Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What can I take on walks that may help if a dog attacks us.

502 replies

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 06/06/2023 20:39

I've noticed that some very nasty dogs are being walked on our usual local walks around a pretty village.

With the recent spate of attacks and my suspicions of the owners, is there anything that could help in the event of an attack eg high pitched noise like rape alarm.
? What do you do if a dog goes for the child or yourself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
HappiestSleeping · 07/06/2023 07:52

Weareoutofwine · 07/06/2023 07:12

But data and stats, plus a bag full of growing anecdotal suggests the chances are not infinitesimal.

8,800 hospitizations in 2022 is not infinitesimal. There were 22000 dog attacks on humans - there will have been more that will simply be unreported and escape data sets.

Again I'll state I'm a dog lover. But you can't deny a growing risk.

This is true, however the population is growing, QED the amount of dogs is growing, QED the number of instances will grow. If one takes into account the growing population, then the instances aren't actually growing more than would be expected by the increased friction caused by more people (and dogs) occupying the same space.

The real solution here is to have higher penalties for owners who do not control their dogs.

sourcorn · 07/06/2023 07:52

Weareoutofwine · 07/06/2023 07:47

Humour is used for many awful, desperate situations - a list of what one must jnot oke about due to being 'not appropriate' would be rather long. Who should we consult to agree topics which can be joked about? Who is the arbiter of taste and decency?

I'm sure some the comments were from typical trolls trying to get a rise out of mumsnetters - so just try to not engage. But honestly it's gets a tad boring when on many threads posters are continually issued with a list of ever growing topics which must not, in any circumstances ever, be addressed through even the smallest humorous lense.

Fair point. I guess the posts broke the guidelines some how though so they must have had something in them.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/06/2023 07:57

FearTheWankingDead · 06/06/2023 21:47

So is owning a dangerous dog but those owners don’t care so 🤷🏻‍♀️

Good point, well made.

👌

HappiestSleeping · 07/06/2023 08:01

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 07/06/2023 00:43

It's easier to avoid cows than dogs. Cows tend to not to amble through parks, pavements, footpaths and car parks!

Fair point. It isn't that difficult to avoid dogs though. Other than when walking mine, I can't remember ever having had a dog run up to me at random, even when in the park / open space. Again in fairness, I probably wouldn't have thought much of it as I like dogs, so wouldn't have given it a second thought.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/06/2023 08:09

sourcorn · 07/06/2023 07:52

Fair point. I guess the posts broke the guidelines some how though so they must have had something in them.

Not necessarily.

I've seen very inoffensive posts removed because some "speech-police" complain that it's"inappropriate" or "unfair" or "this could upset their great-grandmother if she was reading this in her nursing home" and similar comments.

Personally I think if you don't like what's being posted, just don't read it - unless it's libellous, or inflammatory, it's no-one else's business.

Humour in particular is a way in which people cope with the horrors of life. It helps to de-demonise them. If you can laugh at something, however briefly, and however (as some may say) inappropriately, them if only for a moment, you no longer fear or feel oppressed by it.

It is one of the healthiest and best coping strategies available.

We are all different people, and deal with things in different ways. I know there will probably be an avalanche of "oh so X is fair game is it?" - and there are some things which aren't appropriate for humour (Holocaust, child abuse, cruelty etc) because they are so very terrible that there is not, and never will be, anything even vaguely amusing about them, but most topics can lend themselves to a good laugh. And interestingly, if you do make jokes about these things, then the helpful bits of the information are more likely to stick in your mind.

There is a reason governments and extremists fear ridicule - it is phenomenally powerful, and incredibly healing.

The real solution here is to have higher penalties for owners who do not control their dogs.

And here I agree with @HappiestSleeping . Penalties have got to hurt, and a mere ban, often ignored or circumvented, on keeping dogs doesn't hack it. there should be stinging fines, reparations and even occasional prison sentences on top of any ban.

123wdcd · 07/06/2023 08:13

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 06/06/2023 22:58

@123wdcd
Exactly this is what I mean.

On a normal street with the dog hopefully on a lead one can cross the street.
If it did attack hopefully people can call for help, police, ambulance or distract it.

What I've become aware of recently is by dc walking /jumping around a bit as they do in and field and these dogs may think they are prey and charge. Where can we go in a field? How would be stop it or get it off once locked on.
I'm not a runner my dc arnt fast..

Your pretty vulnerable in that exosed situation.

A strong guy came off a building site and couldn't pull it off. His colleague came with the handle of a tool, got it into its mouth and pulled it back. a bit like using a 'break stick' https://www.pbrc.net/breakstick.html. Really scary, it had high pain tolerance and doing the usual things that would keep a normal dog calm had no effect. The attack also went on until it was pulled back with a metal handle in its mouth. A small child would have been dead by the time it stopped.

On some of the news reports of XL bully attacks, the maulings have gone on until the police arrive. This is not a normal dog attack where it may bite then release if someone goes near its food or toy. The ban on Pitbull mixes needs to be enforced and people need to be honest about the realities of these dogs before there are more tragedies.

123wdcd · 07/06/2023 08:17

Hit send too soon. Don't run, that could trigger it more. If me and DC see one we stay still, sit on a bench, go into a shop, etc. None of us should have to worry about this sort of attack though as these dogs should have been off the streets for decades. Instead they are coming back and even getting sold as family pets.

AllGussiedUp · 07/06/2023 08:25

I have screenshots of some of the deleted posts, not ones that could be taken as funny. They were suggesting horrible things, some in great detail. Mumsnet was right to delete them.

AlwaysGinPlease · 07/06/2023 08:27

AllGussiedUp · 07/06/2023 08:25

I have screenshots of some of the deleted posts, not ones that could be taken as funny. They were suggesting horrible things, some in great detail. Mumsnet was right to delete them.

I reported two that I saw. Absolutely vile, worrying that these people walk amongst normal folk.

sourcorn · 07/06/2023 08:27

HappiestSleeping · 07/06/2023 08:01

Fair point. It isn't that difficult to avoid dogs though. Other than when walking mine, I can't remember ever having had a dog run up to me at random, even when in the park / open space. Again in fairness, I probably wouldn't have thought much of it as I like dogs, so wouldn't have given it a second thought.

Seriously round here it's stupid so many people got lock down puppies and now pretty much every time I go to a park there is at least one dog off lead struggling to be recalled during the hour or so I'm there. 🐕

sourcorn · 07/06/2023 08:28

AlwaysGinPlease · 07/06/2023 08:27

I reported two that I saw. Absolutely vile, worrying that these people walk amongst normal folk.

Glad I didn't see them

Glastobore · 07/06/2023 08:30

My vet said a horse riding whip. This was when we had a dog that used to attack other dogs nearby. It came out of nowhere and attacked my dog. Quite a good suggestion, would give a nasty sting but no permanent damage.

Glastobore · 07/06/2023 08:31

AlwaysGinPlease · 07/06/2023 08:27

I reported two that I saw. Absolutely vile, worrying that these people walk amongst normal folk.

Oh that sounds awful.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/06/2023 08:44

FlissyPaps · 06/06/2023 21:42

You absolutely can dislocate a dogs jaw by doing that.

This is a tactic taught in prevention management of violence and aggression courses.

Good luck, then.

I just hope you're attacked by a pug and not an Ambull.

Weareoutofwine · 07/06/2023 08:52

I agree @HappiestSleeping - increased penalties needed, stronger enforcement (so increased policing budgets for a manybmany things!) alongside a revision to the Dangerous Dogs Act (though this Act probably needs completely looking at - but doubt there is parliamentary time or will for a new Bill and approach sadly).

Alongside all this - better training for people, increased understanding of the history of a breed and the traits which were selected.

I agree with previous posters on the American Bully XL - avoid and prevention is best.

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 07/06/2023 08:53

@123wdcd this is what worries me me the prolonged attack.

I think another drum in tactic to app family is to make site someone gets police and ambulance on the go... One person needs to get calling and remain calm to do so.

OP posts:
Emotionalsupportviper · 07/06/2023 08:54

billybear · 06/06/2023 21:55

i carry a fold up brolly ,the sort the flips out full length,a very nasty dogs where i live, would flip out to full length and hit the attaching dog

Actually, this might be effective with many dogs. I hadn't thought of it but even the sudden change in size of the brolly might cause them to pause and think.

It really depends on the breed, the individual dog, how well trained it is, the reason it is being aggressive - so many factors.

I wonder how many people on this thread have been up close to these American bully XLs...I had a recent experience that has genuinely made me consider buying a knife... nothing else (other than a gun) could have stopped it if it's owner hadn't manage to somehow hang on to it. I am experienced with dogs but this breed is on another level to anything that has come before, they are responsible for half of all dog related deaths in the UK since 2011. And they are absolutely terrifying when out of control. @DZbornak

Agree - they are large, very, very powerful dogs and they seem to be bred purely as canine weapons. (Yes, yes - the drama - but frankly, there is no other reason to have this type of dog).

Often the idiots/ thugs who own them can't (physically) control them, they frequently have harnesses rather than collars (illegal - all dogs in UK are required to wear a collar with owners details), they are very short-haired to the extent that their coats are like an armour - you cannot get a grip on them as they are slippery, and far too often they have cropped ears (illegal) - I mention this because if (say) my grandson was attacked I wouldn't think twice about grabbing and twisting a dog's ear to turn the aggression onto myself, but you can't do that with a crop-eared dog.

AlwaysGinPlease · 07/06/2023 08:55

@Emotionalsupportviper they were removed because they were disgusting. Don't make stupid excuses.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/06/2023 09:01

AlwaysGinPlease · 07/06/2023 08:55

@Emotionalsupportviper they were removed because they were disgusting. Don't make stupid excuses.

I didn't see them. I don't know why they were removed.

However I do know that harmless posts have been removed in the past because of "snowflake" complaints, and that was what I was pointing out. Are you always so aggressive? You could have made the same point in a pleasant manner but you chose not to. Unnecessary. my dear.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/06/2023 09:03

AllGussiedUp · 07/06/2023 08:25

I have screenshots of some of the deleted posts, not ones that could be taken as funny. They were suggesting horrible things, some in great detail. Mumsnet was right to delete them.

Thank you- that's all I need to know.

GSD20 · 07/06/2023 09:03

Honestly if one of those comes within sight I just get away from it any way I can. I’m experienced with dogs but I won’t take the risk of being anywhere near one if there’s another choice.

If you can’t I suppose you could try and stand your ground like you would with a normal type of dog. We were attacked by another bloody cockapoo last week, it was lunging for my giant dogs legs. I growled and lunged towards it which did make it back off long enough for the useless owner to get it. I would only try this if your experienced enough to tell if a dog is all mouth or if it’s actually going to follow through though.

It’s honestly crossed my mind to carry weapons because of some of the things I’ve seen them do.

WisherWood · 07/06/2023 09:07

Saddogmum · 06/06/2023 23:46

dogs tend to attack when they feel under attack. You can look out for warning signs for this. Dogs are actually lovely animals who will only attack when they are scared and frightened

This applies to normal dogs, yes. But it doesn't apply to some of the dogs bred to fight or guard. They can be extremely reactive and their attack mode is a really frightening thing to witness.

I’ve owned dogs in the past. I still look after some. I think dogs are great, mostly. But large guarding or fighting breeds can be very dangerous. You really don’t want an 11 stone molossoid dog coming at you. An animal that’s been bred to guard against lions is by definition dangerous. The idea that it’s quite cute really and more afraid of you than you are of it is, sadly, nonsense. As I said, I have in the past choked them but it's not something I'd recommend. I have no idea how bite sticks work and don't fancy the chance of that versus a jaw strength of over 300 psi.

I agree with PP. really your best defence is to avoid them and try to get ownership and breeding very tightly controlled. Not with knee jerk legislation but with something properly thought out and drawn up, which is going to take years to be effective.

123wdcd · 07/06/2023 09:07

Weareoutofwine · 07/06/2023 04:27

Starting point, I am an experienced dog owner, and all round dog lover. My breed of choice is a Dobermann.

OP I can completely understand and relate to your fear. I think many of the trite replies stating 'its the owner not the dog', or 'go to your GP for anxiety' are utterly ill informed on the recent increase in dog on dog attacks (and brutality of said attacks) and the increase of attacks on people. Stats include - 10 people killed in the UK in 2022, the average in the 20 years previous is 3 per year. This year alone 5 people have been killed. Hospitalisation (hospital episode data) ,from dog attacks, have also doubled over the past 15 years from around 4600 in 2007 to c8800 in 2022.

Reports suggest that all 5 fatalities this year are down to American Bullies. If you've ever seen this breed or dealt with one - you'll know they are extremely powerful, and frankly they worry me greatly

I agree with some previous posters American Bullie XL should be added to the Dangerous Dog Act and there needs to be better enforcement of said Act. There also needs to be improved resources around training, and dog ownership in general. Most dogs and owners are fabulous and many companion breeds are bred so that they make wonderful family pets when combined with good training and responsible ownership

American Bullies and other Pitbulls are a product of their very selective intentional breeding - and that is historically to fight - they have high muscle mass and serious biting strength. Like most breeds selective breeding has taken place to result in clear dominant traits, we should be clear on this when understanding dogs - and there are consequences to this. Retrievers retrieve, grey hounds have instant speed, pointers point - you get the picture!

Pitbulls have been used as a foundation to create the American Bully breed. Pitbulls were not in their breeding bred to be a loyal companion - they were breed to carry out brutish sustained attacks on bulls. And then later and now continually amongst a minority of people for dog fighting.

Owners of the Bulls are often ill prepared, they don't know about the breeding history, or some don't care and perhaps some enjoy the status symbol of owning a large powerful dog.

Any rate I'm running the danger of banging on! What I'm trying to say is the breed landscape and dog ownership has changed considerable in 20 odd years plus (and attack and fatality stats back this). I think OP is sensible to be alive to this

If my local walking areas had an influx of Amercican Bullie dogs, particularly off the lead with clearly inexperienced owners or owners who are obviously 'enjoying the status', I would find new places to walk and train. If one of these dogs hit prey drive and simply did what it is historically bred to do most of us would not be able to fight it off. The Americal XL is a vast powerful animal.
If in any doubt just Google it, and also Google how some breeders market the litters.

This is a great post. Could not agree more. So frustrating to see people saying any dogs can be dangerous. Any dogs can bite, but fighting dogs are unique in the damage they can do and their combination of prey drive with strength. They absolutely do not have the receptivity to training and restraint that other large dogs like Dobermanns or Malinois have. What happens with pit bulls or XL bullies is that just by being dog smart is not enough to be safe around them - telling kids not to approach dogs without asking the owner, to leave sleeping dogs, leave dogs that are eating, watch body language, etc. Their prey drive means they will lock onto a target and go for the neck. They are dangerous animals that have no place in the community.

Nothing is more frustrating than seeing the BS about bull breeds being 'nanny dogs'. The historic pictures of kids with pit bulls were from a breeder called Colby, trying to find a broader market for his fighting dogs. They killed his nephew with a bite to the neck: https://blog.dogsbite.org/2010/05/1909-fatality-john-p-colbys-fighting.html

1909 Dog Bite Fatality: John P. Colby's Fighting Pit Bull Kills Nephew - DogsBite Blog

John P. Colby and son Louis (1922), Colby's Pincher (top) and Colby's Twister. View Archive Article Newburyport, MA - While researching fatal pit bull attacks of the early to mid 1900s, we came across the most damaging fatal attack the … Continue readi...

https://blog.dogsbite.org/2010/05/1909-fatality-john-p-colbys-fighting.html

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/06/2023 09:21

What happens with pit bulls or XL bullies is that just by being dog smart is not enough to be safe around them . . . Their prey drive means they will lock onto a target and go for the neck. They are dangerous animals that have no place in the community. @123wdcd

Spot on.

They are an animal which has been deliberately bred to be a weapon - either in dog fights, or to set onto police by dealers etc.

They are also currently being bred as a money laundering exercise by many thugs. They get round the "can't have more than X bitches or Y litters without registering as a breeder" by keeping male dogs only and selling the semen.

Pups are sold for £000s - a nice little earner and a good way to hide cash you shouldn't have.

They are not a breed which has any purpose other to intimidate (at the very least).

There are small American Bulldogs which are about the size of a cocker and these appear to be pleasant enough dogs (though I don't know a lot about them) - but these XL creatures are appalling.

Emotionalsupportviper · 07/06/2023 09:33

123wdcd · 07/06/2023 09:07

This is a great post. Could not agree more. So frustrating to see people saying any dogs can be dangerous. Any dogs can bite, but fighting dogs are unique in the damage they can do and their combination of prey drive with strength. They absolutely do not have the receptivity to training and restraint that other large dogs like Dobermanns or Malinois have. What happens with pit bulls or XL bullies is that just by being dog smart is not enough to be safe around them - telling kids not to approach dogs without asking the owner, to leave sleeping dogs, leave dogs that are eating, watch body language, etc. Their prey drive means they will lock onto a target and go for the neck. They are dangerous animals that have no place in the community.

Nothing is more frustrating than seeing the BS about bull breeds being 'nanny dogs'. The historic pictures of kids with pit bulls were from a breeder called Colby, trying to find a broader market for his fighting dogs. They killed his nephew with a bite to the neck: https://blog.dogsbite.org/2010/05/1909-fatality-john-p-colbys-fighting.html

Those news reports are chilling.