Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

has anyone managed to pay for private school on a lowish salary? I am so worried about ds going to state school

916 replies

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:31

Me and ex are divorced. DS is 3.5. Ex pays me 700 a month, he never sees DS so obviously that amount would change if he did start to see him.

I have been to some schools near here to look at them because if ds does go to a private school then I would want him to go to the nursery part too, from the word go. At the moment he goes to a nursery near the house which is average at best, despite an outstanding ofstead rating.

The schools are awful. There are so many kids. Barely any smartly dressed. Seems to be no order and organisation. Pick up is 3:20 (?!) so god knows what would happen to my job.

I really really want him to go to private school and the one I’ve seen is around 18k a year for primary. Has anyone done this on a low salary and if so how? Did you move house or downsize etc. I don’t want to do anything extreme but my priority is this and I would do what it takes it there’s a way.

OP posts:
cheekyduck · 16/08/2023 21:18

RoseslnTheHospital · 16/08/2023 21:10

@cheekyduck "Mine were learning French, having music lessons, having authors come in to give talks, access to a huge library, all before they were even 5 at Pre-Prep."

The state primary my children attend does French, music lessons, authors coming in to give talks, a big library...... I don't think that's massively unusual, at least not in the south east of England.

That's great , but the one I was offered had no dedicated language teacher, or music teacher or even music room, the library was a just a room about as big as a large living room .

I said in my post its a great school, its rated outstanding , but it comes down to resource. I'm not saying 'Prep is better', mine just has better resource than the state down the road.

I also have lots of contacts in teaching and know its a shit show for many teachers in state primaries , forgetting the pupils and parents and social problems, the interference from Gov and new initiatives, shit pay, teachers at Primary school don't strike easily.

RoRosmama · 16/08/2023 21:17

@Butterflyfluff

strongly believe that if you can’t afford the lifestyle that goes with private schooling, then you shouldn’t do it.

Nothing worse than being the kid who can’t join in with anything that has a cost because there’s no money left after paying the basic fees.

This!!!

Couldn't agree more. My cousins went to a private school, paid for by a wealthy family member. They didn't have the lifestyle, fancy cars, nice big house etc and they were snubbed by a lot of the students and parents. They suffered a lot.
I too went to a private school and hated it and we had money.
Each to their own I guess. I firmly believe if you want to learn it doesn't matter where you go.

Punkyskullyy · 16/08/2023 21:17

LazyGaaGaa · 16/08/2023 21:10

I have no experience of private schooling.

My 3 children attend the local state primary school. It's disorganised chaos on a good day and communication is utterly dire. The uniform policy is ridiculously strict: shirt and tie, itchy knit jumpers, tailored trousers, socks must match trouser colour and coats must match jumper colour. Hair tied up at all times.

Recent Ofsted was "outstanding" and the SATS results are consistently in the top 5% of the country.

There are children in each of my childrens classes who don't wear the uniform, don't own school shoes and do not wear a coat in winter months.

There are children who turn up to school with dirty faces and messy hair. There are children with very poor personal hygiene.

There is a child who wears the same boots all year round since starting school, they are obviously several sizes too big and the laces have fallen out long ago.

There is a child who wore their father's shorts to every swimming lesson.

I could go on and on but you cannot judge a child or a school on appearance.

Young children don't have a say in how they appear, or whether their hair and clothes are clean or their shoes are polished. They are children. There may be other reasons as to why a child appears untidy; they may not tolerate their hair being brushed or the feel of their school uniform against skin.

Their parents may not have been taught basic skills, they may not afford uniform and haircuts or they may just simply not care!

In our experience, these "non smart" looking children are of the kindest in the class with great morals and values. They're the children that others want to be around because of who they are inside, not their exterior.

These children are turning up every day to access the national curriculum that they're entitled to and that is all that matters.

👏🏼

MarshyMcMarshFace · 16/08/2023 21:16

unhw · 16/08/2023 20:45

Really not sure why people are so offended by me simply asking how I could do something to give my ds the best start in life. Some of the posts are crazy.

Not ‘offended’.

Your thread title and OP do not actually talk about a best start, you say you are ‘so worried about Ds going to state school’, half your reasoning being that few children are ‘smartly dressed’.

It makes you sound ridiculous (‘so worried’ about the schooling 93% of children experience) and snobby

People telling you that doesn’t make them ‘offended’.

Augend23 · 16/08/2023 21:14

saffy2 · 16/08/2023 20:57

As a household we earn £45k a year. Two of us. Together. And I wouldn’t even class us a low income household 😂😂😂😂😂😂 it is absolutely bat shit crazy that this woman earns 76k alone and thinks she’s on a ‘lowish’ income. She’s extremely privileged and extremely deluded.

The average full time salary is just under £30k now, so two average incomes would give a household income of £60k, or around £1900 each assuming a 5% pension contribution and a student loan.

Assuming the same thing on a salary of £76k, that's £3900, or almost the same amount as two people earning 30k in spite of her salary being £16k more. I don't think this is wrong - we tax on an individual basis in the UK not a household basis and I don't have a problem with that. But it does mean single parent households have similar problems to single income households but without the choices that go alongside it.

The minimum wage for a 40 hour week is now £21k, so £45k for a two income household is only a little over two full-time minimum wage incomes - so while it's great that you feel comfortable on that, it seems quite feasible some households won't.

WhiteFire · 16/08/2023 21:14

RoseslnTheHospital · 16/08/2023 21:10

@cheekyduck "Mine were learning French, having music lessons, having authors come in to give talks, access to a huge library, all before they were even 5 at Pre-Prep."

The state primary my children attend does French, music lessons, authors coming in to give talks, a big library...... I don't think that's massively unusual, at least not in the south east of England.

It happens in my deprived corner of the north east too.

MichaelAndEagle · 16/08/2023 21:14

Your panic and desperation is reminiscent of some people I know who have only known the rarified world of private education and cannot fathom how anyone could cope with the horrors of state education.

Agree with this.

I also agree with PPs that have said it is common for GPs to pay for private school. Are you sure they won't help you out if this is so important to you?

Flatulence · 16/08/2023 21:13

If you can't afford it right now, how on earth might you afford it when your child is older with the corresponding higher fees? 18k now will likely be getting towards 30k plus by the time your child is in senior school; the senior schools near me are already 25k ish for day boys and girls.
Is your salary likely to rise significantly in the next decade?
Its worth noting that in Key Stage 1, private primaries don't really offer any advantage over state schools, other than smaller class sizes.
You mention the extended day; many state primaries offer wrap-around care for a relatively small fee and/or most parents look at using childminder who picks up/drops off at your chosen school.
Fee-paying schools also tend to have longer holidays (typically 18 weeks versus 12 weeks). Have you accounted for that extra cost?
Academically a lot of fee-paying schools frankly aren't that good. Yes, some are excellent, but a lot are - for want of a better word - crap (full of kids that are rich but thick, IYKYK).
Looking ahead, there's also a really significant drugs culture in some fee-paying senior schools, and not just in urban areas (my husband boarded at a major public school in the 90s and there was huge use of class A drugs; as far as he's heard nothing much has changed. And I have heard similar from friends who attended day and boarding schools in various parts of the country and from friends and colleagues whose children have attended/looked at attending fee-paying schools near me).
You also need to think about the wider social aspect.
Yes, your parents might be able to support with things like nice clothes and holidays, but will your son feel embarrassed about where you live because it's not as flash as his mates' houses? A uni friend of mine was at a fee playing school and told me that in her whole time at senior school she never ever invited friends over as she lived above a Chinese takeaway.
Obviously, it's entirely your choice. But if you're determined to send your child to a fee-paying school wouldn't it be better to squirrel away as much money now and put that towards fees when he's older as that's where a private education can make the biggest difference. Anything in which you feel a state school lacks can be mitigated for via extra-curricular pursuits (music, sports, languages etc.) and you'd still be quids in. That'd also give you time to see what he's good at/interested in and pick a school that suits him best and pursue a bursary to boot.

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:12

You certainly do not get wrap around care at most state schools. Some at best. Parents absolutely choose private schools for wrap around care.

This must be location specific

Packageholiday · 16/08/2023 21:11

Op you are covering many mn trip /trigger wires here.

Seemingly putting state school down, purporting to be on a low salary and so on.

If it helps I asked a similar one question about bursary a long time e ago and I'm on a truly lower salary with no richest parents and the comments were also extremely challenging.

Sugargliderwombat · 16/08/2023 21:11

unhw · 16/08/2023 20:45

Really not sure why people are so offended by me simply asking how I could do something to give my ds the best start in life. Some of the posts are crazy.

I'm not offended but it's not necessarily the best start. Is it really worth crippling yourself financially? Adding stress ? Would you child not potentially have a better start if you could have a couple of days a week off? I think people are offended that you assume it's a better start than their children have had, but it isn't necessarily.

cheekyduck · 16/08/2023 21:11

Isitautumnyet23 · 16/08/2023 21:04

The thing about private school is it will not just be the cost of the fees, but everything will be more expensive on top of that (speaking as someone who went to one). I wouldn’t want to be spending every last penny on fees because there are going to be alot more expenses on top of that (uniform, transport, school trips etc). Also, the friends they mix with will most likely be fairly well off (I know there are kids whose grandparents pay, overseas forces kids etc so not everyone is wealthy), but a large proportion of kids are.

Trust me, the teachers are no better in a private school than in a state school. They definately do not necessarily focus on the kids more (we got away with alot of naughty things!). Im not sure if you’ve seen the documentary about the inner city school in Manchester (I think?)on Channel 4 (cant remember what its called?) but my teachers at private school, although some were lovely and brilliant, had nothing like that level of energy and commitment to their job that these teachers seem to. The same can also be said for Grammar school. Although im in support of them, sending your child to one does mean you get a better quality teacher.

I would see how they do at Primary school, find one that offers a breakfast/after school club and if necessary, use a tutor to boost them in the upper years of primary school (if you feel for any reason they are not being pushed enough to their level).

Without being cheeky, nothing irks me more than privately educated people harking on how its waste of time and how wonderful state schools ( which they have no experience of ) is wonderful.

You just can't make sweeping statements like 'teachers are no better in private school than state'. Some private schools are shit, some state schools are shit, but the metric which you can't deny is resource.

https://ifs.org.uk/articles/growing-gap-between-state-school-and-private-school-spending#:~:text=As%20a%20result%2C%20the%20gap,spending%20levels%20in%202019%E2%80%9320.

The growing gap between state school and private school spending | Institute for Fiscal Studies

At its recent conference, the Labour party committed to removing charitable status from private schools and the associated exemptions from VAT and business rates. The extra funding would then be used to increase state school spending and would be targe...

https://ifs.org.uk/articles/growing-gap-between-state-school-and-private-school-spending#:~:text=As%20a%20result%2C%20the%20gap,spending%20levels%20in%202019%E2%80%9320.

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:11

The 8.5k maintenance does make a difference but I suppose it's uncertain.

RoseslnTheHospital · 16/08/2023 21:10

@cheekyduck "Mine were learning French, having music lessons, having authors come in to give talks, access to a huge library, all before they were even 5 at Pre-Prep."

The state primary my children attend does French, music lessons, authors coming in to give talks, a big library...... I don't think that's massively unusual, at least not in the south east of England.

LazyGaaGaa · 16/08/2023 21:10

I have no experience of private schooling.

My 3 children attend the local state primary school. It's disorganised chaos on a good day and communication is utterly dire. The uniform policy is ridiculously strict: shirt and tie, itchy knit jumpers, tailored trousers, socks must match trouser colour and coats must match jumper colour. Hair tied up at all times.

Recent Ofsted was "outstanding" and the SATS results are consistently in the top 5% of the country.

There are children in each of my childrens classes who don't wear the uniform, don't own school shoes and do not wear a coat in winter months.

There are children who turn up to school with dirty faces and messy hair. There are children with very poor personal hygiene.

There is a child who wears the same boots all year round since starting school, they are obviously several sizes too big and the laces have fallen out long ago.

There is a child who wore their father's shorts to every swimming lesson.

I could go on and on but you cannot judge a child or a school on appearance.

Young children don't have a say in how they appear, or whether their hair and clothes are clean or their shoes are polished. They are children. There may be other reasons as to why a child appears untidy; they may not tolerate their hair being brushed or the feel of their school uniform against skin.

Their parents may not have been taught basic skills, they may not afford uniform and haircuts or they may just simply not care!

In our experience, these "non smart" looking children are of the kindest in the class with great morals and values. They're the children that others want to be around because of who they are inside, not their exterior.

These children are turning up every day to access the national curriculum that they're entitled to and that is all that matters.

Startrekkeruniverse · 16/08/2023 21:09

unhw · 16/08/2023 19:50

@paddleboarder12 what would that achieve though? We are currently in a ‘good’ area. I genuinely haven’t come across any decent state schools

“I genuinely haven’t come across any decent state schools”. 🤣

What, in the whole country? Give your head a wobble OP, you sound like a massive snob.

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:09

As an aside... do people earning 70k really qualify for bursaries? I thought they would be for actual low earners...

In some London secondaries definitely.

The trouble is wage stagnation & housing costs

Accounting for inflation 75k is approx 40k in the early 00s & 50k in the 10s & now she's paying higher tax

TizerorFizz · 16/08/2023 21:08

You certainly do not get wrap around care at most state schools. Some at best. Parents absolutely choose private schools for wrap around care.

Many of us do not see why primary Dc need to learn with a broad mix of Dc. In some country areas you just don’t find this. You certainly should expect a much broader set of activities in a prep. Definitely better sport, music, art and drama. After school clubs too. If this is not clearly evident, I would not say it’s a great prep school. Smaller class sizes are good but below 16 can be too small. Always check what your money is buying. Better food too and school trips. It comes at a cost though.

my DDs were privately educated and they are definitely ok and so are their friends. All got very good jobs too.

Meowandthen · 16/08/2023 21:07

This surely cannot be genuine! No decent state schools? How insulting to teachers and pupils, past and present.

And if you are genuine, you can’t afford it and need to get your head into the real world.

VikingsandDragons · 16/08/2023 21:06

I wrote a reply in good faith, and several more posts came in in the meantime. I have to believe you're having us on at this point, if your priority was private school on a salary that while high for the average, is low as a single salary to send to private there's no way you'd be cutting your hours. Only you can decide what you value most, is private school worth sacrificing time with your DC, free time for yourself, holidays, living in your dream house, driving a new car, heck on your budget nights out and hobbies are going to have to be considered purchases. Private school is a sacrifice worth making to you or it isn't, but you can't work part time AND achieve the fees, £72k isn't leaving you much room if any so why on earth would you cut it if this is something you value. You'll also be laughed out the door going for a bursary having chosen to cut your hours. There were more than 40x the number of funding requests at my kids school this year as funding available. I do not know if the time I have sacrificed over the years to get my children to private was the right choice, and I can't name the last time I worked less than a 65 hour week, but we made the choices we felt were best for our family. You need to be frank with yourself and decide what you're willing to do to get your kid there, or let go of this dream, because only you are there to provide this for them, don't look externally for someone else to solve this problem with a bursary or a magic wand, most kids can't have that oppertunity for precisely this reason - it's a huge expense and for most people that requires a lot of sacrifice to make it possible.

cheekyduck · 16/08/2023 21:06

Whattodo112222 · 16/08/2023 19:52

I think private primary is a waste.. if you really want him to go to a private school then save up all you can and put it towards secondary where it'll count the most.

Save up for private secondary that is way more expensive, and OP would qualify for a bursary? What an awful idea…

It’s a cart before the horse argument. Prep school gives kids an advantage that
later years can never be replicated, the early years are SO IMPORTANT. We just don't get it in this country, soft skills in the early years.

YES, secondary school is important, but the years 5 to 7 especially are so important for development of life long skills.

Mine were learning French, having music lessons, having authors come in to give talks, access to a huge library, all before they were even 5 at Pre-Prep.

My local primary that is rated outstanding is a great school, but their library was tiny compared to the prep school mine attend, they had scant music , no art studio, no language teachers, no swimming pool, I could go on and on...But I pay a fortune in fees for these soft skills , its foolish to dismiss this as a 'waste of time'.. the price of everything and the value of nothing comes to mind.

Page 2 | has anyone managed to pay for private school on a lowish salary? I am so worried about ds going to state school | Mumsnet

Me and ex are divorced. DS is 3.5. Ex pays me 700 a month, he never sees DS so obviously that amount would change if he did start to see him. I have...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4873712-has-anyone-managed-to-pay-for-private-school-on-a-lowish-salary-i-am-so-worried-about-ds-going-to-state-school?page=2

saffy2 · 16/08/2023 21:06

Oh and people literally move to my town for
the schools, primary and secondary. Catchments are literally meters away from the school and it is a blood bath every single year on admissions. People pay fortunes to live next door to schools to ensure they will get in.
you definitely could move to a better area to find decent schools in my opinion. The schools here are excellent, primary, secondary and grammars in secondary. My sons secondary school is in the top 20 in England 👌🏼 there are two others in the top 20 in this town too. ☺️ and I don’t pay a penny for my kids education.

lovewoola · 16/08/2023 21:05

@Fallingthroughclouds it's completely normal for gps to pay for private school, even more so if they are wealthy.

Iwasafool · 16/08/2023 21:05

You need to sit down and work out exactly how much you have coming in every month and all the essential outgoings, eg mortgage, council tax, gas/elec/water, food, transport and so on. See how much is left. If it is £1,500 a month you can just about do it, if it is less then you can't. Even if you can just about do it you need to think what you'd do if the fees go up, and they will.

How much equity do you have in your property, could you release some. Not sure it is the wisest thing to do but I've heard of people doing it.

Isitautumnyet23 · 16/08/2023 21:04

The thing about private school is it will not just be the cost of the fees, but everything will be more expensive on top of that (speaking as someone who went to one). I wouldn’t want to be spending every last penny on fees because there are going to be alot more expenses on top of that (uniform, transport, school trips etc). Also, the friends they mix with will most likely be fairly well off (I know there are kids whose grandparents pay, overseas forces kids etc so not everyone is wealthy), but a large proportion of kids are.

Trust me, the teachers are no better in a private school than in a state school. They definately do not necessarily focus on the kids more (we got away with alot of naughty things!). Im not sure if you’ve seen the documentary about the inner city school in Manchester (I think?)on Channel 4 (cant remember what its called?) but my teachers at private school, although some were lovely and brilliant, had nothing like that level of energy and commitment to their job that these teachers seem to. The same can also be said for Grammar school. Although im in support of them, sending your child to one does mean you get a better quality teacher.

I would see how they do at Primary school, find one that offers a breakfast/after school club and if necessary, use a tutor to boost them in the upper years of primary school (if you feel for any reason they are not being pushed enough to their level).

Swipe left for the next trending thread