Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

just got thrown out of a bar for having a (private) conversation with my friend about immigration

359 replies

Ozandtom · 01/09/2023 01:23

Just to give some background I am a child of an immigrant (my father) and my mothers parents both came from Ireland. Me and a friend met up this afternoon for lunch and a few drinks. We went to a local bar and ended up staying until last orders when it got quiet and we got on the subject of the state of the country and cost of living. I brought up how with the pressures on all our services were not helped by the amount of people coming into the country. Pointing out that we are a small island compared to the rest of the world and the people arriving on boats were reaching safe countries before making their journey here. My friend disagreed and said that this country was built on immigration to which I agreed but replied that we had seen such a massive increase in the last 20 years (something like 10 million). This is where we were interrupted by one of the bar staff who said he’d like us to finish our drinks and anyway he “didn’t like the tone of our conversation”. Me and my friend were shocked. We’ve never been asked to leave a bar due to a conversation we were having. She called it communism, I said it’s cancel culture. AIBU to think his reaction is completely out of order ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Aranas · 01/09/2023 18:33

Either your conversation truly was private and you were asked to leave for other reasons, or it wasn't private at all, and your misinformed views could be heard by the barman.

FWIW, yes you have freedom of speech, but if I owned an establishment and you were saying the same thing there, you would be told to voice your opinions elsewhere.

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 18:34

It is rather confusing people posting about small boats and at the same time worrying about the population of the UK having risen by about 10million in the past 30 years.

People crossing in small boats accounts for less than 1% of that increase.
Indeed even last year, where there was the highest number of small boats crossing, those people made up less than 8% of the net migrants to the UK in the year.

middler · 01/09/2023 18:36

Thedancingbear look all those things you mention contribute to the problem of pressures on services and maybe the OP will alter their viewpoint by reading your posts and others on here (or not) but if people can't even have conversations about these subjects no one develops their views, or shifts their views or understands there is a different way of looking at things. If conversations just get shut down there can be no development of viewpoints at all or exchange of different points of view. I think we just need to learn to respect difference a bit more and appreciate that people do hold views different to our own and we can have non hostile conversations about those views. I feel uninformed about this subject.I am a little more informed from reading some of these posts which can only be a good thing I support every single refugee on those boats coming in but I know not everyone takes my position. I just don't support people being shut down for expressing their viewpoint and I don't want to be the kid of arrogant twit who won't listen to anyone who does not agree with me.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 18:45

middler · 01/09/2023 18:36

Thedancingbear look all those things you mention contribute to the problem of pressures on services and maybe the OP will alter their viewpoint by reading your posts and others on here (or not) but if people can't even have conversations about these subjects no one develops their views, or shifts their views or understands there is a different way of looking at things. If conversations just get shut down there can be no development of viewpoints at all or exchange of different points of view. I think we just need to learn to respect difference a bit more and appreciate that people do hold views different to our own and we can have non hostile conversations about those views. I feel uninformed about this subject.I am a little more informed from reading some of these posts which can only be a good thing I support every single refugee on those boats coming in but I know not everyone takes my position. I just don't support people being shut down for expressing their viewpoint and I don't want to be the kid of arrogant twit who won't listen to anyone who does not agree with me.

But I (and another poster) are trying our hardest to engage in those conversations and all that's coming back is 'free speech innit, can't say nuffin'.

I was chided upthread for saying you couldn't win the hearts and minds of these people because they had no hearts or minds. Well, we've tried using facts and arguments, and PPs weirdly don't seem interested. I think my point is proved.

middler · 01/09/2023 18:53

Thedancingbear look you might not change someone's mind in one moment with a few posts because people tend not to do that but your posts and other posts do make people think about things and there is great value in that but the moment you say you can't win the hearts and minds of "these people because they had no hearts and minds, then people are less likely to listen to you because you are dismissing them for not immediately agreeing with you. I just think when we are respectful of each other and not dismissive there is room to develop our views on things, but you can't do that unless you are free to have the conversation.

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 19:06

If anyone does actually want to engage in a discussion about the pressures on public services, we could perhaps start by considering why the government which funds state schools has imposed on state schools a 43% increase since 2019 in employer pension contributions. A charge that immediately goes back to the government anyway, but the government of course has not funded that increase in costs that schools as employers have to pay. What impact do we think this change has had on the provision in state schools?

MalcolmsMiddle · 01/09/2023 19:07

Ozandtom · 01/09/2023 01:48

It’s relevant because living in a democracy means freedom of speech and opinions

You do have freedom of speech - you said your opinions. What you don't have is freedom from consequence. Maybe the barman over-reacted given the time and place but please don't confuse freedom of speech with being able to say what you want without reproach.

pointythings · 01/09/2023 19:12

If you're using the 'well, they've been through a safe country' argument then you're at best ignorant. Asylum seekers are not in any way legally obliged to seek asylum in the first safe country they come to.

And if the barman was asking other people to drink up and go, has it occurred to you that they wanted to get on with the job of cleaning and tidying so that they could actually go home when their shift finished? If everyone stayed until the last minute, that would have to be done after closing and it isn't as if bar work pays particularly well so why would anyone doing it want to go beyond their hours?

Couldyounot · 01/09/2023 19:28

We’ve never been asked to leave a bar due to a conversation we were having. She called it communism, I said it’s cancel culture.

A friend and I were asked to leave a pub in Exeter once for singing a Derek and Clive song. We got the harmonies right and everything. Nope. "Offensive and in bad taste" so out we went. Clearly we were being communistically cancelled.

And their beer was off, too.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 19:30

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 19:06

If anyone does actually want to engage in a discussion about the pressures on public services, we could perhaps start by considering why the government which funds state schools has imposed on state schools a 43% increase since 2019 in employer pension contributions. A charge that immediately goes back to the government anyway, but the government of course has not funded that increase in costs that schools as employers have to pay. What impact do we think this change has had on the provision in state schools?

While we're at it, the government has mandated (welcome and justified) pay rises for teachers this year and last. Schools are obliged to pay these, but the government has not given the schools any more funding to allow them to do this. So headteachers have just had to find the money via cuts. Net effect? Among other, bigger classes and fewer resources.

But overcrowding and pressure on public services are immigrants' fault, innit?

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 19:38

pointythings · 01/09/2023 19:12

If you're using the 'well, they've been through a safe country' argument then you're at best ignorant. Asylum seekers are not in any way legally obliged to seek asylum in the first safe country they come to.

And if the barman was asking other people to drink up and go, has it occurred to you that they wanted to get on with the job of cleaning and tidying so that they could actually go home when their shift finished? If everyone stayed until the last minute, that would have to be done after closing and it isn't as if bar work pays particularly well so why would anyone doing it want to go beyond their hours?

To be fair, as I understand it, the 'first safe country' point often invoked by anti-immigrant types is legally correct. We aren't obliged to take people from war-torn countries unless it happens to kick off in, say, France or Ireland.

But look at the conflict in Syria - the adjacent 'safe' countries include Turkey and Iraq (both shitshows to varying degrees); the wealthier countries bordering Syria are Lebanon (tiny) and Israel (trust I don't need to explain). The burden of refugees fleeing a war zone is significant, and I and lots of others think it's the moral thing for wealthier countries to take their 'fair share'. It's worth remembering that both France and Germany take more refugees than we do.

If people don't like that, then that's their prerogative, and they can vote for parties that are happier for the victims of war to die in camps in the desert. As I say, hearts and minds.

Isittimeformynapyet · 01/09/2023 19:43

BlackForestCake · 01/09/2023 12:10

It's not the job of bar staff to police other people's opinions. End of.

Suppose the shoe were on the other foot and you were asked to leave because a barman didn't like your opinion about Boris Johnson or the NHS or Palestine or strikes or Just Stop Oil?

Would that be acceptable? They can serve who they like, after all?

If the shoe were on the other foot surely OP would be kicking the barman out 🤔

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 19:51

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 19:38

To be fair, as I understand it, the 'first safe country' point often invoked by anti-immigrant types is legally correct. We aren't obliged to take people from war-torn countries unless it happens to kick off in, say, France or Ireland.

But look at the conflict in Syria - the adjacent 'safe' countries include Turkey and Iraq (both shitshows to varying degrees); the wealthier countries bordering Syria are Lebanon (tiny) and Israel (trust I don't need to explain). The burden of refugees fleeing a war zone is significant, and I and lots of others think it's the moral thing for wealthier countries to take their 'fair share'. It's worth remembering that both France and Germany take more refugees than we do.

If people don't like that, then that's their prerogative, and they can vote for parties that are happier for the victims of war to die in camps in the desert. As I say, hearts and minds.

Case law from 1999 upheld in the HoLs, makes clear that asylum seekers may apply for asylum having transited other countries first.

https://levinslaw.co.uk/dinghies-in-the-channel-illegal-entrants-and-immigration-offences/

I imagine those who drafted the Refugee Convention had in mind the fate of those on the St Louis when they made that provision.

Dinghies in the Channel - Illegal entrants and immigration offences - Levins

There is much controversy in the media at the moment about migrants crossing the Channel in dinghies. In this article, we set out to explain some of the relevant law and clear up some misconceptions. This article is intended to be a general commentary...

https://levinslaw.co.uk/dinghies-in-the-channel-illegal-entrants-and-immigration-offences

HulaChick · 01/09/2023 19:57

Totally agree with you and your line of conversation - we cannot, as a country, mop up all immigration influxes. To not be calloused to hold a point of view and be able to discuss it, even in a public place, is absolutely awful. For people to immediately jump up & down & shout 'bigot' is just a ridiculous reflex reaction. There are many issues around unchecked immigration. Everyone should be allowed & able to hold & discuss their opinions. To not be allowed to is a sad day for Society.

BrightLightTonight · 01/09/2023 20:00

People in this country died to protect our freedom of speech.

I believe that it was Voltaire who said “I disagree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it”

pointythings · 01/09/2023 20:01

@thedancingbear as far as I understand it, the point about first safe country is correct in UK law but not in international law under the Refugee Convention.
If UK law were applied, the UK would never have to accept any refugees, which would be appalling and immoral. Which makes UK law on this appalling and immoral, but that's what the UK is right now.

StefanosHill · 01/09/2023 20:04

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 19:38

To be fair, as I understand it, the 'first safe country' point often invoked by anti-immigrant types is legally correct. We aren't obliged to take people from war-torn countries unless it happens to kick off in, say, France or Ireland.

But look at the conflict in Syria - the adjacent 'safe' countries include Turkey and Iraq (both shitshows to varying degrees); the wealthier countries bordering Syria are Lebanon (tiny) and Israel (trust I don't need to explain). The burden of refugees fleeing a war zone is significant, and I and lots of others think it's the moral thing for wealthier countries to take their 'fair share'. It's worth remembering that both France and Germany take more refugees than we do.

If people don't like that, then that's their prerogative, and they can vote for parties that are happier for the victims of war to die in camps in the desert. As I say, hearts and minds.

How many would make you feel it’s enough to not be heartless?

Btw there is a charity that allows anyone to give a room to a Syrian refugee, which maybe some of the give up property posters do already

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 20:08

pointythings · 01/09/2023 20:01

@thedancingbear as far as I understand it, the point about first safe country is correct in UK law but not in international law under the Refugee Convention.
If UK law were applied, the UK would never have to accept any refugees, which would be appalling and immoral. Which makes UK law on this appalling and immoral, but that's what the UK is right now.

The UK government could of course try to apply UK law in that way, but it expected that the courts would bring such a prosecution to a halt due to the UKs obligations under international law.

In other words whilst UK law doesn't have provision for asylum seekers to cross safe countries, whilst the UK is part of the refugee convention, those seeking asylum can cross safe countries and apply for asylum in the UK.

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 20:28

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 19:06

If anyone does actually want to engage in a discussion about the pressures on public services, we could perhaps start by considering why the government which funds state schools has imposed on state schools a 43% increase since 2019 in employer pension contributions. A charge that immediately goes back to the government anyway, but the government of course has not funded that increase in costs that schools as employers have to pay. What impact do we think this change has had on the provision in state schools?

I am surprised that no one wants to engage in such a discussion this evening.

I look forward to having the opportunity to discuss the ways in which the government has ensured schools are underfunded and then encouraged people to blame migrants for the situation tomorrow.

lollipoprainbow · 01/09/2023 20:33

HulaChick · 01/09/2023 19:57

Totally agree with you and your line of conversation - we cannot, as a country, mop up all immigration influxes. To not be calloused to hold a point of view and be able to discuss it, even in a public place, is absolutely awful. For people to immediately jump up & down & shout 'bigot' is just a ridiculous reflex reaction. There are many issues around unchecked immigration. Everyone should be allowed & able to hold & discuss their opinions. To not be allowed to is a sad day for Society.

Agreed and there's some very aggressive nasty posters on here sneering at anyone with a different opinion to them.

Lovepeaceunderstanding · 01/09/2023 20:37

Ozandtom · 01/09/2023 01:42

Actually no closing time was 12, last orders 11 and this was 11:30. He didn’t like what I was saying so asked us to leave. I wasn’t being offensive, just my view of things in a private conversation. Are we not living in a democracy?

@Ozandtom
you were not being unreasonable at all but some people seem to find freedom of speech and thought unacceptable. Scary isn’t it?

phoenixrosehere · 01/09/2023 20:53

You’re in a public place, not your own home so no, it wasn’t a private conversation. It was a conversation you chose to have in public. Plus as you said, it was quiet and last orders, and the barman could hear it, anyone else around could likely hear it too.

It is not “cancel culture” or loss of your freedom of speech to boot you out of a private establishment for discussing a known controversial topic that can get very heated between people especially in a place that serves alcohol. The bar staff might have experienced this topic coming up and had issues in the past with it resorting to aggressive behaviours and rather than just wait to see how it plays out, nip it in the bud before anything starts.

Moonwatcher1234 · 01/09/2023 21:50

middler · 01/09/2023 17:53

Yes this.

"Closing down conversations does not achieve harmony, it just breeds resentment."

I think some of the Brexit voters were giving a big two fingers up to the people of the UK(many seen on this thread) who look down their nose at anyone who does not hold their specific views as being uneducated or lacking literacy. It is so arrogant to just dismiss people because they don't hold your viewpoint and to see your viewpoint as being the right one and people absolutely hate it. I think we need to listen to others rather than just shut them down as if only our take on things is valid.

I am not even agreeing with the overall OP's viewpoint, I am simply defending her right to express it and getting told I am uneducated, can't think for myself.This attitude is what is polarising people in the UK, also in the US.

Well that’s not true is it - you have repeatedly been expressing agreement with OP view until you were busted for posting old links and skewed stats.

minou123 · 01/09/2023 22:40

BrightLightTonight · 01/09/2023 20:00

People in this country died to protect our freedom of speech.

I believe that it was Voltaire who said “I disagree with what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it”

If you're talking about the UK, then no, we dont have "freedom of speech".
We never have. So, nobody died to protect it, because we never had it to begin with.

Also, Voltaire didn't say that.

BrightLightTonight · 01/09/2023 23:40

minou123 · 01/09/2023 22:40

If you're talking about the UK, then no, we dont have "freedom of speech".
We never have. So, nobody died to protect it, because we never had it to begin with.

Also, Voltaire didn't say that.

Edited

We have had freedom of speech - not so much now days 🤬

And I did say I wasn’t sure if it was Voltaire, would be good if you could confirm who actually made the quote, rather than just slag me off for mis-naming. Or are you just happy to be superior?