Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed about SIL stealing baby's name?

312 replies

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 10:42

My DB's wife is a complicated sort of person and they don't have a great relationship. They had several rounds of IVF over 8-10 years and finally had 2dds, the second born recently. They have given their second baby the same name as my youngest dc. Well, not the same name exactly, one letter is different (think Helena vs Helene).

My DD isn't too bothered about it, at first she thought it was a compliment but apparently, it wasn't! SIL just 'always wanted that name'! DB tried to discourage her but she was apparently adamant.

The baby is here now and very cute and we all love her, but I am secretly seething about the name. My DP are already getting the dc muddled and DM recently sent my DD a birthday card with her name spellt wrong - ie using the slightly different spelling of her cousin's name.

My DPs are elderly, happy and proud about all their DGC and just want a harmonious family life so they have changed the subject when I've grumbled about it. Because DB's relationship with SIL is so fraught already I obviously can't rock the boat by saying anything to SIL.

But AIBU to privately feel really annoyed? I just can't understand why someone would do this. There are so many names in the world! Surely some should be off-limits??

OP posts:
CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 11:06

WimpoleHat · 14/05/2023 11:01

Why shouldn't she have the name she's always wanted?

Because it’s not all about her and her alone. That child is born into a family and is part of that family and there are other things to consider. And the “but I’ve always wanted…..” line can get a bit silly, especially as there are (literally) thousands of other choices that you can make for a name. For example, I have a friend who always dreamed of having a little boy named William. But she then married a Mr Williamson and changed her name. And then stuck to her guns about the boy’s name….. Similarly, where there’s another child in the family with the same name, surely it’s just easier/nicer all round to pick something else? In the situation the OP describes, she’s narked and the grandparents are probably a big bewildered and/or on tenterhooks, desperately trying not to slip up. There are thousands of names; it just seems like unnecessary hard work.

Thanks @WimpoleHat that's basically exactly how I feel about it! At least someone understands 🙂

OP posts:
DarkForces · 14/05/2023 11:04

Because let's be honest, your db not having a day is not actually what you care about is it op? It's all about you

Saschka · 14/05/2023 11:04

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 11:03

If you think about this from a different angle, what you are basically saying is you are annoyed that she wasn't willing to give up naming her child what she had always wanted to, for the sake of not mildly inconveniencing your DD. I don't think it's a reasonable expectation.

Everyone seems to be ignoring the fact that she went against her own DH's wishes too, he literally had no say in his own dd's name?

But that’s between him and her, isn’t it? You can’t be pissy about what goes on in someone else’s marriage.

TheSnowyOwl · 14/05/2023 11:04

WimpoleHat · 14/05/2023 11:01

Why shouldn't she have the name she's always wanted?

Because it’s not all about her and her alone. That child is born into a family and is part of that family and there are other things to consider. And the “but I’ve always wanted…..” line can get a bit silly, especially as there are (literally) thousands of other choices that you can make for a name. For example, I have a friend who always dreamed of having a little boy named William. But she then married a Mr Williamson and changed her name. And then stuck to her guns about the boy’s name….. Similarly, where there’s another child in the family with the same name, surely it’s just easier/nicer all round to pick something else? In the situation the OP describes, she’s narked and the grandparents are probably a big bewildered and/or on tenterhooks, desperately trying not to slip up. There are thousands of names; it just seems like unnecessary hard work.

But that’s all just in your opinion and unless you are the one naming the child, your opinion doesn’t come into it.

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 11:03

aSofaNearYou · 14/05/2023 11:00

I agree with this.

If you think about this from a different angle, what you are basically saying is you are annoyed that she wasn't willing to give up naming her child what she had always wanted to, for the sake of not mildly inconveniencing your DD. I don't think it's a reasonable expectation.

Their child's name can be very important to people, far more than it should be to you.

If you think about this from a different angle, what you are basically saying is you are annoyed that she wasn't willing to give up naming her child what she had always wanted to, for the sake of not mildly inconveniencing your DD. I don't think it's a reasonable expectation.

Everyone seems to be ignoring the fact that she went against her own DH's wishes too, he literally had no say in his own dd's name?

OP posts:
JulieHoney · 14/05/2023 11:03

She didn’t steal a name, she chose one very similar to the name of your child who is 10 years older. They’ll be Big Hel and Lille Hel (or whatever)

Don’t sweat the small stuff. No one will get confused - I managed to have two uncle Petes and two cousins called Claire/Clare and never got muddled.

Landndialamrhf · 14/05/2023 11:02

Db didn’t fight hard enough or decided what she wanted was fine, so please don’t follow the old trope of poor old men who are just at the mercy of their wife’s whims, who had no say and therefore take no responsibility or blame in the couples decisions.
id say that trope alone is a massive reason so many women don’t like their in laws.

Yes you can be annoyed but she probably wanted the name for years. So you have to get over it.

you’re also blaming her because her in laws are failing to get the children’s names correct. That’s hardly her issue. I’m sure she’ll spell your child’s name fine.

WheelsUp · 14/05/2023 11:02

Unless your brother and SIL plan to use a nickname that is your DD's name eg their dd is Ella but they plan to call her El when your dd is Elle then Yabu
My SIL used my son's middle name as her son's first name and I found it strange that she'd ask as he's not the only person in the world with this name but maybe she would not have been happy if the situation was in reverse so she checked.

DarkForces · 14/05/2023 11:02

Her dh did not go through ivf in any comparable way to your sil. In the same way my dh fid not go through an ectopic pregnancy, operations, pregnancy and birth. I 100% chose dd's name. He got the surname after all.

Saschka · 14/05/2023 11:01

It’s annoying, but if this child is 9 years younger than yours, the cousins aren’t likely to be very close. Your DM may mix things up, but my DGM used to get me mixed up with my cousins too, and we have totally different names.

I’d assume she has ridiculously strong views on this particular name for whatever reason, and let it go.

Chispazo · 14/05/2023 11:01

I think it's weird @CattytheFatty happy for them that they had their children but two cousins with the same name, almost, it's confusing. And there is one set of grandparents with two grandchildren with almost the same name, bananas imo. I'm not British though, this idea that ''nobody owns a name'' doesn't sound right to me. I would not put grandparents in a situation where they had TWO grandchildren with the same name! and one aunt and one uncle with a niece and child with almost the same name. How can people say ''This doesn't matter at all''. Confused

Pinkdelight3 · 14/05/2023 11:01

But if she absolutely desperately had to have this name, why didn't she use it for her first dd?

Maybe cos it was so similar to yours and there was another name she also loved but when the second was a girl, this was the other name she wanted. You're desperate to make her unreasonable here, but you have to get over it. She did not 'steal' anything. It's not even the same name. Plus your DD is much older by the sounds of it and cousins often don't end up being very relevant in a person's life. Your parents misspelling a few cards is no big deal. They won't actually get your DDs mixed up as people.

WimpoleHat · 14/05/2023 11:01

Why shouldn't she have the name she's always wanted?

Because it’s not all about her and her alone. That child is born into a family and is part of that family and there are other things to consider. And the “but I’ve always wanted…..” line can get a bit silly, especially as there are (literally) thousands of other choices that you can make for a name. For example, I have a friend who always dreamed of having a little boy named William. But she then married a Mr Williamson and changed her name. And then stuck to her guns about the boy’s name….. Similarly, where there’s another child in the family with the same name, surely it’s just easier/nicer all round to pick something else? In the situation the OP describes, she’s narked and the grandparents are probably a big bewildered and/or on tenterhooks, desperately trying not to slip up. There are thousands of names; it just seems like unnecessary hard work.

EsmeSusanOgg · 14/05/2023 11:01

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 10:56

Honestly, I have had plenty of compassion, and have been very supportive over the years, but I still don't understand using the same name as a cousin. I don't think she would have named her dc the same name as one of her own siblings' dc - and my db was opposed to the choice but she went ahead anyway.

I'm not sure why IVF is a golden ticket for disregarding other people's feelings (including her own husband's, who after all, went through the IVF as well)

I should probably have used a better example than Helene/Helena because the actual name is much more unusual to the point of being rare

Totally understand OP.

If you want to be petty you could use a diminutive occasionally/ get your DP to for example Helly1 (your DD) and Helly2 (their DD).

HellYeahAurora · 14/05/2023 11:00

Nobody owns a name ti steal from anyone else.

MasterBeth · 14/05/2023 11:00

You feel what you feel, but your sister-in-law didn't steal your daughter's name. Your daughter still has it.

aSofaNearYou · 14/05/2023 11:00

SchoolShenanigans · 14/05/2023 10:55

What?!

She's always wanted that name, and probably, without the fertility issues, would have chosen it before you chose it for your child.

She was delayed having her children, through no fault of her own. Why shouldn't she have the name she's always wanted?

I really don't understand how it's got anything to do with you. YABU.

I agree with this.

If you think about this from a different angle, what you are basically saying is you are annoyed that she wasn't willing to give up naming her child what she had always wanted to, for the sake of not mildly inconveniencing your DD. I don't think it's a reasonable expectation.

Their child's name can be very important to people, far more than it should be to you.

JenniferBarkley · 14/05/2023 10:59

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 10:57

But if she absolutely desperately had to have this name, why didn't she use it for her first dd?

DC2 has a name I always loved but DH didn't like at all. Between dc1 and dc2 he came round to it, but it was never on the table for dc1.

Maybe she regretted not choosing it for dc1.

TheFairyCaravan · 14/05/2023 10:59

No one owns a name and it’s not worth getting riled about.

My cousin named her DS the exact same name as DS2 and his middle name is DH’s name. We give no shits. My gran, who was very elderly at the time, never once got confused between them. They always got the birthday card they were meant to get.

It simply does not matter. Your SIL has watched so many babies being born while being so very desperate for own. Now she’s got the chance to call her baby the name she’s always wanted to. Have a heart fgs.

BellaJuno · 14/05/2023 10:59

I can see why it irks you but given her fertility history, she possibly has an attachment to the name that is stronger than any awkwardness over its closeness to your DDs name. As your DD is older, everyone is going to know she chose the name knowing the similarity and you had named your DD first. Take it as a compliment to your excellent taste in names!!

TheSnowyOwl · 14/05/2023 10:58

I really don’t get the issue but I do see this comes up time and time again, so I appreciate there is something here that just doesn’t register with me.

It has historically been very normal for families to repeat the same names time and time again throughout the generations. If there is a name that you love so much that you named your child it, doesn’t it make sense that others will also love it (or a close variant) as much?

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 10:58

myrtleWilson · 14/05/2023 10:57

So there's an age gap of about 9/10 years between your DD2 and theirs?

Yes

OP posts:
CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 10:57

Pinkdelight3 · 14/05/2023 10:53

If I'd been through all that struggle to have DCs, I'd darned well call the baby the name I'd always wanted. And people do have names they'd always wanted to call their DC, some girls think about this when they're playing with dolls so it's hardly a mad concept to think she'd 'always' had it in mind, and thought about it even more when she was going through IVF.

But if she absolutely desperately had to have this name, why didn't she use it for her first dd?

OP posts:
myrtleWilson · 14/05/2023 10:57

So there's an age gap of about 9/10 years between your DD2 and theirs?

CattytheFatty · 14/05/2023 10:56

PipinwasAuntieMabelsdog · 14/05/2023 10:53

As an IVF mum, YABU. DSIL has been privately peeved devasted over the years about other people's children and she probably wanted to use the name she chose for years. Have some compassion @CattytheFatty

Honestly, I have had plenty of compassion, and have been very supportive over the years, but I still don't understand using the same name as a cousin. I don't think she would have named her dc the same name as one of her own siblings' dc - and my db was opposed to the choice but she went ahead anyway.

I'm not sure why IVF is a golden ticket for disregarding other people's feelings (including her own husband's, who after all, went through the IVF as well)

I should probably have used a better example than Helene/Helena because the actual name is much more unusual to the point of being rare

OP posts: