Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Talk to me if you are an only child or only have one child....

153 replies

Noangelbuthavingfun · 19/07/2023 12:35

Feel utterly emotionally drained. Am 46....one DS...wonderful. He is 12. Long story short we started trying for no 2 when he was 4. 4 miscarriages later including one on IVF and we kind of had to accept it wasn't meant to be and I'll never forgive myself for not trying sooner but...
AIBU to feel like I've failed DS. He asked the other day can he give a sibling and ut brought it all back....
So talk to me if you are an only child OR have only one child. Don't hold back .... pros and cons . I need balanced perspective. Thank you !

OP posts:
Strawberriesandpears · 19/07/2023 18:29

I think it's clearly a complex issue, but ultimately, I do think that people who have a happy relationship with their siblings into adulthood have the best family set up and chance of support with some of life's tricker things to navigate.

If I had another life and could choose that for myself (rather than being an only child) I 100 percent would.

As an example, I have an aunty (not a blood relation) who has 3 sisters. They are like a force to be reckoned with. They will always have each other. One of them (who is single and doesn't have kids) recently got cancer and the others rallied round and looked after her. What a comfort it must be to have that sort of safety net. I desperately wish I had that for myself.

MrsMariaReynolds · 19/07/2023 18:20

I'm an only child who is also raising only child DS who is now 15. I wouldn't change any of it for the world. Things are so much simpler for us compared to families with more than one child, and I say that sincerely. I have an incredibly close relationship with my parents, and my son is bonded to us in really similar, very special way, even as a tricky teen. You absolutely haven't let your son down at all.

cobden28 · 19/07/2023 18:15

I'm an only child of a Mum who was herself an only child, and I have just the one child myself. Mum (now 92) actually had a half-brother but as both were born out of wedlock, a great social sin/disgrace in the 1930's - both children were adopted spearately and Mum was brought up as an 'only'.

Mum only had me and was divorced very acrimoniously from my late Dad when I was still in infants' school, so a sibling for me was never on the cards.Dad remarried and had a diughter by his second wife but my half-sister and I were brought up separately, in different households at opposite ends of the country, so to all practical intents and purposes I'm an 'only' as that's what I was brought up as.

I fell pregnant by accident wwhen I was 35 after having been told by a female GP that there was no sense in my continuing to use contraception as I was too old to get pregnant - my daughter was born when I was just turned 36 !! My ex and I hadn't originally inrended tio have chldren at all, but I sailed through my pregnancy despite my 'advanced age'. I would then have liked to have had a sibling for her but my ex was out of work at the time and refused point-blank to stay at home to look after two babies; I had a steady job in the civil service so had to return to work as soon as my maternity leave ended because we needed my salary to pay the mortgage & bills.

I was sterilised when I was 41 and daughter was 5 because we couldn't afford to raise a second child and I was having problems with the contraceptive method used, so that ruled a second child out altogether. I then had a hysterectomy when I was 51 ( last-ditch attempt to cure the horrendous PMS I'd suffered from sonce puberty), Daughter is now approaching age 32 with no children and no plans for children in the forseeable future - but realises that her advanced age (ie over 25) isn't in itself a bar to pregnancy should she decide in the next few years she wants to have a child and make me a granny.

VeryQuaintIrene · 19/07/2023 18:04

CecilyP · 19/07/2023 17:28

I have a couple of friends, both the youngest of 3, who became their mother’s carers after their fathers died. They do everything, the others do nothing! They have to cope with both the responsibility and resentment towards their lazy uncaring siblings!

Dear God, I am not disagreeing with either of you. I know this happens. And from my own recent lived experience, it is also bloody hard work being literally the only one who deals with a depressed and difficult (though much loved) mother approaching her end, that's all.

Roastingcoffee · 19/07/2023 17:53

I am a happy parent to a happy only child. I sometimes wonder why we’re all encouraged to come down on one side of the fence or the other - surely we all know that having a child isn’t always a choice we can make, and that every family environment is different and complex

it reminds me a bit of the child free/ parenting discourse, where people without children are made to feel lesser than/ selfish/ odd. Not by any person in particular, but by the culture at large. It seems like flawed logic to me - eg no doubt parents frequently feel like they have to be selfless for their kids, but that doesn’t mean that non parents spend their time being selfish.

likewise, people see the benefits of having a sibling and think that people without siblings have the opposite, negative experience - being a sibling helps you share, so onlies are selfish. But it’s not as simple as that.

op, it’s natural to have to take time to grieve the child/ren you hoped to have. Good luck on your journey.

Elvis1956 · 19/07/2023 17:46

I'm an only child. I'm outgoing, make friends easily, happy with my own company. I'm inventive, can entertain myself and can play chess, cards and even monopoly on my own!!
Only negative... I can't share, it's not the fact that others may have more than me, but that I may end up with more than others. To fix it we even count out smarties!

booksandbrooks · 19/07/2023 17:32

Windercar · 19/07/2023 12:54

Your post is pretty offensive to those of us who have chosen to have one child. It’s sad you think I’ve failed my child because I don’t. In fact our relationship and home life is amazing so.

I don't think it's offensive in the least. You have to do what's right for you but OP should be able to express her feelings around her family and fertility without being sneered at. She's opening up about her recurrent miscarriages, give her a break.

I'm an only and I remember at 12 absolutely longing and aching for a sibling. It's an emotional age and we can't always get what we want.

It's much easier to facilitate the activities and needs of a single child. You can offer them different support and opportunities. When I became pregnant with my second the opportunists and plans that were curbed by it really hit me.

CecilyP · 19/07/2023 17:28

VeryQuaintIrene · 19/07/2023 16:51

@Thinkbiglittleone You aren't properly understanding what I am saying - it's guaranteed that an only child will be left to deal with everything. With siblings, there's more variety of possible experience. We aren't really disagreeing but it's not rubbish to say that dealing with aging parents may be difficult if there's just one of you.

I have a couple of friends, both the youngest of 3, who became their mother’s carers after their fathers died. They do everything, the others do nothing! They have to cope with both the responsibility and resentment towards their lazy uncaring siblings!

CecilyP · 19/07/2023 17:22

AIBU to feel like I've failed DS. He asked the other day can he give a sibling and ut brought it all back....
So talk to me if you are an only child OR have only one child. Don't hold back .... pros and cons . I need balanced perspective. Thank you !

At 46 , there really isn’t much you can do about it now so I’m not sure what the point of all the angst is. FWIW, DS, also an only child, has never asked about brothers or sisters. He did, however, ask about grandparents as most of his friends had grandparents. Both sets were gone by the time he was 4 so there wasn’t much we could do about that! In much the same way as there’s not much you can do about having another child.

Moneynewpence · 19/07/2023 17:11

Noangelbuthavingfun · 19/07/2023 12:35

Feel utterly emotionally drained. Am 46....one DS...wonderful. He is 12. Long story short we started trying for no 2 when he was 4. 4 miscarriages later including one on IVF and we kind of had to accept it wasn't meant to be and I'll never forgive myself for not trying sooner but...
AIBU to feel like I've failed DS. He asked the other day can he give a sibling and ut brought it all back....
So talk to me if you are an only child OR have only one child. Don't hold back .... pros and cons . I need balanced perspective. Thank you !

With one exception all the only children I have ever known have been lovely, well balanced people.
Sadly the exception is my late father, but his lack of siblings was never the issue.

Gonnawashmymouthout · 19/07/2023 17:05

were a one and done family. Don’t regret it for a moment. We have more time and money for one child. We can give him all the activities he wants.

we took years to have DS so just so pleased to have him

Beezknees · 19/07/2023 17:05

Strawberriesandpears · 19/07/2023 16:37

I think you are right. Yes, I do have a partner, although the relationship is only a few months old. I think he is 'my person' though, so that is good. 😊

I do hope that counselling would help. I know I am not the only person in this situation who feels like this though. For example:

💐

RuthW · 19/07/2023 16:56

I am an only and have an adult only.

Pros - we are very close

She grew up to be very independent and mature

My life got back to normal quicker

Less stress than friends

More money

You can take one child to most places

Those are the first ones I've thought of.

Cons
Can't think of any

VeryQuaintIrene · 19/07/2023 16:51

@Thinkbiglittleone You aren't properly understanding what I am saying - it's guaranteed that an only child will be left to deal with everything. With siblings, there's more variety of possible experience. We aren't really disagreeing but it's not rubbish to say that dealing with aging parents may be difficult if there's just one of you.

Jellycats4life · 19/07/2023 16:45

You haven’t failed your son. None of this was your choice or your fault. It’s was simply the hand your family was dealt.

I can offer a difference perspective, maybe. I was an only child, again not by choice, because my mum suffered repeated miscarriages. Then, surprisingly, she had a pregnancy that stuck. My sibling was born when I was 10, in year 5.

It’s a big age gap. In many way we were both only children living under the same roof. We have always been at massively different life stages. It’s very difficult to be close in those circumstances. I don’t really remember him being a teen because I’d moved out by then and we didn’t really speak or see each other.

As adults were physically and emotionally quite distant. Maybe because he’s male 😉 but I wonder if things would have been different if we’d been closer in age. I mean, we don’t even share the same family memories because he didn’t exist for most of my childhood. We were born in totally different decades!

This is a long winded way of saying that, if you could wave a magic wand and give your child a sibling tomorrow, it wouldn’t be all sunshine and rainbows. Sibling relationships aren’t a guarantee of love and companionship even when born close together. I love my brother but it’s not a typical sibling relationship by any means.

Strawberriesandpears · 19/07/2023 16:37

Beezknees · 19/07/2023 16:34

I really do think it's important that you look into counselling, you shouldn't have to live like this. Am I right that you have a partner? Can you talk to them about how you're feeling?

I think you are right. Yes, I do have a partner, although the relationship is only a few months old. I think he is 'my person' though, so that is good. 😊

I do hope that counselling would help. I know I am not the only person in this situation who feels like this though. For example:

To be genuinely afraid of my future and spending it alone and dying alone? | Mumsnet

I’ve never been in a relationship, I haven’t totally given up, but I’m not exactly imagining a future with a partner anymore. I’m an only child, pare...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4830447-to-be-genuinely-afraid-of-my-future-and-spending-it-alone-and-dying-alone

Beezknees · 19/07/2023 16:34

Strawberriesandpears · 19/07/2023 16:31

Maybe, although I do think about it from morning to night. It was the first thing I thought about when I woke this morning, and I was shaking with fear before I even got up. 😕

I really do think it's important that you look into counselling, you shouldn't have to live like this. Am I right that you have a partner? Can you talk to them about how you're feeling?

Strawberriesandpears · 19/07/2023 16:31

Beezknees · 19/07/2023 16:27

Feeling a bit anxious isn't OTT, but I do think it's extreme to say it's terrifying.

Maybe, although I do think about it from morning to night. It was the first thing I thought about when I woke this morning, and I was shaking with fear before I even got up. 😕

Beezknees · 19/07/2023 16:27

Meerkatdog · 19/07/2023 16:13

How can you tell someone that is seeking therapy that it is an OTT reaction?
Are you saying she should pretend she doesn't feel that way? Or just belittling her emotions?
It's quite a big deal to feel alone and that you have no family either the same age or younger, it would worry me too.

Feeling a bit anxious isn't OTT, but I do think it's extreme to say it's terrifying.

blahblahblah1654 · 19/07/2023 16:27

I have a DS who is 3 and he will probably be an only. I've had 2 miscarriages after him including one at 20 weeks and severe preeclampsia with my son and the late miscarriage so it could be too dangerous to try again. He's only very young but has never asked or seemed curious about wanting a sibling. This could change. I have a younger brother and we aren't close. My DH is one of three and doesn't speak to his siblings. No fall out but they aren't close.

Strawberriesandpears · 19/07/2023 16:26

Meerkatdog · 19/07/2023 16:13

How can you tell someone that is seeking therapy that it is an OTT reaction?
Are you saying she should pretend she doesn't feel that way? Or just belittling her emotions?
It's quite a big deal to feel alone and that you have no family either the same age or younger, it would worry me too.

Thank you. It is difficult.

I'm only 36 but I've started thinking about things such as planning my own funeral as I will have nobody else to do it. In fact, I am considering a straight to the crematorium type thing (no service) as there will be no family to attend. It feels very sad. In a way I feel like my life is already over. 🙁

I don't know what to do with my possessions either. I think I may start getting rid of them (or at least not acquiring any more) as there will be nobody to clear my things out and I don't want to leave a big mess behind.

I'll also have to start looking at appointing a solicitor to sort out my estate, I guess. It feels like a lot to be thinking about at a relatively young age, but it's necessary. Facing your own mortality like this is difficult. I think it has sent me into a bit of a depression to be honest.

cinnamonfrenchtoast · 19/07/2023 16:18

I'm an only child, but my parents are both from big families (they're both one of six) and my DH is one of five.

I love being an only child - obviously I have nothing to compare it to, but neither my parents or DH are close to their siblings. In fact, all DH's siblings live within five minutes of us and he hasn't seen any of them since last year Grin

My mum rings her older sister every couple of months, the other she hasn't had proper contact with in over a decade and her brothers are all dead. My dad speaks to his older sister on Facebook but has no relationship with any of the others. There's never been a falling out, they're just not close and have nothing in common other than the same parents.

Your DS may like the idea of a playmate or sibling but there's no guarantee they'd get on or even like each other.

Meerkatdog · 19/07/2023 16:13

Beezknees · 19/07/2023 15:16

That's a very OTT reaction.

How can you tell someone that is seeking therapy that it is an OTT reaction?
Are you saying she should pretend she doesn't feel that way? Or just belittling her emotions?
It's quite a big deal to feel alone and that you have no family either the same age or younger, it would worry me too.

WaitingfortheTardis · 19/07/2023 16:08

I am an only child and have an only child by choice, I honestly can't imagine what a sibling would bring to her life. I never wanted a brother or sister either. Dd is a happy, friendly, confident, loving child.

WimpoleHat · 19/07/2023 16:05

I’m an only, I have two (who get on very well) and my DH is one of three (who don’t - he says quite openly he wishes he had been an only child). So my main message is this: there is no such thing as the perfect set up or the right way to have a family. Circumstances rule - and you need to make the best of what you have; revel in the positives (for only children, that’s usually more time and money) and try to mitigate the negatives.

I never minded being an only child growing up; I’ve found it a lot more challenging as an adult - no wider family to share in my own children and sole responsibility for one very difficult elderly parent. But then again, my DH doesn’t get on with his siblings and finds them pretty useless helping with his elderly parents, so there are no guarantees. Similarly, while one of the undoubted highlights of motherhood for me has been watching the relationship between my DC evolve and grow, I know I’m very lucky that they get on; one of my friends spends a good chunk of her time refereeing between her two who constantly bicker to the point that they suck any joy out of anything. So - on balance - yes, if finances aren’t an issue and you have a sibling that you love dearly, then that probably is the best option. But you can’t guarantee either of those!