Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask about Jehovah's Witnesses?

375 replies

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:40

There's a Kingdom Hall right at the end of my street. Always extremely busy a couple of nights a week and open everyday I've gone past.

I'm intrigued at what happens in there. It gives off cult vibes but I could be wrong.

Does anybody know what happens during these meetings? Can non JW attend or is that usually not accepted?

I did use to work with a JW but she never spoke much about her religion, all I really knew was that she didn't partake in celebrations.

Interested to hear experiences on here Smile

OP posts:
SD1978 · 03/02/2023 03:33

@BankOfDave - the penmanship is always beautiful- no matter where you are- amazing cursive, beautiful block letters. They should run penmanship classes......that would get the people in......Grin

Mumtobabyhavoc · 03/02/2023 04:25

Membership ripped my friend's family apart. Cult.

Nat6999 · 03/02/2023 04:31

Some of my mum's neighbours are Jehovas Witnesses, they often have gatherings at their house before going on the knock, we are all black balled after my mum lost her temper when they tried knocking at her door for the third time in a week. If you don't want them to call again, tell them you are a Catholic, that is what I did when they knocked at mine, they couldn't get away fast enough & have never been back again.

Downunderduchess · 03/02/2023 04:39

All religions are odd. When you are looking from the outside (and even sometimes from the inside), a lot of things don’t make sense. I grew up & was educated as a Catholic. I don’t think of myself as being religious anymore. I don’t need a bunch of (typically) silly old misogynists making up rules for me to follow. No thanks, I’ll just live my life and try to be a decent person.

Some of the worst things have been perpetrated in the name of religion.

I truly don’t understand why people don’t see its a business like most others. Make money and get people to do your bidding in the name of whoever.

I don’t see JW as better or worse than any other religion, they are all messed up.

daffodilday · 03/02/2023 05:27

No more cult like than Catholics or Church of England . They’re just more vocal about their beliefs.

Tara336 · 03/02/2023 06:02

A family friend is a JW and shes great. She doesn't really talk about it really and we have a little joke now and then. DM is Catholic so they are quite unusual friends in that way. DM joked the other day she had lit a candle for our JW friend which she found hilarious. The JW seem to be very supportive of her as she's elderly and alone and I can't see anything wrong with that. She has nothing financially to offer them at all. She hasn't tried to convert us and won't try, she knows my thoughts on religion

LastOfTheChristmasWine · 03/02/2023 06:07

They don't believe in academic education beyond compulsory school age, because doomsday is imminent.

The result is that their children aren't allowed to do A Levels or go to university, no matter how bright they are, and instead have to do vocational courses like childcare and plumbing at an FE college. I saw it happen to a couple of people I was at school with who had a string of A and A* grade GCSEs. It's a terrible waste of potential.

They also discourage friendships outside of the group, making it harder to develop a support network that might help them leave, and practice shunning if someone steps out of line.

They make huge time demands on people to go and proselytise - of the order of 10-16 hours a week, plus time spent at Kingdom Hall, +++ .... it's certainly a high demand religion.

milkyaqua · 03/02/2023 06:15

en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jehovah's_Witnesses_beliefs

Also: If you are ever polite to them, when they come a'calling, you will then have to be spectacularly rude to get them from coming and knocking at your door over and over and over again, for years and years. And then you may have to ask the leader of the hall to really stop them doorknocking.

listsandbudgets · 03/02/2023 06:19

Anecdotally - my mum has for many years lived in the middle of no where... One day in the early 90s she was happily sunbathing... in the nude... when a couple of JWs came through the gate and into the garden... They were apparently extremely polite - left as fast as they could and never returned!!

I've had them at the door many times and I'm always polite to them as I do respect other people's right to a religion and I know that spreading the message is a huge part of theirs but I also make it clear that I do not wish to join.

I had a couple of their hand written letters too. It makes me smile to see the effort they put into it and I do agree their writing is beautiful.

Another thing that puts me off apart from the shunning and very strict values and lack of birthdays and the blood transfusion thing is that as far as I know that they don't vote.

I believe there are some very strange rules around Kingdom Halls and how quickly they have to be built - I think it has to be done within 3 days.

Maximo2 · 03/02/2023 06:38

Zoeyclash · 02/02/2023 22:49

They don't celebrate birthdays - poor kids 😢

Our JW children at our school just have a different day when they get presents. The parents and children are some of the loveliest families we have at school and it’s hard to marry the cult stories that are obviously true as well.

What irks me is that they are not ‘allowed’ to read stories about witches, ghosts, magic, etc. Knocks out at least half my repertoire. But I asked one mum what happens with GCSE texts at high school with her older ds who I also taught - she said they just get on with it! 😮

follyfoot37 · 03/02/2023 06:55

Alannahxx · 02/02/2023 22:42

It's a cult. And one that kills people. ( have watched as a hcp as someone died due to refusing blood)

Don't be ridiculous. It does not kill people. However, the consequences of some of their beliefs can be. But so can any other religion's beliefs and actions.
So no, OP, it is not a cult
And why not try reading about things rather than asking people on MN who think anything outside c of e is devil worship

PermanentTemporary · 03/02/2023 06:55

'Some of the ladies meet to clean the Kingdom Hall'

Ah well, something in common with most religions there.

follyfoot37 · 03/02/2023 06:59

cecilyyb · 02/02/2023 22:46

@BankOfDave funny you say that, cos on more than on occasion we have also received a hand written letter through the post. Assuming it's from somebody who goes to the Kingdom Hall

We get hand-wriiten letters too. I admire the fact that someone has the patience to do this.
The content however, does not make mexwant to belive in god/christ or any other of the made up beings we are supposed to be with once we are dead

follyfoot37 · 03/02/2023 07:01

UWhatNow · 02/02/2023 22:50

They take the Bible literally. So there is something that says you shouldn’t ‘consume’ blood. There is good reason for this because if you actually tried to drink it it would congeal in your throat and probably choke you. However they translate that as taking it intravenously too. They can often take plasma or saline instead.

hahahahah
Congeal in your throat and kill you!!!
Is that you, Stephen King?!!!!

Cantwait4summer94 · 03/02/2023 07:03

ToBeOrNotToBee · 02/02/2023 23:40

Your own ignorance is showing.

Perhaps you better go out and actually meet some believers.

One of my closest childhood friends was raised a witness. His mum was the kindest, most genuinely lovely women you could hope to meet.

I was then in a relationship with a man raised a witness for many many years, with parents and siblings being active members of a kingdom hall. Despite all your assertions that they raise their kids to be homophobic, holocaust deniers and other nonsense, the opposite is true.

I've also cared for many witnesses in the capacity as a midwife, and the hostility they got from colleagues the second they mentioned their faith was awful. Genuine discrimination, with midwives openly stating they would refuse to care for them and Dr's laughing at their beliefs during ward rounds.

For no other religion is this accepted, but its considered fine for Jehovah Witnesses.

Why?

Because of wilfully ignorant people like you.

the doctors and colleagues laughing and discriminating against JW patients are disgusting

HoneyBadger525 · 03/02/2023 07:04

My friend grew up close to the JW Community but was not an active member so she lived a very liberal, normal teenage existence and was very down-to-earth. However, when she married a man whose family were staunch Witnesses she changed. They and their children are now so judgemental and they certainly seem in some way brainwashed. They say it as though they are doing things in the best interests of others but each time I see her, it feels so forced and unnatural. She doesn’t feel like the person I once knew. It’s as though it’s an obligation to say nice things or offer help. There has been a definite shift in her behaviour and attitude and I don’t feel it’s for the better. The stories I have heard, particularly about shunning certainly ring alarm bells and give the impression of a cult-like organisation. She does not push the religion on me, but there is an undertone to everything she says, like it’s almost scripted. I will say that at gatherings her family and friends have always been extremely welcoming and friendly but that there is consistently the same judgemental vibe coming from them. I find it really difficult to spend time in their company as I feel like I am constantly nervous about what I say. It’s a shame as we were once so close but it makes me feel uncomfortable.

Blueuggboots · 03/02/2023 07:09

They believe their place in heaven will be affected by the number of people they convert, hence the pushy nature on doorsteps.

It's a horrible religion that breaks up families. Steer well clear.

vera99 · 03/02/2023 07:12

They are not healthy but then again they are not evil. Best left alone to their own devices. I've had a few around for chats over the years and had good arguments with them and they left happy but didn't come back. They refused to honour Hitler and the Nazi authority so ended up persecuted and exterminated as undesirables so that's quite a faith they had which they could have renounced and saved themselves but they didn't. Unlike Jews of course that had no such choice.

encyclopedia.ushmm.org/content/en/article/nazi-persecution-of-jehovahs-witnesses

Hobbesmanc · 03/02/2023 07:12

I've worked with Witnesses and a close friend was brought up as one. She left as a teenager but remains close to the family. In fact her mum is one of the loveliest women, she explained to me once that they try to recruit people because they genuinely want to save as many people as possible

There's bad folk in every group and demographic.

TooTiredToWork · 03/02/2023 07:13

Believe me - the blood thing is still an issue these days. And I say that as an anaesthetist who works in maternity. I have had several cases of massive haemorrhage where without a doubt the woman would have died without transfusion. Yes there are improvements - and new technologies, and we try always to reduce blood usage, but sometimes there is no alternative

Having to spell out to someone that their decision may well result in their death - and checking that they are ‘fine’ with that is not an easy part of my job. I often wonder how informed such a decision is when they’ve been brought up deep with in the JW community. Is it really their decision?

I also know HCPs that still carry deep scars from treating patients who refused blood and died. Some of these have left Medicine rather than face the same situation again

The view around blood is based on a very specific interpretation of three noble verses - two old testament and one new. This interpretation is not shared by any other religious group who follow the same scripture

Outtasteamandluck · 03/02/2023 07:23

My ex DP was a JW.

It's a religion that hasn't been around all that long. It was founded in 1881.

They do hold certain beliefs: no sex before marriage and dating is supervised, only wedding anniversaries are celebrated no birthdays or Christmas.

If there's 'scandal' they all huddle together and cover it up.

They predicted the end of the world was coming many times and even went as far to predict the date's obviously when it didn't happen they had to stop as it made them look stupid.

My ex was told not to study at school because the end of the world was coming. 🤷‍♀️

Relationships are very (or were) traditional- men work and women stay at home. Non JW girls are referred to as 'wordly'.

Meetings at the KH are bible scriptures / talks led by an elder.

It all had a very community feel, everyone supposedly looks after each other. Except if you do something they deem wrong (normal). Then you are ex-communicated (cut out). Even parents are told to shun their children. And they do.

And then there's the no blood. It's because it's not your own and therefore pure.

Ex DP's parents were genuinely the nicest people you could meet. Always willing to help. They didn't fully accept me but that's ok. It worked both ways.

Like a PP said, re a cult. it's hovering on the line.

clarabellabunting · 03/02/2023 07:39

otherwayup · 02/02/2023 23:22

@ToBeOrNotToBee
Absolutely no need to call me disgusting.

As I have said, I'm happy (and would be somewhat relieved) to be corrected.
But still no explanation as to why jw children were removed from holocaust learning?
I'm simply sharing my experience and pondering why on earth this ever happened!!

JWs talk a lot about how they are the most persecuted religion - it is part of their belief system that they are hated and discriminated against by the rest of the world. In my experience, they mention a lot that they were targeted in the holocaust. Perhaps they do not like that this would likely not be mentioned in a normal school holocaust lesson, and that it would become clear to their children that the Jews are far more persecuted?

romdowa · 03/02/2023 07:42

I went to school with a girl whos parents were witnesses. I think she had a quite strict upbringing , especially from her father but her and her other sister went completely off the rails, drinking , partying , children outside of marraige , divorce and even though their father was strict , they were never shunned . Their parents have actually relaxed as they got older, they now buy their grandkids Christmas and birthday presents. It's just a bit sad that it took them so long to relax and you can really see that the extreme religious upbringing really had an affect on them.

shrunkenhead · 03/02/2023 07:43

They always seem to be on a big recruitment drive, which makes me wary. If I'm going to pick a religion I'll do my own research, thanks.
A JW I once worked with was learning all sorts of languages to enable her to "spread the word". Many at her kingdom hall were French speaking immigrants from Africa (I forget whereabouts) which made me realise they were targeting vulnerable people.
Not sure of the distinction between religion and cults, tbf, OP but if you're looking to broaden your social circle I'd find a job or enrol at your local college for a part time course.

ChangedmynameagainforChristmas · 03/02/2023 07:44

Welcome to the hotel California