Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed about SIL stealing baby's name?

312 replies

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 10:42

My DB's wife is a complicated sort of person and they don't have a great relationship. They had several rounds of IVF over 8-10 years and finally had 2dds, the second born recently. They have given their second baby the same name as my youngest dc. Well, not the same name exactly, one letter is different (think Helena vs Helene).

My DD isn't too bothered about it, at first she thought it was a compliment but apparently, it wasn't! SIL just 'always wanted that name'! DB tried to discourage her but she was apparently adamant.

The baby is here now and very cute and we all love her, but I am secretly seething about the name. My DP are already getting the dc muddled and DM recently sent my DD a birthday card with her name spellt wrong - ie using the slightly different spelling of her cousin's name.

My DPs are elderly, happy and proud about all their DGC and just want a harmonious family life so they have changed the subject when I've grumbled about it. Because DB's relationship with SIL is so fraught already I obviously can't rock the boat by saying anything to SIL.

But AIBU to privately feel really annoyed? I just can't understand why someone would do this. There are so many names in the world! Surely some should be off-limits??

OP posts:
Itsanotherhreatday · 14/05/2023 14:46

But I have to say I’ve changed my mind a bit after your update that this is a family name, your DH grandmother and I think you are BU

How is DH family connected to OPs brothers wife?

NewNovember · 14/05/2023 14:46

My SIL did the same but no IVF similar too my dd being Clarissa known as Clara she named her dd Clare . Neither her nor her husband my BIL thought to ask us . Now it just sounds weird at grandparents.

aSofaNearYou · 14/05/2023 14:49

But emotions are a funny thing aren’t they. Did she need to change it, no? She has every right to keep the name she wanted. But she has to accept that by keeping it she could cause a rift that affects everyone else in the family potentially. The SIL has to decide how much she really wants to name above all others.

I would consider OP at fault if it did cause a rift, though, not OP. Yes it's a bit of a pain for her but she ought to recognise that it undoubtedly means more to SIL to use it, than it does to her for it not to be used, just to avoid spelling errors.

SIL should not have to worst that it will cause a rift if she uses it. A bit of annoyance, maybe, but not a major fall out.

Ilovelurchers · 14/05/2023 14:52

I come from a cultural background where we often reuse names. We love it! My daughter's middle name (should have been her first name but my then husband overruled me) is one loads of female members of my family of all generations have. Should have been my name too but my mom bucked the trend and gave me a fashionable name instead, much to my chagrin now.

Had I not lost my son he would have had my husband's granddad's name first name, my dad's name as a middle name, and I would have tried to stick my husband's name in there somewhere too.

Clearly this is not your thing OP though - while I can't empathise with you hating the reuse of names (it seems so normal and lovely to me) it's fair enough for you to feel as you do. Also best to let go of the anger though if you can, as there are far bigger and more important things in the world to worry about, as others have said. And you can't change the baby's name now so why worry?

I do hope your sister-in-law doesn't read the thread - the situation is pretty specific, and it would be a shame to upset somebody at such a stressful time in her life, especially if her marriage is also rocky as you say. Poor woman - lots to cope with from the sound of it.

Ilovelurchers · 14/05/2023 14:59

Itsanotherhreatday · 14/05/2023 14:31

It has historically been very normal for families to repeat the same names time and time again throughout the generations

It’s not the norm now though is it? It’s now considered rude and unacceptable.

You don’t own a name

Why do I hear this as if it’s coming from an 8 year old playground bully?

I hadn't noticed this when I wrote my last post, sorry.

You are being a bit culturally imperialistic here (I don't mean to be nasty - I'm sure you don't mean to be). There are lots of cultures, sections within cultures etc, where isn't considered rude and unacceptable at all. (In fact it's news to me that anybody feels so ardently negative about the tradition to be honest).

But my family and my current husband's family, for example, both frequently reuse names and we aren't "rude and unacceptable", just because we aren't exactly like you.

loislovesstewie · 14/05/2023 15:14

Actually it is the norm to reuse names, which is why I got into trouble with DH's family as I would not use one of his family names. It's just a horrible name! We did use other family names but they are ones we like.

Liorae · 14/05/2023 15:16

Itsanotherhreatday · 14/05/2023 14:31

It has historically been very normal for families to repeat the same names time and time again throughout the generations

It’s not the norm now though is it? It’s now considered rude and unacceptable.

You don’t own a name

Why do I hear this as if it’s coming from an 8 year old playground bully?

I don't know anyone who would consider this rude and unacceptable. I think it's a Mumsnet thing, not a normal thing.

Liorae · 14/05/2023 15:18

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 12:01

Well, that's certainly an energetic response! 😳

Energetic and very apt.

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 15:38

Liorae · 14/05/2023 15:18

Energetic and very apt.

Not really. I don't find it particularly apt or helpful to draw comparisons between trivial AIBU dilemmas and the situation in Ukraine

OP posts:
Pipsquiggle · 14/05/2023 15:55

@CattytheFatty

It would annoy me too, however, there are a few things that might slightly mitigate the impact of this

Do you see them a lot? My DC see their cousins about 4 times a year so if they did share a name it really wouldn't impact their lives day to day.

The age gap means they won't actively be socialising with each other.

Your DB and DSIL relationship seems weird. DB should not have capitulated on this as naming a baby is important. If he doesn't/ didn't like the name, he should have put his foot down. When we were choosing names for our DC we both had 'power of veto' which meant neither of us had our 'favourite' name for either child as we both didn't like each other's first choice. I thought everyone did this.

TooOldForThisNonsense · 14/05/2023 15:57

Katherine1985 · 14/05/2023 14:39

I thought you’re SIL was BU but deserved a bit of consideration due to 8-10 years of IVF

Not claiming to even imagine what that does. But I did have a few years of multiple losses so can remember what that does to a person month by month.

But I have to say I’ve changed my mind a bit after your update that this is a family name, your DH grandmother and I think you are BU

Yes it’s a family name of the OP’s husband. Not of the SIL!

Liorae · 14/05/2023 16:10

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 15:38

Not really. I don't find it particularly apt or helpful to draw comparisons between trivial AIBU dilemmas and the situation in Ukraine

Perhaps you should view it as a lesson in perspective.

Katherine1985 · 14/05/2023 16:18

Itsanotherhreatday · 14/05/2023 14:46

But I have to say I’ve changed my mind a bit after your update that this is a family name, your DH grandmother and I think you are BU

How is DH family connected to OPs brothers wife?

Oh maybe I misunderstood something! I thought OPs husband and BIL were brothers

SerafinasGoose · 14/05/2023 16:19

Malificent1 · 14/05/2023 13:21

Ahh the usual MN chorus of “no one owns a name.”

But it’s fucking weird. It is. Most people can grasp that.

OP there’s nothing you can do, but it’s a ridiculous situation. She sounds like a prize idiot.

I agree. Incidentally I am also an IVF mum. Several rounds and five miscarriages, so I do know the pain of infertility: and no, in response to a different PP upthread, it's not the same for the father as the mother. The losses are equally as devastating, but it's the mother's body that takes the serious physical hit of egg harvesting and down-regulation, both of which are awful and invasive: both painful and in terms of artificial hormones making you feel really peculiar. It isn't possible to compare the two experiences: not least the anguish and physical pain of a miscarriage and the surgery needed to remove it.

None of these experiences is a get-out-of-jail-free card for behaving badly toward others, and frankly, I'd find it quite patronising if such excuses were made on my behalf. Other people around you will continue having children. You just have to come to terms with it, and unfortunately it does mean keeping your own feelings very much to yourself.

'Henrietta' is a lovely name and I also love the diminutive 'Hetty'. The most important thing now is to ensure your family doesn't foist a version of the name on your DD that she doesn't want. In those circumstances you and she would be quite justified in correcting them every time.

As to the theme of ownership, the same applies to weddings but it's amazing how proprietorial people can be over that. That it's THEIR day, therefore they can do, say, invite who they want, under the terms they want, and expect complete capitulation, is a regular theme on MN.

Nobody 'owns' a day. They don't 'own' the weeks, month and year surrounding that day either, but considering this, there's a hell of a lot of gatekeeping goes on. I'm not buying that the 'nobody owns a name' style of poster would be this nonchalant if the same thing happened to them.

No question: it IS an odd thing for someone to do.

Liorae · 14/05/2023 16:20

Passerillage · 14/05/2023 12:58

The downside of everybody being determined to have completely unique names for their children is that family names die out. I think it's lovely that the two of you have - inadvertently - created a family name. Just think of it that way.

While that is lovely, and how most would view the situation, i suspect the OP would prefer to seethe and draw her brother in if she can.

Katherine1985 · 14/05/2023 16:24

Ilovelurchers · 14/05/2023 14:52

I come from a cultural background where we often reuse names. We love it! My daughter's middle name (should have been her first name but my then husband overruled me) is one loads of female members of my family of all generations have. Should have been my name too but my mom bucked the trend and gave me a fashionable name instead, much to my chagrin now.

Had I not lost my son he would have had my husband's granddad's name first name, my dad's name as a middle name, and I would have tried to stick my husband's name in there somewhere too.

Clearly this is not your thing OP though - while I can't empathise with you hating the reuse of names (it seems so normal and lovely to me) it's fair enough for you to feel as you do. Also best to let go of the anger though if you can, as there are far bigger and more important things in the world to worry about, as others have said. And you can't change the baby's name now so why worry?

I do hope your sister-in-law doesn't read the thread - the situation is pretty specific, and it would be a shame to upset somebody at such a stressful time in her life, especially if her marriage is also rocky as you say. Poor woman - lots to cope with from the sound of it.

Same here. A first cousin has the full version of my name as first name, but different spelling (Kathryn). Half sister has it as her middle name. Then my mum’s cousin’s daughter has my exact first name (diminutive of Katherine) AND middle name

Liorae · 14/05/2023 16:52

pecantoucan · 14/05/2023 13:35

Oh. OK.

I think just silently stew for a day then you're going to have to get over it for the baby's sake

I strongly support silence is not the OP's strong point.

Zone2NorthLondon · 14/05/2023 17:20

Ahh the usual mn machinations and supposed social rules around names it reeks of entitlements. As always on these threads peculiar rules and alleged etiquette are trotted out as a widely understood social norm. No. These so called rules are a confection and repeated only to gain an advantage in this social situation. There is no widely understood or adhered to rule that a name cannot be replying a family

Robinni · 14/05/2023 17:27

DarkForces · 14/05/2023 13:52

Those sound pretty different to me. Anyway, you have a choice, let it spoil away at you and try to get others involved and agreeing with you or let it go and not let it impact your day. Whatever you choose to do nothing will change the children's' names

Theres lots of things other people do I'd love to change but all I can do is reframe my thinking and make the best of my short time on the planet. The person you're impacting most negatively is you and this thread isn't helping

^ This

Robinni · 14/05/2023 17:33

mosiacmaker · 14/05/2023 14:03

I don’t understand the big deal at all either. I think I would be more annoyed if a friend did this than a relative tbh as most relatives socialise in such different circles from each other. I guess it could be confusing for your great great grandchildren with the try to do the family tree though.

Why?! One H will have her DH surname and the other her DB surname. They are born a decade apart, their middle names will differ, and the H names are spelt and pronounced differently 🤷‍♀️

Am in agreement with somebody else who said she probably called her first born something else out of respect to you (or because a different sex) and then thought stuff it, I have had to wait ten years for my baby girl and I want to call her what I want, without having to consult with extended family.

The same name issue is incredibly common, how it impacts you depends on how YOU respond to it.

Them changing the name is not going to happen. So either you find a way to be ok with it. Or you get angry and bitter and let it upset the entire family dynamic. Up to you.

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 17:40

SerafinasGoose · 14/05/2023 16:19

I agree. Incidentally I am also an IVF mum. Several rounds and five miscarriages, so I do know the pain of infertility: and no, in response to a different PP upthread, it's not the same for the father as the mother. The losses are equally as devastating, but it's the mother's body that takes the serious physical hit of egg harvesting and down-regulation, both of which are awful and invasive: both painful and in terms of artificial hormones making you feel really peculiar. It isn't possible to compare the two experiences: not least the anguish and physical pain of a miscarriage and the surgery needed to remove it.

None of these experiences is a get-out-of-jail-free card for behaving badly toward others, and frankly, I'd find it quite patronising if such excuses were made on my behalf. Other people around you will continue having children. You just have to come to terms with it, and unfortunately it does mean keeping your own feelings very much to yourself.

'Henrietta' is a lovely name and I also love the diminutive 'Hetty'. The most important thing now is to ensure your family doesn't foist a version of the name on your DD that she doesn't want. In those circumstances you and she would be quite justified in correcting them every time.

As to the theme of ownership, the same applies to weddings but it's amazing how proprietorial people can be over that. That it's THEIR day, therefore they can do, say, invite who they want, under the terms they want, and expect complete capitulation, is a regular theme on MN.

Nobody 'owns' a day. They don't 'own' the weeks, month and year surrounding that day either, but considering this, there's a hell of a lot of gatekeeping goes on. I'm not buying that the 'nobody owns a name' style of poster would be this nonchalant if the same thing happened to them.

No question: it IS an odd thing for someone to do.

Thanks @SerafinasGoose yes it really was odd, with so many names in the world and dd being quite a strong personality in the family it seemed a strange thing to do!

I'll never really understand it but there you go. DD was never bothered and we all love the baby very much, so that's the main thing!

OP posts:
Katherine1985 · 14/05/2023 18:01

Maybe DD being quite a strong personality is what’s brought this on with SIL.

Katherine1985 · 14/05/2023 18:11

*strong personality in the family I meant

Try not to take it personally but if ivf went on for as long as your DD’s been around, your DD may have got linked in SIL’s thought processes of the life she wanted. Sometimes we really fixate on one thing to handle grief, loss, or intolerable ongoing stress. And if your DD was very noticeable in the family, she may have been the visual reminder of what SIL wanted and was in pain about not having

Coffeelotsofcoffee · 14/05/2023 18:18

I'm an IVf vetetan and you get lapped so so many times and in the end every bloody name is gone. My chosen name Jack was taken twice yes TWICE by both SILs (one on each side) because it took me and hubby 10 long years to have our son yet the fertiles just seem to bang them out left right and centre . I don't blame ivfers for sticking to their guns and using then names they want no matter how many relatives have snapped them up

SheilaFentiman · 14/05/2023 18:23

I picked DS1’s name when I was 8.

If DH had hated it, we wouldn’t have used it. But if he liked it too and his older sister already had a 10 year old with that name, I would have wanted very much to use it anyway. We see SIL 1-2 times a year - DS1’s name will be his for life.