Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To literally BEG women to set themselves up, financially?

782 replies

CallieRedux · 07/08/2023 14:14

Typed out a long post full of personal details, then deleted, but, honestly, the specifics don't matter. What DOES matter is that you save every tiny bit you can, because having FUCK YOU money is - by far - the most important thing you can do for yourself.

It's saved me from everything from wrong relationships, shit jobs, from natural disasters... I have both made lots of money, and not, but having savings, and the ability to walk away is having POWER, and the best "self care" a woman can have.

Shit happens. Things change. Even to you. Yes, you can save - even a little - when you are poor.

Do it. Please.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Anxioys · 09/08/2023 12:46

@DryIce - this is what happens in countries which have a better record of equality, with better lives for women. And the children appear not to lose out, having engaged fathers. It's a win win

DryIce · 09/08/2023 12:38

SerafinasGoose · 09/08/2023 12:31

The last point is the essential one, I think. It's not always a completely free choice, and the reason is that our society is primarily structured to benefit patriarchal interests.

That's the argument I'd like to see taken apart with a lot more gusto on sites like MN. Unfortunately, most of the SAHM vs. WOHM threads go the same way: each side attacking the other and somehow seeing a different lifestyle decision as a personal affront.

A far more constructive discussion would shift that focus onto how best to benefit women's interests (for a change).

I've tried. And failed.

I thought this thread was quite good at discussing the overall impacts without sniping at each other!

My personal fave new direction would be to see more flexibility at work with both men and women combining work and home duties

SerafinasGoose · 09/08/2023 12:37

Elephantsdontlikechocolate · 09/08/2023 09:59

Shocking some women treat their partners as if they are their young children. A stay at home mother looks after the children, not after a grown man. How disgusting some men will let their partners iron their shirts and make them breakfast. Bleugh. And bleugh. What is wrong with those women and men.

Yep. 'Looking after your husband' is a phrase that's anathema to me.

If, gods forbid, the worst happened to him healthwise I'd make adjustments to my career in a heartbeat if he truly needed my care. I know he'd do the same thing for me.

But a fit, well, able-bodied adult needing to be 'looked after' by another adult? Garn.

The inevitable holiday discussions have come up in his workplace of late, with so many of the women claiming they needed to do their husbands' packing for them and how busy they would be in the run-up toward taking off. It's never even occurred to me to do this! How on earth would I know what someone else wanted to wear? He feels the same, and would be no more minded to let me do his packing that I would be to have him do mine!

Bonkers.

anonymousxoxo · 09/08/2023 12:35

SerafinasGoose · 09/08/2023 12:31

The last point is the essential one, I think. It's not always a completely free choice, and the reason is that our society is primarily structured to benefit patriarchal interests.

That's the argument I'd like to see taken apart with a lot more gusto on sites like MN. Unfortunately, most of the SAHM vs. WOHM threads go the same way: each side attacking the other and somehow seeing a different lifestyle decision as a personal affront.

A far more constructive discussion would shift that focus onto how best to benefit women's interests (for a change).

I've tried. And failed.

These days being a SAHM is pure luxury.

Its the harsh reality, life is so expensive.

Hard enough getting a job these days.

The industry I work in moves sooo fast. Part time isn’t welcomed. If I took years out, I would lose career progression - salary increases - pension and financial stability.

Meanwhile, DH will be the opposite and I’ll be in poverty.

DryIce · 09/08/2023 12:34

TheaPrentice · 09/08/2023 12:30

DryIce - yes I know you weren't being snarky. My point was the same as yours - of course SAHMs should feel valued by DHs and themselves! This goes without saying. But my main point was, whether you work or not, if you decide to have children with a man of the 'what I earn is mine' mentality, then you are likely to reap what you sow.

Yes agreed! A different case even, like some pps, you e always split money and both keep your own. But marrying and then becoming dependent on ansn with that attitude..danger!

SerafinasGoose · 09/08/2023 12:31

TheaPrentice · 08/08/2023 17:49

Being a SAHM does not need to be the inevitable disaster it is made out to be on here. As @EarringsandLipstick says, choice is always a good thing. There is no right way when it comes to families. It's a shame that too many women who would like to SAH, no longer can due to the cost of living necessitating two incomes these days.

The last point is the essential one, I think. It's not always a completely free choice, and the reason is that our society is primarily structured to benefit patriarchal interests.

That's the argument I'd like to see taken apart with a lot more gusto on sites like MN. Unfortunately, most of the SAHM vs. WOHM threads go the same way: each side attacking the other and somehow seeing a different lifestyle decision as a personal affront.

A far more constructive discussion would shift that focus onto how best to benefit women's interests (for a change).

I've tried. And failed.

TheaPrentice · 09/08/2023 12:30

DryIce - yes I know you weren't being snarky. My point was the same as yours - of course SAHMs should feel valued by DHs and themselves! This goes without saying. But my main point was, whether you work or not, if you decide to have children with a man of the 'what I earn is mine' mentality, then you are likely to reap what you sow.

anonymousxoxo · 09/08/2023 12:29

notquiteruralbliss · 09/08/2023 12:24

Looking back over 40 + years of marriage I think we made the right decisions in ensuring that my career continued despite having 4 DCs and that income and assets were always joint. We are a team. If we split (not likely at this point) assets would be split 50/50 and I'm fine with that. At any point, they would have been enough to allow both of us to start over.

Initially DH earned more (he was established in a hard to get into career that doesn't pay massively well but is very flexible) and I focused on building my career in an industry that pays well, but offers little flexibility.

From my early 30's, I earned more, but DHs flexible working patterns meant we could juggle 2 FT jobs and DCs. Now I earn over 3 x what DH earns, but 1/3 of that goes on an expensive hobby. DH has no interest in the hobby but doesn't care that I spend 'our' money on it.

When we are both retired, DH's pension will be 2 x mine. The hobby will continue, but done in a less expensive way.

Yeah, this is the way to do it.

anonymousxoxo · 09/08/2023 12:28

Anxioys · 09/08/2023 12:18

@anonymousxoxo - that is foolish and she needs a job.

They’re about to lose their home but still refuses to get a job

anonymousxoxo · 09/08/2023 12:27

Fuckingfuming1 · 09/08/2023 12:09

The issue is for that lady, she feels she’s got enough to do without working as well and she’s probably not wrong.

It feels very unfair, and it probably is.
But and ive said this time and time again and I’ve watched friends do it. You do not have three children with somebody who earns 22 grand a year. If in your mind you’ve made a decision you would like three or four children you will need to marry somebody who earns a lot more and in order to do that you’ll need to earn a lot more yourself a somebody else that up the thread.

There’s really awful consequences for the children in these situations who didn’t asked to be born

Yeah, that is true. She hasn’t been bought up to be told that she needs to work for a living, that’s another issue

notquiteruralbliss · 09/08/2023 12:24

Looking back over 40 + years of marriage I think we made the right decisions in ensuring that my career continued despite having 4 DCs and that income and assets were always joint. We are a team. If we split (not likely at this point) assets would be split 50/50 and I'm fine with that. At any point, they would have been enough to allow both of us to start over.

Initially DH earned more (he was established in a hard to get into career that doesn't pay massively well but is very flexible) and I focused on building my career in an industry that pays well, but offers little flexibility.

From my early 30's, I earned more, but DHs flexible working patterns meant we could juggle 2 FT jobs and DCs. Now I earn over 3 x what DH earns, but 1/3 of that goes on an expensive hobby. DH has no interest in the hobby but doesn't care that I spend 'our' money on it.

When we are both retired, DH's pension will be 2 x mine. The hobby will continue, but done in a less expensive way.

Anxioys · 09/08/2023 12:18

@anonymousxoxo - that is foolish and she needs a job.

DryIce · 09/08/2023 12:12

No I wasn't being snarky, I did think that was an interesting perspective as is the opposite of what I had thought.

I don't think everyone has to do life how I do it, people split their finances loads of ways. I also don't want to fund anyone to sah for me.

I do feel sahms are devalued in general though - I personally prefer to work than stay home. And if I had a sahm like my male colleagues I feel life would be super easy! So I feel its quite obnoxious when those men talk crappie about their sah wives, laud themselves for "earning all the money " and benefit from it!! And they expect their wives to be grateful

Fuckingfuming1 · 09/08/2023 12:09

anonymousxoxo · 09/08/2023 12:01

Here's a thread where a SAHM is refusing to work even though they barely make ends meet and her 3 kids are in school/nursery.

Husband giving me an ultimatum - forcing me to get a job or sell our house | Mumsnet

I wouldn't want to fund that.

The issue is for that lady, she feels she’s got enough to do without working as well and she’s probably not wrong.

It feels very unfair, and it probably is.
But and ive said this time and time again and I’ve watched friends do it. You do not have three children with somebody who earns 22 grand a year. If in your mind you’ve made a decision you would like three or four children you will need to marry somebody who earns a lot more and in order to do that you’ll need to earn a lot more yourself a somebody else that up the thread.

There’s really awful consequences for the children in these situations who didn’t asked to be born

TheaPrentice · 09/08/2023 12:03

DryIce - I think you are agreeing with me!

Personally, I would not have children with a man who wanted separate finances. It is a very unattractive trait and I have zero interest in that mentality.

anonymousxoxo · 09/08/2023 11:36

DryIce · 09/08/2023 11:10

This is an interesting perspective, as what I see is the opposite. I am a feminist and see our income as family money. I think women who don't are often those who've been conditioned to expect not only to shoulder the burden of home life- but also to devalue it and feel they should grateful for the opportunity.

I like to keep my finances separate. I don’t want to combine or join them. I’m happy to pay a percentage of my salary towards bills. I don’t want my credit history ruined or tied to someone else.

For me as a feminist, I don’t feel the need to shoulder the burden of home life cost wise or childcare wise or household chores - I want the money I earned for myself, my children and treats as I work hard. I want to increase my credit history and maintain that.

I work 40+ hours a week sometimes (45) due to travel and have to deal with managers/colleagues work. I’ve earned that money through my hard work. It’s primarily mine, I signed the contract and that money should go to my bank account. I’m the one who studied for years and put myself through university.

I have no desire to fund someone to stay at home to do childcare, household chores and maintenance as many people do it alongside full time work. I’d rather pay for childcare.

Ultimately, working is harder than being a SAHM parent due to the factors I’ve listed above.

There’s also performance reviews, working with colleague and general sexism against women workers.

anonymousxoxo · 09/08/2023 11:33

TheaPrentice · 09/08/2023 10:41

The thing is, if you go into relationships with the mentality too often expressed by supposed 'feminists' on here that it's fine for him to think of his money is his ('he earned it') and you believe that separate finances are the only way to go, this is the exact type of man you will likely get - ie. the type more likely to screw you over in the future.

I like to keep my finances separate. I don’t want to combine or join them. I’m happy to pay a percentage of my salary towards bills. I don’t want my credit history ruined or tied to someone else.

I work 40+ hours a week sometimes (45) due to travel and have to deal with managers/colleagues work. I’ve earned that money through my hard work. It’s primarily mine, I signed the contract and that money should go to my bank account. I’m the one who studied for years and put myself through university.

I have no desire to fund someone to stay at home to do childcare, household chores and maintenance as many people do it alongside full time work. I’d rather pay for childcare.

Ultimately, working is harder than being a SAHM parent due to the factors I’ve listed above.

There’s also performance reviews, working with colleague and general sexism against women workers.

anonymousxoxo · 09/08/2023 11:29

Elephantsdontlikechocolate · 09/08/2023 10:25

This, until men are as likely as women to be SAHP. Women still will be at some disadvantage due to childbirth and recovery time needed but the gap would be a lot smaller.

I agree

DryIce · 09/08/2023 11:10

TheaPrentice · 09/08/2023 10:41

The thing is, if you go into relationships with the mentality too often expressed by supposed 'feminists' on here that it's fine for him to think of his money is his ('he earned it') and you believe that separate finances are the only way to go, this is the exact type of man you will likely get - ie. the type more likely to screw you over in the future.

This is an interesting perspective, as what I see is the opposite. I am a feminist and see our income as family money. I think women who don't are often those who've been conditioned to expect not only to shoulder the burden of home life- but also to devalue it and feel they should grateful for the opportunity.

TheaPrentice · 09/08/2023 10:41

The thing is, if you go into relationships with the mentality too often expressed by supposed 'feminists' on here that it's fine for him to think of his money is his ('he earned it') and you believe that separate finances are the only way to go, this is the exact type of man you will likely get - ie. the type more likely to screw you over in the future.

DrasticAction · 09/08/2023 10:32

@NellyBarney on paper this sounds good.. And I can't deny I hope my own dds end up in good career with partner in good career.. However in RL this doesn't always work, where love comes in...

I know my dh parents were so excited when I first met dh and they dropped me off at our lovely family home in an expensive town.
I could sense their approval.
However they didn't realise that family home was soon to be sold and my patents divorced leading to very difficult and different living arrangements and the emotional fall out deeply affected me.
I had put too much of my reserves emotionally and mentally into their horrific divorce I didn't concentrate on myself at a critical time getting jobs.

Dh then wasn't exactly a promising prospect either however...

When his dp realised I didn't have ££ behind me and dh then was also floundering in the work front they actually treated us v differently from she sister eg being invited to family and friends events.

Sorry, I'm rambling here. The point being that dh and I are both gainfully employed and our issues we had melted away with each other and we have both brought money to the table and it's gone in see saw fashion. We are not well off by a long shot but we love each other and it's sort of worked for us.

Neither of us have amazing careers but we made some sacrifices years ago that are paying off now.

I would be very happy with 100 grand extra but we are just about happy with our lot... And can pay to fix the boiler. People sometimes have different goals and for me to have a reasonably happy home life is key.

Elephantsdontlikechocolate · 09/08/2023 10:25

DryIce · 08/08/2023 19:00

Hah yes definitely recognise the new city dad, suddenly very keen to work late..!

I don't think anyone is blaming SAHMs for workplace issues, just pointing it out as another example of patriarchy that disadvantages women. I am sure it works brilliantly for loads of families, and that is excellent for them. However until the SAHP is as likely to be dad as mum, it perpetuates stereotypes that impact us all. I definitely see the impact of this in the corporate world - around last minute changes in plans, networking put of work hours, travel expectations etc.

This, until men are as likely as women to be SAHP. Women still will be at some disadvantage due to childbirth and recovery time needed but the gap would be a lot smaller.

DrasticAction · 09/08/2023 10:20

@Isaidnomorecrisps unfortunately and it's bizzare for such a carer woman that our boss doesn't seem go address it.

People have tried to gage from m hr but it's app closer shop..

Elephantsdontlikechocolate · 09/08/2023 10:18

EarringsandLipstick · 07/08/2023 22:00

In regards to who I work with

Yes. Who you work with. Which is not everywhere 🤷🏻‍♀️

But in the post from you I quoted you cited generally men with SAHM wives being an issue for female promotion

Hence why I took issue with it. If it's true for you, that's one thing. You can't generalise to everyone. I'm frankly horrified that it seems to be ok to attack SAHM as the cause of issues you perceive.

Well you are also muddling private with public - public sector there is barely any work done by anyone, forget the need for after hours presence

Swipe left for the next trending thread