Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think young women just don’t realise... (TW: fertility/ TTC)

445 replies

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 14:10

Nc as this combined with various other posts would be outing, this is a bugbear I’ve thought about a lot when ttc myself and something today brought it up again...

Anyhow, AIBU to think ladies In their late twenties who freeze their eggs (or plan to as a ‘failsafe’) don’t realise it’s not a guarantee or the same as ‘pressing pause’ on biology?

This comes about as i was chatting to childhood friend (29, same as me) about kids (I have recently had DS so this is why we were chatting about kids) and she said ‘oh x (school pal) froze her eggs recently, if I haven’t had kids by 33 I’ll do the same, x is so relieved to press pause and take the pressure off’ another friend has also mentioned egg freezing recently for the same reason, both have just said they don’t want the responsibility of kids yet but are in a ‘good’ position to do so ... each to their own but all I could think was that it’s all well and good but it doesn’t guarantee anything! Sadly the demon biology also makes it harder to carry as you age too, it’s not all about eggs!

I just think so many in my generation have the attitude that it will just happen later regardless thanks to science but everyone I know who has had kids or tried to have kids later has struggled (not a guarantee ofc but a statistical probability nonetheless)... interested to hear other people’s thoughts on this. Perhaps this is more of a ‘my circle of friends’ issue than a wider one.

YANBU - it’s a concern, many may end up disappointed in the future, not to mention already falling birth rates etc
YABU - mind your own!

OP posts:
Thread gallery
9
Usernamen · 24/05/2023 22:04

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 21:29

This is really interesting ( if a bit off topic) reflecting about how I could feel ready at 27. If you had asked me I would have said I had my fair share of wild youth. I think we grew up younger and I was in London which probrably added to that, by 24 when I moved in with DH I'd been to loads of clubs, seen tons of live music, been interailing and to be honest slept with plenty of guys. I'd been doing all that for the best part of 10 years by then, I was a doctor so I couldn't go out much anyway, I was ready to settle down.

You said upthread that your parents babysat while you went out and partied and now you’re saying you got it out of your system by 24 and are in a career that didn’t afford you opportunity to go out much even if the grandparents were babysitting.

Anyway, we digress.

I think you’re fortunate that you definitely knew you wanted children and when you wanted them (I mean this sincerely). Like the PP, marriage and kids was honestly the last thing on my mind in my 20s. I would have got the ick from any guy talking about it while we were dating!

Basically, people are different 😅

It has been an interesting discussion though.

Mistymist · 24/05/2023 22:02

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 21:44

Yeah, perfect example of male factor. What does it have to do with freezing eggs?

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 22:00

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 21:44

What's the alternative though? Sometimes the time isn't right until your 30's. It is a risk but there are also risks that can come with having children at a younger age too.

Should women force themselves to feel ready in their 20's even though they could potentially be better mothers in their 30's when they might actually feel ready?
Should they have a child with someone who might not be the right person for them but, hey, at least they aren't 35?
Should they concentrate on their career later in life instead?
If so, should they just not worry about finances even though they may be financially better off in their 30's?

Onomatopoeia4 · 24/05/2023 21:57

I mentioned earlier on that I successfully had two children in my thirties and that I'm currently pregnant with my third.

However, I will definitely advise my daughter to start a little bit younger than me (if she wants children).

I had a lot of anxiety that it wouldn't work out for me and I don't want her to go through the same. That stress and pressure is not a good place to be in and I want to protect her against that, if I can.

NotMyDayJob · 24/05/2023 21:55

LeftASituation · 24/05/2023 21:31

I would much rather women waited to meet the right person and had happy and stable relationships than rushed to have kids with any man in the pursuit of fertility.

I would much rather they had the opportunity to develop a career when they wanted rather than panic and procreate just because of people telling them they need to before they turn 30.

Yes reduced fertility is potentially an issue but that’s a risk some women are prepared to take. And that’s ok.

I loved my twenties. I wasn’t a party person. But memories of travelling, fun times with flatmates and being carefree and spending time with friends is something I treasure to this day. My kids have now left home and whilst I still have a fun and fulfilled life, I do still worry about them and cannot be as mentally carefree as I was at 25.

Having kids in my twenties did not cross my mind. If my junior trainees ask my advice about when to have kids I always say don’t do it in your twenties. I won’t change my mind on that.

I would hate to go back to a world where women feel they have to pop out kids asap. No thanks. There is so much more out there for them to do.

Yeah but if you had done that you could have come on this thread and been really smug about the fact you're a lawyer/doctor/academic (other name drop worthy career) and how you'd already met your partner by your early 20s and bought a flat (and managed to do that in London!/other expensive city) and had kids in your 20s (maybe early 30s but let's not get carried away) and were now able to judge all us poor old crones who were silly enough to have fertility problems/make different life choices.

But alas, you didn't and can only offer this much more balanced view

Hollyppp · 24/05/2023 21:51

DespairingALittle · 24/05/2023 16:10

theres a reply up thread where I mention this but no. I’ve never passed opinion either way to them. It’s their choice and I’d never sit there and say I told you so either! But I would be very sad for them if it doesn’t work out and I think a lack of real education and understand of fertility rates and treatments are to blame. As well as misrepresentation in the media.

OP I have the same feelings as you. I don’t give my opinion (which would be to consider their fertility earlier rather than later) when my friends make naive statements. I listen and empathise but privately I do worry for both my SILs (married to my brother and my husbands sister) who are both the same age as me and both want children and both have long term partners but happy to wait until late 30s and have ‘lived more’ and will ‘do IVF’ if they have any issues

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 21:38

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 21:29

This is really interesting ( if a bit off topic) reflecting about how I could feel ready at 27. If you had asked me I would have said I had my fair share of wild youth. I think we grew up younger and I was in London which probrably added to that, by 24 when I moved in with DH I'd been to loads of clubs, seen tons of live music, been interailing and to be honest slept with plenty of guys. I'd been doing all that for the best part of 10 years by then, I was a doctor so I couldn't go out much anyway, I was ready to settle down.

It is interesting. Of course, the biggest difference for me was that I simply just wasn't interested in any of that and wasn't even sure I even wanted it for most of my 20's.

I don't think I would've made a good parent in my 20's. Many are of course but I'm glad I waited.

LeftASituation · 24/05/2023 21:31

I would much rather women waited to meet the right person and had happy and stable relationships than rushed to have kids with any man in the pursuit of fertility.

I would much rather they had the opportunity to develop a career when they wanted rather than panic and procreate just because of people telling them they need to before they turn 30.

Yes reduced fertility is potentially an issue but that’s a risk some women are prepared to take. And that’s ok.

I loved my twenties. I wasn’t a party person. But memories of travelling, fun times with flatmates and being carefree and spending time with friends is something I treasure to this day. My kids have now left home and whilst I still have a fun and fulfilled life, I do still worry about them and cannot be as mentally carefree as I was at 25.

Having kids in my twenties did not cross my mind. If my junior trainees ask my advice about when to have kids I always say don’t do it in your twenties. I won’t change my mind on that.

I would hate to go back to a world where women feel they have to pop out kids asap. No thanks. There is so much more out there for them to do.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 21:29

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 21:16

I wasn't really interested in anything serious until I met my husband. Maybe it was because I was ready or he was just the right person, possibly a bit of both.

I would've ran a mile if a man had started talking about marriage and children in my early to mid 20's but then I did always make it clear from the beginning that I just wanted some fun. I was frankly after some good sex, nothing more. I was working crazy hours, partying, travelling etc and a serious relationship just wasn't a priority to me at that stage.

This is really interesting ( if a bit off topic) reflecting about how I could feel ready at 27. If you had asked me I would have said I had my fair share of wild youth. I think we grew up younger and I was in London which probrably added to that, by 24 when I moved in with DH I'd been to loads of clubs, seen tons of live music, been interailing and to be honest slept with plenty of guys. I'd been doing all that for the best part of 10 years by then, I was a doctor so I couldn't go out much anyway, I was ready to settle down.

suminagashi · 24/05/2023 21:17

SashaPearce · 24/05/2023 14:53

YANBU. I find some of the media/celebrity type reporting on this stuff irresponsible, quoting celebrities like Rita Ora saying she’s frozen her eggs and therefore feels safe, without necessarily accompanying it with info on how much it costs, the invasive procedures involved, the statistical likelihood of it working, etc.

Having said that, I remember how annoyed I used to be by the doom and gloom articles published by the likes of Robert Winston in the Evening Standard a while back, making it sound like no woman over 35 could ever have a baby. Which anecdotally, among my cohort, has not proved to be the case. I think there’s a journalistic art to giving the facts in a helpful way without making it seem like you’re haranguing women.

@SashaPearce can I ask why you're talking about 'the likes of Robert Winston' as though he doesn't know what he's talking about?

Robert Winston was a pioneer in fertility treatments, so it just feels that you're speaking dismissively of his wealth of hands on experience in this field. He's also not a journalist, although articles he writes may well be published in the Evening Standard.

He's the Emeritus Professor of Fertility Studies at Imperial College, not some journo hack who's making it up!

https://www.robertwinston.org.uk/about-robert-winston/

https://www.robertwinston.org.uk/subject/fertility/

He also knows no one can change sex, which is an additional positive in my book.

About Robert Winston | Professor Robert Winston

Lord Winston is Professor of Science and Society and Emeritus Professor of Fertility Studies at Imperial College London. In the 1970s he developed gynaecological surgical techniques that improved fertility treatments. He later pioneered new treatments...

https://www.robertwinston.org.uk/about-robert-winston

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 21:16

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 21:04

DH was my 4th "serious boyfriend " all 4 had talked about timescales for marriage and children- maybe I just gave off those vibes ? Or maybe that's the way things were a bit more in the 90's.

I wasn't really interested in anything serious until I met my husband. Maybe it was because I was ready or he was just the right person, possibly a bit of both.

I would've ran a mile if a man had started talking about marriage and children in my early to mid 20's but then I did always make it clear from the beginning that I just wanted some fun. I was frankly after some good sex, nothing more. I was working crazy hours, partying, travelling etc and a serious relationship just wasn't a priority to me at that stage.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 21:14

CantAskAnyoneElse · 24/05/2023 21:07

Are you religious?
Do you or your partner come from the background where women’s worth is just having a husband and popping out kids?

You write in such a dissociated way, made me think there is a reason to it…

Me ? Religious? Not at all.

squarezero · 24/05/2023 21:12

YABU

Although it might look to you that they're in a perfect position to have children you have no idea really. I remember friends asking me in my 20s (several years into marriage) if I will have children and I'd answer "I don't know maybe one day" which was my polite way of changing the subject because I didn't want to say that I was worried about my marriage, or later that we were having challenges conceiving. It would sometimes generate a "well don't leave it too long it might not happen straight away" response. They too would probably be talking about how naive I was.

Getting involved in other people's fertility is generally a bad idea.

CantAskAnyoneElse · 24/05/2023 21:07

Are you religious?
Do you or your partner come from the background where women’s worth is just having a husband and popping out kids?

You write in such a dissociated way, made me think there is a reason to it…

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 21:04

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 20:56

At 21, I was adamant that I would never get married or have children. I didn't meet my husband until I was 28 and obviously did change my mind about marriage and children in the end but not until I was in my 30's.

I wasn't ready at all to have a baby in my 20's.

DH was my 4th "serious boyfriend " all 4 had talked about timescales for marriage and children- maybe I just gave off those vibes ? Or maybe that's the way things were a bit more in the 90's.

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 20:56

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 20:49

True I always knew I wanted children. TBH I probably saw potential partners through that lens, certainly from 21 onwards, less so at 17.

At 21, I was adamant that I would never get married or have children. I didn't meet my husband until I was 28 and obviously did change my mind about marriage and children in the end but not until I was in my 30's.

I wasn't ready at all to have a baby in my 20's.

Shutupanddance1 · 24/05/2023 20:56

I was in my mid twenties (26) but it took more than a year for us to have DD1 so I do think we aren’t told enough about contraception/conception to make the important decisions when we are younger.

Ponderosamum · 24/05/2023 20:54

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:55

I disagree. I think the way we have organised society is a bitch. It shouldn't be the norm to have to cram everything in, work and education wise, in our peak childbearing years.

totally agree with this

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 20:49

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 20:41

That does involve meeting the person you want to be with at a younger age and actually knowing you want children by then.

True I always knew I wanted children. TBH I probably saw potential partners through that lens, certainly from 21 onwards, less so at 17.

Ponderosamum · 24/05/2023 20:49

Hi OP, Speaking as first time mum at 43, I can tell you that I started TTC at age 37, and I knew I would have a struggle due to having only 1 functioning Ovary and endometriosis. I just wasn't ready till age 37 to try for kids regardless, I did not feel remotely maternal before then and really did not know if I wanted kids at all. I was fully informed of the risks of putting TTC off and the fact that it would be more difficult for me. With hindsight, I wish that I had frozen my eggs in my late twenties / early 30's. It took me a long time to conceive, 7 rounds of IVF in 6 years and 1 miscarriage. Although it all turned out ok for me, given my experience, I think freezing your eggs in your 30's is a practical and proactive thing to do if you are really not ready to have kids for 3 or more years. Of course, It may not work, that is the risk that you take. From my experience of IVF and egg freezing, one of the most important factors to conceiving a healthy child is the age and health of the egg itself, therefore some women will have a better chance of conceiving with frozen eggs taken from them at 30 vs. trying with fresh eggs at 38 or 40. Lastly, everyone knows somebody who has had issues TTC, it is more common now - probably due to the average age of having kids rising to 30, so I think most women these days are really not that naïve about this.

Robinni · 24/05/2023 20:42

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:55

I disagree. I think the way we have organised society is a bitch. It shouldn't be the norm to have to cram everything in, work and education wise, in our peak childbearing years.

^ This

Agree again.

Equality for women in access to the workplace has not taken into account equality of reproductive rights.

SouthLondonMum22 · 24/05/2023 20:41

Neurodiversitydoctor · 24/05/2023 20:30

I was a doctor at 23, bought a flat at 26 and had a baby at 28 (v. unfashionable) We weren't rich (for a longtime) but had a home and good jobs. We had loads of energy (and family help) pregnancy childbirth and sleepness nights barely affected me.

That does involve meeting the person you want to be with at a younger age and actually knowing you want children by then.

Middlelanehogger · 24/05/2023 20:41

I agree with this. I and my friends are in the bracket OP's talking about - "career women" in early 30s who have the money for egg freezing basically.

PP are talking about "well, it's not your business if they don't want kids". But they do. They look around and see messages from women in our industry saying now is the time to go hard in your career, it's sexist to assume women will want kids so the women's group at work shouldn't talk about pregnancy, everyone around us is posting pics from Greek islands looking amazing...

Then their boyfriends are usually in the same bracket, with middle-class ideas of how it's irresponsible to have kids unless you're married and own your home, but of course you'll want a nice wedding which takes 2 years to plan and have you seen house prices in London...

They don't even ALLOW themselves to want kids. The egg freezing is the only way that tiny hope is allowed to make itself felt.

Robinni · 24/05/2023 20:39

orangemagnolia · 24/05/2023 19:40

I do think adults have a responsibility to education teens on fertility to some extent. I received 0 info on this from parents and school, and was surprised when I realised the true ins and outs of fertility and the importance of not leaving it too late. There's a real lack of education in this area.

@orangemagnolia I do agree with you. But then I also think parents should be educating their children on the basics of life such as cooking, budgeting, saving, pensions etc and helping them plan out their lives too.

A lot of this education used to be in home economics which is now sadly sidelined to make way for STEM/IT.

Nothing against STEM, what I trained in, but life skills and practical planning are lacking in most now.

Swipe left for the next trending thread