Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What can I take on walks that may help if a dog attacks us.

502 replies

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 06/06/2023 20:39

I've noticed that some very nasty dogs are being walked on our usual local walks around a pretty village.

With the recent spate of attacks and my suspicions of the owners, is there anything that could help in the event of an attack eg high pitched noise like rape alarm.
? What do you do if a dog goes for the child or yourself?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
21
MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 07/06/2023 00:43

HappiestSleeping · 06/06/2023 23:18

This 👆

Along with pointing out that the chances of anything happening are so remote that you are more likely to have a bit of space junk land on you.

If you really are worried about dog attacks, you should understand 2 things. First, most serious dog attacks are not random in the way the press propagate. The victim is usually known in some way. Second, more people are killed by cows every year than by dogs. I don't suppose you carry anything to ward off dangerous cows, so probably no need to carry anything for dogs either.

It's easier to avoid cows than dogs. Cows tend to not to amble through parks, pavements, footpaths and car parks!

Tophy124 · 07/06/2023 00:44

Just had a google of a bully XL as I stupidly thought they were a type of pitbull and Jesus! Who would want to own one?! They look like orcs! Really failing to see any redeeming features for them. It was these dogs who ripped two children apart and then went for the mother in Tennessee last year, and they had them from puppies.

Tophy124 · 07/06/2023 00:45

MyrtlethePurpleTurtle · 07/06/2023 00:43

It's easier to avoid cows than dogs. Cows tend to not to amble through parks, pavements, footpaths and car parks!

I’d also be nervous if I came across a loose cow just like I would a loose dog lol! So this argument is a moot point for me as I don’t want to see either loose and roaming the streets.

Womblesgash · 07/06/2023 01:13

One of the best things anyone can do to help stop a dog attack is to learn some basic dog body language and recognise when they might go on the attack.

Yes, some dogs might not display the tell tale signs but in many cases, if you know what you’re looking for you it can give you some extra seconds to react by moving away or not getting too close, calling out to the owner etc..

Fisharejumping · 07/06/2023 01:44

Doingtheboxerbeat · 06/06/2023 20:54

Would I be dramatic in thinking that fingers up bums and grabbing back legs would be near impossible in a savage attack with a untrained, feral dog owner with a large dog? It's like advising you to punch a shark on the nose.

I’m sorry but under no circumstances whatsoever will I be sticking my finger up a dog’s bum.

LookAtThatCritter · 07/06/2023 01:48

I carry a taser.

LightDrizzle · 07/06/2023 02:15

That spray looks like a good option. I try the firm, calm “Sit!” command followed by “Away!” with a hand gesture. I’ve recently got a Derby handled walking stick as there are a lot of loose dogs in the rural areas near where I live, my DH has been chased on his bike many times. I haven’t used the stick defensively yet but the idea is that is can be a weapon, or used to hook round any collar to pull a dog off another dog or person whilst keeping it at arms length. I doubt I would be strong enough to wrangle an angry XL Bully on the end of it but then the stray or loose dogs here are usually scrawny specimens. They still have teeth though!

What can I take on walks that may help if a dog attacks us.
Zarataralara · 07/06/2023 02:17

Wrapunzel · 06/06/2023 21:16

We have huge issues with dogs on our local bridleway, I carry a schooling whip even though my horse doesn't need one.

That’s a really good idea.

Titusgroan · 07/06/2023 02:43

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 06/06/2023 22:41

@mnhq

Why have comments been b deleted?

I've not reported any.

Yes it's a serious subject and it's my thread. But we can discuss it with some humour and apart from the usual "have you seen your gp" there was nothing wrong with the comments 🤔

Deleted comments were suggesting severe methods and cruelty to animals.

I read a few extreme ones a short while back.

ItsBritneyBitchhhh · 07/06/2023 03:01

An XL Bully and it’s owner walked past myself and my two kids the other day and it was HUGE.

13m old DS was in his buggy, 24m DD was on a reign (but still holding my hand) when this woman came out of nowhere with this fucking beast trodding along behind her unleashed. There’s absolutely no way that owner would be able to do anything if that monster attacked another dog or person.

I was so unsettled that DD had to be the closest person to walk past the dog but as she was on the reign, I couldn’t switch hands immediately. I’ve never been scared of dogs but since seeing all these articles in the news whilst having children, I really try to stay as far away from them as possible.

Not sure we’ll be having many picnics in the park this summer!

Missingmyusername · 07/06/2023 03:23

Titusgroan · 07/06/2023 02:43

Deleted comments were suggesting severe methods and cruelty to animals.

I read a few extreme ones a short while back.

Bloody hell. Well done mn.

Weareoutofwine · 07/06/2023 04:27

Starting point, I am an experienced dog owner, and all round dog lover. My breed of choice is a Dobermann.

OP I can completely understand and relate to your fear. I think many of the trite replies stating 'its the owner not the dog', or 'go to your GP for anxiety' are utterly ill informed on the recent increase in dog on dog attacks (and brutality of said attacks) and the increase of attacks on people. Stats include - 10 people killed in the UK in 2022, the average in the 20 years previous is 3 per year. This year alone 5 people have been killed. Hospitalisation (hospital episode data) ,from dog attacks, have also doubled over the past 15 years from around 4600 in 2007 to c8800 in 2022.

Reports suggest that all 5 fatalities this year are down to American Bullies. If you've ever seen this breed or dealt with one - you'll know they are extremely powerful, and frankly they worry me greatly

I agree with some previous posters American Bullie XL should be added to the Dangerous Dog Act and there needs to be better enforcement of said Act. There also needs to be improved resources around training, and dog ownership in general. Most dogs and owners are fabulous and many companion breeds are bred so that they make wonderful family pets when combined with good training and responsible ownership

American Bullies and other Pitbulls are a product of their very selective intentional breeding - and that is historically to fight - they have high muscle mass and serious biting strength. Like most breeds selective breeding has taken place to result in clear dominant traits, we should be clear on this when understanding dogs - and there are consequences to this. Retrievers retrieve, grey hounds have instant speed, pointers point - you get the picture!

Pitbulls have been used as a foundation to create the American Bully breed. Pitbulls were not in their breeding bred to be a loyal companion - they were breed to carry out brutish sustained attacks on bulls. And then later and now continually amongst a minority of people for dog fighting.

Owners of the Bulls are often ill prepared, they don't know about the breeding history, or some don't care and perhaps some enjoy the status symbol of owning a large powerful dog.

Any rate I'm running the danger of banging on! What I'm trying to say is the breed landscape and dog ownership has changed considerable in 20 odd years plus (and attack and fatality stats back this). I think OP is sensible to be alive to this

If my local walking areas had an influx of Amercican Bullie dogs, particularly off the lead with clearly inexperienced owners or owners who are obviously 'enjoying the status', I would find new places to walk and train. If one of these dogs hit prey drive and simply did what it is historically bred to do most of us would not be able to fight it off. The Americal XL is a vast powerful animal.
If in any doubt just Google it, and also Google how some breeders market the litters.

WiddlinDiddlin · 07/06/2023 05:14

A few ideas..

Carry high value dog treats (sausage, ham, cheese) for your dog - and also to 'bomb' an incoming dog you are not sure on. Whilst this is unlikely to halt a dog hell bent on an attack, it might well stop a 'friendly but rude' approach turning into a dog fight.

Pop up umbrella - deployed toward the oncoming dog can provide enough shock/startle to stop them, allowing you to do a voice of doom SIT! which can work surprisingly well as its generally the first thing any dog is taught even if they're never taught anything else, or scatter food etc.

Rape alarm, can of compressed air, bite stop spray... YMMV but none are shockingly bad ideas.

Carry a stick, a walking type stick obviously, not a weapon.

However - ensure YOUR dog is comfortable with all these things deployed near them, because you could cause your own dog to bolt or you could cause them to redirect frustration/fear/aggression onto you (particularly if they're on a short lead so the only thing they can bite IS you..). I know many people will say 'my dog would never....' but the truth is, most dogs will if the situation is stressful enough.

If you have a little dog who can be carried, teach them to be picked up with a cue so they know its happening and don't fear it. Whilst picking a little dog up can trigger some dogs to jump up to investigate or snap at a smaller dog (they seem to sense the carried dog is vulnerable), its still likely to be safer. But it is safer still if your dog is not growling/barking/crying because they're scared of being picked up!

Plan where you walk - avoid narrow gaps/paths, tight spaces where you can't get some distance.

Avoid walking head on at another dog with yours on lead, these head on approaches forced by our pavements and short leads can trigger a spat or attack as the dogs come closer together because they're super unnatural. The dogs feel trapped, their options are limited, and its very easy for dogs to misread one anothers body language in this situation (particularly if the oncoming dog has a squashed up face, starey eyes etc, as part of their breed appearance). And of course some dogs are genuinely sending pretty hostile signals long before you come close to them, and their owners can be totally unaware of this.

Arc around, cross the road, get space, try to avoid the direct eye contact by distracting your dog.

If another dog does attack your dog unfortunately there is no sure fire guaranteed 'do this one thing and...' solution.

The most effective thing generally is to try and get a hold of the dogs (one person per dog) by collar and tail, choke out a dog that is clamped down on the other dog (or both if they both are) and avoid pulling, as that can really exacerbate damage.

When the clamped on dog (btw most dogs will do this in a fight, particularly if they're really nervous dogs. If they clamp down and don't let go, then their victim cannot get them. To let go, is to put themselves at risk so they try not to!) lets go, if you have the collar and tail you may be able to launch it backwards a fair distance - not something to do if someone has hold of the other dog but if you're trying to sort a situation with two dogs and just one of you, it may be (particularly if its over a fence or out of a door you can slam shut).

That is far easier said than done and of course puts you at risk of bites from either dog (yes yours will bite you, they won't even know its you).

If you can avoid yelling, screaming, kicking/hitting etc - great. Most people can't, its instinctive.

I've had to do these things a few times (very few fortunately but I have worked at some very dodgy rescue centres when I was much younger) and avoidance really IS the best policy.

HappiestSleeping · 07/06/2023 07:00

ChatWTF · 07/06/2023 00:33

Why the sneery tone? People are allowed to discuss what they should/n’t do in lots of scenarios.

It’s not being mauled to death, it’s general bites and attacks which are a far higher number.

It wasn't intended to be sneery to be honest. Just wanted to point out that the chance of a dog running up to anyone at random and attacking, even if only a bite, is so infinitesimally small that it shouldn't be a worry. I was aiming at humour and not sneery.

Weareoutofwine · 07/06/2023 07:12

HappiestSleeping · 07/06/2023 07:00

It wasn't intended to be sneery to be honest. Just wanted to point out that the chance of a dog running up to anyone at random and attacking, even if only a bite, is so infinitesimally small that it shouldn't be a worry. I was aiming at humour and not sneery.

But data and stats, plus a bag full of growing anecdotal suggests the chances are not infinitesimal.

8,800 hospitizations in 2022 is not infinitesimal. There were 22000 dog attacks on humans - there will have been more that will simply be unreported and escape data sets.

Again I'll state I'm a dog lover. But you can't deny a growing risk.

GSD20 · 07/06/2023 07:13

Nothing will stop an XL, American bully or pit in full attack. It won’t listen to your dogs scary signals (cos that would work in a dog fight…) any attempts to submit (what use is a fighting dog if when the victim cries it lets go) or random hitting, kicking or punching it. I have huge dogs and even they would stand 0 chance against an XL- it’s laughable that one poster thinks her border collie would survive.

Ive seen them tazered, pushed back with taser shields, given enough sedation to knock out a horse and still they get up and go again. No normal tactics will help, most of the time they don’t even know the owner is there. The last one I tried to help with snapped a wooden broom handle clean in half with one bite, didn’t even flinch.

I have no answer to the OP question though! If one comes anywhere near me, my dogs or my kids I’m getting the hell away from it as fast as possible (unless I’m at work and then I’ll deal with it once again 🙈)

newnamethanks · 07/06/2023 07:25

Don't fill your pockets with tasty sausage, cheese and treats in the hope of discouraging an attack. Any old dog will smell them and interest be aroused immediately. If it's a neglected fighting dog, it will come and take them and you won't pause to find your spray/stick/other as above, you won't be able to distract it. They are DOGS, not biddable children. Don't engage, get out of the way.

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 07/06/2023 07:30

The initial comments were silly and jokey and where not encouraging cruelty. They were silly.

What planet is anyone on thinking the poster who suggested marigolds was being serious.

I've seen and been around enough dogs that I know it's prudent to be prepared for this.

Like casting ones mind to where fire exits are anywhere etc.

OP posts:
ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 07/06/2023 07:32

@GSD20 how to get away in fields when it's thinking you are prey.

OP posts:
AllGussiedUp · 07/06/2023 07:34

I think it says it all that you didn’t have an issue with the deleted posts, the ones I saw were awful, but you have an issue with it being suggested that you should see a doctor for possible anxiety.

AllGussiedUp · 07/06/2023 07:36

The initial comments were silly and jokey and where not encouraging cruelty. They were silly.

No, some were encouraging cruel and were designed to be inflammatory. A look at some posters other posts would tell you that.

AllGussiedUp · 07/06/2023 07:36

*cruelty

sourcorn · 07/06/2023 07:38

ThisSummerBetterBeDarnGood · 07/06/2023 07:30

The initial comments were silly and jokey and where not encouraging cruelty. They were silly.

What planet is anyone on thinking the poster who suggested marigolds was being serious.

I've seen and been around enough dogs that I know it's prudent to be prepared for this.

Like casting ones mind to where fire exits are anywhere etc.

It is not appropriate to joke about animal cruelty

Weareoutofwine · 07/06/2023 07:47

sourcorn · 07/06/2023 07:38

It is not appropriate to joke about animal cruelty

Humour is used for many awful, desperate situations - a list of what one must jnot oke about due to being 'not appropriate' would be rather long. Who should we consult to agree topics which can be joked about? Who is the arbiter of taste and decency?

I'm sure some the comments were from typical trolls trying to get a rise out of mumsnetters - so just try to not engage. But honestly it's gets a tad boring when on many threads posters are continually issued with a list of ever growing topics which must not, in any circumstances ever, be addressed through even the smallest humorous lense.

Weareoutofwine · 07/06/2023 07:48

Lens. Urgh typos.