Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The fight back against OFSTED has begun - support needed

342 replies

wantmorenow · 20/03/2023 12:51

Just saw this and it seems genuine and if so then bloody marvellous. Let's hope this is the rallying call to changes with immediate effect. This has been posted today. A Headteacher has refused access to Ofsted tomorrow, I assume in the wake of the coverage of Ruth Perry's death.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4765105-ofsted-needs-to-be-abolished-trigger-warning?page=1

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4765712-ofsted-needs-to-be-abolished-further-details

twitter.com/FloraSCooper/status/1637760884243066881

I've just had the call.
I've refused entry.
This is an interesting phone call.
Doing this for everyone for our school staff everywhere!

School asking for support in person tomorrow 8am if local.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
WarriorN · 21/03/2023 10:27

Unfortunately yes - but we've had all that drilled into us. (We even go through phases of have weekly quizzes- eg where is xyz policy? Who is in charge of xyz? What do you do if xyz happens?) A very involved LEA. Schools can't do this on their own.

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 10:23

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 10:22

@Lovelyveg82 the reports are very short now. I'm appalled at the lack of info on the latests ones. Ours is rubbish compared to the feedback we had and tells parents nothing. They aren't allowed to use certain phrases for example.

You may be thinking of reports from some time ago.

My point is safeguarding is the foundation that underpins everything else.

Indeed

so correct a school should receive a very poor rating for being remiss with none other than DBS checks

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 10:22

@Lovelyveg82 the reports are very short now. I'm appalled at the lack of info on the latests ones. Ours is rubbish compared to the feedback we had and tells parents nothing. They aren't allowed to use certain phrases for example.

You may be thinking of reports from some time ago.

My point is safeguarding is the foundation that underpins everything else.

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 10:21

Swiftbushome · 21/03/2023 10:12

Also however tragic it is that the HT took her own life (and it absolutely IS tragic) it is correct that ofsted should have a duty to automatically "fail" a school where something as basic as DBS vetting hasn't been done correctly?
I would have to be DBS vetted to be allowed to help out for a day camp at my DC cubs group. As is correct.
The thought of my children being in a school with adults who have not been correctly background checked is chilling.

Absolutely

And it is indicative of so much more if the school is remiss with something so important

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 10:20

Slam my experience of recent Ofsted 'looming' was that from the outset of the previous one, safeguarding was embedded (as it should) in the whole school with the support of the LA.

It's all part of a multi service operation but at the same time, with Ofsted specifically focussing on staff understanding of safeguarding (they throw key questions into interviews with staff) it makes schools make sure that the whole picture is focussed on at all times.

There are some basic things linked to safeguarding that a school will be instantly failed on if Ofsted see them. Years ago we were told they must be able to phone to school for the first contact and get through to someone for example. Because it could be a parent or an emergency call.

My point is that it's central the whole picture of a school.

However, that includes the safety of staff and the head.

That school and head teacher were failed by others, as well as Ofsted . As, as you say, schools aren't islands managing themselves.

Swiftbushome · 21/03/2023 10:12

Also however tragic it is that the HT took her own life (and it absolutely IS tragic) it is correct that ofsted should have a duty to automatically "fail" a school where something as basic as DBS vetting hasn't been done correctly?
I would have to be DBS vetted to be allowed to help out for a day camp at my DC cubs group. As is correct.
The thought of my children being in a school with adults who have not been correctly background checked is chilling.

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 09:56

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 09:48

In fact, if you read back on this thread and others, most are saying schools should be inspected for safeguarding - the most important thing - more often

This with bells on.

And I don't like the labour idea of divorcing Ofsted from safeguarding; it should be embedded in the curriculum.

I do like their idea of getting rid of gradings, this has happened for teacher observations.

Safeguarding…. Absolutely

but as a parent…. I would like to know a damn sight more than simply ofsted thinks my child is safe.

I find the reports very useful

slamfightbrightlight · 21/03/2023 09:54

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 07:36

As much as I think Ofsted as a whole is not fit for purpose, it's the only flimsy thing we currently have, bar whistleblowers, to raise concerns about safeguarding in schools.

Not quite but the other methods aren’t well publicised. LAs will routinely (weekly where I am) meet to share information about schools and there is a “schools causing concern” process. Local safeguarding partnerships carry out s11 and s157/175 audits of local schools to assess their safeguarding arrangements (though level of scrutiny of schools’ self-assessments may vary). But whether the average parent would know to raise any concerns to the LA or whether LAs have the capacity to act is a different question.

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 09:48

In fact, if you read back on this thread and others, most are saying schools should be inspected for safeguarding - the most important thing - more often

This with bells on.

And I don't like the labour idea of divorcing Ofsted from safeguarding; it should be embedded in the curriculum.

I do like their idea of getting rid of gradings, this has happened for teacher observations.

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 09:46

Schools have no choice but to have the 'disruptive' children in education. SEND children are not supported by this government.

Write to your MP. Don't vote Tory.

There's been a huge rise in children with ehcps but not in SEND school places. This has been going on for the last 10 years. The bbc recently reported that a significant factor is that medical technology for difficult and premature births or other health conditions has improved life expectancy which is of course fantastic.

But many of these children also need specialist schools. The government will / should have known this but have done nothing.

They've also simultaneously cut school budgets drastically.

We've seen our cohorts move from 'moderate learning difficulties' to 'severe learning difficulties.' We aren't actually as well set up as local SLD schools though we try our best. The children we should have are in mainstream as a result of lack of appropriate spaces.

They've dismantled LEAs and privatised cpd training- complete hotch potch of unregulated education companies.

We've waited for 2.5 years past what we expected for Ofsted visiting; we are SEND and that's not good enough for the children or our mental health. Luckily we still have an LEA in action (more than many areas) who are supportive to local schools, including around support for Ofsted. (I queried this and an slt member who's also Ofsted inspector confirmed we are unusual.) But it's not the same elsewhere.

All of this, Ruth's tragic death included was avoidable.

RuleWithAWoodenFoot · 21/03/2023 09:20

Cyclebabble · 21/03/2023 08:37

As a child I remember a time pre Ofsted. In my school the standards were appallingly low, girls were subject to routine abuse by teachers (physical and sexual) and with no supervision local schools were able to carry on just as they pleased. IMV inspection is important. Happy for there to be reformed, but all of the rest of us are subject to routine appraisals, inspections and audits far more frequently. it is stressful, but is routine in any job.

Again for the hard of hearing at the back, no one, no teachers, are saying that schools shouldn't be inspected. In fact, if you read back on this thread and others, most are saying schools should be inspected for safeguarding - the most important thing - more often.

On issues like curriculum and teaching/learning changes, you can't effect meaningful change in a year, so 3 - 4 yearly is a good timeframe for Ofsted. No one in schools has issue with the next day warnings either.

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 08:54

it is stressful, but is routine in any job.

in the private sector we expect very short notice financial audits. Stressful! But the idea of the CEO stopping access is so laughably ridiculous.

I have enormous respect for teachers. But there is a very real sense that some teachers think they should just be “allowed to get on with it”

And that is just not on!

Cyclebabble · 21/03/2023 08:37

As a child I remember a time pre Ofsted. In my school the standards were appallingly low, girls were subject to routine abuse by teachers (physical and sexual) and with no supervision local schools were able to carry on just as they pleased. IMV inspection is important. Happy for there to be reformed, but all of the rest of us are subject to routine appraisals, inspections and audits far more frequently. it is stressful, but is routine in any job.

AdaLane · 21/03/2023 08:36

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 20/03/2023 20:14

This isn’t true. An inadequate rating means forced academisation. It happened to our school in very similar circumstances. Whole process took a year during which they couldn’t hire a permanent head, couldn’t permanently replace leaving teachers as we were between management, and pupils left in droves due to the uncertainty of what was going on. We are now an academy, everything is much the same as before (because there wasn’t much wrong in the first place), but ofsted won’t now come back for another 4 years, because we’re technically a new school. How this is a good outcome beats me.

And only if an academy trust will sponsor the school. Academy trusts ‘cherry pick’, of course, in the main, they don't want financially unstable schools, those with poor perception, unstable staffing, often in high disadvantage communities. Small rural schools also find it really hard to find academy sponsors.
Academies know the effort, skill and cost required to take on these schools - and make them good again, the pressure involved - so don't.

LA’s continue to maintain the school and support it to move forward, but there is a huge risk, of closure for such schools.

RuleWithAWoodenFoot · 21/03/2023 07:58

@Barbecuebeans

All of those things. I would add to this extremely poor discipline in some schools, where the school bends over backwards to keep the disruptive children in education, while throwing all the other children's education under the bus.

The poor access to support for children who are struggling, either with their mental health or academically.

Schools have no choice but to have the 'disruptive' children in education. SEND children are not supported by this government.

Write to your MP. Don't vote Tory.

Barbecuebeans · 21/03/2023 07:36

I do think there needs to be some oversight by an overarching body: my child's school only got rid of a terrible HT because of a poor Ofsted report. But I agree it shouldn't be a one off inspection body, it should be much more balanced with a supportive element to help schools improve.

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 07:36

As much as I think Ofsted as a whole is not fit for purpose, it's the only flimsy thing we currently have, bar whistleblowers, to raise concerns about safeguarding in schools.

Barbecuebeans · 21/03/2023 07:33

SerafinasGoose · 20/03/2023 13:20

If there is a rising atmosphere of anarchy in UK schools - always taking into account the sensationalism of media reporting - it's not to be wondered at.

Draconian, sexist, anachronistic uniform policy which no one on the continent or in the US appears to need. Humiliating female students by the measuring of skirt lengths. Policing ridiculously petty details like the colour of stitching on shoes. I'm at a loss to see how this either enforces discipline (it doesn't, given the laissez faire attitude of schools to far more serious issues), or improves the quality of education.

Serious safeguarding issues surrounding girls' toileting areas, already having resulted in serious injury to a girl only last week. The extent of this problem is leading to protests by kids because the adults responsible for them will not protect them.

Bullying - of both staff and students - is rife. Victims are being excluded as they present too much of a problem, whilst the perpetrators know they can act with impunity.

The system firing off a snotty letter because your Year 4 sick kid's been absent one day in the autumn term. This for a child with an impeccable attendance record leading up to that date - no requested holidays and only one other sickness absence in that time - and who has never once, since the first day of Reception, been late.

A profession that can't keep its staff and are currently striking because conditions are intolerable.

A life ruled by metrics rather than teaching real subjects to real people.

Terrible methods of literacy and numeracy teaching. Phonics is dreadful, a whole teaching system based on the tiny Clackmannanshire study with a small population sample to determine the demographics being failed by then-current literacy teaching. A kneejerk report based on those inconclusive findings and voila! The same demographic is being failed by this system of teaching to the one being used before.

Numeracy levels woeful. The far east are doing something right whilst we are going very wrong.

Now an Ofsted lockout.

This is the result of Tory policy and a succession of inept, clueless education ministers, the worst of which we hadn't seen until Michael Gove. Teaching is a profession in crisis.

All of those things. I would add to this extremely poor discipline in some schools, where the school bends over backwards to keep the disruptive children in education, while throwing all the other children's education under the bus.

The poor access to support for children who are struggling, either with their mental health or academically.

GettingThereCharleyBear · 21/03/2023 07:27

@fairywhale what was evil?

Her family and friends have said it was very much the OFSTED - I have friends who are HTs who are on the edge of burnout due to the constant pressure of the inspection so can totally see how this would tip someone over. Please don’t minimise it.

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 07:23

I need to catch up on the whole thread.

I was devastated by the death of this poor woman. I can actually imagine exactly what she went through as a teacher of 21 years, who's had burn out several times and mh issues due to the pressure and demands of education.

I however I have to say that, given what I know of the process and how safeguarding is the heart of an inspection, I thought this was a foolish move.

The education system is an absolute mess and Ofsted are too. But I don't believe this was the correct cause of action.

I used the Ofsted teacher survey to completely destroy the Tory government who I saw as having put schools, heads and Slts in ridiculous positions through their privatisation of educational resources, which mean that slts are forced to put unreasonable pressure on teachers and creating horrific work loads.

Schools shouldn't be left for 12 years without inspection. That's a major safeguarding fail on Ofsted. They are absolutely culpable in this case as are the government too.

Zonder · 21/03/2023 07:23

Anything could have tipped that person over the edge. People take their own life for various reasons all the time, including for failing in their jobs, relationships and so on.

Nick Robinson talking about this right now on radio 4. Her family said she was under terrible pressure and was badly criticized in the inspection. So they definitely think it was because of Ofsted.

Zonder · 21/03/2023 07:18

Ofsted reports are far from perfect and are usually too lenient and lax and miss quite a few red things but do make schools more accountable.

Not sure they make schools accountable for the important stuff. And is it accountability or support and encouragement that works best?

fairywhale · 21/03/2023 07:14

Of course they took an issue with "flossing" - it is indeed sexualised. Fortnite isn't suitable for under 13s, it's rated Teen. And the other inappropropriate play they picked up on, they were correct in doing so - if it looked like peer on peer abuse, it probably was. What happens in the school when the ofsted inspectors aren't there is probably much worse.
How perverse to be defending this behaviour in young kids. Those campaigns are started ptobably by those who are happy to make violent sexualised games and the weird dolls in suspenders and g-strings available to kids.
The school has 12% more boys than girls on roll, wonder why that is.

crisscross101 · 21/03/2023 07:13

Well if this was round 1, Ofsted won. Confused

LlynTegid · 21/03/2023 07:10

I agree with assessment and inspection, just think it needs to change. One or two words cannot describe a school, as an Ofsted rating does.

Swipe left for the next trending thread