Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand what she’s spending it on

516 replies

Idlovetoknow · 29/07/2023 21:58

It’s my mother. She’s a pensioner and a widow, but she working. She cannot deal with her finances. She’s been on the phone tonight weeping over how much of a dire situation she’s in financially, but I don’t see how.

income from work: £1100 (after tax)
state pension: £800
widows pension: £1600 (think this is after tax too)
private pension: £200/300 (she was wooly on this)
so total income around £3600 a month

No mortgage, no rent, no grounds costs.
council tax £200 a month. Power £150 (let’s say 200 to round up) food and pet food £400, car £450 petrol £100, health insurance £200, phone £50, sky £50, pet insurance £80- that’s £1300 at an absolute max

i don’t understand. She’s not being frauded or taken advantage of, but i don’t understand. I try to talk to her for instance tonight when she rang frantic over money but she gets into such a tizz she can’t tell you anything. I’ve asked for months for all bills and bank statements to go over expenses but she can’t produce them

Anyone any ideas?

OP posts:
BarbaraofSeville · 01/08/2023 17:17

OP, upthread I mentioned that there was a money coaching service being talked about on here a few months back, that your DM would probably be an ideal candidate for, if she'd engage with them, but I couldn't remember the name.

By coincidence, this thread about it just popped up again on my TIO.

Octopus Money Coach | Mumsnet

I heard about this job recently and it sounded really interesting. I'm thinking about transitioning into semi retirement from my almost full time well...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/money-matters/4781015-octopus-money-coach

EL8888 · 01/08/2023 13:36

FictionalCharacter · 31/07/2023 10:22

Spot on. This is a selfish, manipulative, financially very comfortable woman who has already seen a professional financial advisor and decided to do the opposite of what they advised. Now she's blaming her daughter for her imagined financial difficulties. But she is absolutely not short of money. She has a good income, chooses to be extravagant and has substantial savings and investments - she isn't running out of money.

All the people here talking about incorrect tax, scams, dementia or that she's grieving or lonely are barking up the wrong tree.

OP you have already spent too much time and emotional energy on her, when you have your own life and family that should be your priority. The only sensible thing to do is disengage and ignore the moaning, but you won't do that. So you've set yourself an impossible task. Your mother demands that you help her but won't let you. If you don't stop letting her play you, you'll have all this anxiety permanently.

This

I'm confused as to why OP is getting such a hard time. Her and her husband work 2 jobs, have 2 young children and don't live that near her mother. Whereas her mother is literally living the life of Riley. Whilst throwing lot of histrionics which feel very much like "my diamond shoes are too tight".

I sympathise massively. I'm spread thinly myself and have a histrionic mother. I feel like boundaries and grey rock are needed. Plus some stock phrases to be copy and pasted into conversations "why don't you see a financial advisor / accountant", "lm a project manager, lm not qualified in..". "What has Walter (or whatever your brother name is) suggested...".

Whatever you do won't be enough and further on down the line will be "wrong" (in her opinion rather than actually obviously). This is the joy of being the scapegoat

Turfwars · 01/08/2023 12:53

Ah OP I get you. I'm the scapegoat child as well. And a DM that should have lived easily on what Dad left her but is now broke and needs to sell up.
In her case, she's likely pissed it away playing Lady Bountiful with her extended family.
I'm the one who has to arrange everything for her, or help her buy what she needs but it's only so she can absolve herself and blame me when her impulsive purchases turn out to be wrong.
Luckily I have siblings who see the dysfunctional dynamic and even the favourite is still burdened with their own set of issues and challenges when it comes to DM, so we've got each other's backs.
I stay well out of any decision and purchase now as much as I'm able to but still...

mylifestory · 01/08/2023 12:24

check out narcissistic personality disorder. maybe that rings true to your childhood etc. they like to overspend and cant control money, thinking 5* hotels is what they deserve etc even if they cant afford it. also being cagey about their finances and seeking attention. i wdnt take any notice if this is the case even tho it is yr mother.

Ellyess · 01/08/2023 12:19

Nohelpfromme
I'm really sorry to hear of what you go through.
Mine too, made heavy demands. It was too much when she kept lying.
Solidarity and sympathy means everything even if you can't suggest what to do. Knowing people understand because they are going through it too, and that they bother to send their love and understanding really helped me. I sincerely hope it helps our OP.
I do hope our OP can step back a bit and enjoy her own family. My experience was that the more I did the more the demands grew. I had to become very detached and useless in regard to the demands put on me. On the phone I'd change the subject.

People who cannot. write in with supportive help or sympathetic understanding should keep away. I think it shows just how small-minded and mean a few people are when they write nasty remarks, especially to an OP who has written in for help with something that is distressing her.

SequentialAnalyst · 01/08/2023 12:15

BarbaraofSeville · 01/08/2023 11:51

Ooh ooh ooh!!! Is that an AI generated reply in the wild @Ellyess?

Biscuit

@Ellyess nice reply

Ellyess · 01/08/2023 12:06

CecilyP · 31/07/2023 11:36

That’s a great post from Kazzyhoward OP, explaining how hard it is for her. And that’s her job, she’ll get paid for it and she’s not emotionally involved. You already have a job and 2 small children; you can’t possibly take this any of this on. I agree with others it’s pointless asking to see the paperwork- you don’t have time to look at it.

You just sound too nice; too patient, too helpful. You do just have to stop. Next time she complains about her tax, just say it’s the same for everyone! Next time she complains about being £400 short, tell her to sell some investments, next time she says she can’t afford the phone, tell her to sell the sports car.

The reality is she has so many assets that she could use to generate funds should she really need to. She also works 20 hours has no dependents, so she has time to sort out her own problems.

She’s 68, not a doddery old lady. She’s perfectly capable of organising things that she wants like her holidays. Next time she moans, just say, mum I really don’t have time! Because you really don’t!

Yesssss!

Morgysmum · 01/08/2023 11:59

Maybe suggest you both go to her Bank. They can see where the money is going. She might be more calm in front of someone from the bank.
Is she likely to fall for mail fraud? My mil hasn't but I am surprised, as when we moved from living with them, she would send us our post, even the stuff that was clearly junk mail, simply because it said private. But clearly junk.

Ellyess · 01/08/2023 11:57

BarbaraofSeville ·
I'm sure it's really witty! But I didn't really get it. Sorry. Maybe you will explain.

temosmail · 01/08/2023 11:54

She's lying

Ellyess · 01/08/2023 11:54

Dear CatMum000 ·
What a nightmare! I just hope there were no debts left once the assets were sold.
I had to have an inward laugh though, as, being practically housebound, I have to have everything delivered. The dog's food and pee-pads are the biggest parcels. Pee-pads as I can't get to open the back door quickly enough for them to go out in the morning. I get all my food delivered and some things to keep my computer going. Also some second-hand books. And milk with a few supplies the Modern Milkman delivers.
I know I have a neighbour opposite whose chief hobby is keeping an eye on the her neighbours. No doubt she has me marked off as being like your M-in-law. Heaven forbid!
FlipFlop1987
I suppose I should be sticking up for them as I'm nearer that generation. But I simply get exasperated. My iPad was 12 years old and my laptop nearly as old. Neither can be updated any more. I looked and looked until I found an ex-demo iPad which is a recent one and which I could afford at a little over 50% of the retail price. It should see me out. The laptop will be replaced with a refurbished one. As I said, I need to do my shopping online as I cannot get out, so the laptop is necessary. Also, because I am house-bound, it is my link with the outside world.

BarbaraofSeville · 01/08/2023 11:51

Ooh ooh ooh!!! Is that an AI generated reply in the wild @Ellyess?

Ellyess · 01/08/2023 11:34

Dear Idlovetoknow,
I read your replies as far as I could (I'm short of time - sorry).
I'm a widow, pensioner on a much lower... err.. that's MUCH lower income than your mother. I mean the sort that makes me choose between food and heat sometimes and not having central heating. I am disabled and had to stop working through disability. I have trouble with the daily expenses. But I usually just about scrape by. I am very well educated and held a good position in a job requiring high qualifications but the car accident obliterated my career. I never go out except for medical appointments. No car, no holidays. Your mother might do well to think of people like me, and there are many worse off than I.

I think money is as much an attitude as a reality. Some people my age are simply frightened, I often am, by the cost of living these days. They may be unrealistic about what they can afford. The price of heating has terrified many of us.

I think your mother is emotionally blackmailing you. I'll be blunt - sorry - she sounds very spoilt, with her many first class holidays: It must upset you but I saw this in a different light when you said;
"She broke down sobbing in a car dealership because she couldn’t have both a £600 a month car and 5 holidays a year (btw these holidays are 2 weeks at a time and she’d never lower herself to stay in anything less than 5 stars… maybe a 4+ boutique hotel maybe, she’d treat herself to 1st class here and there too)" and two houses and, sorry, 5 bedrooms is a big house, and a new car every 3 years, sobbing in the show-room because she wants the top model - that alone speaks of a very manipulative person to me. As for her grudge that she 'only' gets half of her late husband's pension, well, when he was alive, did he not need some of it, and does she not have earning capacity of her own? She sounds terribly selfish and terribly 'entitled'.

I'm so sorry, Idlovetoknow, I think your mother's 'money problems' do not exist at all but that she has a personality problem and is burdening you with her monetary worries because she can get your attention and because she actually believes she is entitled to a life of luxury with a high income. I feel extremely sorry for you to have to go through her kind of phone calls and her unreasonable complaints about her finances and what she wants. You have your own children and she should be supporting you - not financially although she could if she tried, but emotionally. But she is someone who only thinks of herself. Her world revolves around herself and she thinks she somehow has the right to have everything she wants; she believe she needs only the most luxurious life with the most expensive lifestyle money can buy. I expect your father found this very hard. Now he has passed, she is using you as her emotional battering ram.

Try and keep a distance between her whining about money and your feelings. It is a manipulative, selfish, attention-seeking device. Just stay neutral. Say obvious things like, 'Well you are not starving, you are managing well. If necessary you could cut back on some spending. Maybe get a cheaper car." Remain cool and calm. Just sound neutral and friendly but unemotional. It's not your problem and do not expect her to change. I'm afraid she is too old for this.

Above all, take care of yourself, your own family and enjoy your life with them. Lots of love, Elle. 💐

CatMum000 · 01/08/2023 11:27

My MIL sadly passed away in 2018. She had various forms of income and took holidays regularly. She had retired around 3 years earlier with substantial pension lump sum plus downsized her property releasing further funds. It wasn't until she passed that we found out the extent of the debt she was in due to compulsive spending, premium face treatments etc and a bad QVC habit. Neighbours told us 3 parcels a week were arriving. She had a huge chest full of it, wardrobe full of new clothes for the upcoming holidays. Extent of the debts were £20,000 from credit cards, overdrawn accounts borrowing from one to pay another. Could be a similar situation to this. Shopping channels are like kryptonite for some people. Perhaps more direct questions are needed. Do not assist financially until you have answers. PS MILs paperwork including all banking letters were shredded. Good luck.

FlipFlop1987 · 01/08/2023 10:24

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 31/07/2023 22:23

My in laws do this. Every time something breaks, straight to John Lewis regardless of price. My MiL has just bought an iPhone (just the phone itself) outright from there despite her phone provider offering her one with no interest as part of her monthly contract. Then she was pissed off when EE wouldn't set it up for her/transfer all her stuff in store!

There’s no reasoning with them either is there. My FIL got talked into a huge iPad in JL, to be used instead of a phone so he has to carry a satchel with him everywhere and uses the iPad to make calls. It’s ridiculous, he isn’t blind, he just needed a simple to use phone 🤦🏻‍♀️

Kanfuzed123 · 01/08/2023 09:33

2jacqi · 01/08/2023 08:15

to be honest, it sounds more like depression to me. also lack of company. contact bank and get online access to all her accounts and credit cards etc. you can then work things out in your own home when kids are in bed

you know that no one can do that right? You can’t just phone up a bank and asked them to send someone’s statements to you?

Ganainm488 · 01/08/2023 08:16

I had DO tax code when I changed job. I didn’t notice as I’d taken a drop in salary and expected a lower income. 3 years later I spotted it. One phone call to HMRC and it was sorted over the phone and a lump sum for overpaid tax was put into my bank account within 2 weeks.
However I don’t think this is your main problem. Your mum’s behaviour is screaming narcissistic personality type. This is not a diagnosis or label just a way of describing the behaviour. You’ve probably been controlled and treated like this all your life. Which is why you are still trying to help her despite her unreasonable behaviour. I suggest you spend time understanding narcissism and the effect it has on you, so you know how to deal with it. If you don’t have time then listen to a podcast. Mel Robbins podcast on this subject is an eye opener if you’ve never considered narcissism before.

StopStartStop · 01/08/2023 08:16

Dementia.
Fear of keeping records of finances.
Ask her if you can help. Get all the info together, and go through it until she knows where she's up to.

2jacqi · 01/08/2023 08:15

to be honest, it sounds more like depression to me. also lack of company. contact bank and get online access to all her accounts and credit cards etc. you can then work things out in your own home when kids are in bed

Kazzyhoward · 01/08/2023 08:14

BarbaraofSeville · 01/08/2023 08:09

There's also phones, and there's phones.

I buy a new phone every 3 or 4 years when I see a good offer on a half decent Android, on Black Friday or similar. None of these have cost more than £150 and I usually sell the old one for about £50 on ebay.

Compare with the cost of getting a new iphone every time it comes out and letting the old one sit in a drawer, giving it to a family member or just recycling it because it's broken (none of my phones have ever been broken and am not especially careful, have dropped a few) yet a lot of people to be continually breaking their phones. The cost of doing phones this way is enormous.

There also seem to be loads of people who continue paying the "full" monthly contract price long after the contract period has expired instead of moving to a cheaper "sim only" tariff. I just don't understand them at all. It's often just a click of a button on the mobile phone's app and they could save £10-£40 per month easily. And yes, those who just churn the contract into a new phone for no real reason. The mind boggles at the amount of money people waste.

Downdoneandout · 01/08/2023 08:11

@Idlovetoknow she sounds like my mother but with more money (although whatever mine has she would absolutely spend!). Down to the childish refusing to talk to you if you don’t meet her unreasonable expectations and the ‘golden child’ brother who does sweet FA except to constantly drain her finances and cause additional drama.

The expectations that I rescue her (from financial woe, plus any other issue she has - she was quite perturbed that I wasn’t a tv electrician the other day) are constant, unreasonable and stressful. It is a complete 1 way street of tale and no give, and you have your own stressors and life to manage.

She is an adult woman who is responsible for herself. She is not your responsibility; your child is. I say this as it’s what I gave to tell myself constantly (although I’m not very good at doing it consistently!!).

She is looking for your pity as her narcissistic supply (and possibly a actual financial hand out - which will prove your love and her wonderfulness of course!). I’d hazard a guess that even if you added the extra stressor of driving up there, the financial papers would be ‘lost’ and you’d get tears and drama rather than any actual solutions!

She needs to go back to a financial advisor and get them to sort it, or bring all her papers down next time she visits. I would broken record that, and refuse to engage in further conversation about it.

Don’t know if it’s of help, but this book was really useful to me: You're Not Crazy - It's Your Mother: Freedom for daughters of narcissistic mothers - new edition
https://amzn.eu/d/3rOLkqX

Good luck! X

https://amzn.eu/d/3rOLkqX?tag=mumsnet&ascsubtag=mnforum-am-i-being-unreasonable-4860332-to-not-understand-what-shes-spending-it-on

BarbaraofSeville · 01/08/2023 08:09

There's also phones, and there's phones.

I buy a new phone every 3 or 4 years when I see a good offer on a half decent Android, on Black Friday or similar. None of these have cost more than £150 and I usually sell the old one for about £50 on ebay.

Compare with the cost of getting a new iphone every time it comes out and letting the old one sit in a drawer, giving it to a family member or just recycling it because it's broken (none of my phones have ever been broken and am not especially careful, have dropped a few) yet a lot of people to be continually breaking their phones. The cost of doing phones this way is enormous.

AndIKnewYouMeantIt · 01/08/2023 06:55

PickAChew · 31/07/2023 23:12

I wouldn't criticise buying a phone outright. Most of the time it is genuinely cheaper to do that and take out a SIM only plan than pay for a phone on a contract.

It wasn't in this case.

Iwant2stayanon · 01/08/2023 06:32

Is she one of those people that thinks she is broke because she doesn’t have £3k plus in her current account at all times?

But seriously maybe she has racked up some debt she is struggling with. I would definitely try and encourage her to share with you so you can help. Good luck OP.

SequentialAnalyst · 31/07/2023 23:28

Ah, thanks I didn't know that about joint tenants.

Swipe left for the next trending thread