Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask how responsible dog owners would react in this situation?

97 replies

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 07:20

We live in a terrace house, 2 up 2 down sort of size with long parallel gardens.
We have 2 toddlers. Our neighbours have 2 dogs that weigh more than my husband. Think Great Dane/mountain dog sized. Huge.
We’ve raised concerns about them before and how we worry they could jump the fence (it is low, as stipulated in the deeds).
Well last night, one jumped the fence. Luckily only DH in the garden, still nearly knocked him over.
Now we’re waiting to have the conversation with them about wtf they’re going to do about it.
I said they should be offering to pay for a more substantial fence (even though it is our fence on the deeds).

Am I also BU for thinking they’re idiots for having this type of dog in a tiny house? The wife has already been pulled over by them on their leads.

OP posts:
VickyEadieofThigh · 17/06/2023 13:06

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

What a horrible thing to suggest. Deliberately poisoning a dog would be a criminal offence, by the way.

QueenofKattegat · 17/06/2023 13:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You'd attempt to poison and potentially kill them? That's vile.

Fightyouforthatpie · 17/06/2023 13:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

How kind

oakleaffy · 17/06/2023 13:04

@Numbertwenty IF the deeds allow it, they absolutely should get a fence to keep their dogs in.

Mum lives in a 'Conservation area' where it is stipulated that the front garden fences of the houses in that zone have to have a specific fence {literally step over height!}..When visiting I sometimes do step over the gate -

I assumed your house would be like this, but if it's not, then the dog owners themselves need to get decent high fencing so their dogs can't injure your children {Or get poisoned by dropped grapes and raisins}.

Fightyouforthatpie · 17/06/2023 13:03

I like to think I am a responsible dog owner so I'd say I wouldn't have these dogs in that situation.

Pearlsaminga · 17/06/2023 13:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

oakleaffy · 17/06/2023 13:00

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 07:20

We live in a terrace house, 2 up 2 down sort of size with long parallel gardens.
We have 2 toddlers. Our neighbours have 2 dogs that weigh more than my husband. Think Great Dane/mountain dog sized. Huge.
We’ve raised concerns about them before and how we worry they could jump the fence (it is low, as stipulated in the deeds).
Well last night, one jumped the fence. Luckily only DH in the garden, still nearly knocked him over.
Now we’re waiting to have the conversation with them about wtf they’re going to do about it.
I said they should be offering to pay for a more substantial fence (even though it is our fence on the deeds).

Am I also BU for thinking they’re idiots for having this type of dog in a tiny house? The wife has already been pulled over by them on their leads.

That is an accident waiting to happen.

Why the heck did they get large dogs if your deeds say you have to have low fencing?

I have 2 metre fences all around my garden to contain dog, and my dog is small.

So many people have huge dogs they haven't a hope in hell of training and dealing with responsibly.

Tell your neighbour that your children eat raisins and 🍇 grapes {these are toxic to some dogs} and the woman might try and control her dogs better.

Also, say you have toxic plants - anything to make her keep her mutts out of your garden and to keep your children safe on their own property.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 17/06/2023 12:58

I like to think I'm a responsible dog owner so I wouldn't use my right of way with the dogs, I'd only use it for the bins etc. I would leave my house by the front door with the dogs, no discussion. I'd also immediately pay for a large high fence. But I am not an arsehole who buys 2 big dogs they can't cope with. You know for a dog to be a concern it only has to make a person feel frightened, it doesn't have to actually attack someone. And in this case, the sheer size of it means even if they are just being friendly an accident could happen.

So yeah, difficult conversation to be had but they are entirely responsible.

RunningUpThatMill · 17/06/2023 12:57

We had a dog who jumped over the wall chasing our neighbour's cat. I'm not sure whether he wanted to hurt it? A week later we had installed a fence higher than the wall, which went all the way up the garden. Our neighbour hadn't insisted on this. It was the only way to stop it happening again, and we paid for it.

Your neighbours may not be able to finance this, so leads, as suggested by PPs, should be used in the meantime.

Beesandhoney123 · 17/06/2023 12:47

Check the deeds in detail, and put up a fence, and maybe a fence to fence off the open bit with a gate.

Ask your neighbours what they are going to do about it and how quickly. Do they stop the barking? Mention that too, whilst you're at it.
Our dogs bark at doors opening but they are supposed to. They stop instantly when told. Otherwise they would drive me mad, not just the neighbours.

survivalmodemum · 17/06/2023 12:37

If this were my dog I would be absolutely horrified. My dog as a puppy used to escape under the fence into my elderly neighbours gorgeous garden (because she adores him) despite neighbour saying it was ok (he also loves her!) we sorted all the fences so it wouldn’t happen again. I definitely think a responsible owner should be putting measures in place to ensure this doesn’t happen again.

LakieLady · 17/06/2023 12:33

It's the dog owner's responsibility to control their dogs so they need to sort it.

The boundary that isn't my responsibility was just hedge when I moved here, and I didn't realise it had gaps in it, and my dog got into next door's. My neighbour is an arsehole and was really shitty about it, so I patched up the gaps. I worked in the legal department of a local authority at the time, and spoke to one of the property solicitors about it. They confirmed that it was my responsibility to keep my dog from entering another property.

Arsehole neighbour then get a new dog that was like a lab, but larger, and one day it crashed through the hedge and attacked my (much smaller) dog. He actually managed to pull some fur out of my dog's bum, so it could have been much worse. NDN still wouldn't do anything about it, even though we offered to split the cost, so we put chain link fence all along the length of the hedge.

Luckily, it cost nothing as my then DH got a load of chain link and posts that were left over from a fencing job that had been done where he worked.

Purplecatshopaholic · 17/06/2023 12:29

If I was them, I would have put up a higher fence before I got the dogs (which in fact is what I did in my own garden, I have large dogs myself). I would also train them properly (maybe a work in progress if these are young dogs). I would only have them out in the garden on a training lead until properly trained. However, if they are not doing these things.. if I was you in this scenario I would be putting up a higher fence myself. Presumably you can’t force them to do it, so if you want one you will need to invest in one yourselves..

dogfoodonmysocks · 17/06/2023 12:23

I adopted one large dog while living in house like you describe. Rescue wouldn't have let me if I hadn't had fences at least 5 foot. I also put in a double gate system so the neighbours could use their right of way safely, but always supervised dog in the garden anyway. Dogs do sometimes escape, they're smart and determined. But if it happens once a responsible owner does everything they can to prevent it happening again!! The potential dangers (to others and to the dog!) aren't worth the risk. The dangerous dogs act is a nuclear option though, so if you think they are ultimately caring just ill-informed owners I'd give them a chance before deploying that!

Tinkerbyebye · 17/06/2023 12:18

As a dog owner I wouldn’t have big dogs ina small house, and certainly not ina garden where deeds stipulate a low fence

i would be putting some lattice fencing up so it’s higher

then again I would never buy a house where it’s low fencing only, I want my privacy

EvilElsa · 17/06/2023 12:16

As a responsible dog owner I'd be apologising profusely and making sure it never happened again, be that by using a lead or longline in the garden or securing the garden at my own expense. I certainly wouldn't be offended at being asked to keep my dog in my own garden!

Numbertwenty · 17/06/2023 12:09

Thanks for helpful replies, I’ll try to update once we’ve had the conversation.
So far no attempt to stop any routes in to our garden or anything so I don’t think they think it’s as much of a big deal as I do!

OP posts:
Anyotherdude · 17/06/2023 10:09

You can’t get a rescue dog unless your fences will contain said dog, so they need to get training and containing theirs. They should also put up a tall chain-link fence on their property until their dogs are fully trained.

Judystilldreamsofhorses · 17/06/2023 10:08

We used to have a dog who could make himself the size of a tiny mouse to escape through what we eventually realised was a minuscule gap in the fence. He was a cocker spaniel, and his worst crime was visiting neighbours he knew would feed him, but we put up an ugly, very expensive, six foot brick wall. Our dog, our problem. (Plus embarrassing to be constantly collecting him from people who would say, he’s just having his sausage roll, then we’ll walk him round!)

SoccerStars · 17/06/2023 10:02

OP, one more thing - pp are correct to say they don’t need to pay for the fence but important to add they do need to make sure it’s under control. How they do that is up to them.

Like in the example of my neighbours dog jumping up at me, she said “what I am supposed to do?” I advised her to keep it on lead whereas I actually should have told her to figure it out because that is her responsibility.

So yes strictly speaking it may not be their responsibility to specifically errect a fence but it is their responsibility to ensure their dog doesn’t do this or it’s clearly breaking dog legislation as per link .

If they try and ask you for solutions, I’d say initially bat it back to them and ask then what they intend to do to prevent your out control dog coming in your garden. If you’re too prescriptive from the outset with specific requests, they might start coming out with all sorts of objections eg. “if you want a fence then pay for it.”

Be polite and friendly initially but also be assertive. The law is on your side. If they are decent dog owners they will see the only solution is to keep dogs on lead in garden or build fence.

StrongTea · 17/06/2023 10:00

Can they section off their garden with a high fence going across the middle then raise the side sections so dogs can’t get out?

LizzieSiddal · 17/06/2023 09:48

DisplayPurposesOnly · Today 08:37
It's your fence, it's up to you to install a higher one if that's what you want
.
What a responsible dog owner should do about large dogs is a different question.

Agree with this. Plus it’s your responsibility to protect your Dc, so I would have a polite conversation with them but if they don’t immediately offer to pay for a higher fence I’d be organising it myself.

DisplayPurposesOnly · 17/06/2023 08:37

It's your fence, it's up to you to install a higher one if that's what you want.

What a responsible dog owner should do about large dogs is a different question.

aSpanielintheworks · 17/06/2023 08:28

If it was me I'd have a really polite conversation and ask them their thoughts, as obviously the dogs being able to jump the fence posed a danger to your young children and means you have to carefully condider times you are able to use your own garden. If the dogs have already jumped, they will be fully aware of the problem. It's easier now than the 'what might happen if they jump' scenario.
If I was the dog owner (and I do have a loopy Spaniel!) it would mean a camping style longline that screws into the ground while I looked for a more permanent solution. I like the trellis idea, especially if you or they grow something up it, it doesn't have to be unsightly or particularly strong, a visual barrier will be enough to stop a dog attempting to jump.
I would, as a dog owner, expect it to be my responsibility to keep my dogs under control no matter who's fence it is.

bozzabollix · 17/06/2023 08:13

Think maybe a conversation with the neighbour in a pleasant manner might be the way forward. Just ask what they think the solution is?

Also if the dogs are great Dane’s and mountain varieties they are very gentle breeds, yes they’re young so probably a bit daft but if those breeds they’re very unlikely to be nasty. Maybe actually meeting them properly might be an idea? You’re obviously scared but thats often because it’s the unknown. I met an enormous dog the other day that frankly looked very scary but it turned out he was so chilled out and pleasant, I’d rather have one of those land on from me next door than a small aggressive dog.

This has reminded me of our situation. We’ve got a large garden that backs onto several other houses and there is a big gap in the fence belonging to our neighbour. We’ve offered to pay for it to be done to keep our dog in, the neighbour has refused so our dog goes barging in there. He lost his dog a year ago so we can only assume he likes her going in! Wish we could mend it. We should swap him with you who’d be only too happy!