Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To take voluntary redundancy @ £115k

206 replies

anon5mill · 13/08/2023 19:22

Around £80k after tax. Or should I stay in current role with package of £140-150k + pension, healthcare. Current role is comfortable and suits lifestyle. Could be difficult to find another role with the same flexibility and money. Have niggling doubt about taking the redundancy. Have dependents, already own home, no debts. Likely to be made redundant within next 18 months if not now.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
EldenRing4 · 27/08/2023 14:44

PigletJohn · 27/08/2023 14:28

The person who is an independent contractor, is not the person being offered redundancy, who is an employee.

OMG are you THE PigletJohn?
Ok yes I didn't realise person I was replying to wasn't OP anymore thanks for pointing that out. Even so am starstruck if you are

@CantHaveTooMuchChocolate sorry I thought you were the OP. my bad! but hopefully my points haven't been complete rubbish

PigletJohn · 27/08/2023 14:28

The person who is an independent contractor, is not the person being offered redundancy, who is an employee.

EldenRing4 · 27/08/2023 14:13

CantHaveTooMuchChocolate · 27/08/2023 13:47

Sorry I probably wasn’t being too clear, I’m a contractor, via my own limited company (consultancy) - a PSC basically. I tend to provide solutions for enterprise clients, so these do have to scale, be extremely robust, secure and reliable. Some are smaller clients where I’ll deliver a complete end to end solution, others are larger such as banks etc where I’ll provide consultancy or development skills where they don’t have them. So I’m definitely more technical than managerial.

I agree, I think the non technical management roles are really struggling atm, but also think the tech roles are too (more my level), it feels across the board atm, I’ve heard of experienced developers who are applying for warehouse jobs to pay bills, etc. It’s the worst market I’ve seen since 2008, possibly even worse as no end in sight.

Ah OK! That confused me as I wondered how you could be made redundant from your own company, don't think you can be made redundant as a contractor? But I don't know much about contracting anyway never having done it myself, only what I've been told by other people.

I'm actually shocked at how quickly things have changed. Even at my company a year ago there were at least 10 pages of roles at any given time for UK locations now it's barely 3. And they're all mostly low level. Of course our hiring process is a bit archaic and people tend to 'earmark' internals before creating them jobs... but it really drove the point home.

However a lot of my age group (early-mid 30's) tend to be changing jobs pretty easily still. There's a definite ageist bias in the industry. I also think a lot of people who 'specialised' (e.g. 15+ years as a Java dev) get overlooked in favour of people who put all the buzzwords on their CV and know a little of everything but not much in-depth. The JD's I see these days companies want an entire IT department for one person and it's especially endemic for things like 'full stack' engineering.

CantHaveTooMuchChocolate · 27/08/2023 13:47

EldenRing4 · 26/08/2023 13:56

I'm still not sure what that means - if you 'run' a small consultancy are you one of the people just below the 'C-suite'/owner?
Certain orgs with a lot of legacy infrastructure are still hiring with this skillset. For people that have technical knowledge of all the 'overall' bits. Government bodies the like DWP, GCHQ (although they're not legacy!) for example and not just in London, Manchester has quite a few for example. I don't think they will match that level of, but like 80K?

It's quite valuable as a lot of specialists (say, front-end devs) won't know about backend things and vice versa. Those who have spent their career in small firms may also not have encountered the challenges of building for robust operations such as resilience, scale and reliability.

My boss for example (at senior manager level) makes technical decisions but is still relatively hands-on, speaks at technical conferences and in live debugging etc is still an ace at the command line, so he could still 'step down'.

Others however have only been 'technical' for a short while then gone on to business/architect roles with little hands on. Or project/programme manager type roles. These are the sorts of people struggling IME.

Edited

Sorry I probably wasn’t being too clear, I’m a contractor, via my own limited company (consultancy) - a PSC basically. I tend to provide solutions for enterprise clients, so these do have to scale, be extremely robust, secure and reliable. Some are smaller clients where I’ll deliver a complete end to end solution, others are larger such as banks etc where I’ll provide consultancy or development skills where they don’t have them. So I’m definitely more technical than managerial.

I agree, I think the non technical management roles are really struggling atm, but also think the tech roles are too (more my level), it feels across the board atm, I’ve heard of experienced developers who are applying for warehouse jobs to pay bills, etc. It’s the worst market I’ve seen since 2008, possibly even worse as no end in sight.

EldenRing4 · 26/08/2023 13:56

CantHaveTooMuchChocolate · 26/08/2023 13:40

Sorry for the late reply. I run a small consultancy (contractor), and generally supply end to end solns for my clients or consultancy, so server side (Java, database, etc), front end (JS, typescript, etc) and requisite infrastructure (kubernetes, docker, oauth2 security, etc). You’re right these fields are now ultra competitive and very few vacancies at all.

Edited

I'm still not sure what that means - if you 'run' a small consultancy are you one of the people just below the 'C-suite'/owner?
Certain orgs with a lot of legacy infrastructure are still hiring with this skillset. For people that have technical knowledge of all the 'overall' bits. Government bodies the like DWP, GCHQ (although they're not legacy!) for example and not just in London, Manchester has quite a few for example. I don't think they will match that level of, but like 80K?

It's quite valuable as a lot of specialists (say, front-end devs) won't know about backend things and vice versa. Those who have spent their career in small firms may also not have encountered the challenges of building for robust operations such as resilience, scale and reliability.

My boss for example (at senior manager level) makes technical decisions but is still relatively hands-on, speaks at technical conferences and in live debugging etc is still an ace at the command line, so he could still 'step down'.

Others however have only been 'technical' for a short while then gone on to business/architect roles with little hands on. Or project/programme manager type roles. These are the sorts of people struggling IME.

CantHaveTooMuchChocolate · 26/08/2023 13:40

EldenRing4 · 13/08/2023 22:44

What role do you do, out of interest?
Sorry, not related to OP post but I work for a large multinational firm and we're heading for a round of redundancies too in the tech departments. Mostly senior, non-technical roles though. Lots of ambitious, strategic 'growth' projects have been cut.

A lot of recruitment going on in my area still (infrastructure engineering) but that's probably because so few people have the skills needed. Things like front-end, Java developers etc are getting very competitive.

Sorry for the late reply. I run a small consultancy (contractor), and generally supply end to end solns for my clients or consultancy, so server side (Java, database, etc), front end (JS, typescript, etc) and requisite infrastructure (kubernetes, docker, oauth2 security, etc). You’re right these fields are now ultra competitive and very few vacancies at all.

RosemaryDill · 19/08/2023 17:41

I had a similar offer 16 years ago when I was 49.
The initial offer was voluntary redundancy but I and others, held out and got compulsory redundancy which was a better package. My children were 11 and 9.
We were mortgage free and DH took early retirement soon after.
I never regretted it for a second. However I changed direction, worked very part time in flexible jobs after taking a year off.
I put all the money in a SIPP so got most of the tax back.

Wouldyouguess · 19/08/2023 17:34

I wish I had a problem like that.

CatMum000 · 19/08/2023 17:33

yes, only the proportion of it over a defined limit, e.g. First £30k tax free

TheWayoftheLeaf · 15/08/2023 15:25

F0RBIDDEN · 13/08/2023 19:42

I have reached peak disappointment in myself. I earn 20k. MN makes me feel like such a fucking failure all the time.

Ask for more money

Wrapunzel · 15/08/2023 12:34

thanks for this thread OP. I'm a reasonably high earner in a flexible role, too, and have been with my employer a while, I always have my redundancy payout modelled in case it happens to me! The conclusion you've reached is a decent one, it's nice to have options.

Wenfy · 15/08/2023 12:07

I earn £150k, no huge bonuses, work to task rather than hours, but am mostly remote so I can set these hours. I’m always around for DC as a result.

CyberCritical · 15/08/2023 12:00

Noangelbuthavingfun · 15/08/2023 00:19

What do you tech women earn average a year gross including your bonuses ?? Genuinely intrigued as I thought it was a 60 hour plus Week for anyone in tech. Please do share ! Too old to retrain but would like to understand so can influence my nieces !

I'm cyberSec in a leadership role, £95k plus 20% annual bonus.

Hours can be long, especially if there's an incident or audit, but it averages out and 100% home working so able to flex around school drop offs and events.

TenderDandelions · 15/08/2023 11:54

@anon5mill Is there any possibility of contracting/freelance work in your industry?

Just another thought re working for yourself and picking and choosing your own rates and hours, etc?

Notmygreen · 15/08/2023 07:08

I would wait 18 months, is another year of earning your salary and gives you time to find another job.

Can I ask you what do you do in tech? I want to go into tech but there are so many roles that I'm not sure what's best ... cybersecurity? Web development? UX Design? What should I study? Thank you.

Workquestion11 · 15/08/2023 07:04

F0RBIDDEN · 13/08/2023 19:42

I have reached peak disappointment in myself. I earn 20k. MN makes me feel like such a fucking failure all the time.

I'd be delighted with 20k
I don't even earn 15k
Always going to be someone worse off

Noangelbuthavingfun · 15/08/2023 00:19

What do you tech women earn average a year gross including your bonuses ?? Genuinely intrigued as I thought it was a 60 hour plus Week for anyone in tech. Please do share ! Too old to retrain but would like to understand so can influence my nieces !

Johnisafckface · 15/08/2023 00:07

F0RBIDDEN · 13/08/2023 19:42

I have reached peak disappointment in myself. I earn 20k. MN makes me feel like such a fucking failure all the time.

You’re not alone. I envy those who are mortgage free and have high salaries. But I guess that’s life 😂

CyberCritical · 14/08/2023 22:29

MaryQueenofSocks · 14/08/2023 21:25

@jeaux90 @Totalwasteofpaper @SweetPotatoAndPeanutStew

I think I've found my tribe 😁

Anyone up for a Women in Tech thread, where can completely and unashamedly wax lyrical about our profession? Celebrate the successes without apology (and moan about how crap Teams is 😂).

Sorry OP for hijacking your thread!

Can I join, even though I'm in the dreaded CyberSecurity group?

FlipFlop1987 · 14/08/2023 21:51

F0RBIDDEN · 13/08/2023 19:42

I have reached peak disappointment in myself. I earn 20k. MN makes me feel like such a fucking failure all the time.

Me and you both, I’ve got two degrees and been in the police for 12 years, my wages have gone backwards in that time despite being higher scales 🙄

anon5mill · 14/08/2023 21:45

MaryQueenofSocks · 14/08/2023 21:38

@EldenRing4

Of course! the more the merrier 😁

I'll wait to see who else is in, then I'll setup a new thread tomorrow.

Count me in too!

OP posts:
MaryQueenofSocks · 14/08/2023 21:38

@EldenRing4

Of course! the more the merrier 😁

I'll wait to see who else is in, then I'll setup a new thread tomorrow.

EldenRing4 · 14/08/2023 21:32

MaryQueenofSocks · 14/08/2023 21:25

@jeaux90 @Totalwasteofpaper @SweetPotatoAndPeanutStew

I think I've found my tribe 😁

Anyone up for a Women in Tech thread, where can completely and unashamedly wax lyrical about our profession? Celebrate the successes without apology (and moan about how crap Teams is 😂).

Sorry OP for hijacking your thread!

Can I join?
I haven't been on any adventures in beaches/sunlit plains yet but enjoying choosing my hours somewhat

MaryQueenofSocks · 14/08/2023 21:25

@jeaux90 @Totalwasteofpaper @SweetPotatoAndPeanutStew

I think I've found my tribe 😁

Anyone up for a Women in Tech thread, where can completely and unashamedly wax lyrical about our profession? Celebrate the successes without apology (and moan about how crap Teams is 😂).

Sorry OP for hijacking your thread!