Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The fight back against OFSTED has begun - support needed

342 replies

wantmorenow · 20/03/2023 12:51

Just saw this and it seems genuine and if so then bloody marvellous. Let's hope this is the rallying call to changes with immediate effect. This has been posted today. A Headteacher has refused access to Ofsted tomorrow, I assume in the wake of the coverage of Ruth Perry's death.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4765105-ofsted-needs-to-be-abolished-trigger-warning?page=1

www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4765712-ofsted-needs-to-be-abolished-further-details

twitter.com/FloraSCooper/status/1637760884243066881

I've just had the call.
I've refused entry.
This is an interesting phone call.
Doing this for everyone for our school staff everywhere!

School asking for support in person tomorrow 8am if local.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
MarshaMelrose · 22/03/2023 17:46

How did the fightback go?

Lovelyveg80 · 22/03/2023 16:09

an inadequate brought about by a date missed off a completed action for instance. I have seen this.
This is half the story.

the key is what the action was. And if there was no documented date and no evidence to prove when the action had been completed… quite possibly a safe guarding risk had been ongoing for an unacceptable amount of time.

Lovelyveg80 · 22/03/2023 16:06

@RuleWithAWoodenFoot

s, you can't effect meaningful change in a year,

seriously? I can’t tell you how this would go down in any private enterprise whatsoever.

a year is sufficient to make meaningful change and if a school gets a RI or poor rating then to wait 3/4 years to make meaningful change is bloody unfair to the current kids.

any RI school that blanches at making meaningful change in a year is…. Shit

Fairislefandango · 22/03/2023 15:58

So teachers/leaders/union come up with something better then.

You honestly think the government would be remotely interested in listening?

AdaLane · 22/03/2023 15:17

Logicoutofthewindow · 22/03/2023 09:59

@AdaLane Perhaps this answers why safeguarding concerns should mean a failed Ofsted.

@LogicoutofthewindowI would argue that the LA’s annual safeguarding visit, looking at all of the evidence that Ofsted check, is more rigorous as it is a full day with only a safeguarding focus, not all aspects over two days.

Visits include meetings with staff to test out knowledge, tracking through CP records (anonymised), safer recruitment, H&S actions, drills, meeting with pupils to gain their view, meeting with the DSL, DDSL, CoGovernors and governor accountable for safeguarding - all separate to triangulate the information they provide. We check behaviour logs, staff and governor training logs, test out how up to date school safeguarding is....etc etc.
In addition, the LA HR team carry out a check of schools SCR and leave school leaders with actions to complete. This checks not just compliance but also the culture. It includes the curriculum, to test out and support developments so that we know how well children are taught to keep themselves safe.

I know safeguarding is vital. I think there is, though, a difference between a culture of where children are not safe and must be improved and an inadequate brought about by a date missed off a completed action for instance. I have seen this.

On the positive I have also seen where a more sensible approach from an inspector who was confident that school culture of safeguarding was strong and the missed date was put down to an administration task.

I know that this isn't all LA’s, I know it is inconsistent across academy trusts. I know this is severely limited in some LA’s due to central government funding cuts. Safeguarding does, however, remain a legal statutory duty of the LA, with the Director of Childrens Services, ultimately responsible.

blackpearwhitelilies · 22/03/2023 11:10

Cyclebabble · 22/03/2023 10:00

But you are looking to control the types of review you are subject to. Reform is one thing but what comes out needs to be a strong robust process that parents can rely on and which is not overly influenced by teachers and their unions.

An effective review process should be one that is shaped by both reviewer and reviewee. In my line of work reviewees are consulted when the review process is updated or overhauled. A much more productive outcome is likely if there is effective dialogues and buy-in throughout the process.

Cyclebabble · 22/03/2023 10:00

RuleWithAWoodenFoot · 21/03/2023 09:20

Again for the hard of hearing at the back, no one, no teachers, are saying that schools shouldn't be inspected. In fact, if you read back on this thread and others, most are saying schools should be inspected for safeguarding - the most important thing - more often.

On issues like curriculum and teaching/learning changes, you can't effect meaningful change in a year, so 3 - 4 yearly is a good timeframe for Ofsted. No one in schools has issue with the next day warnings either.

But you are looking to control the types of review you are subject to. Reform is one thing but what comes out needs to be a strong robust process that parents can rely on and which is not overly influenced by teachers and their unions.

Logicoutofthewindow · 22/03/2023 09:59

WarriorN · 22/03/2023 08:29

Yes.

That's been drummed into me during 20 odd years of teaching.

And the LA can be doing all sorts of safeguarding things on the coal face for children safeguarding wise but they don't inspect school procedures in the way Ofsted do. It's part ot Ofsted to make sure safer recruitment and safeguarding is as water tight as current knowledge and guidance can make it.

Labour want a separate, more regular, safeguarding inspection, and certainly leaving a school un inspected for over a decade is a safeguarding fail on Ofsted's part. But I feel strongly that it should be part and parcel of the school inspection to embed practice.

@AdaLane Perhaps this answers why safeguarding concerns should mean a failed Ofsted.

WarriorN · 22/03/2023 08:29

Yes.

That's been drummed into me during 20 odd years of teaching.

And the LA can be doing all sorts of safeguarding things on the coal face for children safeguarding wise but they don't inspect school procedures in the way Ofsted do. It's part ot Ofsted to make sure safer recruitment and safeguarding is as water tight as current knowledge and guidance can make it.

Labour want a separate, more regular, safeguarding inspection, and certainly leaving a school un inspected for over a decade is a safeguarding fail on Ofsted's part. But I feel strongly that it should be part and parcel of the school inspection to embed practice.

Lovelyveg80 · 22/03/2023 06:02

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 19:06

I don't know much about the case at all to comment.

I've always understood that a safeguarding fail / weak procedures equates to inadequate no matter the quality of teaching and learning.

And so it should

Gilmorehill · 21/03/2023 21:38

Fairislefandango · 21/03/2023 16:31

So sick and tired of non-teachers assuming that when teachers criticise Ofsted we mean that there shouldn't be any appraisal or accountability (because teachers are lazy and don't want to be made to do our job properly, unlike people in proper jobs 'in the real world' obviously Hmm).

Me too.

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 19:06

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 15:09

And I stand by my opinion that a school that is lax on the legal checks re someone having unsupervised access to a child, is extremely concerning and serious and warrants a poor rating.

I also would suggest it indicates a general lax attitude to safeguarding if something so important was neglected

I don't know much about the case at all to comment.

I've always understood that a safeguarding fail / weak procedures equates to inadequate no matter the quality of teaching and learning.

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 18:56

The school has 12% more boys than girls on roll, wonder why that is.

My son's year is 40 boys, 20 girls.

WarriorN · 21/03/2023 18:54

https://www.edapt.org.uk/support/knowledge-base/can-teachers-boycott-ofsted/

>>>What are the implications for a headteacher who refuses to comply with an inspection?

In addition to the potential criminal offence mentioned above, headteachers should also consider the employment consequences of their decision. Whilst individual contracts can vary, it is likely that refusal of this sort could be deemed to be a breach of contract with their employer as it is likely that any contract would have an implied term to support any Ofsted process. This is particularly relevant given the safeguarding responsibilities and processes that Ofsted routinely inspect.
It is also possible that such conduct could be deemed to constitute ‘gross misconduct’ which could lead to suspension or dismissal. The fact that the act is also a criminal offence adds weight to the likelihood of this meeting a threshold for gross misconduct.
If the headteacher were to be instructed by the appropriate body e.g. School Governors, to comply but refused this instruction, this may also be grounds for disciplinary action.
Headteachers should also be wary of publicly declaring any intentions on social media etc around refusal to comply with Ofsted. This could lead to an argument being made that this could bring the school or employer into disrepute. <<<<<

AdaLane · 21/03/2023 18:30

It isn't as if there are no checks though. Especially where LA’s are still strongly in place supporting schools, @Logicoutofthewindow.

I posted this on another similar thread.

‘We have.

Safeguarding advisors in the LA, who support and train staff.
Education advisors also carrying out annual safeguarding visits, support to improve and follow up of actions.
Education advisers who carry out investigations flagged up through Ofsted complaints.

The Safeguarding Children Board, has an annual audit to be completed and monitored by governors and leaders and returned. The Safeguarding Board conduct a visit to check out the audit in a random selection of schools.

Of course, much of the above is carried out only in LA’s who still have advisers. Much of the school improvement funding from central government has been diverted away from LA’s.

Academies are responsible for most of the above themselves too.

In our maintained LA schools it isn't as if OFSTED is the only check to keep children safe.’

Abraxan · 21/03/2023 17:32

So how about teachers come up with a workable alternative then instead of the head teacher of a school posting she would 'not let Ofsted in' and random Twitter posts about protests outside the school etc. I mean seriously, she needs to step back and think (about more than her strange Twitter posts).

So teachers/leaders/union come up with something better then. However, schools do need to be held accountable. Safeguarding is paramount and a school that doesn't safeguard should fail (Ian Huntley types will prey on children if not checked).

Many have tried, numerous times.
They are ignored.
The government isn't interested in listening to what schools think would actually be useful and helpful.

saraclara · 21/03/2023 17:24

Logicoutofthewindow · 21/03/2023 16:38

So how about teachers come up with a workable alternative then instead of the head teacher of a school posting she would 'not let Ofsted in' and random Twitter posts about protests outside the school etc. I mean seriously, she needs to step back and think (about more than her strange Twitter posts).

So teachers/leaders/union come up with something better then. However, schools do need to be held accountable. Safeguarding is paramount and a school that doesn't safeguard should fail (Ian Huntley types will prey on children if not checked).

They have. Many times. The government has ignored those suggestions.

Abraxan · 21/03/2023 17:24

The school has 12% more boys than girls on roll, wonder why that is.

Could be huge number of reasons, usually down to birth rates in different years.

Local school has a larger ratio of boys than girls. Simply more boys born in the catchment area than girls. It's an oversubscribed highly thought of school.

So I really wouldn't think the ratio is to do with parents of girls refusing to send their children there.

Logicoutofthewindow · 21/03/2023 16:40

Fairislefandango · 21/03/2023 16:21

Schools do need monitoring. We have a couple of local secondary schools that have underperformed for several years now. Some of the primaries are outstanding and so oversubscribed.

But what makes you think that the inadequate schools are the ones that get rated inadequate by Ofsted and the outstanding ones are the ones that get rated outstanding? That's certainly not been my experience. The system only works if Ofsted are looking for the right things (you know - the things that actually benefit children) and if they are nationally consistent at finding them. Neither of which is the case, from what I can see.

The 2 local schools that are rated inadequate are also described by parents as awful. The head of one left after a few months stating it was a lost cause and the teaching staff didn't want change. Can only speak of these locally but parents are aware and unhappy at how poor they are. Our children deserve better than that.

Logicoutofthewindow · 21/03/2023 16:38

Fairislefandango · 21/03/2023 16:31

So sick and tired of non-teachers assuming that when teachers criticise Ofsted we mean that there shouldn't be any appraisal or accountability (because teachers are lazy and don't want to be made to do our job properly, unlike people in proper jobs 'in the real world' obviously Hmm).

So how about teachers come up with a workable alternative then instead of the head teacher of a school posting she would 'not let Ofsted in' and random Twitter posts about protests outside the school etc. I mean seriously, she needs to step back and think (about more than her strange Twitter posts).

So teachers/leaders/union come up with something better then. However, schools do need to be held accountable. Safeguarding is paramount and a school that doesn't safeguard should fail (Ian Huntley types will prey on children if not checked).

Fairislefandango · 21/03/2023 16:31

So sick and tired of non-teachers assuming that when teachers criticise Ofsted we mean that there shouldn't be any appraisal or accountability (because teachers are lazy and don't want to be made to do our job properly, unlike people in proper jobs 'in the real world' obviously Hmm).

Fairislefandango · 21/03/2023 16:21

Schools do need monitoring. We have a couple of local secondary schools that have underperformed for several years now. Some of the primaries are outstanding and so oversubscribed.

But what makes you think that the inadequate schools are the ones that get rated inadequate by Ofsted and the outstanding ones are the ones that get rated outstanding? That's certainly not been my experience. The system only works if Ofsted are looking for the right things (you know - the things that actually benefit children) and if they are nationally consistent at finding them. Neither of which is the case, from what I can see.

Logicoutofthewindow · 21/03/2023 16:15

Lovelyveg82 · 21/03/2023 14:22

The very notion that a school would hire a foreigner and not do the appropriate checks, even if that does mean delay, will be indicative of a general laissez faire attitude to safeguarding.

and goodness knows what else.

Indeed. If this is true then it should fail.

Logicoutofthewindow · 21/03/2023 16:13

Schools do need monitoring. We have a couple of local secondary schools that have underperformed for several years now. Some of the primaries are outstanding and so oversubscribed.

What ways would you have schools being held to account @wantmorenow ? The vast majority of us in lots of occupations are held to account for our work standards, it's common practice.

Perhaps it's an individual thing rather than blame OFSTED for her suicide. Many schools face a drop in standards but few would deem it worth taking a life for. Things can be turned around.

User8646382 · 21/03/2023 15:36

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 21/03/2023 15:05

It was in The Times. And you’re right, I’m sorry, it wasn’t a visitor. It was a parent helping a child with reading, but I’ve just double checked the article and they were indeed helping in an ‘employed’ capacity, my mistake.

”an incident in which a parent was employed at the school to help a child who was struggling with English. She says the parent had been checked through the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS) but a separate check on police records from the parent’s country of birth could not be made, and the school did not do a further risk assessment.”

I stand by my opinion that that doesn’t mean the whole school deserves an inadequate rating regardless of everything else about it that was good.

They could have got round the problem by doing a risk assessment stating that the child would not be left alone at any point with the unvetted parent. That wouldn’t have been great, but they would probably have got away with it without being downgraded.