Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how responsible dog owners would react in this situation?

97 replies

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 07:20

We live in a terrace house, 2 up 2 down sort of size with long parallel gardens.
We have 2 toddlers. Our neighbours have 2 dogs that weigh more than my husband. Think Great Dane/mountain dog sized. Huge.
We’ve raised concerns about them before and how we worry they could jump the fence (it is low, as stipulated in the deeds).
Well last night, one jumped the fence. Luckily only DH in the garden, still nearly knocked him over.
Now we’re waiting to have the conversation with them about wtf they’re going to do about it.
I said they should be offering to pay for a more substantial fence (even though it is our fence on the deeds).

Am I also BU for thinking they’re idiots for having this type of dog in a tiny house? The wife has already been pulled over by them on their leads.

OP posts:
Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 21:52

No they never use their front door, they don’t answer it. Visitors go round the back.

We didn’t remain as calm as planned because of some of the things he said. If we have to report them for anything I think our life will become living hell.

OP posts:
Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 21:53

NotEverORNever · 17/06/2023 21:17

That's a shame the talk didn't go well. Sometimes people initially react badly to being criticized about something but then, once they have calmed down and thought about it realism that the criticism was fair.

I'll keep my finger crossed that your Neighbour falls in this group of people.

we already know he doesn't, no reasonable person would have those dogs in that home, now OP has insulted his most prized possessions, he'll be looking for some way to punish her for daring to speak against him

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 21:55

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 21:52

No they never use their front door, they don’t answer it. Visitors go round the back.

We didn’t remain as calm as planned because of some of the things he said. If we have to report them for anything I think our life will become living hell.

what are you going to do now?
he will make it his mission to make your lives hell because you dared to confront him

rosielemonaddde · 17/06/2023 22:07

I would tell them they need to pay for fences large enough to stop this happening again, or you will be reporting them for putting children in danger.

There are too many incidents with dogs killing babies and children, they need to be responsible.

You wouldn't have to fork out for a new fence if it wasn't for their dogs being out of control so they should foot the bill as they are causing it.

EvilElsa · 17/06/2023 22:11

What was his defense? Why did be get so angry?

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 22:11

rosielemonaddde · 17/06/2023 22:07

I would tell them they need to pay for fences large enough to stop this happening again, or you will be reporting them for putting children in danger.

There are too many incidents with dogs killing babies and children, they need to be responsible.

You wouldn't have to fork out for a new fence if it wasn't for their dogs being out of control so they should foot the bill as they are causing it.

really?? after hearing about how this person behaves you think he's going to take orders
😂😂
OP is well and truly fucked.

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 22:13

EvilElsa · 17/06/2023 22:11

What was his defense? Why did be get so angry?

he got angry because he's a arrogant nutter with enormous dogs and someone has called him out
that's just how people like that behave

Tygertiger · 18/06/2023 08:20

What is in your deeds about access at the back? I also live in a house with shared access at the rear but the deeds are clear that it is only for certain things, eg to allow for window cleaners to access the rear of the properties. We’re not allowed to just walk across people’s gardens because we don’t fancy using the front. It would be worth checking if they are allowed to solely use the back when in most circumstances they could be using the front.

SoccerStars · 18/06/2023 10:29

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 21:52

No they never use their front door, they don’t answer it. Visitors go round the back.

We didn’t remain as calm as planned because of some of the things he said. If we have to report them for anything I think our life will become living hell.

Sorry to hear that. I was trying to be optimistic but I could see this happening tbh. People were saying use the legislation as a last resort, and fair enough - but it was clear that it would indeed come to that. If he was a reasonable or considerate dog owner, he would have been proactive in coming over and letting you know he would be sorting the problem out immediately. It was very telling that you had to open the dialogue.

I think now you’ve started challenging them you either need to retreat completely if you don’t want the hassle or stand up to them and follow it through.

Personally I’d do the latter. I walk through the streets and avoid dog mess, I avoid going into parks altogether due to out of control dogs so the last
place I’ll let a dog owner make me feel uncomfortable is my own property.

If it’s any consolation, I’m a single woman but when I stood up To my neighbour (who lives with her male partner) the second time her dog tried to jump at me she was very mouthy but I told her I’d already reported her, which I had and did a second time too. I don’t know if others complained or she was advised to let go off the dog, but the dog no longer lives in the flat building. Either way I’m glad I stood up to them. Maybe they’ll think twice before they get a dog they don’t have time for in a small upper floor flat.

SoccerStars · 18/06/2023 10:36

rosielemonaddde · 17/06/2023 22:07

I would tell them they need to pay for fences large enough to stop this happening again, or you will be reporting them for putting children in danger.

There are too many incidents with dogs killing babies and children, they need to be responsible.

You wouldn't have to fork out for a new fence if it wasn't for their dogs being out of control so they should foot the bill as they are causing it.

I agree with this, or they need to agree to keep their dogs on leash. I think there’s no point backing down now because you’ve already opened the can or worms so either way they’ll be hostile to you. Therefore you may as well make sure they pay for the fence /agree to always supervise their dogs in the garden. The council /dog warden/ police can definitely make them do the latter.

Someone commented saying they had a friendly breed and that is completely irrelevant. All dogs are capable of snapping and with huge dogs like those, they can easily injure a toddler even when they’re being friendly!

I’d advise you to get some kind of security camera if you can so you can have evidence about the extent of things. For all you know there could be times when you’re out as a family that the dog has been in your garden.

SamphiretheTervosaurReturneth · 18/06/2023 11:01

In that situation I wouldn't have that kind of dog.

Pearlsaminga · 18/06/2023 11:25

I told her I’d already reported her, which I had and did a second time too. I don’t know if others complained or she was advised to let go off the dog, but the dog no longer lives in the flat building. Either way I’m glad I stood up to them. Maybe they’ll think twice before they get a dog they don’t have time for in a small upper floor flat
@SoccerStars that's a relief and good to know that you were able to get a result!
Are you prepared to say who you reported them to? 🙏

JMSA · 18/06/2023 11:29

A training lead (much longer than average) in the garden would be a good, cheap compromise to hopefully keep everyone happy.

SoccerStars · 18/06/2023 13:18

Pearlsaminga · 18/06/2023 11:25

I told her I’d already reported her, which I had and did a second time too. I don’t know if others complained or she was advised to let go off the dog, but the dog no longer lives in the flat building. Either way I’m glad I stood up to them. Maybe they’ll think twice before they get a dog they don’t have time for in a small upper floor flat
@SoccerStars that's a relief and good to know that you were able to get a result!
Are you prepared to say who you reported them to? 🙏

Yes! I live in a flat development and I reported them to the housing manager who spoke to them the same week!

SoccerStars · 18/06/2023 13:21

And just to add, I told the housing manager I’d escalate it to the council if nothing was done about it. And I would have!

Pearlsaminga · 18/06/2023 13:29

SoccerStars · 18/06/2023 13:21

And just to add, I told the housing manager I’d escalate it to the council if nothing was done about it. And I would have!

You must be very relieved that you were able to have this resolved, but the fact that they were renting from a housing association seems to be what gave you the leverage that you needed.
I think the op is dealing with owner occupiers so there isn't the same chain of command to protect from nuisance neighbours 😕

Throwncrumbs · 18/06/2023 13:34

I would be saying that access through your garden for the dogs stops also they need to sort out a better way of stopping them jumping over the fence. I think as they use the access for the dogs the dogs see it as part of their territory now. I would say if it happens again you will be taking things further police, dog warden or a solicitor . They are massively in the wrong. Stupid people!!

IDontWantToBeAPie · 18/06/2023 16:28

Hmm. I don't think it's reasonable to ask them for a better fence. While it's their dogs that are the danger it's YOUR children you're worried about and YOUR fence. So you should replace your fence.

Pearlsaminga · 18/06/2023 16:50

Idk if it's reasonable or not but I wouldn't mess about asking them, I'd install the biggest sturdiest fence I could and possibly plant something on the other side that would create a strong impression on anything that managed to breach it.

SoccerStars · 18/06/2023 16:51

Pearlsaminga · 18/06/2023 13:29

You must be very relieved that you were able to have this resolved, but the fact that they were renting from a housing association seems to be what gave you the leverage that you needed.
I think the op is dealing with owner occupiers so there isn't the same chain of command to protect from nuisance neighbours 😕

Yes I was relieved - thanks!

That's a good point. Although some do own their flats here, they still have to obey the building rules as we all pay service charges. But yes it would be trickier if we all lived in seperate houses and were owners.

I privately rented during covid in a massive 40 storey flat development and there was a vicious looking dog clearly stronger than its owner that kept trying to go for me despite it being on a leash. I reported that also to building managers, but they took weeks to get back to me and when they did they just said they’d have a word with the woman who owned it but I don’t think they did. Thankfully I moved out shortly after, it was a disaster waiting to happen. I think dogs like that don’t belong in large tightly packed flat developments. I suspect it was a “lockdown dog” never really had these kind of incidents pre-2020.

SoccerStars · 18/06/2023 16:55

IDontWantToBeAPie · 18/06/2023 16:28

Hmm. I don't think it's reasonable to ask them for a better fence. While it's their dogs that are the danger it's YOUR children you're worried about and YOUR fence. So you should replace your fence.

They are legally obliged to keep their dogs under control, they don’t need to build a fence true…but they need to come forward with an immediate alternative to ensure their dogs don’t escape again.

This is why I suggested the Op just tell them to make sure this stops happening rather than instruct them on exactly how to do so.

fences aren’t cheap. They shouldn’t be out of pocket like that and sets a bad precedent. What if they move & live next door to a struggling single parent and same things happen and they insist that person has to pay out of their pocket to stop their out of control dogs?

I’d definitely keep kids inside until it’s resolved either way so there’s no risk to them but paying for fence is a step too far IMO.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page