09/2023 20:05

Actually @Lastchancechica the data prove you wrong. The US Naval Postgraduate School has been keeping statistics.

I bow to no one in my horror of even one shooting death at a school. But from 1999 to earlier this year (24 years) the data in total were

440 people in total dead in school shootings. That includes perpetrators and police

Just under 1250 injured

Again this is a horror. But in a country of 350,000,000 people over a period of 24 years anything that kills fewer than 25 people per year on average is not a statistically significant killer.

That is honestly a horrific statistic and if you don’t think so then that must be a desensitisation issue. Many of them will be children.

Ahos19 · 19/09/2023 08:31

You are not being unreasonable. This would be a huge move. Maybe most important to consider is schooling for your children especially your 12 year old, if they come back at age 15 the schooling would have been different. I think you would need to look into international schools rather than British schools on return. Utah is beautiful and has good skiing/hiking. Park City is a resort town. It is also primarily white. Many people are talking about LDS - which is the Mormon religion. Everyone I have met who is Mormon is lovely my only caution would be that a lot of socializing will be done through the church and you might feel left out and your kids might feel social pressure to join. We have friends who live there and love it and are not Mormon. It could be a super exciting adventure, you and your kids will probably adjust fairly quickly. Just strongly consider your kids educational path as they will not be prepared for the testing in the UK. (We are Americans living in the UK with two school aged kids). Good luck!

knitnerd90 · 19/09/2023 02:31

mathanxiety · 18/09/2023 22:12

Being behind is not at all a given, @knitnerd90. Socio-economic factors and frankly individual levels of intelligence play a huge part in determining where a child will find him or herself in terms of attainment.

If starting all day school at age 4 made a positive difference, we could expect to see England and Wales at the top of the international tables in education, and we don't.

What I would expect, though, is that American kids are behind for a while, but that they catch up eventually. Then the problem isn't that kids are behind; it's that the curricula become increasingly different and it gets harder to shift paths. I know that my oldest, who is quite bright (1st year at a very good university) definitely lagged a bit because of their late start. Overall I think it came out in the wash, though it gets hard to compare in later high school because of the different approaches.

Fifisneighbor · 19/09/2023 00:29

American here... I haven't been to Park City but it is known to be spectacular for outdoor activities, especially skiing. It's a very touristy area so even though it is Utah, I don't think you'll be quite as overwhelmed by the Mormon stuff as you would be in a smaller and less well-traveled town in Utah.

And also people saying America is not safe for women and it's so dangerous. Not true! I know the news is bad but that's their job to make you all think it's all doom and gloom. It's not. There are problems, like any country. And there are lovely people who would welcome you.

junbean · 18/09/2023 22:23

Ok I had to retract my first response, as I wasn’t thinking of kids being in school at first. I live in the same region as Utah. If you are a nature lover and are willing to homeschool, definitely go.

But, the fact is, active shooter drills and UK lockdown drills are not the same. Active shooter drills will traumatize your kids. The younger they are the worse it will be- they don’t know the drills aren’t real and actually believe someone is shooting up the school. I had to start homeschooling mine because of this. They’re going to carry that with them forever. I moved to a really safe cute little mountain town with almost no crime, and a few months ago my elderly neighbor was assaulted with a gun. I have countless other stories along the same lines. I grew up with guns and learned how to shoot + safety when I was in diapers. I’m not being emotional or political, gun violence is taking over the country. It doesn’t matter who you are or where you are from, if you live here it will affect you. I’m working on leaving for this and other reasons likely stated here by others. It’s just not a good place for women and children.

mathanxiety · 18/09/2023 22:12

Being behind is not at all a given, @knitnerd90. Socio-economic factors and frankly individual levels of intelligence play a huge part in determining where a child will find him or herself in terms of attainment.

If starting all day school at age 4 made a positive difference, we could expect to see England and Wales at the top of the international tables in education, and we don't.

Pipsquiggle · 18/09/2023 21:30

Are you coming back @Frenchcroissant?

MissNowt · 18/09/2023 21:13

Utah is a beautiful state & the people are really friendly. Go for it!

Totallyterrific · 18/09/2023 21:12

Im fascinated by Mormonism (from a critical perspective). Not a chance would I consider moving to Utah. Huge No. Even though it would mean I could have daily interactions on a topic that interests me. Massive huge NO!

knitnerd90 · 18/09/2023 21:08

Mm, I don't know I'd say "most" gun owners are responsible. The issue is that they all think they are okay, it's some other gun owner who is the problem.

There is massive regional variation in gun ownership and violence. The Mountain West, overall, is fairly high ownership for a bunch of reasons: western mystique, outdoors sports and hunting being very popular, and in rural areas, wildlife and protection. It can be a shock to people coming from Europe that there's pretty serious wildlife in a lot of the US and it comes pretty close to people. I have friends who live on the suburban/rural fringe and have had black bears walk through their yards.

Schools vary quite a bit from place to place so the generalisations about American education are useless. Kids here start full time education later (either in kindergarten or 1st grade depending on school district; the district we were in when oldest was in kindergarten still had half days). If a child isn't in full-time school until the equivalent of English year 2, then of course they'll be behind in years 5&6.

mathanxiety · 18/09/2023 20:44

Delphinium20 · 18/09/2023 18:40

I was just in a restaurant a few weeks ago and a car drove past and pops of gunfire came from it.

Granted, I live in a large city, but it's in a state with a very high standard of living. It's not all gloom and fear but gun deaths are not rare. So not sure where that idea that "most gun owners in the US are responsible" came from.

That stat of 60 gun deaths a year - I could only dream! As of August 1, there were 25,198 gun deaths in the US in 2023. In 2021 it was a total of 48,830.

While I can't count all the people I know of in my community who have died by gun deaths, I can count 3 who I considered very close friends and family.

The statement that most gun owners are responsible comes from observable reality. If barely any gun owners were responsible, the carnage would be unimaginable.

Your assertiom that it's a wild and lawless country otoh is based on one incident in which one or possibly two gun owners were not behaving responsibly.

The 60 gun deaths a year is a statistic from Utah, I believe. Most of those deaths were suicides.

Many neighborhoods of large cities are not safe. Many are places where you can safely leave your door unlocked at night. A relatively well off state can have pockets of deprivation. A relatively poor state can have pockets of affluence. In most states, there's a large middle group. It's a big country. Most states are bigger than the UK.