Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how responsible dog owners would react in this situation?

97 replies

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 07:20

We live in a terrace house, 2 up 2 down sort of size with long parallel gardens.
We have 2 toddlers. Our neighbours have 2 dogs that weigh more than my husband. Think Great Dane/mountain dog sized. Huge.
We’ve raised concerns about them before and how we worry they could jump the fence (it is low, as stipulated in the deeds).
Well last night, one jumped the fence. Luckily only DH in the garden, still nearly knocked him over.
Now we’re waiting to have the conversation with them about wtf they’re going to do about it.
I said they should be offering to pay for a more substantial fence (even though it is our fence on the deeds).

Am I also BU for thinking they’re idiots for having this type of dog in a tiny house? The wife has already been pulled over by them on their leads.

OP posts:
cobden28 · 17/06/2023 13:23

If it's your fence but their dogs that are the problem, they should pay for any fence alterations to make it too high for the dogs to jump over, ie on their side of the boundary put up tall fence posts with panels at the top of the posts that cover the distance between the top of your fencing and the top of their posts. In the meantime, beause I know that fencing is expensive, the neighbours should only have the dogs out in their garden if someone's out there with them to keep an eye on them. And I'd also reccommend lots more exercise than they're obviously currently getting 0 as well as dog training classes!

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 13:24

In my opinion, a non-dog owner, they are under exercised. The partner cannot take them out herself after they pulled her over, they told us that.
As a few PPs have said, I am worried about their size more than anything. They would flatten my youngest just by wagging their tail. And I know I can’t dictate what they own but I can still secretly think they’re stupid to do so in the house that they live in.

OP posts:
starfishmummy · 17/06/2023 13:58

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 07:59

Trellis would be the only option we could afford though it would look awful and probably not last.
Really helpful link, I’d love to present them with all of those facts but hope it won’t come to that as we generally have a good relationship.

Even then maybe its maybe not enough. Years ago we lived in a terrace which had gsrdenwalls about 5ft high and the neighbours great dane still got over that (and did huge poos in our garden.)

It was resolved by them always supervising him when he was outside.

cartagenagina · 17/06/2023 14:06

The main issue isn’t the size of the dogs, but the fact they aren’t properly trained (and possibly under exercised)

My old NDN had a gigantic Rottweiler that looked like it could rip your head off. When our fence came down in a storm, he still played in the garden, but never crossed into our garden. Despite vicious teasing from my cats! He was properly trained.

I agree that you need to have a calm and sensible talk with neighbours. Explain that you are worried your child might be flattened and that you are pretty scared and unable to use garden properly.

I think offering to go 50/50 on improving the fence would be a reasonable offer.

Frequency · 17/06/2023 14:14

I have a large breed dog and a short front garden fence. The large dog is not allowed unsupervised in the front garden atm. He doesn't yet realise he can jump the fence but is ushered away when he gets too close and has been taught not jump up onto surfaces.

If he ever realises he can jump the fence or gives me any indication that he knows he can jump the fence he won't be allowed in the front garden off lead.

I wouldn't move into a house with short fencing on the back garden and if I'd already lived in one prior to getting a dog I probably wouldn't have a adopted a large breed.

It's their dog and their responsibility to keep it safe and contained on their own property. If they're not willing to train and supervise and use longlines if needed then they should be asking you for permission to change the fencing at their expense.

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 14:15

@Numbertwenty sadly there is nothing you can do, you will just have to live in fear of these dogs.
The owners will refuse to do anything to restrict the freedom and enjoyment of their fur babies and there's nothing you can do to make them.

Spidey66 · 17/06/2023 14:21

I'm a dog owner, but these don't appear responsible. Firstly, they have 2 enormous dogs in what appears to be a very small house, and secondly they have not dogproofed the garden. Regardless of the deeds and whose fence it is, they need to ensure the dogs can't get into your garden. If they won't make the fence higher and/or more sturdy, they need to ensure the dogs are not off lead or unsupervised. We dogproofed our garden before we got her.

I hate dog owners like this, as it gives all of us a bad name,

coffeecupsandwaxmelts · 17/06/2023 14:23

Our dog once jumped the fence into next doors garden - he wasn't allowed in the garden unleashed until we heightened the fence!

BounceyB · 17/06/2023 14:23

I feel for you OP. I have quite a big, energetic dog. He gets 2.5 hours walking a day, most days and an hour of play outside of this. I imagine this is what their dog needs.

I think it's fair to ask them for a contribution or alternatively, ask them to propose a solution to stop the dogs from doing it. Even if you didn't have children, it's your garden and it's a nuisance and will stop you from enjoying your space.

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 14:37

BounceyB · 17/06/2023 14:23

I feel for you OP. I have quite a big, energetic dog. He gets 2.5 hours walking a day, most days and an hour of play outside of this. I imagine this is what their dog needs.

I think it's fair to ask them for a contribution or alternatively, ask them to propose a solution to stop the dogs from doing it. Even if you didn't have children, it's your garden and it's a nuisance and will stop you from enjoying your space.

Do that op, ask them nice and polite ☝️👀
they will laugh in your face and carry on doing exactly as they please, they enjoy the fact that you are scared of their fur babies.

ismu · 17/06/2023 14:40

If you don't want to put trellis up you could put a second temporary fence using bamboo or panels- something light and cheap - and put it about 50cm in to your garden creating a sort of double fence. This should deter them from jumping as they won't be able to judge the depth or see over.
I think a trellis would probably be better though as pp said.

TouchingNoses · 17/06/2023 14:43

If it was me, I would be offering to pay to raise the fence so the couldn't get in and then discuss with you and agree suitable fencing that works for both parties.

Daveismyhero · 17/06/2023 15:17

As the owner of a large dog, I would automatically assume that if the fence needs altering to keep my dog safely enclosed inside my garden, that would be my financial responsibility. If we eve move to somewhere with a low fence, I'd have to approach the neighbours and ask if I could put up a larger fence, at my personal expense as my dogs safety is my responsibility. That includes ensuring he doesn't accidentally hurt someone else

Hellishforest · 17/06/2023 15:29

The fence in my garden was deteriorating on one side. It belongs to my neighbour but if was dog was getting through I would have made it secure. My dog is my responsibility to keep within my boundary.

Poppysmom22 · 17/06/2023 15:40

I am the owner of two LARGE dogs the first investment before they came home was garden security -secured gates, loose dog signs, tall fencing. For their safety. If god forbid anything happens, they pay with their lives, it might be worth pointing that out to them.

Poppysmom22 · 17/06/2023 15:43

And with all the dog attacks in the news don't mince your words and pussyfoot around it you want a secure fence in the next 2 weeks or you will be reporting them for having our of control dogs you might want to recommend puppy school. If mine had breached my fence I would expect you to lose the plot and make these demands

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 17:18

or you will be reporting them for having our of control dogs
report to whom?
No one gives a fuck, nothing will happen to these people or their fur babies

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 20:35

It didn’t go well and now he’s shown he’s a truly unreasonable man I think our lives are about to become very awkward.

OP posts:
Chiaia · 17/06/2023 20:43

As you have toddlers, perhaps the dogs could have free run of their garden in the evening when your children are in bed. In the daytime they should be on leads and supervised.
The dogs are quite possibly still at the exuberant puppy stage; they will mature and respond to recall.
Speak to your neighbours and formulate a plan.

DiscoBeat · 17/06/2023 20:57

As a dog owner it's absolute basics to dog proof the garden. If a taller fence isn't permitted on the deeds I would be getting a more appropriately sized breed for the house and garden.

ThisIsACoolUserName · 17/06/2023 21:01

I'm a dog owner and my worst nightmare is my dog getting out, because I'd be concerned for her safety. So no, I don't think it's unreasonable to expect the dog owner to pay for better fencing that will keep their dogs (and your child) safe.

GatesOfBabylon · 17/06/2023 21:12

I am a dog person.

It was clear they were completely unreasonable before you spoke to them.

In your shoes I would make it really difficult for them to walk across my garden. Think garden pots etc.

I would also sort the fence myself but they should have done this - before getting the dogs.

Thinkbiglittleone · 17/06/2023 21:14

As a dog owner I would be mortified and I would replace the fence so it's higher.

As a parent, I would replace the fence myself to keep my kids safe and argue the money afterwards.

NotEverORNever · 17/06/2023 21:17

That's a shame the talk didn't go well. Sometimes people initially react badly to being criticized about something but then, once they have calmed down and thought about it realism that the criticism was fair.

I'll keep my finger crossed that your Neighbour falls in this group of people.

Littlefish · 17/06/2023 21:29

It's not what you're asking, but do they really NEVER use their front door, and always use the access across your garden?

Have you checked the deeds for the specifics of the wording for the use of the access?

It's seems really unreasonable to me if they are using it constantly.

Swipe left for the next trending thread