Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Depression denial, trauma caused by parent

33 replies

Lostwifehelp · 15/02/2023 09:22

My husband is going through depression (I think) except he doesn’t think it’s depression and thinks he’s fundamentally changed as a person after certain realisations about his childhood. As a result he’s unwilling to seek help (therapy or medication).

His trauma is related to an aspect of his religious upbringing. His mother has apologised for it but continues to be part off a religious cult. This is unacceptable to him because this shows to him that she hasn’t really understood and her apology is hollow. I think it’s impossible to change her religious views. He thinks once he has completely messed up his life she might realise how bad her religious cult is. Why he needs that I don’t understand. He’s obviously deeply hurt.

I love him and want to help him but I feel completely lost. He thinks only he knows how to deal with this and nobody else can understand what he’s going through, so I’m being unreasonable by asking him to try to fix it through therapy or medication.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Lostwifehelp · 17/02/2023 08:30

@Starseeed I do believe things can get better but it’s so so difficult hard battling his sense of hopelessness. He keeps saying he knows himself and therapy can’t help him. He seems to prefer the idea of moving out so we can all be better off without him.

@Chrimbob Yes I agree I just can’t convince him that he has to find healing himself. It’s really frustrating but I do also sometimes wonder what kind of mother sees her child in pain and refuses to acknowledge that the thing that has caused her child pain is wrong?

OP posts:
Starseeed · 16/02/2023 12:54

Btw Waking the Tiger by Dr Peter Levine might be another good book to look up. There’s a fantastic hopeful quote in there that is very true:

“I have come to the conclusion that human beings are born with an innate capacity to triumph over trauma. I believe not only that trauma is curable, but that the healing process can be a catalyst for profound awakening—a portal opening to emotional and genuine spiritual transformation.”

Chrimbob · 16/02/2023 12:51

It sounds like he's saying unless his mother says/does x, nothing can change. But she won't ever do this. So then nothing will change for him. He's putting the responsibility for his wellbeing in someone else's hands and unfortunately she's never going to be/dp what he feels he needs. He needs to take responsibility for himself or he's going to be stuck.

Starseeed · 16/02/2023 12:50

Glad it was helpful. Things absolutely can get better - I’m proof! Therapy - any journey to healing - can often make things feel worse initially because it means facing all the horrible feelings you’ve been avoiding and sorting through them before things start to feel better. But it really is the best process ever when you begin to learn that feelings aren’t terrible and to find some agency again. It can take some convincing to get there though - that’s the tricky bit, learning to trust the process.

Lostwifehelp · 16/02/2023 12:45

@Starseeed
Thanks so much, that’s super helpful. Good point about medication suppressing things. I think the anger has already become depression. I’ve come to realise through the contributions here that he still needs more time to process these feelings and is no where near the acceptance stage yet. I’ll try to help him by being there to listen, but obviously I’m not qualified so ideally he will agree to seek therapy, even though the prospect doesn't appeal to him. I’ve been looking at Gabor Mate’s videos on YouTube. I’m trying to share stuff with him that will give him a sense of hope that things can get better.

@Thelnebriati Sorry I just wanted to clarify my husband was not a victim of sexual abuse. His brother was, but that wasn’t done by the parents and it wasn’t anything to do with the cult.

OP posts:
Thelnebriati · 16/02/2023 12:32

Therapy might be a scary prospect for him because it involves him having to feel his feelings. That can literally feel like death for an abused child - to feel feelings that the parent has decided aren’t acceptable, and that will result in the child being abandoned i.e. death (as a child is inherently vulnerable without adult protection in the wild - it’s a primal fear). Gaining some intellectual understanding of this and recognising that this is childhood fear that he doesn’t need to have now in adulthood might encourage him to make a step forward towards therapy.

I would show him that paragraph.
But having been through what your husband is going through, I think that he is still at the stage where he is trying to repair the relationship, and get his mother to see that she should be a parent. To him that means she needs to leave the cult, for him.
What he is yet unable to see is that his parents are child sexual abusers and so a normal parent-child relationship is impossible without some serious long term therapy on their part. Which he cannot control. He is unable to take himself to therapy, but he is unable to see that his parents are also unable to voluntary go for therapy.
It may be that they would never normally have done that without being groomed by a cult. It may be they sought out the cult because it normalises CSA.

He needs therapy with someone who understands CSA and grooming, so he can process the fact he is a victim of CSA, he cannot fix his abuser or mend the relationship any more than he could when he was a child.
He has other choices but they are not palatable to him at this stage.

Starseeed · 16/02/2023 11:31

Sounds like he’s furious with his mother and the anger comes out as wanting to hurt/punish her by wanting to wreck his life. It’s a raging inner child response, turned in on the self instead of the parent as that’s the only way for the child to maintain connection/attachment with the parent. (See Gabor Maté’s books)

It’s totally reasonable for him to be furious with her. Anger not expressed can become depression though - have personal experience of this (I experienced childhood abuse/neglect with narcissistic parents and a religious cult aspect too).

The anger needs to be allowed and expressed, and then the depression will naturally lift. Therapy is one way to do this. He could also explore trying to express it on his own through journalling, shouting at the sea, vigorous exercise, maybe something like hitting golf balls or boxing etc - whatever floats his boat and that’s a safe way for his body to express the anger stuck inside, as long as it doesn’t involve hurting other people and allows him to fully express himself.

Therapy is ideal because then he gets someone listening compassionately. But maybe you could you help him start the process of feeling his anger by being compassionate towards it (as long as he’s not expressing it in a way that hurts you/others) and encouraging him to find a safe outlet for it?

Therapy might be a scary prospect for him because it involves him having to feel his feelings. That can literally feel like death for an abused child - to feel feelings that the parent has decided aren’t acceptable, and that will result in the child being abandoned i.e. death (as a child is inherently vulnerable without adult protection in the wild - it’s a primal fear). Gaining some intellectual understanding of this and recognising that this is childhood fear that he doesn’t need to have now in adulthood might encourage him to make a step forward towards therapy.

Medication often suppresses feelings so isn’t always a solution - more like a sticking plaster. All the anger will still be there inside him and medication can have the effect of numbing feelings, so making it very difficult to connect with the anger and release it.

Lostwifehelp · 16/02/2023 11:15

@Ruth212 Yes she was a weak bystander with my brother in laws sexual abuse. He went NC with her for a few months but is talking to her again. With my husband’s trauma she actively caused it. My father in law said that he didn’t really want to do it, but as she’s the family matriarch she made the decision. With going NC my husband doesn’t want to punish his father who suffers from anxiety or our children who really love their grandparents.

OP posts:
Ruth212 · 16/02/2023 11:04

With you saying she has gradiose notions about herself and she neglected to stop sexual abuse and protect her other son. I'd be going NC if I was your husband and begin to heal. She's toxic and you're aren't being too harsh. She's basically a weak bystander and didn't protect her children.
Kind of reminds me of my dad except it wasn't sexual abuse, was physical abuse from my mother and my dad did NOTHING to stop it. He also has grandiose tendancies and loves to put other down mixed in with a bit of flattery to keep you around. I'm in the process of going low contact and I've stopped feeling guilty about not wanting to see him. I haven't seen or spoke to my mother in 2+ years. The healing begins when you cut off emotionally.

Lostwifehelp · 16/02/2023 10:29

@AnotherEmma Thanks! I will check those books out. I think it will be a long road convincing my husband that she’s not capable of accepting that she’s wrong. I think he sees her cognitive dissonance around other aspects of her religious views play out and sees potential for growth eg she has not given her daughter less in her will even though that is what her religion requires.

@Theshadowsthecurtainsmake Thanks for sharing your experience. Has the therapy helped her? I am wondering now if some space from his parents could help even though they have been accepting of his decision. I come from the same religious background as my husband so I can somewhat relate, but my parents were much more moderate in their beliefs and I wasn’t told from childhood that my parents had me in order to serve the community and that was my purpose in life, so losing faith and leaving the community was much less traumatic for me.

OP posts:
AnotherEmma · 16/02/2023 10:02

I think it's possible to acknowledge that someone's actions were/are unacceptable while also acknowledging that they are just human, with imperfections, and if not forgiving them for their actions, understanding that they are perhaps not capable of acknowledging they were/are wrong. It's a lot to come to terms with, especially if it's your parent(s).

I really recommend the books "Toxic In-Laws" for you and "Toxic Parents" for your DH (although you could read it too), both by Susan Forward.

Theshadowsthecurtainsmake · 16/02/2023 09:52

@Lostwifehelp I am in the same position with my wife and I’m sorry to say it is a very long road. She left the religion (and her parents house) at 18- she had stopped believing before that but couldn’t afford to leave before then. It is now 20 years later and she still struggles… not every day or even month but every time it is somehow brought back to her (yesterday was because her mum wrote to our son).

She has trauma responses to hymns/churches/priests/ we had to remove our son from church visits at school etc.

She doesn’t contact them anymore and has had one long and one short stint at therapy- your husband has to one way or another accept that his mothers religion is more important than him. It’s wrong, but it is true. It is the same for children abused in any way- the abuse is wrong and the parents are not good people.

Lostwifehelp · 16/02/2023 09:37

At the moment he is talking to me about what he feels and it’s hard to get the balance right between validating his feelings about his mother but also trying to get him to see that he can’t change the fact that her religious beliefs will always come first.

I get on quite well with her and we both don’t think she’s a ‘bad’ person, but she has been raised to believe that it is noble to sacrifice your child for your religion and that has been coupled with having certain narcissistic traits (having grandiose notions about herself). People do overcome religious brainwashing but it has to come from within them and manipulating her into it is wrong.

I do think she has also shown some terrible parenting. Her other son told her as a child that her nephew had tried touching him sexually and her only response was to reprimand him and not remove him from her sons room (where he stayed for a few years and continued to abuse him).

I don’t really know how to feel about her anymore. When we are talking about stuff I go between thinking I am being too forgiving off her to thinking I am being too harsh towards her.

OP posts:
Lostwifehelp · 16/02/2023 08:18

@AnotherEmma Yes it was actually having children that brought this all up. The film Boy Erased had come out shortly before our first child was born and it triggered something in my husband, probably because it’s about how religious parents overlook their child’s well-being in order to put their child through a religious program (which is what happened with my husband).

I hadn’t thought that medication might help him get through the therapy. That actually sounds like a good idea. The challenge is that he is really against taking anything and I can understand why. I have been through two brief spells of depression in my life and I refused when he asked me to take something but what I went through was much more related to circumstances and when those changed I got better whereas his issues are much more deep seated and not going to go away on their own. You’re right, I’m very much a fixer ❤️

OP posts:
AnotherEmma · 15/02/2023 21:31

Sorry to hear that therapy made him feel much worse - I'm not surprised though as with experiences as traumatic as his, I'm sure it's normal for it to get worse before it gets better Sad It's so difficult when you have young children and I think parenthood can often bring up painful issues from your own childhood. One book that's often recommended is "the book you wish you parents had read", I wonder if he would be open to reading that.

I wonder if medication would give him enough of a boost to be able to cope with therapy, or just feel more able to cope in general while he moves towards feeling ready to try therapy again.

Anyway, this is for him to work out not you, but I'm a "fixer" too so I understand Flowers

Lostwifehelp · 15/02/2023 20:31

@AnotherEmma Thanks. I’ve tried to send him a few articles today about grieving about childhood trauma. Will see with him over the next few days if he has read them.
We do have very young children and that’s about the only thing that seems to give him a little happiness these days. Otherwise he describes feeling nothing about anything.

@JustAnotherManicNameChange Yes I think you’re right. It’s actually not that long in terms of the issue he is dealing with. This stuff always bothered him but last summer he decided to get therapy and it made it much worse. I think he did it for about 6-8 weeks and then got very busy with work. Perhaps if he had persisted things would have eventually got better.

OP posts:
JustAnotherManicNameChange · 15/02/2023 19:51

Lostwifehelp · 15/02/2023 19:33

@Onnabugeisha Thank you ❤️ It is tough to see someone you love suffering and to not be able to help them. I can’t really talk to anyone in real life as I don’t know if he would appreciate me sharing his issues so I really appreciate strangers offering advice on here.

@JustAnotherManicNameChange Yes you’re right. For a while I tried to be more understanding of her circumstances. She was indoctrinated and that’s why she didn’t put her child first and she didn’t realise the long term consequences of her actions etc. But I have reached out to her to tell her how much her child is suffering and how he desperately needs a few words from her, but she won’t do it. I know what I would do if I knew my child was hurting so much. But maybe I’m being unfair because I don’t have any deep seated religious beliefs that I value more than my children. Anyway you are right, that he needs to understand the solution won’t come from her but I can’t seem to convince him off that at the moment:

The thing is... it takes time. And i know a year seems like a long time for you but he's probably still in the throes of it. Think of it as grief and all the stages that come with it. Only with the added heartache that he thinks he could have his mum back if she did what he wants her to. So he loses her all over again and again and again. Because he still has either misguided hope or a need for her.

What happened last year?

AnotherEmma · 15/02/2023 19:45

It might seem obvious to you (and us) that he needs therapy but of course you can't force him. He's not ready. However, would he read some books, do you think? I don't know which books would be best for this kind of situation - it's very specific and complex - but there must be books out there. Perhaps if you post on the Stately Homes thread, the knowledgable people on there might be able to point you in the right direction.
www.mumsnet.com/talk/relationships/4660201-november-2022-well-we-took-you-to-stately-homes

I do sympathise with the difficult position you're in. You can't fix it for him, you can only support and encourage him, but his state of mind also has a negative impact on you, and it must be frustrating that he is not willing (or not ready) to seek the help that you feel he needs.

Do you have children?

Lostwifehelp · 15/02/2023 19:33

@Onnabugeisha Thank you ❤️ It is tough to see someone you love suffering and to not be able to help them. I can’t really talk to anyone in real life as I don’t know if he would appreciate me sharing his issues so I really appreciate strangers offering advice on here.

@JustAnotherManicNameChange Yes you’re right. For a while I tried to be more understanding of her circumstances. She was indoctrinated and that’s why she didn’t put her child first and she didn’t realise the long term consequences of her actions etc. But I have reached out to her to tell her how much her child is suffering and how he desperately needs a few words from her, but she won’t do it. I know what I would do if I knew my child was hurting so much. But maybe I’m being unfair because I don’t have any deep seated religious beliefs that I value more than my children. Anyway you are right, that he needs to understand the solution won’t come from her but I can’t seem to convince him off that at the moment:

OP posts:
JustAnotherManicNameChange · 15/02/2023 18:51

She didn't put him first as a child. He wants her to put him first now. She can't or won't so he's in for a lot more disappointment and heartache. I understand that yearning, but even if she did it wouldn't fix the past trauma. That's what he needs to understand and accept. Then he'll be ready for external help ,and it sounds like he desperately needs it.

Onnabugeisha · 15/02/2023 17:07

Lostwifehelp · 15/02/2023 14:37

@Onnabugeisha Yes I’ve tried to explain that but he just points to examples of people who have left the cult and says that if they can do it so can she. I also don’t feel like it’s for him to try to change her beliefs. She is happy in this religious community/cult. I agree that he will need to find a way to heal without the apology that he wants

Yeah, I was sure that you had pointed this out to him already, problem is you love him so he’s going to think you’re trying to salve his feelings. He’d be better off hearing that from a therapist. You’re really amazing to be trying to get him help btw. It can’t be easy for you.

Lostwifehelp · 15/02/2023 14:58

No he won’t go NC with her. To be honest given all the crap the cult teaches about valuing the cult above all else and socially isolating people who leave it, it has somewhat surprised him that his parents have been accepting of his decision to leave it.

OP posts:
Bababear987 · 15/02/2023 14:50

Would he consider going NC with her?

I have had therapy and had to realise that I will never get what I want from my parent because they are incapable of giving me what I need. Its not that they wont, they cant and not matter how much I reason or try to explain they simply dont see it. People have to see it for themselves, she needs to want to leave the cult for her.

Lostwifehelp · 15/02/2023 14:37

@Onnabugeisha Yes I’ve tried to explain that but he just points to examples of people who have left the cult and says that if they can do it so can she. I also don’t feel like it’s for him to try to change her beliefs. She is happy in this religious community/cult. I agree that he will need to find a way to heal without the apology that he wants

OP posts:
Onnabugeisha · 15/02/2023 12:54

He wants her to go further and say the childhood devotion scheme/cult is wrong, which she won’t do.

She cant do it. Not won’t. That’s what brainwashing and psychological torture does to an adult. If she leaves the cult, she might one day be able to break free from the brainwashing and realise this for him. For his own sake, he needs to understand she is still in that bubble and so she isn’t going to be able to even comprehend that the cult has gone down a dark path much less understand the damage she did to him. It’s tough, but he needs therapy to be able to heal without an apology from her or anyone in the cult.