Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Made in Chelsea blokes - twins via surrogate

358 replies

HermioneKipper · 25/04/2023 19:39

More “celebs” commissioning a woman’s body to buy a baby.

When is this going to be made illegal 😡

And twins again. So many of them have twins. I think I get a bit triggered by this especially as I have twins and know how dangerous twin pregnancy can be for both mother and babies. And what it does to a woman’s body. No one could consent to this.

Had to switch off Giovanna Fletcher and her simpering podcast when they started talking about “their” miscarriages. Horrific amounts of bleeding, pain and horrendous wrenching emotional pain for you was it mates? No, didn’t think so.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ily0xx · 27/04/2023 17:59

LongAway · 27/04/2023 17:55

They harvest and fertilise then hold on ice many babies at once, Kim Kardashian and Paris Hilton spoke about it.

Yes and it’s still a horrendously invasive process if you can easily just have sex instead. And they’ve spoken publicly about their fertility issues.

LongAway · 27/04/2023 17:55

ily0xx · 27/04/2023 17:52

I really doubt it, you have to go through IVF which is much harder than having sex

They harvest and fertilise then hold on ice many babies at once, Kim Kardashian and Paris Hilton spoke about it.

ily0xx · 27/04/2023 17:52

SummerLovingDays · 27/04/2023 15:20

I only hope that Ayda Williams didn't use a surrogate for their last child because her and Robbie weren't having much sex.

Heterosexual or homosexual the whole surrogacy thing is deplorable.

I really doubt it, you have to go through IVF which is much harder than having sex

Gothambutnotahamster · 27/04/2023 17:50

Completely agree @Comby

LongAway · 27/04/2023 17:36

Comby · 27/04/2023 17:25

Surrogacy pieces always focus on the intended parents, occasionally on the surrogate and never on the baby. There are very few balanced pieces in the MSM. Everyone seems to forget laws changed because adoptees and donor-conceived children grew up and demanded legislation reflect their actual experiences, not the ones adults assumed they'd have.

Re alleged homophobia. I don't see how it's bigoted for anyone to worry that many of these children might well resent not only being deprived of a mother but being raised outside of a traditional set up. It's assumed, again, by adults that it'll make no difference to children. Read some 'modern' books to help them along and all will be well! I'm sorry, but that is naive beyond belief.

Us who worry about surrogacy are actually not preoccupied with the adults, including gay men and whether they can parent well (I'm sure they can), but what the child might want. It's their life FFS.

What's horrendous about it is it's a situation that never needed to arise. It's not like adoption where adults (usually) try to make the best of a bad situation for a child, this is a contract between adults, produce the child and exchange. That disturbs many people, it's not those Mumsnetters being Mumsnetty. Whenever MSM sites have the balls to leave comments unmoderated there's not a lot of gushing by the broader public either !

Due to the brain damage inflicted at birth and being brought up by narcs, I think you will have the Jazz Jennings type situation, where the abused child won't even realise.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4792594-jackie-green-reacts-to-kjk

Jackie Green reacts to KJK | Mumsnet

[[https://twitter.com/The_StateMedia/status/1650560961353248769 https://twitter.com/The_StateMedia/status/1650560961353248769]] Above is a clipped ve...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4792594-jackie-green-reacts-to-kjk

Comby · 27/04/2023 17:25

Surrogacy pieces always focus on the intended parents, occasionally on the surrogate and never on the baby. There are very few balanced pieces in the MSM. Everyone seems to forget laws changed because adoptees and donor-conceived children grew up and demanded legislation reflect their actual experiences, not the ones adults assumed they'd have.

Re alleged homophobia. I don't see how it's bigoted for anyone to worry that many of these children might well resent not only being deprived of a mother but being raised outside of a traditional set up. It's assumed, again, by adults that it'll make no difference to children. Read some 'modern' books to help them along and all will be well! I'm sorry, but that is naive beyond belief.

Us who worry about surrogacy are actually not preoccupied with the adults, including gay men and whether they can parent well (I'm sure they can), but what the child might want. It's their life FFS.

What's horrendous about it is it's a situation that never needed to arise. It's not like adoption where adults (usually) try to make the best of a bad situation for a child, this is a contract between adults, produce the child and exchange. That disturbs many people, it's not those Mumsnetters being Mumsnetty. Whenever MSM sites have the balls to leave comments unmoderated there's not a lot of gushing by the broader public either !

LongAway · 27/04/2023 15:54

The whole phobe thing is rediclious when it comes to surrogacy. I thought Sarah Jessica was as bad as Kim Kardashia (though there are rumours about Kanye) too.

All people think about are sob stories from people who aren't going to even make the best parents, as all they think about is themselves, who induce illness into newborn babies. They are users, they aren't nice people no matter how they manipulate people to justify it.

SummerLovingDays · 27/04/2023 15:20

I only hope that Ayda Williams didn't use a surrogate for their last child because her and Robbie weren't having much sex.

Heterosexual or homosexual the whole surrogacy thing is deplorable.

LongAway · 27/04/2023 15:10

Clymene · 27/04/2023 14:43

In U.K. law currently, a woman who gives birth to a child is its mother. We make no distinction if the genetic material that contributed to that child is hers or not. In fact, if you look at the conception boards here, women who use another women's eggs to conceive a child do not consider that woman to be the child's biological mother, they refer to her as the donor.

I find the way the language changes depending on whether the mother is going to keep the baby or not very interesting.

Poor children.

Accessories for for selfish narcs with sob stories, who think only of themselves.

00100001 · 27/04/2023 15:10

ChateauMargaux · 27/04/2023 14:00

Well yes, in my mind... but there was some discussion earlier on the thread over the titles, if the person gestating the child is not the egg provider..

Woman gestating*

Fixed it for you.

Clymene · 27/04/2023 14:43

In U.K. law currently, a woman who gives birth to a child is its mother. We make no distinction if the genetic material that contributed to that child is hers or not. In fact, if you look at the conception boards here, women who use another women's eggs to conceive a child do not consider that woman to be the child's biological mother, they refer to her as the donor.

I find the way the language changes depending on whether the mother is going to keep the baby or not very interesting.

HermioneKipper · 27/04/2023 14:06

ChateauMargaux · 27/04/2023 14:00

Well yes, in my mind... but there was some discussion earlier on the thread over the titles, if the person gestating the child is not the egg provider..

WOMAN not person gestating

Biological mother (egg donor) or Birth mother (pregnant mother) will do.

I do agree with all your other points

OP posts:
ChateauMargaux · 27/04/2023 14:00

Well yes, in my mind... but there was some discussion earlier on the thread over the titles, if the person gestating the child is not the egg provider..

HermioneKipper · 27/04/2023 13:54

ChateauMargaux · 27/04/2023 13:53

Echoing that it is not homophobic to say that taking a baby away from the woman who grew it in her uterus at the moment of birth is inflicting intentional trauma onto that child. There is a physiological connection between the birthing human and the child which results in neurological changes as part of the gestation and birth process, that is totally absent from any connection between the baby and the male human who provided the sperm, even though they will be genetically linked. There are other neurological links and developments that are made in the days and weeks after birth that does bond babies to their immediate care givers, so they will also bond with the intended parents but severing this link between birthing human and child, is trauma which will impact both the birthing human and the child. How they assimilate that trauma is dependant on many other factors and it may not be evident in the future, but it will be imprinted on them forever.

Birthing human?

you mean mother right?

OP posts:
ChateauMargaux · 27/04/2023 13:53

Echoing that it is not homophobic to say that taking a baby away from the woman who grew it in her uterus at the moment of birth is inflicting intentional trauma onto that child. There is a physiological connection between the birthing human and the child which results in neurological changes as part of the gestation and birth process, that is totally absent from any connection between the baby and the male human who provided the sperm, even though they will be genetically linked. There are other neurological links and developments that are made in the days and weeks after birth that does bond babies to their immediate care givers, so they will also bond with the intended parents but severing this link between birthing human and child, is trauma which will impact both the birthing human and the child. How they assimilate that trauma is dependant on many other factors and it may not be evident in the future, but it will be imprinted on them forever.

OutsideLookingOut · 27/04/2023 13:14

ComtesseDeSpair · 25/04/2023 20:57

How other people parent is up to them. Not everyone agrees that surrogacy is “ripping a baby away from its mother.” There will be aspects of your parenting which some other people would deem inadequate or abusive. If they believe that that’s the case, then they have the option to parent their children differently, just as you have the option not to use a surrogate if you dislike it and think it’s wrong.

The more time I spend on MN reading about all the fucked up situations people decide to have babies in, the more I realise quite how many people really aren’t equipped to be parents at all due to ill-health, neurodiversity, emotional immaturity, financial instability, shit relationships, or just their own sheer utter selfishness - except they’re fertile heterosexual people, so nobody can stop them doing what they want. Start there condemning those idiots, if you give a shit about the well-being of babies.

I may not be pro surrogacy (think there should be a lot of checks involved, just be from compassion rather than financial etc) but I completely agree with this.

inigomontoyahwillcox · 27/04/2023 13:10

It is categorically not homophobic to say that 2 gay people who are not biologically able to get pregnant and birth a child (AKA men) have the right to get a child by another means. Creating a child is not a right FFS.

Just like it isn't transphobic if the prospective parent was trans or ableist (for want of a better term) if they were suffering from infertility, etc.

Life is not fair - this perceived right for everything to be 100% hunky dory for you all of the time (and sod the consequences for anyone who may be harmed in the process), is utterly ridiculous, and the epitome of narcissism. Especially if this isn't down to an illness/condition but instead due to you not being in the 50% of the population that were built to produce and carry children (again, AKA men).

You don't NEED one of your own, you WANT one of your own. This may be an incredibly strong desire, but it doesn't automatically give you the right.

Full disclosure, I have secondary infertility, I have also supported a gay colleague's (successful) application to adopt by writing him a letter of recommendation.

HermioneKipper · 27/04/2023 12:57

ChateauMargaux · 27/04/2023 12:49

That article is harrowing... beautifully written but hard to read.

Nick said 'I need one of my own'...

WANT WANT WANT. All about what the adult wants.

not a passing thought to the babies and what they might want.

They won’t be able to contact their biological mother - the egg donor - because their new mother said no. They’ll know they were taken away from their birth mother immediately. She had no say in whether she could breastfeed - no thought about her feelings or what it might do to her body. (I was absolutely drowning in milk at a twin mum on day 3 and in pain with engorgement)

It was such a sad read. Especially her daughter wondering if she too would be given away 😢

OP posts:
ChateauMargaux · 27/04/2023 12:49

That article is harrowing... beautifully written but hard to read.

Nick said 'I need one of my own'...

HermioneKipper · 27/04/2023 12:47

Yes I’m no longer responding to people accusing me of being homophobic. I’m not and I know I’m not. I don’t care if you’re straight or gay, man or woman - surrogacy in all forms is wrong for ANYONE.

I’ve said many times and been disbelieved (!) that I’m friends with a gay couple who’ve adopted and I think it’s wonderful. Those children were in a horrible situation in the foster system and it’s fantastic that they are now much happier (albeit with huge issues to deal with) in a loving home.

I can also understand why people would rather use surrogates than adopt as adoption is extremely hard and often the child or children has a lot of trauma.

That doesn’t make it ok to exploit a woman’s body to get what you want - essential buying a baby. I disagree with it fundamentally. And that comes from a place of wanting to protect women and their bodies from people who would use them for their own gain.

OP posts:
Comby · 27/04/2023 12:35

For those accusing everyone of homophobia, why don't you search the bloody archive for past surrogacy threads involving straight couples - you'll discover the exact same arguments against surrogacy being made. Sophie Beresiner (straight married woman) was particularly loathed.

Clymene · 27/04/2023 12:27

Woah, that article Sad

Clymene · 27/04/2023 12:17

It's nothing to do with MN not having nuance @OriginalUsername2, it's about a targeted attempt to reframe disquiet about surrogacy as homophobia.

HermioneKipper · 27/04/2023 12:09

drspouse · 27/04/2023 09:46

Can you not see any problems with doing this for a family member, even if it's started with the best intentions?
This story only goes up to the birth, and already the mother was finding her family members were too intrusive, her daughter was anxious about being given away. What happens when the family all meets up and the twins ask her how she could give them away? When she disagrees with how the children are being raised? Normally you'd expect to get parenting advice (sometimes actually helpful) from family members who have children, this makes the whole relationship completely unnatural.
What if the twins want to live with her when they are older? This is very common for adoptive children.

https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2013/apr/27/secret-diary-of-a-surrogate-mother

I found this article chilling

OP posts:
OriginalUsername2 · 27/04/2023 11:05

Jazsimone · 25/04/2023 20:55

@HermioneKipper

"I’m not homophobic at all. I know two gay couples that have adopted and think it’s wonderful."

The classic "I have a gay friend" COURSE YOU DO.

God there is no room for nuance on mumsnet is there.