Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Young children on the train on their own...

133 replies

highlandcrusader · 13/09/2023 15:45

I'm on a train from SE to Scotland. 5 young children, ages between 2 - 13 I would say got on and settled on the seats near me (table seats area). They all looked absolutely exhausted and all feel asleep as soon as they sat down. There are no parents or carers anywhere near. Also, they smell quite bad, like they haven't washed in a while.
AIBU to think this is weird?

I know it's none of my business but it feels strange to me. Especially the little one who can't be older than 2 should not be on a train without an adult?

OP posts:
Needmorelego · 14/09/2023 10:10

@Lifeinlists I meant the thread has gone weird. Rather than helping the OP with advice about what to do it has just switched to something that really is a completely different subject and essentially has become irrelevant to the OP.
I like the way you say it "went on to a branch line" 😂🚂

Lifeinlists · 14/09/2023 10:04

@Needmorelego

Not 'weird' at all.
Someone said in the 1970s a 4 year old alone on a train, going to boarding school for the first time, with luggage, no experience of where she was going and 'struggling ' and 'sobbing', was ignored.

This was to illustrate that very young children did this, evidently routinely as no-one intervened, and haven't times changed as OP's scenario is now so different.

A few of us questioned the likelihood of the 1970 events as described. Hence the conversation went on to a branch line.

Needmorelego · 14/09/2023 09:20

This thread has gone weird. A person was worried about a group of children on a train but turns out they were with their Dad and all was fine - but now it's turned into a strange argument about whether or not 4 year olds got sent to boarding school by themselves back in the 70s.
What has something that may or may not happen over 50 years got to do with the OPs concerns?
Odd.

Lifeinlists · 14/09/2023 09:12

@sashh
My scepticism is about the tale of a 4 year old in England in the 1970s getting on a train alone, with luggage and no experience of her destination, managing to deal with all that and get off at the right place, "sobbing", and no-one intervening (or calling social services which did exist). I suspect accurate recall has faded over the years.

No indication that she was deaf or blind either - which would have made the scenario even more incredible.

As for a 4 year old at a mainstream boarding school in the 1970s; I'd be fascinated to know which one it was. Lowood School?

IsleofSkies · 14/09/2023 08:33

I roomed at Uni with a student whose parents had sent all 4 away to Boarding School , aged 5, so immediately post WW2.

Nope, not mainstream schools in the UK.
My friend who spent their entire education in boarding schools, including one of the top 3, was 'sent' away to school at 7, and was born in 1942.

Definitely a thing in the previous centuries - Mrs Austen , I believe sent her children away as babies and only had them back when they were more 'civilised'.

'Previous centuries' - like when? Before trains existed?

Barelybarefoot · 14/09/2023 07:43

My 16 year old can’t either 😂

sashh · 14/09/2023 03:32

@Lifeinlists

I worked with a Dr a number of years ago who's father used to travel between boarding school and his parent, I can't remember where the parents were, it could have been India. But he was basically put on a train and made his own way to the ship and other adults just kept a look out for him. This would have been pre WW II

Also in the 1970s schools for deaf children were mostly boarding school and children attended from age 4. Often they didn't know where they were going because their parents were hearing so communication was difficult.

Honeychickpea · 14/09/2023 01:45

In the book A Little Princess by Frances Hodgson Burnett published in 1905, the youngest girl at Miss Minchin's was Lottie, aged four.

Lifeinlists · 14/09/2023 01:21

@ElizaMulvil
Some upper class families sent babies to wet nurses in Jane Austen's time, and earlier. It wasn't uncommon but not all of them survived.

This doesn't equate with a tale of a lone 4 year old negotiating a train journey with luggage, finding a destination with no help and being ignored by all other adults whilst sobbing into the bargain. In the 1970s. When boarding for 4 year olds was not a thing and lone tiny children were not sent up chimneys. I suspect the friend's memory has been somewhat embroidered down the years as it's a good tale.

ElizaMulvil · 13/09/2023 22:54

I had a friend who went to boarding school with Nuns, aged 4 ( just pre war).
She left just before 7 when her aunt returned from Germany 1939 and insisted she came home again.

I guess it was more common earlier on. Her mother and aunt had gone at a similar age. ( Though with the 'excuse' that their mother had died so the father just kept the oldest one (9) at home to look after him.)

I roomed at Uni with a student whose parents had sent all 4 away to Boarding School , aged 5, so immediately post WW2.

Definitely a thing in the previous centuries - Mrs Austen , I believe sent her children away as babies and only had them back when they were more 'civilised'.

Missedmytoe · 13/09/2023 22:50

IsleofSkies · 13/09/2023 21:56

@Missedmytoe That is nonsense. Children aged 4 in the 70s did not go to boarding schools and travel alone on trains.

I was working then, and travelling by trains a lot across the UK.

I can only tell you what my friend told me. In all the time I have known them they've never lied to me.

They spent a lot of time as a child living in an orphanage - so perhaps it was there they went. Maybe they travelled with an older sibling who abandoned them on the train in favour of their friends. All I can relate is what they told me.

Again, I don't wish to derail OP's thread. Had I realised my comment would cause so much consternation I'd have not posted.

BadLad · 13/09/2023 22:48

I boarded at 6 in the 1980s, but it was unusual and there was only one other boy aged six. Lots of seven year-olds.

Maireas · 13/09/2023 22:38

Had you been a lost, sobbing 4 year old, people would have helped.

Wbeezer · 13/09/2023 22:31

Children as young as four certainly did board, usually when parents lived abroad but sometimes due to family circumstances. My elderly neighbour was sent to Scotland to board from Ceylon when she was four, never felt close to her parents after that.
I imagine it did linger on as a practice into the seventies in very small numbers, as a lot of old fashioned things did. Even now some boarding schools still mention occasionally taking children younger than seven in their blurb.
Also in the 70s I was put in charge of my younger siblings on a coach from Scotland to Cumbria, I was 11, they were 10 and 7. I remember finding it quite stressful as my brother started mucking about and I was very nervous of missing the bus after the toilet stop! Nobody checked we were OK, or spoke to us at all!

IsleofSkies · 13/09/2023 22:24

JudgeJ · 13/09/2023 22:17

I too don't believe it happened like that, even then there were limits about how young children could be to travel alone.

Exactly.

I have older friends who went to boarding schools at 7. There is no way a child of 4 is accepted at boarding school. There is no such thing.

I have friends who have taught in boarding schools since the 1970s (before they retired.)

A bit too much 'vivid imagination' at work on this thread.

JudgeJ · 13/09/2023 22:17

Spinningcats · 13/09/2023 20:29

A friend of mine was sent off to boarding school, quite alone, on a train, aged 4. This was back in the 70s and nobody took a blind bit of notice as they sobbed, struggled with their luggage, and had to find their destination station with no help.

I’ll file this in my ‘things that didn’t happen’ folder. The 70s wasn’t the bloody Middle Ages you know. People didn’t ignore sobbing 4 year olds. Or send them off to find a school they didn’t know how to find!

I too don't believe it happened like that, even then there were limits about how young children could be to travel alone.

IsleofSkies · 13/09/2023 21:56

@Missedmytoe That is nonsense. Children aged 4 in the 70s did not go to boarding schools and travel alone on trains.

I was working then, and travelling by trains a lot across the UK.

IsleofSkies · 13/09/2023 21:54

highlandcrusader · 13/09/2023 17:31

My friend's MIL boarded from the age 4 too. It really affected her. She was completely emotionally unavailable for her kids and unable to deal with or discuss any emotional issues in the family.

No boarding school in the Uk takes 4 year old boarders.

I have first hand knowledge.

The youngest is 7 - prep schools.

WimbyAce · 13/09/2023 21:50

LaurieFairyCake · 13/09/2023 19:29

Hmmm... 8 children is REALLY unusual

Do they all look to be from one family?

When we came home on the ferry Sat there was a family with 8 children so it is possible.

Maireas · 13/09/2023 21:09

Spinningcats · 13/09/2023 20:29

A friend of mine was sent off to boarding school, quite alone, on a train, aged 4. This was back in the 70s and nobody took a blind bit of notice as they sobbed, struggled with their luggage, and had to find their destination station with no help.

I’ll file this in my ‘things that didn’t happen’ folder. The 70s wasn’t the bloody Middle Ages you know. People didn’t ignore sobbing 4 year olds. Or send them off to find a school they didn’t know how to find!

It's clearly nonsense. A sobbing 4 year old ignored? Nope.
Also - with luggage? Negotiating trains? Maybe they were 14, not 4.

Riotact · 13/09/2023 20:47

For posters saying kids don’t smell. They do. I work with kids for over a decade. And I think parents become immune to kids smelling but lots of kids generally have a smell.

VaddaABeetch · 13/09/2023 20:34

How did. 4 year old find their destination, were they able to read it?

Spinningcats · 13/09/2023 20:29

A friend of mine was sent off to boarding school, quite alone, on a train, aged 4. This was back in the 70s and nobody took a blind bit of notice as they sobbed, struggled with their luggage, and had to find their destination station with no help.

I’ll file this in my ‘things that didn’t happen’ folder. The 70s wasn’t the bloody Middle Ages you know. People didn’t ignore sobbing 4 year olds. Or send them off to find a school they didn’t know how to find!

ireallycantthinkofaname · 13/09/2023 20:23

yeah, reported that one for gross and utterly unnecessary racial stereotyping which contributes bugger all to the thread.