Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

just got thrown out of a bar for having a (private) conversation with my friend about immigration

359 replies

Ozandtom · 01/09/2023 01:23

Just to give some background I am a child of an immigrant (my father) and my mothers parents both came from Ireland. Me and a friend met up this afternoon for lunch and a few drinks. We went to a local bar and ended up staying until last orders when it got quiet and we got on the subject of the state of the country and cost of living. I brought up how with the pressures on all our services were not helped by the amount of people coming into the country. Pointing out that we are a small island compared to the rest of the world and the people arriving on boats were reaching safe countries before making their journey here. My friend disagreed and said that this country was built on immigration to which I agreed but replied that we had seen such a massive increase in the last 20 years (something like 10 million). This is where we were interrupted by one of the bar staff who said he’d like us to finish our drinks and anyway he “didn’t like the tone of our conversation”. Me and my friend were shocked. We’ve never been asked to leave a bar due to a conversation we were having. She called it communism, I said it’s cancel culture. AIBU to think his reaction is completely out of order ?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Clymene · 01/09/2023 10:27

@thedancingbear Yes I'm saying that. I find it quite astounding that I have to spell it out to you because I'm mystified how you jumped to that conclusion in the first place.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 10:33

Clymene · 01/09/2023 10:27

@thedancingbear Yes I'm saying that. I find it quite astounding that I have to spell it out to you because I'm mystified how you jumped to that conclusion in the first place.

I apologise, I misunderstood you.

But I don't agree that we are under some kind of moral or practical obligation towards racists to treat them like reasonable human beings. Arseholes will be arseholes, and they have more power if we entertain their views. It allows them to drag the Overton window over to the nasty bit of the right, and I think it increases not reduces the risk of an extremist cohort actually getting some power.

The whole question's an interesting one, but I don't think this is the place for it, what with all the pigeons shitting everywhere.

RadishAndTwiglet · 01/09/2023 10:41

I do mean can't or won't listen. Various posters throughout this thread have made sensible arguments and drawn people's attention to facts and information, and they have largely been ignored. Look at any other thread on this site on the subject and the same pattern is there.

That's not evidence that people can't or won't listen. Just because they aren't responding to let you know they've changed their minds, or that you've educated them a bit or given them food for thought on something doesn't mean they aren't listening. They are continuing to bat for their own side, making their own points heard, as are you, I am going to assume. People don't generally back down and admit defeat in any debate in the moment, but you have no idea whether, in some people, you might be making headway in small incremental steps. To say people are heartless and mindless is a very extreme and histrionic response to not managing to get people to fully accept your POV on this particular subject.

CherryMaDeara · 01/09/2023 10:42

it got quiet

I brought up how with the pressures on all our services were not helped by the amount of people coming into the country.

Pointing out that we are a small island compared

It sounds like you started speaking loudly enough for others to hear so you could either (i) have people agreeing with you or (ii) kick off a fight.

It also sounds like you thought you were being interviewed (e.g. 'brought up', 'pointed out'). Have you been practising this speech with a hairbrush in case you get interviewed by GB News?

Justneedagirlname · 01/09/2023 10:54

middler · 01/09/2023 06:30

I think you will find it is a lot more than 1.2 million people coming into the UK over ten years closer to 3.5 million. The issues that come with an expanding population are significant and not simply solved by a few governmental decisions as they affect the very infrastructure of a country, so you need far more homes, more schools (more teachers and that is such a poorly paid stressful job no one wants to do it anymore), more roads, more doctor surgeries, more hospital wards. Maybe a significantly higher tax rate for all of us could begin to address those issues-everyone up for that? Because improving the infrastructure costs a lot of money which is why governments avoid it as it won't get them voted back into power. The point is two people should be able to have a conversation without being policed by the righteous squad.

Yes, you need all of that, and government is not doing anything. They are not even maintaining existing infrastructure. They have been in power for 13 years now, with abysmal results. If you underinvest by 5% every year, the compounding effect over 10+ years is staggering.

However this is needed regardless of immigration- even if population is just naturally increasing or ageing - and that’s my point. Immigration of younger people who work and pay taxes (and some are high earners and some are working in public services) isn’t the main problem here.

in fact NHS is crumbling ALSO because many immigrants who worked there went home (and if the government took their heads out of their a* they would at least increase both numbers of university/training places for doctors and nurses back in 2016 (SEVEN years ago!), and increased NHS salaries to keep the staff. Right now they are behaving like absolute morons, no wonder the people working for NHS are leaving in droves.

And issues with food supply chain were also caused by lack of immigrant workers. You can’t have your cake and eat it.

they wasted ‘fat years’ from 2010 when country recovered from the recession by continuing with austerity, then wasted billions by bringing on Brexit without a plan (so for 6 years they were fighting instead of actually governing the country) and now post Brexit and post Covid we are in lean years with no money and 13 years under investment.
The taxes are already very high on earners, they need to start taxing wealth.

so: if you want to reduce immigration you need to have a proper plan how are going to manage without these pesky immigrants. And you STILL will end up with stretched public services if you don’t invest into them.

Beezknees · 01/09/2023 10:57

You're free to say whatever you like, but bar owners are free to refuse service to whoever they like as well.

zingally · 01/09/2023 11:01

If one of the bar staff could hear your conversation, then it wasn't as private as you thought.

Greywhippet · 01/09/2023 11:22

Blanketsburg · 01/09/2023 07:52

Empty words, but I'm sure they make you feel good 👍

Picking on someone for their English means you took the low road. Own it.

its fair game- if someone who is moaning about immigration can’t correctly use their own language when most immigrants are at least bilingual and often highly educated then that’s particularly funny.

Greywhippet · 01/09/2023 11:26

Clymene · 01/09/2023 09:36

It occurs to me that some of the sneering on this thread is exactly what enabled Mosley to get such a toehold. You'd think we'd have moved on since then and 100 years on, some people have learned nothing.

Don’t be so ridiculous. Economic issues and friends in high places enabled Mosley to get a toe hold, not ‘sneering’. People who whinge on about immigration are hardly a beleaguered and marginalised group when pretty much the entire popular media is anti- immigrant and both major parties are bending over backwards to woo the bigots

Clymene · 01/09/2023 11:46

@Greywhippet it enabled him to gain support from white working classes.

And Gordon Brown made exactly the same mistake in 2010 which was a massive contribution to Cameron's election success and the rest of us having to endure 13 years of Tory shit rule.

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 12:02

RadishAndTwiglet · 01/09/2023 08:26

OP said:

I brought up how with the pressures on all our services were not helped by the amount of people coming into the country.

As not every immigrant is an NHS doctor or nurse, or a teacher, and we know we have an massive shortage of decent, affordable housing in the UK, this statement is pretty much true. You can argue all you like about the wider reasons or solutions, but it's pretty accurate to say that more people creates more pressure on public services, when expansion of intrastructure, the NHS etc., hasn't kept pace with the expansion of the population. And not everyone who comes into the country (or their future offspring) is going to be a net contributor to our system. That's fine, not everyone is going to be a high earner and we need people to do the essential, lower earning jobs too. But to use the argument that most immigrants are young and will therefore 'contribute' to the tax pot is a bit of a fallacy really. In real terms, if you take more out by way of public services and in-work benefits, child benefit, HB, etc, then regardless of the fact that you pay your taxes, you are actually a net beneficiary of the system, not a net contributor. The problem comes when we have too many of the latter and not enough of the former.

Pointing out that....the people arriving on boats were reaching safe countries before making their journey here

Also true. It's just true. Not an opinion. Simply a plain old fashioned fact. We know all the arguments about why it shouldn't matter in some people's eyes, but it doesn't make the statement any less true.

My friend disagreed and said that this country was built on immigration to which I agreed but replied that we had seen such a massive increase in the last 20 years (something like 10 million).

Forget the arguments about net migration cancelling out some of the figures for net immigration. It's irrelevant. Let's just look at numbers in the country now, compared to 30 years ago.

From the Office For National Statistics: The UK population at mid-year 2021 was estimated to be 67.0 million, an increase of 3.7 million (5.9%) on the population in mid-2011.

In 1993, 30 years ago, the population of the UK was 57, 647, 463.

Today it's estimated to be 67, 736,802. That's an increase of over 10 million.

By 2053 it's estimated to be around 71, 800,000. So in the next thirty years that's an increase of another 4m +

If you are going to hold bigoted views, you may have to accept that other people don't want to be subjected to them

How do we know that the OP said anything bigoted? From what she's said here I only see facts. Not views or opinions.

I don't talk to people with your views.

That pretty much sums up every single thing that has gone wrong in western culture over the last few years. A generation of young people who think refusing to engage at all with anyone who holds different views to them with is a healthy way to understand one another.

I would have been offended if I overheard your conversation. You were/are offensive

How? By stating some facts? If facts offend you then you have the problem, not the OP.

You're unreasonable and ignorant and the stats you quite are wild fantasties peddled by others. There were not stats quoted as such, the OP estimated that the population had grown 'by something like 10 million' in the last 20 years. However, a quick google at official government websites and the ONS will show you that her estimate is not so far off. pretty It's something like 8m in the last 20 years, but over 10m in the last 30 years.

And as I said above, the people arriving on boats having travelled through safe, non-war torn countries where they could have claimed asylum is also true. So there hasn't really been any 'wild fantasy peddled by others' has there?

If you have loud racist or xenophobic conversations in public, you have to accept the consequences OP.

I agree about having loud drunken debates, it's annoying to have to listen to them when you are trying to mind your own business. But there is absolutely no evidence here that the OP said a single thing that was racist or xenophobic. She may well have done, but we don't know because we weren't there. Certainly from what she has told us here, she hasn't said a single racist or xenophobic thing. It is not racist or xenophobic per se to have opinions or concerns on levels of immigration, pressures on public services and housing, and future population projections. If you think that it is, then you are a huge part of the problem.

It’s sad that people so intelligent, like you, are duped into thinking there’s ‘millions’ of people coming to our country. There isn’t, there’s so very few asylum seekers compared to our population…

Millions of people 'coming'? In the present tense? Where did the OP ever say that? She talked about the millions of people who have already come. You are putting words in the OP's mouth.

When people talk about 'millions' in immigration terms, they don't just mean current immigration figures in the here and now,. They mean the amount accumulated over previous years, their offspring born in the UK and future projections that affect our population size as a whole. If do wish, when people want to have a proper debate about the pros and cons of mass immigration, that the people in the 'for' camp would at least listen to what people in the 'against' camp actually say, and not just respond to what you think they mean. Coming at it from the angle of 'you must be a pretty stupid racist and a xenophobe' is not very helpful or very clever.

At the risk of introducing some facts again to this discussion.
There are estimated to be over a million empty homes in England.

Also worth noting that travelling through safe countries is irrelevant to UK and international law on asylum seeking.

See https://levinslaw.co.uk/dinghies-in-the-channel-illegal-entrants-and-immigration-offences/

for a more detailed discussion of this.

I presume anyone who wants to discuss safe countries, will follow it to its logical conclusion and argue that the UK should withdraw from the UN Convention on refugees.

Dinghies in the Channel - Illegal entrants and immigration offences - Levins

There is much controversy in the media at the moment about migrants crossing the Channel in dinghies. In this article, we set out to explain some of the relevant law and clear up some misconceptions. This article is intended to be a general commentary...

https://levinslaw.co.uk/dinghies-in-the-channel-illegal-entrants-and-immigration-offences

biscuiteer · 01/09/2023 12:04

Museya15 · 01/09/2023 07:05

Why are they hard baked beliefs, I'm stating fact!?

Do you buy your bread on the thick side? 🙄

As for stating facts, no you are not stating any facts.

  1. Learn how to use the two different words bred and bread
  2. Look up fact versus opinion.
  3. Stop reading shite.
Catsmere · 01/09/2023 12:09

SapphireSeptember · 01/09/2023 09:38

Since when was France a war torn country? I know up to 1945 it was, and I know Paris can be scary, but I've missed those threads, so...

Yeah, iirc it was about people having to go through war-torn countries en route to Britain and posters pointing out that protests in France really don't put it into that category.

BlackForestCake · 01/09/2023 12:10

It's not the job of bar staff to police other people's opinions. End of.

Suppose the shoe were on the other foot and you were asked to leave because a barman didn't like your opinion about Boris Johnson or the NHS or Palestine or strikes or Just Stop Oil?

Would that be acceptable? They can serve who they like, after all?

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 12:13

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 12:02

At the risk of introducing some facts again to this discussion.
There are estimated to be over a million empty homes in England.

Also worth noting that travelling through safe countries is irrelevant to UK and international law on asylum seeking.

See https://levinslaw.co.uk/dinghies-in-the-channel-illegal-entrants-and-immigration-offences/

for a more detailed discussion of this.

I presume anyone who wants to discuss safe countries, will follow it to its logical conclusion and argue that the UK should withdraw from the UN Convention on refugees.

There's really no point in posting facts. They're not interested.

But it's also worth noting that we're on track for around 15,000 small boat crossings this year (we're currently on 11,000ish, but the peak has passed).

At this rate, and assuming 4 people per house, it would take two and a half centuries for them to fill up the existing empty housing stock in this country.

The population has risen over recent years, owing to a variety of factors, many of which apply worldwide. But this is overwhelmingly not being driven by asylum seekers.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 12:15

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 12:13

There's really no point in posting facts. They're not interested.

But it's also worth noting that we're on track for around 15,000 small boat crossings this year (we're currently on 11,000ish, but the peak has passed).

At this rate, and assuming 4 people per house, it would take two and a half centuries for them to fill up the existing empty housing stock in this country.

The population has risen over recent years, owing to a variety of factors, many of which apply worldwide. But this is overwhelmingly not being driven by asylum seekers.

It's also worth remembering that many asylum seekers are young and from the middle classes (it takes money to get from Syria to the UK). Many speak good English. There will always be bad eggs, but on the whole these are people who can help build our economy, not weigh it down. If we give them the chance.

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 12:16

Greywhippet · 01/09/2023 11:26

Don’t be so ridiculous. Economic issues and friends in high places enabled Mosley to get a toe hold, not ‘sneering’. People who whinge on about immigration are hardly a beleaguered and marginalised group when pretty much the entire popular media is anti- immigrant and both major parties are bending over backwards to woo the bigots

Shall we discuss Daily Mail headlines at this point?

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 12:17

BlackForestCake · 01/09/2023 12:10

It's not the job of bar staff to police other people's opinions. End of.

Suppose the shoe were on the other foot and you were asked to leave because a barman didn't like your opinion about Boris Johnson or the NHS or Palestine or strikes or Just Stop Oil?

Would that be acceptable? They can serve who they like, after all?

If I was mouthing off about any controversial subject in an inappropriate manner and place then yes, it could raise eyebrows.

And it's the bar staffs' employer who gets to decide what their job is. End of.

jgw1 · 01/09/2023 12:22

Catsmere · 01/09/2023 12:09

Yeah, iirc it was about people having to go through war-torn countries en route to Britain and posters pointing out that protests in France really don't put it into that category.

For reasons that I hope are obvious to all, whenever someone talks about safe countries and asylum seekers travelling through them my mind turns to the St Louis.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MS_St._Louis

MS St. Louis - Wikipedia

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MS_St._Louis

ToWhitToWhoo · 01/09/2023 15:07

BlackForestCake · 01/09/2023 12:10

It's not the job of bar staff to police other people's opinions. End of.

Suppose the shoe were on the other foot and you were asked to leave because a barman didn't like your opinion about Boris Johnson or the NHS or Palestine or strikes or Just Stop Oil?

Would that be acceptable? They can serve who they like, after all?

If I was shouting about it in an uncontrolled fashion, yes, they'd have the right.

It's not their job to police people's opinions, but it is their job to police people's behaviour.

ToWhitToWhoo · 01/09/2023 15:31

Clymene · 01/09/2023 11:46

@Greywhippet it enabled him to gain support from white working classes.

And Gordon Brown made exactly the same mistake in 2010 which was a massive contribution to Cameron's election success and the rest of us having to endure 13 years of Tory shit rule.

So you believe in cancel culture? You want everyone who disagrees with you to shut up, and if they don't, then they will cause hard-right-wingers and fascists to gain control? You regard all disagreement as 'sneering'? OK, but then don't present yourself as a champion of free speech, because you're the opposite!!!!

And Oswald Mosley (who was incidentally as upper-class and elitist as you could get) and his fascists certainly didn't start out as mainly concerned with immigration, which was not a big thing in the 1920s and 30s. They latched on to that many years later. Their big thing in the 20s and 30s was antisemitism and support for Jew-hating Europaean leaders like Hitler and Mussolini. Should everyone have just shut up about any disagreements with that????

As for Gordon Brown, he was never expected to win the 2010 election, and the main reason was the economic downturn, which was caused by the global banking crisis, but the sitting local PM always gets the blame. Perceptions of his personality did not help, but it's not as though Labour would have won if not for that one incident!

Clymene · 01/09/2023 15:36

@ToWhitToWhoo - what? Not at all. I'm not the person calling for people to be kicked out of bars for making ignorant and ill informed statements. I think people should be platformed. It's only by letting people speak that you can counter their arguments.

My point was about the sneering going on in this thread. People were slagging off a poster for typing bread rather than bred and saying she was thick.

Ad hominem arguments are usually a last resort rather than a first. And when you've got an army of facts to counter some of these baseless assertions, it seems counter productive to start out looking like you've not got anything in your arsenal.

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 15:49

Clymene · 01/09/2023 15:36

@ToWhitToWhoo - what? Not at all. I'm not the person calling for people to be kicked out of bars for making ignorant and ill informed statements. I think people should be platformed. It's only by letting people speak that you can counter their arguments.

My point was about the sneering going on in this thread. People were slagging off a poster for typing bread rather than bred and saying she was thick.

Ad hominem arguments are usually a last resort rather than a first. And when you've got an army of facts to counter some of these baseless assertions, it seems counter productive to start out looking like you've not got anything in your arsenal.

I don't think people were 'slagging her off' in fairness. I think they were taking the piss. They weren't trying to make a serious point against the PP, because it would be wasted effort.

Racists have no intellect or compassion. You will get nowhere by appealing either to their heads or their hearts, because they don't exist.

ToWhitToWhoo · 01/09/2023 15:55

thedancingbear · 01/09/2023 07:57

There's no point in arguing with them because they are impervious to critical thinking, or to facts (cf. plenty of people have been more factual and constructive on this thread, and the posts are largely ignored). What I can do in the limited time available is point out the almost universal connection between racism and poor literacy.

Not sure. I think that poor literacy is associated with not being good at disguising one's racism. There are plenty of highly educated racists, but they are more likely to know how to get away with their racist comments by expressing them in more subtle language. Still racist, however.

neverbeenskiing · 01/09/2023 15:56

If I was trying to enjoy a quiet drink in a bar and someone started spouting racist nonsense loudly enough for me to hear, I would probably leave. You obviously weren't being subtle, if the barman could hear you then other customers will have been able to. Maybe he could see that you were annoying others and didn't want to lose business, or maybe he just didn't want to listen to you scape-goating immigrants because he found it offensive. Either way, good on him. It's not like you were man-handled out of the place, insulted or treated aggressively, he calmly asked you to finish your drink and leave. Free speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences, so if you go choose to express bigoted views in public then you need to accept the possibility that some people will want to distance themselves.