Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That schools should not be telling children they are born in the wrong bodies?

485 replies

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 08:44

www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-11646881/I-asked-daughters-teachers-not-call-boy-reported-social-services.html?s=08

This is so alarming now - just how many children do we think are born in the wrong bodies?

Is this not now just science fiction?

YABU - Rainbows are magic

YANBU - It's brainwashing. No child is born in the wrong body and schools must be held to account.

OP posts:
RichardBarrister · 19/01/2023 10:25

whereaw · 19/01/2023 09:51

I haven't done enough research (yet) but for some time now the thing that has worried me more than anything is the increasing acceptance and increasing ubiquity of pornography in society, and the untold damage that is doing to society and people (changing the way we think feel, experience pain and pleasure and understand who we are... the list goes on)... I am starting to think that the two things are not unrelated

Absolutely. Trans children’s charity Mermaids, a charity used and signposted to by many schools employed several men extremely questionable out if work interests.

One employee posted frequently and graphically on social media about his use of sex toys, one did a very explicit porn shoot for a magazine (using his real name and fully linkable to Mermaids) and a trustee has spent years advocating for greater acceptance for paedophiles. All have now left ir resigned but their activities were very open and there is no chance that their employer was not aware.

Mermaids also advertised directly for a young person to do a photoshoot in their bedroom and recruited an 11 yr old boy who posed for pictures with a male model sat on a bed dressed in exaggerated dolly costumes which are associated with a strand of porn. Last time I looked it was still on their website.

This is just one children’s charity in the trans sector. There are a number of other charities in the sector aimed at children that gave serious safeguarding failings, be that hosting mixed sex mixed age swimming sessions with parents not allowed and only requirements to ‘cover your bottom half’ to another charity being led by James Rennie, one of the worst paedophiles ever convicted in Scotland.

There still hasn’t been a proper investigation of this charity that runs events fit young people and complainants are coming forward saying that they were groomed and exposed to adult sexual activity.

I am emphatically not saying that all trans people are predators as we are frequently accused, but if you exempt a group from safeguarding rules and turn a blind eye to their behaviour, you will definitely attract predators. That’s how it works, be it Catholic priests or 1980s children tv presenters. If any group is regarded as being above suspicion that privilege will be abused.

Meanwhile the Scottish government has just made it easier for any predator to erase a previous identity and obtain a new birth certificate. The concept of trans is explained as a person having gender dysphoria. The Scottish government have just opened up the GRC process to people who do not have a diagnosis of gender dysphoria. As there is no widely accepted working definition of trans or gender identity, it has effectively opened it up to everyone. Including the fraudsters and the predators.

MumOfYoungTransAdult · 19/01/2023 10:24

It’s the Daily Mail. I read several newspapers and they never report things in an unbiased and holistic way. Few of them do, but the DM is one of the worst for misrepresenting things and hyperbole- I therefore choose never to base opinions upon or waste emotions on anything they publish.

Do feel free to link to a less biassed version from another newspaper. I am no fan of the DM but silence is also bias.

You can go look at the named sources like Transgender Trend if you want to check for bias.

I therefore choose never to base opinions upon or waste emotions on anything they publish.

Lucky you. I wish I could afford to do that.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 10:17

NCLegalQuery · 19/01/2023 09:50

It’s the Daily Mail. I read several newspapers and they never report things in an unbiased and holistic way. Few of them do, but the DM is one of the worst for misrepresenting things and hyperbole- I therefore choose never to base opinions upon or waste emotions on anything they publish.

That is fine. But if that is your only discussion point for this thread, it says more about you and your prejudices than anything else.

The daily mail, the Telegraph and the Times are some of the only papers that publish anything on this topic.

Would you like to tell us what you dispute about the article?

StephanieSuperpowers · 19/01/2023 09:58

One thing that confuses me about the zealots is that they position this as so important that it must be acted on immediately or very serious consequences (even suicide) are likely, but also so trivial that it doesn't warrant any investigation.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/01/2023 09:53

Children are the casulties.

Yes all children are the casualties not just the ones who are sold the lie and put on a harmful pathway but also the ones who have to lie about what they can see with their own eyes and, of course, the girls who will lose out to the inclusion of males in their spaces and sports.

whereaw · 19/01/2023 09:51

I haven't done enough research (yet) but for some time now the thing that has worried me more than anything is the increasing acceptance and increasing ubiquity of pornography in society, and the untold damage that is doing to society and people (changing the way we think feel, experience pain and pleasure and understand who we are... the list goes on)... I am starting to think that the two things are not unrelated

NCLegalQuery · 19/01/2023 09:50

It’s the Daily Mail. I read several newspapers and they never report things in an unbiased and holistic way. Few of them do, but the DM is one of the worst for misrepresenting things and hyperbole- I therefore choose never to base opinions upon or waste emotions on anything they publish.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/01/2023 09:49

I know of no person who legitimately travels the opposite direction.

I think many parents legitimatise it in their own heads in the role of protector of their child.

It baffles me that intelligent women who are confident in their opinions block and cry bigot though. If their arguments were genuinely sound and not just 'won't you think of my child', then they would have the courage of their convictions to explain why we are wrong.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 09:44

When you understand how young people are used to prop up the males who have very different motivations (usually denied vehemently), you cannot go back.

I find the first instinct people have is to accuse you of conspiracy theories. It is far better that people come to see it in their own time. I know of no person who legitimately travels the opposite direction.

There is a reason for it. People seeking the truth, however blunt, cannot ignore the truths they discover.

NettleTea · 19/01/2023 09:32

whereaw · 19/01/2023 08:56

@Helleofabore Interesting. So, why aren't the trans community fighting for more research into medical care and treatment and long term health and futures of trans people who face a unique set of difficulties that no 'cis' person could ever hope to understand... rather than access to women's spaces? Odd.

The only high profile campaigning you will see is for access to free cosmetic surgery /SRS and drugs
There is no push for investigative / talking therapy, as the accepted narrative is that the MH problems are only due to a lack of access to drugs and surgery, and hateful transphobia to anyone who says NO

The rot started way way back with the mix of language between transexual and transvestites - look on the feminist board for info of the history of the Beaumont society for how that worked

The next step to remove it as a MH issue (thereby throwing transexuals under the bus) and removing the need for a diagnosis of gender dysphoria - mainly because the majority pushing are transvestites, and would be easily identified and refused GRC by the current model.

To prove its not a MH issue, it needs to be inherant, there from birth, part of who they are (like being gay/lesbian) so by that reasoning it needs to be present from birth/childhood. So in a world thats becoming increasingly gendered (due to marketing/consumerism/porn????) its possible to spot the outliers. Beaumont society was traditionally strongly anti gay - they refused entry to transexuals - and we know that the male drive when lost in fetish is selfish to the extreme (read multiple stories of the surprisingly narcissistic partners of the transwidows) so in order to fulfil their desires, does it matter if gay kids and autistic kids get damaged???

so we see a push in education, and a push in trendy online circles to re-educate the youth from cradle, and their parents/teachers of this new gender identity issue.

Children are the casulties. The teens/young people, riling against society as many have done before, but never having the power given here, are the foot soldiers. The funding coming from the opportunistic drug and surgery companies, and the power from the middle aged rich white men, who previously would have in previous eras been exposed as 'rich MP/High Court Judge caught in compromising position' but who now get awarded for coming to work as Pippa.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 09:22

Not hard to work it out. Sorry.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/01/2023 09:22

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 06:05

I hope you don’t mind wanda, I am just adding this article published in the telegraph overnight.

"Teachers are to be warned against “socially transitioning” children who question their gender, The Telegraph has learned.”

“Allowing pupils to change their names and pronouns to match their preferred gender could have a major impact on their psychological wellbeing, schools will be told in new guidance.
There has been growing concern about teachers allowing children to embrace a new gender identity at school, in some cases without the knowledge of their parents.
The official advice, due to be published by the Department for Education (DfE) in the coming months
”

www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/01/18/letting-gender-confused-children-socially-transition-could-harmful/

(archive copy. archive.ph/1yWHu )

And discussion started on this link below.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4723286-telegraph-letting-pupils-socially-transition-harms-well-being-teachers-told

The ball is beginning to roll. Whenever we see an action taken in the UK, often after another country has taken that action already, other countries tend to follow. Such as the admission that puberty blockers are certainly not reversible the way patients and parents of patients were being assured by heavily-invested individuals and groups.

I think this may well result in some parents of gender non conforming children removing their children from schools on the basis that the school system cannot keep them safe.

I know that there are already a number of trans identifying children who are not attending school from groups that I belong to.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 09:21

whereaw · 19/01/2023 08:56

@Helleofabore Interesting. So, why aren't the trans community fighting for more research into medical care and treatment and long term health and futures of trans people who face a unique set of difficulties that no 'cis' person could ever hope to understand... rather than access to women's spaces? Odd.

Well… now that is a very interesting question. And often asked and never answered. Even by the regular transitioned male regular posters that used to be on MN.

It starts to make sense when you realise which people in the trans community hold the power. It is it hard at all to work out. It is the mature males. Just like in the rest of the society. Misogyny is misogyny regardless of the gender of the male serving it up.

And it is only once you start to understand just how little women’s health has been considered that adds another piece of the puzzle. It is only recently that female specific symptoms were published for some major diseases and health issues.

Look how long it takes to get a diagnosis on Endometriosis?

Why don’t mature males want the very best health outcome for female people? Well, to do that would require :

constant acknowledgment that females are very different from males to start with.

acknowledgement that the motivations for transitioning is very different in most females compare to many male people. (Female transitioners have been heavily abused for that suggestion)

and that leads to the lack of adequate and useable definition of what it is to be ‘trans’ and who is and isn’t trans.

And the list goes on.

Bringing those issues to public attention after convincing everyone that you are not allowed to debate, acceptance only, transwomen are women, how would that even work?

But of course, that is only part of the issue.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/01/2023 09:18

And some, as we have seen here on this thread, do not care at all.

It is the women who do not care that bother me. I've come across a very intelligent woman in the autism community whose son identifies as a girl. She is a solicitor by profession but she is so blinkered to having her child treated as a female in all circumstances with access to all spaces as though he is female that she has lost all sense of perspective.

She has now written a book about her experiences and she hosts a number of internet groups for autistic families, she uses these groups to also promote trans rights. Anyone who queries any aspect of this, I did from the point of view of autistic girls and women's rights are instantly removed and told they are bigots. She has effectively created an echo chamber in the autism community and it is all about the wonderful sparkly rainbow community.

It is all about her child. it is a bit reminiscent of Susie Green imo.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 09:05

Yes lifeturns

This is exactly where we get to when we lack definitions and when we accept the lies told by activists and their lobby groups.

We were told back in Hansard nearly 20 years ago that no male would access the provisions set aside for females. We were assured that no male would seek to access women’s refuges for instance. Because no male would call themselves female.

Now we have indeed had males leverage the fact that some people called them women and treated them ‘just like women’ that they were female and should be fully treated as female. In all aspects of life.

That is the result of kindly calling males ‘women’. Some people haven’t realised yet that this has happened.

And some, as we have seen here on this thread, do not care at all.

whereaw · 19/01/2023 08:56

@Helleofabore Interesting. So, why aren't the trans community fighting for more research into medical care and treatment and long term health and futures of trans people who face a unique set of difficulties that no 'cis' person could ever hope to understand... rather than access to women's spaces? Odd.

lifeturnsonadime · 19/01/2023 08:50

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 07:03

Here is another aspect of this issue covered off in the Times today.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/dc24e850-9771-11ed-91ab-4070465550ba?shareToken=f6be73b0c64c75f44d7720d201626e58

Because as has been pointed out, the actions taken by the schools and parents could need consideration under any conversion therapy bill. This bill is back getting more discussion. Particularly in light of the Cass report that will be published this year and the interim report released in 2022.

But this is where definitions are so desperately needed.

We need clear definitions of :

Trans person
Gender
Gender Identity
Conversion Therapy
Conversion Practices

When people say that conversion therapy needs to be banned then the knee jerk response will will be 'of course' because conversion therapy, as per old speak, was sleep & food depravation, injecting substances & other physical intimidation. Of course these practices have no 'place in modern Britain'.

In current time conversion practices seems to have taken on a different meaning and afaik the likes of Stonewall and Mermaids have changed its meaning to any kind of talking therapy which falls short of instant affirmation.

This is, in my opinion, to answer @WandaWomblesaurus post last night which asks 'did we fall asleep?, how we have got here. Along with the mantra of Trans Women are Women which is a complete lie. Women are adult human females, and this is yet another word which lobby groups have attempted to change the meaning of with some degree of success.

Lawmakers cannot make laws unless terms are clearly defined. Where they do they are bad laws.

Lilavanblue · 19/01/2023 08:04

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Agree, and yet I know a woman, a mum, who endorsed this person on social media.
She also started identifying as non-binary herself couple of years ago, whatever that means (and I say it as someone who has always admired gender non-conforming people).

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 07:55

HandScreen · 18/01/2023 16:00

The right to self-identify. I have no problem with trans people in sports or single-sex spaces.

Maybe this will help others who are still in the mode of ‘I don’t mind males being in female single sex spaces or sports’.

Just because you, personally, don’t care, do you honestly feel you have the right to disregard the opinions and needs of other women and girls? That you, as an individual, get to ignore what is now known about the needs of other women and girls and priortise the needs of males?

Maybe this is also appropriate here:

Every journey goes

“I’m kind! TWAW!”
“If they’ve transitioned they can use female spaces”
“They’re saying what to lesbians?”
“What is autogynophilia?”
“You mean they’re saying they actually ARE women?”
“Wait. What laws have changed?”
“I don’t care if you call me a bigot”
“TWAM.”

twitter.com/salltweets/status/1615624765963931651?s=46&t=cwB2MhT1vSN7a6R3_cKXlg

Because not one person on this planet can change sex. Ignoring that many females can accurately sex a male when seeing them in person, seeing them move and hearing their voice, simply means you have priotised males over the needs of traumatised females. If you believe that makes you morally superior, that is fine.

Others will just continue to disagree. And the readers of this thread wondering what the fuck is happening will see your morally superior contributions for what they are.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 07:03

Here is another aspect of this issue covered off in the Times today.

www.thetimes.co.uk/article/dc24e850-9771-11ed-91ab-4070465550ba?shareToken=f6be73b0c64c75f44d7720d201626e58

Because as has been pointed out, the actions taken by the schools and parents could need consideration under any conversion therapy bill. This bill is back getting more discussion. Particularly in light of the Cass report that will be published this year and the interim report released in 2022.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 06:21

What was needed urgently, starting back when the rapid growth of the young female cohort was noticed, was solid and robust research.

I remember reading how “no debate” stifled research, how people were vilified for even suggesting there were issues.
Just like we have had posters on this thread write posts about how anti-trans it is to even have this discussion, how poisonous, how transphobic - the list goes on.

Those posts are just ridiculous examples of emotional manipulation. Because that is all those posters have. There is no reasoning, there is no evidenced discussion behind those posts. Just emotion, polarisation and hyperbole. Just emotionally manipulative posts.

Those posts are a great example of why children and teens are in this situation without the robust evidence driven support they need. It is because of this polarisation. Thinking based on ‘if you are not 100% supportive, you are a hateful bigot’.

Even research papers into the long term health risks to female bodies seem to be scarce. The long term side effects are really unknown still. However, much is known already. We only have to look at the health of the girls and women who took testosterone for sport (knowingly or not) For females, the risk of transition is huge. We also hear about the health complications from the detransitioners.

There are already studies about the very early dementia risks for women who lose their ovaries (for any reason) in their 20s, I hope that more conclusive research will be publicised soon. But it seems to be that the life shortening risks to females is greater than for males and this is rarely acknowledged. Why?

Who benefits from that?

We get told on MN about the women who microdose on ‘T’ for cosmetic reasons. They are not trans people but seem to think testosterone is perfectly safe to use to enhance their ‘look’? This is a ramification of the lack of open discussion about the negative side effects. Detransitioners have reported the coercion within the community to not discuss the negative side effects with anyone. Not even amongst the community.

Who benefits from that?

Of course reasoned discussion is needed.

If this expected DoE guidance somehow has been misrepresented or changes before release, parents and others will still continue the fight. Regardless of the people who will seek to shame us. Accuse us of ridiculous things.

We have to.

Helleofabore · 19/01/2023 06:05

I hope you don’t mind wanda, I am just adding this article published in the telegraph overnight.

"Teachers are to be warned against “socially transitioning” children who question their gender, The Telegraph has learned.”

“Allowing pupils to change their names and pronouns to match their preferred gender could have a major impact on their psychological wellbeing, schools will be told in new guidance.
There has been growing concern about teachers allowing children to embrace a new gender identity at school, in some cases without the knowledge of their parents.
The official advice, due to be published by the Department for Education (DfE) in the coming months
”

www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/01/18/letting-gender-confused-children-socially-transition-could-harmful/

(archive copy. archive.ph/1yWHu )

And discussion started on this link below.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4723286-telegraph-letting-pupils-socially-transition-harms-well-being-teachers-told

The ball is beginning to roll. Whenever we see an action taken in the UK, often after another country has taken that action already, other countries tend to follow. Such as the admission that puberty blockers are certainly not reversible the way patients and parents of patients were being assured by heavily-invested individuals and groups.

WandaWomblesaurus · 18/01/2023 22:01

www.tiktok.com/@thejeffreymarsh/video/7148976129175489838

More classic Marsh

mobile.twitter.com/millihill/status/1535191853607297024

I mean what are we dealing with here - social contagion, internet influencers, entire friends groups coming out as trans, kids desperate to stop their puberty and to remove body parts, many of whom are autistic, schools changing their names and treating them as though they are the opposite sex, detransitioners with horrible side effects saying they have terrible regrets and women threatened for saying it's wrong.

Did everyone fall asleep?
2023 - what will be the breaking point where parents en masse stand up and say enough?

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 18/01/2023 21:15

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Marsh is very much a risky person. They actively have posted content about how ‘some families don’t understand you like we do’ and the contact them and be part of the glitter family.

This person is a dangerous influencer because this doesn’t get the pushback it should.

Then again, Mermaids were encouraging children to enter discord server chat sessions as well. This movement has so much invested in detaching children from their family and making children and young people feel that their family hates them.

It really is concerning to see this behaviour accepted. There is a word for it, but we cannot seem to say that word on MN without deletion.

EasterIsland · 18/01/2023 21:14

YANBU. It’s a lot of social contagion and it’s cruel to suggest to children they can change sex. They can’t.

All they can do is be one life-long medical patients and often have artificially shortened lives because of the effects of the cross-sex hormones. We still don’t have enough data on the long term effects of pumping a human body full of high doses of artificial chemically produced cross-sex hormones.

“Social transition” can be dangerous as it do often leads to medical transition in the affirmation model.