Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husband excluding nephew with challenging behaviour

214 replies

einter · 11/06/2023 12:11

So my Nephew has challenging behaviour. He is 8.
My Brother and his Wife have mental health problems and difficulties parenting. Eldest child is in care and they have another son and she is pregnant again!
My Nephew has challenging behaviour:
When he's in your home he will go to the fridge and take food out without asking, deliberately ruin food for attention like taking bites out of a load of applies so no one can eat them. He will pretend other children have hurt him when they haven't. Tells lies about people. Screams randomly or asks for things in a REALLY loud voice. He will get very angry if he doesn't get what he wants or loses a game he's playing. He will push and smack his younger brother who is 2.
Social services are aware but seem to take a VERY passive approach to the family.

When I have my nephew on his own he is fine as he has 1-1 attention. Literally no challenging behaviour. But that's rarely possible as I have two sons.
For some reason I'm the only one who is does not display attention seeking behaviour with. I'm not sure why.

Anyway after one particular day where my nephew, destroys a lot of food in our fridge, walked all over the house in dirty shoes, jumped all over the beds with those same shoes on despite being told it would break the beds, pushed my son over almost knocking him down the stairs, dropped food all around the house and broke my sons toys, pulled my sons hair and screamed constantly. My Husband says he's protecting our children and he's not staying again or being around them.
He's arranged a big joint birthday party for our sons (both august babies) and he is insisting my nephew is not coming and that actually it's not fair to have a child like that who could be violent towards our sons friends especially the younger ones.
I can kind of understand where he's coming from with the pushing and hair pulling.
But we're also having a family birthday party and he's insisting even for the meal my nephew is not coming.

My brother and his wife are understanding and seem passive towards my nephew. They have said they don't like him either and hes 'annoying' so they can understand and try and avoid him themselves now.

AIBU to think despite all his behaviour he should be included?

OP posts:
Freefall212 · 11/06/2023 14:59

Clearly being around everyone is a trigger or overstimulating for yoru nephew. Not only is not fair to your children and Dh to have their days and house ruined, it is also putting your nephew in a situaion where he is in distress and in a state of emotional and behavioural dysregulation. It isn't benefiting anyone. Your nephew isn't enjoying it either. You have said a few times that he does well in 1:1 with you. Then that is what you prioritize. Creating space and an environment where he feels safe and calm and can interact in a way where he also feels in control of himself. So no to the birthday and meal but instead you take him out more often. Sure it is a little time away from your own kids but that is a sacrifice worth making.

PostOpOp · 11/06/2023 14:59

Ok it's your kids birthday party, they get to decide who cones. But a separate family dinner/tea "party" could also be done where he can enjoy himself - not at home. What about a family birthday picnic at a park where he can run around and play, and there's cake and candles too?

You need to prioritise the birthday children for their main party, that's only fair. If nephew is upset by not coming to main party (does he need to know?) then tell him you all have a special one with him because the big party is classmates only (or whatever) but you still wanted a party with him. And that way it's out of your house, there's a party, he's made to be special as well and well, it's a decent compromise.

It's heartbreaking though hearing about his life. Totally heartbreaking. That doesn't mean your children have to have something special ruined either by his actions, or fear of his actions.

RantyAnty · 11/06/2023 14:58

I'm with your DH on this. Regardless of what issues the nephew has, he's abusive towards your children.

See him 1-1 occasionally but keep him away from your home and children.

Gift your brother a vasectomy for Christmas.

BadNomad · 11/06/2023 14:54

You are rather judgemental about your brother and SIL. Do you feel their difficulties are less valid because they are mental health related? I notice how you are fine with criticising their parenting (or lack of) yet you dismiss your own decisions which are causing harm to your own children. You are allowing your children to be put in danger, you are facilitating them getting hurt, you are allowing your children's possessions to be destroyed, you are enabling all this. and still wanting to put the needs of this other child before your own. At least your brother and SIL have a reason for why they're not doing too great. What's your excuse?

Gymnopedie · 11/06/2023 14:51

Sorry OP but you need to rethink. It may be your nephew who has the behavioural problems now, but if you're not careful in a few years time it might be your own DCs. What are you teaching them? That it's OK to damage furniture and toys, to spoil the food, to pull hair and push - and there are no consequences. In fact the behaviour is rewarded with 1-1 time.

I feel incredibly sorry for your nephew as I'm sure we all do, but you can't let your own DCs be collateral damage in your determination to be his rescuer.

SpidersAreShitheads · 11/06/2023 14:50

Birdsmakingnests · 11/06/2023 13:50

I imagine….
…when 1-1 he behaves well as his needs are being met.

Behaviour is communication, he doesn’t know how to express how he is feeling.

He doesn’t know how to regulate his emotions.

Negative attention is better than no attention in his eyes.

Bless his cotton socks, if intervention is not put in place soon, this behaviour will only escalate in his teenage years.

Absolutely this.

Also, autistic children can sometimes misbehave - for reasons completely unrelated to autism. In the same way that any child can.

So the question is - what's going on with this child's behaviour? Is it emotional dysregulation due to his autism and inability to communicate in that moment, or is he displaying disruptive behaviour due to trauma and/or poor parenting? Or is he just desperate for attention of any kind?

Either way, you don't invite him to the party. It's not fair on the other children, especially those whose birthday it is.

However OP, your mention of "he's fine with me" feels a bit like a stealth boast, or a dismissal of his needs. If he's autistic, then you just haven't been in a 1:1 situation where he's overstimulated. It's much easier to manage an autistic child's needs when you're 1:1 and you can often prevent things getting to the point where they have a meltdown. But you can't magic autism and learning difficulties away, even if you're an excellent caregiver.

My point of this OP is that I think 1:1 time with you would be really helpful for this child, but please be prepared for the fact that he might not always display model behaviour. There may be times when he can't cope or suffers from sensory overload. How will you feel about him if this happens? He needs someone who's not going to give up on him when things go tits up, and if you don't think you'll be able to cope, then it's fine to step away now.

The world is really tough for autistic folk and generally people aren't great at making space for individuals who are different in some way. Growing up is hard at the best of times, but when you're neurodivergent, it can feel like a fucking mountain. And throw in parents who describe their child as "annoying" then the poor kid hasn't got anyone who's helping them learn how to navigate the world and develop appropriate coping skills.

As a general rule, I think it's helpful for parents to teach their children that some others may act differently. But I don't think this extends to allowing their birthday celebrations - or other occasions - to be dominated by a child who has much more challenging needs. Everyone needs the space to relax and enjoy themselves, and that includes your DC.

Your DH has understandably said your house is now out of bounds. Only you and your DH can decide whether you could take your nephew to the park (or somewhere else) with your DC sometimes, or whether you could set up some regular 1:1 time with him. There's no right or wrong answer here - but you do need to be guided by how your own DC feel and make sure that you're not prioritising your nephew over them.

For info - I'm autistic/ADHD and I have two autistic DC, one with quite significant needs.

Oubliette86 · 11/06/2023 14:49

You have a cheek criticising your DB & SIL’s parenting when YOU are failing your own children by not protecting them! Your children are being physically hurt & having their belongings destroyed in their own home - the place they should feel the safest - and you are actively allowing it. As their mother, you should be protecting them from harm but instead you are deliberately exposing them to it. Your DN pushed your DS & he “almost” fell down the stairs, what exactly are you waiting for before you put your children first? For your DN to actually push them down the stairs? Broken bones? Drawing blood?

Absolutely carry on seeing your DN 1-1 as that’s what seems to be of most benefit to him but exposing your own children to harm like this is quite frankly unforgivable. If you carry on like this, your children are going to remember that you put your DN first over them & it will your destroy your relationship.

timetorefresh · 11/06/2023 14:49

I think if I was you I'd be putting my kids before my nephew

aSofaNearYou · 11/06/2023 14:47

Im with your DH tbh. The only thing I'd put my foot down about is family events, but the rest, he's right.

HamBone · 11/06/2023 14:44

Haven’t RTFT. He clearly can’t come to the joint birthday party as children could potentially be hurt.

Re. The family meal. Is there any possibility that a family member or two could be assigned to look after him and give him 1-to-1 attention? It sounds as if he’s OK when an adult is directly interacting with him-are there any games or activities he particularly likes?

I agree with your DH that your own children’s’ safety needs to come first, but I completely understand your sympathy towards your DN. He’s not being parented properly nor given the support he needs, and probably gets easily overwhelmed. Poor child. ☹️

Kennykenkencat · 11/06/2023 14:42

Whilst I completely understand why you don’t want him anywhere near your children. I do feel sorry for this lad who is quite clearly crying out for attention

Why on earth are his parents pregnant with another child when they have no interest in the one they have.

Could you suggest that they get him tested for ADHD. (You could dangle the carrot that if he is found to be ND then apart from meds to calm him down and to stop him being “so annoying” they could claim DLA for him. Maybe money will motivate them to do something for him)

What are there issues with mental health If their Ds is found to be ND then one or likely both of them will get the same diagnosis.

IncomingTraffic · 11/06/2023 14:40

Also, the husband feels that the OP’s nephew is a danger to his sons.

Husband says he's protecting our children and he's not staying again or being around them.

He doesn’t want their violent cousin around them any longer.

Thing are clearly very bad. And the OP’s children are people with needs and feelings rather than props in the rescuing her nephew story.

wingingit1987 · 11/06/2023 14:37

I think it’s really crap of you to put your own kids at risk like that. I would be hounding social work to better manage your inadequate brother and his wife but I certainly wouldn’t risk my own children’s safety.

IncomingTraffic · 11/06/2023 14:36

a bonus treat for them and something the nephew can participate in and enjoy

are we sure time with the cousin who pushes them, pulls their hair and breaks their stuff is what they’d consider a ‘bonus treat’?

It doesn’t sound like their mother is as interested in how they feel about time with their cousin as she is about ‘including’ him.

MeMyCatsAndMyBooks · 11/06/2023 14:36

How sad that his parents have given up on him and so has everyone else by the sounds of it.

What about his grandparents can't they give him 1-1 time? This boy is failing and like this because he's not being taught values and life skills he needs, he sounds highly neglected and add in autism on top he's being failed by everyone.

Mamma1246 · 11/06/2023 14:36

I have an autistic child and with this kind of disregulated unhappy behaviour, I wouldn't be putting him in those scenarios either.

Having said that, if you're confident he does well with parties then I wouldn't have a problem with him coming, provided that your kids are ok with him being there and that they have a choice about it and shouldn't feel obligated just because it's family. And you need a plan for if he does not do well - either his parents take him home or you take him away to calm down.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 11/06/2023 14:34

deliberately ruin food for attention like taking bites out of a load of applies so no one can eat them. He will pretend other children have hurt him when they haven't. Tells lies about people. Screams randomly or asks for things in a REALLY loud voice. He will get very angry if he doesn't get what he wants or loses a game he's playing

It is unsafe for all concerned to subject your sons friends to this at their party . .

DismantledKing · 11/06/2023 14:33

Your husband is right, and you are very, very unreasonable.

DuesToTheDirt · 11/06/2023 14:33

Got to be honest, I'm with DH, I wouldn't want him in my house.

Jerabilis · 11/06/2023 14:30

If your son had been pushed down t stairs would that have been enough for you to say no more? Or would you have said “it’s fine he’s not really been hurt”? Your husband has found his limit with the danger he is willing to expose his children to. You haven’t. What is your limit?

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 11/06/2023 14:30

Were there similar behaviour challenges with the older child who was taken into care ?
Did that escalate beyond the behaviour that your 8yo nephew is displaying ?

Are your inadequate Bro/SIL hoping that you will take on the full time care of your nephew as they already have another 2yo and a new baby on the way ?

123wdcd · 11/06/2023 14:27

He is probably excluded a lot. I would try to do something separately for your DC and nephew, so a bonus treat for them and something the nephew can participate in and enjoy. If he always wrecks the house I would take them out to a play ground and to get ice cream, then let them burn it off, or to a play centre.

We have some very difficult DNs who possibly have ASD (a lot of indicators, family history on one side, hints from school ignored and behaviour issues challenging for DNs and without a diagnosis seen as bad behaviour). It is really challenging to spend time with them, but short trips to something they enjoy and can focus on (rather than difficult encounters other kids) means they are not excluded.

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 11/06/2023 14:26

He has almost pushed your son down the stairs and pulled his hair, @einter, but that isn’t enough violence against your child for you to agree with your dh that it’s time to protect your children from your nephew?

If he had pushed your son down the stairs, he could have ended up with broken bones, a fractured spine (maybe causing paralysis) or a head injury (could cause long term disability or death).

The only reason this didn’t happen is sheer luck - next time your child might not be so lucky. Your dh is right, and your nephew should no longer be welcome around your children or in your house.

Prescottdanni123 · 11/06/2023 14:22

I feel sad for your nephew can understand where your husband is coming from. He is no doubt fed up of seeing his kids constantly being pushed, having their hair pulled, their toys broken etc. Your son could have had some nasty injuries if he had been knocked down the stairs.

itsgettingweird · 11/06/2023 14:20

Einter you mean to be so rude to me?

Especially as I mentioned doing something as small group because you can give him 1:1 and he's fine with you this way and I didn't once say he didn't like parties. I mentioned his behaviour being because he could be dysregulated. You can can the noise and crowds of parties but if your sensory system doesn't function properly (quite common with autistic people and part of diagnostic criteria) you can behave in a way that isn't ok (crashing into people, unable to control behaviour like biting into lots of food etc) and with added MLD with asd you may not realise your behaviours impact on others.

Just because he's happy behaving the way he is doesn't make it ok.

I stick by what I said about maybe finding a smaller activity with you as a small group and he gets invited to that birthday party.

But if you'd rather snap my head off about all people with autism not being the same (ps I've worked with autistic people for 25 years Wink) then go ahead.

Because all that does is make it clear you don't think Yabu and think everyone should just agree with that 🤷‍♀️

Swipe left for the next trending thread