Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed about SIL stealing baby's name?

312 replies

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 10:42

My DB's wife is a complicated sort of person and they don't have a great relationship. They had several rounds of IVF over 8-10 years and finally had 2dds, the second born recently. They have given their second baby the same name as my youngest dc. Well, not the same name exactly, one letter is different (think Helena vs Helene).

My DD isn't too bothered about it, at first she thought it was a compliment but apparently, it wasn't! SIL just 'always wanted that name'! DB tried to discourage her but she was apparently adamant.

The baby is here now and very cute and we all love her, but I am secretly seething about the name. My DP are already getting the dc muddled and DM recently sent my DD a birthday card with her name spellt wrong - ie using the slightly different spelling of her cousin's name.

My DPs are elderly, happy and proud about all their DGC and just want a harmonious family life so they have changed the subject when I've grumbled about it. Because DB's relationship with SIL is so fraught already I obviously can't rock the boat by saying anything to SIL.

But AIBU to privately feel really annoyed? I just can't understand why someone would do this. There are so many names in the world! Surely some should be off-limits??

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
cobicat · 08/06/2023 08:27

This happened to me too! Quite an unusual name, no family links to the name on SIL's side, only 3 years age difference between the dc. It did really annoy me, TBH. Just seemed so unnecessary and avoidable.

SheilaFentiman · 16/05/2023 14:42

trisfreya · 16/05/2023 14:32

have a thought for Clare in Derry girls

'Clare Clare Devlin . Names after both her grandmothers . Who were both called Clare.

😀😀

trisfreya · 16/05/2023 14:32

SheilaFentiman · 15/05/2023 12:02

I‘m glad the thread has helped and you feel that you can move on.

FWIW about the spelling, I could never remember if my MIL was (let’s say) Claire or Clare and I had to check my address book every time I wrote her a card! Hopefully it’s a one off from your DPs.

have a thought for Clare in Derry girls

'Clare Clare Devlin . Names after both her grandmothers . Who were both called Clare.

shams05 · 16/05/2023 09:11

I don't see the issue really as there's quite an age gap. My ds has the same name as my sils son. It was my grandfather's name and we siblings had agreed that whoever had a boy first would have first dibs on the name.
When we got married dhs sister was pregnant and chose that name for her Ds. I had my ds6 years later and used the same name, not because she had used it but because it was a name that meant something to me. Nobody bat an eyelid, my sis in law was actually quite pleased that we'd also liked the same name.
It's really no big deal in the grand scheme of things. The boys are 21 and 15 now, live on either side of the country, have their own likes and career paths and nobody mixes them up.
I'd give your brother a little credit here, their relationship can't be that bad if they've stayed together through multiple rounds of IVF.

x2boys · 16/05/2023 09:03

Meh I have a 70,s hyphenated name so say, " Sarah-Jane" and have an older cousin called "Jane" similarly two.other of my cousins ,who.were also cousins were Emma, and Gemma,

phoenixrosehere · 16/05/2023 09:01

aSofaNearYou · 16/05/2023 08:38

We see SIL 1-2 times a year - DS1’s name will be his for life.

That's the thing - it's sort of being treated by some on here like cousins are such close relations that it would be ridiculous to consider giving them the same names, sort of like they're siblings.

I think that's a reflection of how close some people are with their cousins, but it isn't the case for everyone. Even if they see each other once a month, which I'd say is fairly often, this isn't anywhere near as significant a portion of their life as the time they're not together. It's not a core relationship, or when where you'd expect to need to avoid people having the same name. It's more like a friendship.

That is why I said if she is really attached to the name, having a cousin with the same name might not be a strong enough reason not to use it. It will matter far more to her to use it, than it should matter to her OP and her DD for her to not use it so they don't have to be occasionally inconvenienced.

*That's the thing - it's sort of being treated by some on here like cousins are such close relations that it would be ridiculous to consider giving them the same names, sort of like they're siblings.

I think that's a reflection of how close some people are with their cousins, but it isn't the case for everyone. Even if they see each other once a month, which I'd say is fairly often, this isn't anywhere near as significant a portion of their life as the time they're not together. It's not a core relationship, or when where you'd expect to need to avoid people having the same name. It's more like a friendship.*

Yes. I said upthread I have two cousins with the same name, named after their fathers. They’re also less than a year apart and their name is common. No one batted an eye about it and both live in different areas. They see each other maybe 1-2 a year and we all know which one we’re referring to. There is no grand confusion on who is who nor is it difficult as some want to make it out to be.

CattytheFatty · 16/05/2023 08:57

And then she DID call him my son’s name. I think that’s really weird. It’s not a family name and it is fairly unusual. I just don’t get why anyone would do that.

Yes, given the amount of thought people give to choosing names, I’m a bit surprised that so many people insist this isn’t odd. I think a lot of posters would be more taken aback than they claim if their own brother or sister called a child the same name as one of theirs (without it being a traditional family name etc)

After something one poster said, I am actually wondering whether this has something to do with DD’s big personality, the wider family are always asking/talking about her so her name is mentioned more than the other dgc by my parents, for example. She isn’t objectively super talented/clever/beautiful or anything like that just a very sunny sort of child who is always picking up funny new hobbies or doing amusing things.

OP posts:
aSofaNearYou · 16/05/2023 08:38

We see SIL 1-2 times a year - DS1’s name will be his for life.

That's the thing - it's sort of being treated by some on here like cousins are such close relations that it would be ridiculous to consider giving them the same names, sort of like they're siblings.

I think that's a reflection of how close some people are with their cousins, but it isn't the case for everyone. Even if they see each other once a month, which I'd say is fairly often, this isn't anywhere near as significant a portion of their life as the time they're not together. It's not a core relationship, or when where you'd expect to need to avoid people having the same name. It's more like a friendship.

That is why I said if she is really attached to the name, having a cousin with the same name might not be a strong enough reason not to use it. It will matter far more to her to use it, than it should matter to her OP and her DD for her to not use it so they don't have to be occasionally inconvenienced.

mainsfed · 16/05/2023 06:24

Katherine1985 · 14/05/2023 16:18

Oh maybe I misunderstood something! I thought OPs husband and BIL were brothers

Not maybe, you did misunderstand.

TheOriginalEmu · 16/05/2023 03:53

pecantoucan · 14/05/2023 13:34

One of you is saying it wrong

No they aren’t. In parts of Scandinavia it’s pronounced hen-ree-et-uh. Essentially the same as the anglicised version.

TheOriginalEmu · 16/05/2023 03:42

Mischance · 15/05/2023 19:38

I think that if anyone takes offence at this there is probably some pre-existing aggro in family relationships anyway.

There was no pre-existing aggro between my cousin and I when she did it. It mostly bothered me because we had children in the same school during her pregnancy and we sat waiting one day chatting about things and I asked if she liked any names, she said ‘oh I like my sons name but obviously I wouldn’t call him that as you used it’ and I laughed and said ‘yes that would be weird!’ And then she DID call him my son’s name. I think that’s really weird. It’s not a family name and it is fairly unusual. I just don’t get why anyone would do that.

FUPAgirl · 15/05/2023 22:52

That would definitely make me secretly seethe op! A family member named their pet after my DC and it still gives me rage, I find it bizarre. Henrietta is a beautiful name too unusual for her to get away with using it in this situation. I totally get your annoyance!

Mischance · 15/05/2023 19:38

I think that if anyone takes offence at this there is probably some pre-existing aggro in family relationships anyway.

phoenixrosehere · 15/05/2023 18:04

BlueRedCat · 15/05/2023 14:10

@Mischance honestly I think how people feel about it depends on how people grew up and how names are viewed in the family. In my family and husbands there is commonality in middle names but each cousin always has had different names. Being given the same name as a cousin is weird to me as it basically tells them they aren’t special. It is annoying enough in a class to have the same name as another child but awful if going to stay with grandparents and having to be referred to as big Amy and little Amy. But that’s my take. I totally understand there are families where this is a non issue.

Being given the same name as a cousin is weird to me as it basically tells them they aren’t special.

I find this bizarre and sad. Many children will run into children with the same name at school and will likely see them more than their own cousins if they have a common or popular name.

I have cousins with the same name because they were named after their fathers and my DH has cousins who were named after their father, both of us from different English-speaking countries and it isn’t uncommon in either. Very few people thinks anyone less special because they have the same name as someone else.

Mischance · 15/05/2023 17:19

Being given the same name as a cousin is weird to me as it basically tells them they aren’t special. - well, as McEnroe would have said - "You can't be serious!" Do you really think that our dear Little X feels any less loved and special than Big X? It is actually rather sweet as, when they are together, they gravitate to each other and the big one totes the little one around and has a special bond with him.

FeelingwearyFeeelingsmall · 15/05/2023 15:08

This MN obsession with 'owning' names is crazy. In my (very large ) family children tend to be named after parents and grandparents so nearly every family unit has a child called Nicholas or Nicola, a Patrick or Patricia, Christopher or Christine etc. Sometimes there can be brief moments of confusion but no one has suffered an identity crisis or taken the wrong child home after a party.

SheilaFentiman · 15/05/2023 14:55

I was “middle Sheila” amongst my paternal second cousins, there’s also a “big Sheila” and a “little Shiela” We are only ever all in the same place for weddings, funerals and big birthdays so it never bothered me!

BlueRedCat · 15/05/2023 14:10

@Mischance honestly I think how people feel about it depends on how people grew up and how names are viewed in the family. In my family and husbands there is commonality in middle names but each cousin always has had different names. Being given the same name as a cousin is weird to me as it basically tells them they aren’t special. It is annoying enough in a class to have the same name as another child but awful if going to stay with grandparents and having to be referred to as big Amy and little Amy. But that’s my take. I totally understand there are families where this is a non issue.

Mischance · 15/05/2023 13:21

Crunchymum · 15/05/2023 12:52

Two of my 7 GC have the same name - no-one cares a jot. They all have better things to think about. We just call them Big X and Little X.

Whilst nobody owns a name, I do find this odd. I mean why?

We are a massive family (my 3 kids have 19 first cousins and counting) but I'd expect the question to be asked if I had decided to name one of mine the same name as an older cousin.

it doesn't have to be a big deal but I'd have fully expected my mum or MIL to ask my why I was picking the exact same name.

Why not? Both sets of parents loved the name - both had good reasons for choosing it. The first time it was chosen simply because they liked it; the second because it was a family name on the in-law side.

What difference does it make to anyone at all? These two children do not live in the same house (so no confusions), they do not live in the same area, they will grow up and settle somewhere miles apart no doubt. Even if they lived in the same street it does not matter a jot!

It is quite beyond me why anyone would take offence at this - it is a non-problem.

Crunchymum · 15/05/2023 12:52

Two of my 7 GC have the same name - no-one cares a jot. They all have better things to think about. We just call them Big X and Little X.

Whilst nobody owns a name, I do find this odd. I mean why?

We are a massive family (my 3 kids have 19 first cousins and counting) but I'd expect the question to be asked if I had decided to name one of mine the same name as an older cousin.

it doesn't have to be a big deal but I'd have fully expected my mum or MIL to ask my why I was picking the exact same name.

AccountantMum · 15/05/2023 12:50

I don't think you should care - I have a younger cousin with the same name different spelling Amy/Aimee and it would never cross my mind that my mum would be annoyed about it. Surely she can call here baby what ever she would like to.

It's fairly normal to have the same name within families and i'm sure she wouldn't have chosen her daughters name for any other reason than she likes the name, in fact her using the name shows she probably thinks a lot of you and your children as if she didn't it may have put her off.

If she has always wanted to use that name it's good she didn't feel like she had to change her mind because there was a similar name in the family already.

justpushingthrough · 15/05/2023 12:42

I find it odd to be honest.

If its an unusual name then it means even more so that they wanted to stand out a little but obvs this wont be the case as both cousins have the same name.

Incidentally this did slightly happen to me, we had a name picked out, DH cousin was also pregnant at the same time, we didnt know each others names and we didnt know what gender we were having.

She had her girl first and named her Ivy, which was thee name we wanted.

I had a girl 1 month later and picked another name which i love even more and so pleased shes called that, and not Ivy.

Sis in law should have picked another name.

chuichi · 15/05/2023 12:35

I'm on the fence here for this one - it is likely SIL had always wanted this name but due to them having issues with conceiving, you've had your DD first and therefore used the name first.

She is also likely to have wanted the exact same name as you've named your DD but now she's slightly renamed it by changing the 1 letter. So I think she's at least giving some respect and not using the exact same name.

Sure I'd be annoyed too :( but since SIL is insistent on using that name she has the absolute right to give her child that name :(

SheilaFentiman · 15/05/2023 12:03

…and there are no other Claire/Clares - it just wouldn’t stick!

SheilaFentiman · 15/05/2023 12:02

I‘m glad the thread has helped and you feel that you can move on.

FWIW about the spelling, I could never remember if my MIL was (let’s say) Claire or Clare and I had to check my address book every time I wrote her a card! Hopefully it’s a one off from your DPs.

Swipe left for the next trending thread