Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To literally BEG women to set themselves up, financially?

782 replies

CallieRedux · 07/08/2023 14:14

Typed out a long post full of personal details, then deleted, but, honestly, the specifics don't matter. What DOES matter is that you save every tiny bit you can, because having FUCK YOU money is - by far - the most important thing you can do for yourself.

It's saved me from everything from wrong relationships, shit jobs, from natural disasters... I have both made lots of money, and not, but having savings, and the ability to walk away is having POWER, and the best "self care" a woman can have.

Shit happens. Things change. Even to you. Yes, you can save - even a little - when you are poor.

Do it. Please.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Thepeopleversuswork · 10/08/2023 22:06

@TheaPrentice

Everyone has soooo much to say about SAHMs - without defining what they actually mean by s SAHM.

It’s a fair challenge.

FWIW I have no judgement for anyone who chooses to stay at home provided they can afford to.

I do draw a distinction between women taking a few years out to be with small kids and professional housewives.

Choosing to scale back commitments and focus on young family is totally understandable: working with small kids is a big burden and many families really struggle with maintaining this and having both parents working.

But I think actively setting out to spend decades in a state of dependency on your husband and critically to plan to do this beyond the point when your children are all in full time education is a whole other ballgame. Yes there are plenty of worthy distractions etc and yes there are ways to mitigate the financial risk but I do think maintaining a sense of purpose and security is harder when the whole foundation of your financial life basically depends on whether or not you meet your husband’s approval. And while I wouldn’t judge anyone for this per se I would consider it reckless. And certainly wouldn’t want this for my daughter.

The problem is that quite a lot of women start with scenario A and find that they get tipped into scenario B.

Lockeddownagain · 10/08/2023 22:02

You should.due to financial abuse I can't leave my marriage I've taught my nine year old to save my family qre spenders and im fucked

BorgQueen · 10/08/2023 21:45

I’d prefer DD didn’t marry, even though they earn the same she has a much better pension and she ( via a gift from us) put 90% of the house deposit.

She will also inherit everything from us, apart from 20% that is reserved for our Grandson.
If she does marry then we’ll change our wills so DGS gets 50% of our estate. That’s incase she inherits then dies and then SiL could well get her inheritance if she hasn’t willed her half of the house to DGS. Her partner has two older kids.

TheaPrentice · 10/08/2023 21:27

"Your hypothetical SAHM in a multimillion pound London home - how does she survive in the 18 months it takes to get through divorce proceedings and liquidate the assets? How does she pay for the divorce lawyers?"

Why is it hypothetical? It's most definitely is not. And why wouldn't she have access to the same money as the DH if all accounts / savings are shared? Often done / most of it will be in her name anyway, for tax reasons.

Everyone has soooo much to say about SAHMs - without defining what they actually mean by s SAHM. Do you mean a woman who doesn't work for a year or two? Probably not likely to be a massive deal in the scheme of things but again, depends on what she did. A woman who takes the pre-school years out? Again, could be risky - or not, depending on the individual circumstances. Or a woman who leaves work altogether - likely to only happen in families who can easily afford this and don't miss the extra income. There are families with SAHMs and they still have live-in nannies. Loads of families like this in certain areas. There will be SAHMs who are financially vulnerable, of course. But there will be women who work who are financially vulnerable too - depending on their income. Regardless of any of this, I don't know how we got to a point in society where some women have convinced themselves that it's optional for a man to share his money with a woman who has given birth to his child / children. Some women even celebrate this as 'equality.' It's really not.

ScarlettSunset · 10/08/2023 20:27

I was a mum who worked. My ex wouldn't share money (contributed nothing at all) and was financially abusive (before this was legally recognised).
Because I was working and had an income I was able to escape the situation. I didn't have much in savings but having that regular income made a difference.
If I'd been a SAHM and he'd been abusive in a different way, I'd probably still be living like that now as I wouldn't have been able to just get out.

manontroppo · 10/08/2023 20:25

TheaPrentice · 10/08/2023 20:09

Well it depends what you mean by SAHM, doesn't it? A SAHM in a £5, £10 plus home (no mortgage) in London (many of them, by the way) is hardly financially vulnerable is she? A woman working on MW or even a medium wage is hardly sorted for life. Even a 'high earning' woman (again everyone defines this differently) could be left with very little if she has huge debts or lots if children or lived in Central London etc etc etc. The point is, it's all relative.

Your hypothetical SAHM in a multimillion pound London home - how does she survive in the 18 months it takes to get through divorce proceedings and liquidate the assets? How does she pay for the divorce lawyers?

TheaPrentice · 10/08/2023 20:09

Well it depends what you mean by SAHM, doesn't it? A SAHM in a £5, £10 plus home (no mortgage) in London (many of them, by the way) is hardly financially vulnerable is she? A woman working on MW or even a medium wage is hardly sorted for life. Even a 'high earning' woman (again everyone defines this differently) could be left with very little if she has huge debts or lots if children or lived in Central London etc etc etc. The point is, it's all relative.

manontroppo · 10/08/2023 19:52

TheaPrentice · 10/08/2023 18:39

Yes, of course you can want women to avoid financial vulnerability. Don't we all.

Its obvious though that how financially vulnerable you are is far more complicated than 'SAHM v WOHM.' Financial vulnerability depends on all sorts of factors - eg. assets / passive income; whether you own your properties or have mortgages; debts; savings / investments; geographic location; size of family and so on so on. Reducing it to 'SAHM or WOHM' is weird because millions upon millions of women who work will be far more financially vulnerable than many SAHMs. People make decisions in relative terms.

It's up to each woman to protect herself and her children - Yes absolutely! But it's a far more complex issue than railing on about SAHMs as if they are the cause of all woes and doom and gloom. Some will be vulnerable, others will not. Just like working women. It's all relative. And what is the point of linking to other threads all the time? You could find a thread about literally any woman in any scenario, including working mums being financially abused by men who won't share finances with their wives - the mothers of their children who they have brought into the world. When the hell did this become optional for men and why are women colluding with it? It's as if they've been brainwashed because this is certainly not 'equality.' And it's definitely not 'feminism' to pander to these men and facilitate their attitudes.

There seems to be a thread like about such 'men' every day. It's not SAHMs who are the problem. It's men who see supporting their families as somehow optional and who have no integrity. And the women who facilitate this misogyny, mistaking it for 'equality.' It's NOT equality and it's certainly not 'feminism.' It's deplorable. When men can get pregnant, give birth and the whole aftermath, then we can have a different conversation.

I very much doubt your assertion that millions of women who work are more vulnerable than SAHM, and if anything it would be the other way around. That is exactly why the debate is reduced to SAHM vs WOHMs, because SAHMs generally are more financially vulnerable.

For every SAHM on Mumsnet who says they have pension contributions paid and a BTL providing income, I’d bet there are at least 5 more with zero independent source of finance.

And you can rail all you like that it’s a disgrace that men take so little responsibility - that won’t keep a roof over your head when your “D”H has deployed the divorce lawyers or kicked the bucket at the age of 45.

SouthLondonMum22 · 10/08/2023 19:35

TheaPrentice · 10/08/2023 18:39

Yes, of course you can want women to avoid financial vulnerability. Don't we all.

Its obvious though that how financially vulnerable you are is far more complicated than 'SAHM v WOHM.' Financial vulnerability depends on all sorts of factors - eg. assets / passive income; whether you own your properties or have mortgages; debts; savings / investments; geographic location; size of family and so on so on. Reducing it to 'SAHM or WOHM' is weird because millions upon millions of women who work will be far more financially vulnerable than many SAHMs. People make decisions in relative terms.

It's up to each woman to protect herself and her children - Yes absolutely! But it's a far more complex issue than railing on about SAHMs as if they are the cause of all woes and doom and gloom. Some will be vulnerable, others will not. Just like working women. It's all relative. And what is the point of linking to other threads all the time? You could find a thread about literally any woman in any scenario, including working mums being financially abused by men who won't share finances with their wives - the mothers of their children who they have brought into the world. When the hell did this become optional for men and why are women colluding with it? It's as if they've been brainwashed because this is certainly not 'equality.' And it's definitely not 'feminism' to pander to these men and facilitate their attitudes.

There seems to be a thread like about such 'men' every day. It's not SAHMs who are the problem. It's men who see supporting their families as somehow optional and who have no integrity. And the women who facilitate this misogyny, mistaking it for 'equality.' It's NOT equality and it's certainly not 'feminism.' It's deplorable. When men can get pregnant, give birth and the whole aftermath, then we can have a different conversation.

You're assuming that it's only men who won't 'share' their finances. I wouldn't marry someone who expected me to hand over every penny to be shared in a joint account.

It isn't financial abuse if it's an agreement and it isn't financial abuse if someone has their own money and doesn't need to be supported by anyone else.

TheShellBeach · 10/08/2023 19:10

anonymousxoxo · 10/08/2023 18:13

She said: don’t have the money to pay it all - I did wonder why he had some extra money .

I can’t see where she said she’s paid and the last update was 6 hours ago? 20 pages long!

I can't help what you can't see!
She's made a payment.

ithoughtitwasyouelectricblue · 10/08/2023 18:56

OhComeOnFFS · 07/08/2023 14:59

I agree with you. I'm also horrified by the number of women here who have children without getting married and then end up so vulnerable, often without a pension or an income.

When I had my first child I was married, very high earner, no siblings, oodles of inheritance due his way. I had a moderate income and nhs pension. I got shafted by his far superior (ie expensive) lawyers and whilst I got school fees paid I ended up with less equity than I put into the home. I just couldn't afford to fight for a better deal (ex would get his solicitor to write to mine almost daily saying fuck all but I'd get billed for the envelope getting opened. My solicitor and I agreed he would open them once a fortnight and not bother me unless a decision needed to be made to save costs).

My other two children were born without a marriage (I was keen, he wasn't). I thank my lucky stars he wasn't keen. I was always the consistent high earner (many promotions) and I walked away with my full pension intact, my career in excellent health and so pleased it turned out that way because he turned out to be an absolute arse and has spent 6 years pulling every trick in the book to not pay CMS.
He always said he didn't need a pension as we could quite comfortable live off mine and he didn't have to 'waste' his money on one .... 😂😂😂 oh how I laugh now as I approach NHS retirement age or at least an age to consider it. He will have very modest inheritance and a grabby sister who will have her hands all over every penny she can get.

TheaPrentice · 10/08/2023 18:39

Yes, of course you can want women to avoid financial vulnerability. Don't we all.

Its obvious though that how financially vulnerable you are is far more complicated than 'SAHM v WOHM.' Financial vulnerability depends on all sorts of factors - eg. assets / passive income; whether you own your properties or have mortgages; debts; savings / investments; geographic location; size of family and so on so on. Reducing it to 'SAHM or WOHM' is weird because millions upon millions of women who work will be far more financially vulnerable than many SAHMs. People make decisions in relative terms.

It's up to each woman to protect herself and her children - Yes absolutely! But it's a far more complex issue than railing on about SAHMs as if they are the cause of all woes and doom and gloom. Some will be vulnerable, others will not. Just like working women. It's all relative. And what is the point of linking to other threads all the time? You could find a thread about literally any woman in any scenario, including working mums being financially abused by men who won't share finances with their wives - the mothers of their children who they have brought into the world. When the hell did this become optional for men and why are women colluding with it? It's as if they've been brainwashed because this is certainly not 'equality.' And it's definitely not 'feminism' to pander to these men and facilitate their attitudes.

There seems to be a thread like about such 'men' every day. It's not SAHMs who are the problem. It's men who see supporting their families as somehow optional and who have no integrity. And the women who facilitate this misogyny, mistaking it for 'equality.' It's NOT equality and it's certainly not 'feminism.' It's deplorable. When men can get pregnant, give birth and the whole aftermath, then we can have a different conversation.

tattooedteagull · 10/08/2023 18:22

Wish I could like this a thousand times over!

anonymousxoxo · 10/08/2023 18:21

JamSandle · 10/08/2023 18:17

Absolutely agree.

I absolutely shiver when I hear some women say they want to live on a man's money.

Absolutely dangerous.

Very!

anonymousxoxo · 10/08/2023 18:20

manontroppo · 10/08/2023 18:15

The thing is, you never know that your DH is an arsehole until it’s too late. The relationships board is littered with women who would have sworn blind he was a perfect partner. Until he wasn’t.

And yes - I do think it’s a crying shame that some women give up high flying, intellectually stimulating careers to be SAHM. It’s almost always because the “D”H can’t be arsed to compromise at all, dressed up as “my job is too important and senior to compromise”. The wife then dresses it up as some kind of free choice.

Thankfully, there are an increasing number of two working parent families in my area (academia and medicine) that give lie to the fact that the Man Job is too important to ever pick the kids up from school. If a two surgeon family can make it work, no one else has any bloody excuse.

You're 100% right. Those men are selfish and see household chores beneath them. These same men would be happy if the kids lived with the mother after divorce and do everything/anything to avoid paying maintenance.

SAHM can argue until sun goes down that the money is joint, however:

  1. He signed the contract
  2. The payslip and pension is in his name
  3. He can get a mortgage due to salary/pay slips

Should never be dependent on anyone, I'd say the same if it was a same sex marriage.

anonymousxoxo · 10/08/2023 18:17

parliamoglesga · 10/08/2023 18:16

I think triggered is a buzzword.

can’t defend a point these days without being “triggered”

Yup

JamSandle · 10/08/2023 18:17

Absolutely agree.

I absolutely shiver when I hear some women say they want to live on a man's money.

Absolutely dangerous.

parliamoglesga · 10/08/2023 18:16

anonymousxoxo · 10/08/2023 18:11

I don’t understand why I’m triggered that I want women to be financially independent and their own career, not dependent on a man but ok..

I think triggered is a buzzword.

can’t defend a point these days without being “triggered”

manontroppo · 10/08/2023 18:15

TheaPrentice · 10/08/2023 17:36

"Yup ultimately the pay slips are made to his name, he is the one who earns it and signed the contract"

I have been following this thread on holiday @anonymousxoxo and I can't really work out why you are so triggered by the concept of a SAHM?

It's only a woman looking after her own children you know. It's nothing unusual!

I can see you point about men in your office being able to work later etc because they have a wife at home. I completely understand that.

But, aside from that one valid point, you seem unusually pent up about SAHMs. You've been on multiple threads for days now. Why? Is it because, despite all your protestations about 'I have my own money' etc, you know, deep down, that your husband would never share his money with you or financially support his family the way you see other men doing? Is this the real issue why you protest so much? You can't count on that?

If you yourself can't understand the special bond between a mum and baby, well your DH never will. If you only see things as 'my payslips' and 'his payslips', this is the type of man you will probably get - ie. one who wouid never financially support you or his children. Who thinks giving you money is optional.

Anyway, it's not about 'payslips.' I would never recommend living on someone else's payslips (well, not for too long). The point you are not grasping is that some families act as a unit. It's irrelevant who earns what. They spend as one unit (no need to hide anything from each other); they take out mortgages and investments as one unit. They don't transfer money between each other. Over the years, it doesn't matter who earned what because they have built lives together - they have made money on their investments or property etc. - so many variables. My husband has never referred to anything as 'my money' in over 20 years! How could he - he has a family. He has a certain pride and identity in providing for his family - most men do. Well, the ones I know do. I've never heard of men with children keeping their own private money once they have children - most people would think of this as peculiarly controlling (at best) and abusive (at worst).

The thing is, you never know that your DH is an arsehole until it’s too late. The relationships board is littered with women who would have sworn blind he was a perfect partner. Until he wasn’t.

And yes - I do think it’s a crying shame that some women give up high flying, intellectually stimulating careers to be SAHM. It’s almost always because the “D”H can’t be arsed to compromise at all, dressed up as “my job is too important and senior to compromise”. The wife then dresses it up as some kind of free choice.

Thankfully, there are an increasing number of two working parent families in my area (academia and medicine) that give lie to the fact that the Man Job is too important to ever pick the kids up from school. If a two surgeon family can make it work, no one else has any bloody excuse.

anonymousxoxo · 10/08/2023 18:13

She said: don’t have the money to pay it all - I did wonder why he had some extra money .

I can’t see where she said she’s paid and the last update was 6 hours ago? 20 pages long!

parliamoglesga · 10/08/2023 18:13

I should add as well that I’m an 80s kid (born mid 80s) and my mum worked full time from when I was 6 months old in a professional job (teaching) that would not have allowed for part time in those days. it was most unusual in that era and in that profession to not have a career break.

it’s never once affected my relationship with her and tbh she is the one who has drilled me about having my own money.

anonymousxoxo · 10/08/2023 18:11

parliamoglesga · 10/08/2023 18:08

I don’t think @anonymousxoxo is triggered at all. I hate hate hate that phrase being used to describe someone who’s making a point in a calm manner. We cannot all have the same POV on things but disagreeing wholeheartedly does not mean you’re “triggered”

I don’t understand why I’m triggered that I want women to be financially independent and their own career, not dependent on a man but ok..

anonymousxoxo · 10/08/2023 18:10

TheShellBeach · 10/08/2023 18:08

She made a payment today.
Have you even read the thread?

In her OP it said she couldn’t afford it. Idk why you’re so happy about women being dependent on a man! But, ok.

TheShellBeach · 10/08/2023 18:08

anonymousxoxo · 10/08/2023 18:05

How am I lying? She can’t pay rent, won’t she get kicked out as her DH hasn’t paid it?

She made a payment today.
Have you even read the thread?

parliamoglesga · 10/08/2023 18:08

TheaPrentice · 10/08/2023 17:36

"Yup ultimately the pay slips are made to his name, he is the one who earns it and signed the contract"

I have been following this thread on holiday @anonymousxoxo and I can't really work out why you are so triggered by the concept of a SAHM?

It's only a woman looking after her own children you know. It's nothing unusual!

I can see you point about men in your office being able to work later etc because they have a wife at home. I completely understand that.

But, aside from that one valid point, you seem unusually pent up about SAHMs. You've been on multiple threads for days now. Why? Is it because, despite all your protestations about 'I have my own money' etc, you know, deep down, that your husband would never share his money with you or financially support his family the way you see other men doing? Is this the real issue why you protest so much? You can't count on that?

If you yourself can't understand the special bond between a mum and baby, well your DH never will. If you only see things as 'my payslips' and 'his payslips', this is the type of man you will probably get - ie. one who wouid never financially support you or his children. Who thinks giving you money is optional.

Anyway, it's not about 'payslips.' I would never recommend living on someone else's payslips (well, not for too long). The point you are not grasping is that some families act as a unit. It's irrelevant who earns what. They spend as one unit (no need to hide anything from each other); they take out mortgages and investments as one unit. They don't transfer money between each other. Over the years, it doesn't matter who earned what because they have built lives together - they have made money on their investments or property etc. - so many variables. My husband has never referred to anything as 'my money' in over 20 years! How could he - he has a family. He has a certain pride and identity in providing for his family - most men do. Well, the ones I know do. I've never heard of men with children keeping their own private money once they have children - most people would think of this as peculiarly controlling (at best) and abusive (at worst).

I don’t think @anonymousxoxo is triggered at all. I hate hate hate that phrase being used to describe someone who’s making a point in a calm manner. We cannot all have the same POV on things but disagreeing wholeheartedly does not mean you’re “triggered”