Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be sick of cashless society

612 replies

Ihatepcos · 10/01/2023 09:31

I prefer to use cash, I always have.

I find budgeting and spending so much easier. If I am tapping away on my card I think nothing of constant £3 £6 etc being spent on things I probably wouldn't buy if I was spending cash.

More and more places simply don't take cash and it's driving me mad.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
catlovingdoctor · 10/01/2023 12:56

Yanbu...I much prefer being able to use cash

Itschristmastimeinthecity · 10/01/2023 12:56

AmazonsFuckedUpFreeMusicFeature · 10/01/2023 12:54

Lesser security risk.
In my local shops there is always queue for card ones, not for cash ones

In my local shops there is always queue for card ones, not for cash ones

same here

MajorCarolDanvers · 10/01/2023 12:55

This life now. You need to learn new budgeting techniques.

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:55

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 10/01/2023 12:52

You're fooling yourself; or rather allowing yourself to be fooled by marketing if you think a Revolut account can't be cloned or used by anyone else.

https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/decision/DRN-3265894.pdf

Oh bless you, you don't understand any of it do you?

These people talking about their Nans who can't use a card or write an email....thats just you in another few years!

workinmums · 10/01/2023 12:54

If I ran a fruit stand for about 6 months and I now know more people are likely to buy apples than oranges, Why would I deliberately buy MORE oranges?
Supermarkets are simply catering for the majority, that's all.

ily0 · 10/01/2023 12:54

It’s obvious being ordered from the top down as a way of tracking people and their spending by making it as difficult as possible to pay by cash.

AmazonsFuckedUpFreeMusicFeature · 10/01/2023 12:54

ily0 · 10/01/2023 12:53

🤦‍♀️ You can’t be this stupid surely?! Why don’t they allow you to pay by cash OR card in the machines?! It’s not either or?! Every time I go to the supermarket there is a long queue to use the two machines that allow cash. Why is suddenly the option to pay by cash so difficult when ALL the machines used to allow BOTH payment methods?

It’s pretty obvious to anyone with two brain cells to rub together that this is deliberate.

Lesser security risk.
In my local shops there is always queue for card ones, not for cash ones

ily0 · 10/01/2023 12:53

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:47

Wow. The paranoia! It is deliberate, but it's not sinister, it's simply that they know that a far larger percentage of people WANT to pay with card rather than cash.

🤦‍♀️ You can’t be this stupid surely?! Why don’t they allow you to pay by cash OR card in the machines?! It’s not either or?! Every time I go to the supermarket there is a long queue to use the two machines that allow cash. Why is suddenly the option to pay by cash so difficult when ALL the machines used to allow BOTH payment methods?

It’s pretty obvious to anyone with two brain cells to rub together that this is deliberate.

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 10/01/2023 12:52

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:44

No, you're missing the point. It's so easy to manouvere, you don't need to give your details at all!
I ahve a revolut account, it has a physical card and a virtual card on my phone. On the latter, every time I pay with it using my phone, it generates a new, one time use, card number. Nobody gets my bank account details, or my card details. Nobody can clone it or use it.

By not learning how to use these things properly and safely, you are shooting yourself in the foot. It's so easy to protect yourself from all those things your so worried about but don't actually bother to deal with.

And don't kid yourself that The Man can't find you a track you a thousand times over anyway!

You're fooling yourself; or rather allowing yourself to be fooled by marketing if you think a Revolut account can't be cloned or used by anyone else.

https://www.financial-ombudsman.org.uk/decision/DRN-3265894.pdf

Badbadbunny · 10/01/2023 12:52

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 12:39

Did you go to a private school?
My school had no computers in early 1980s. About 1884/5 they got one computer. There was a big push to get one computer in every school in the country. I never got to use it.
At university in the mid to late eighties all essays were handwritten. There was a computer suite that was only for students doing computer studies. 1989 my first job and offices all still had secretaries and word processors. It was not until 1995 I got a computer at work. I moved to a new job a couple of years later and found myself in an office with a shared secretary and no computer. Had to wait until 1998 for my next computer.
There are always go ahead firms that introduce technology early. But computers have really only been commonplace in offices for about 25 years and are far more recent in the home. For a long time only gamers and those interested in computing had home computers. They were expensive.

Plenty of elderly people can do the very basics such as send an email or use facebook but can't manage anything more complex.

No it was a bog standard comp. I left in Summer 1983 and by then they had 3 classrooms full of computers, one on every desk.

Workplace was certainly not "high tech" - we still had manual hand cranked adding machines, ledgers that we had to write by hand in ink pen, underlining in red ink, etc. Photocopier was a "page at a time one" where you had to use a piece of something like rice paper with the page on the bed and then put the rice paper with a piece of "copier" paper through a roller for the image to be transferred - it was heat transfer rather than ink. We also had a Gestetner duplicator for multiple prints of the same document in purple print which needed to be typed on special sheets that punched letter/number holes into it for the purple ink to go through!

The computers were bought purely for the time consuming "number crunching" work as the owners (both in their 60s) clearly made the decision that saving time (and therefore staff numbers) was worth their massive investment (at the time) in the computer system. They weren't used for "normal" admin nor secretarial work (cheaper wages I assume!). It would take a week to have done a manual/hand set of projections/forecasts for 3 years for a new business start-up (I remember doing them), but that could be done in a day with the computer and spreadsheet software, so massively labour saving. It was funny that the owners hadn't the faintest idea about how to use the computers, had no interest in learning, but could see the potential and payback and loved showing the end result to the client in a "look at us, we're forward thinking" way!

As for your comments about "more complex" things - apps like Monzo are remarkably simple, and are in no way any harder than Facebook to set up and use.

sunseaandme · 10/01/2023 12:51

brrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr · 10/01/2023 09:37

I was happy riding a horse everywhere and suddenly it’s all cars this and cars that

😂😂

AmazonsFuckedUpFreeMusicFeature · 10/01/2023 12:49

Badbadbunny · 10/01/2023 12:14

Yes, I'm an accountant, I know how things have changed. But HMRC are more "targeted" these days, so better use of their resources.

I remember back in the 80s where tax inspectors would be real pains in the arse because of obsessing about small/trivial matters - they were real jobsworths who didn't care about size of tax being recovered - they'd happily spend a day poring over someone's "books" and walk away at the end of it having raised a tax assessment for an extra £5 - it was complete and utter madness.

Or a case involving a coal man, where the inspector spent several months checking every last piece of paper for 6 years, the guy's "work" diary for a couple of years, even driving around the route to check time it would take and mileage etc (before google maps!), checking MOT history for mileage, checking the guy's household bills, checking his passport to see if he'd been abroad on holiday. He just wouldn't accept defeat. He had to in the end, as there was nothing to see, but that was a huge waste of resources and it cost the poor guy thousands in accountancy fees just to defend himself against unfounded challenge!

HMRC are going after the bigger fish in a more controlled way based on intelligence rather than just randomly going on "fishing" expeditions. And they're getting better at it. Starting to see "trickle down" effects now and them targeting specific industries/areas. Just a shame that they still seem frightened of certain communities - they'd never touch scrap dealers and roofers back in the 80s and still won't today!

Lots of the small businesses around me would disagree incl me.
Most of us (my circle) had HMRC on our backs recently for wither minimal mistake or suspected issue. It's madness.
Madder than Immigration and that's something imho!

MadisonAvenue · 10/01/2023 12:49

I’d like a choice.

We were at a football match last season, all food and drink sales are strictly card only and the system failed. They couldn’t, in a stadium of 74000 people, sell any food or drink because there was no way of taking cash.

At a match last week I helped a man out who was standing near the kiosk while I was in the queue, he wanted a drink but only had cash. He gave me his £3 and I bought his drink on my card along with my other purchases.

On the other hand, our two local fish and chip shops will only take cash.

Catspyjamas17 · 10/01/2023 12:48

Plenty of elderly people can do the very basics such as send an email or use facebook but can't manage anything more complex

Plenty of people a lot younger can't either, due to laziness more than anything, my 82 year old mum is better than loads of people much younger with her phone as she is interested and chooses to learn how to do it. It's important to move with the times and try to understand new tech as it comes in.

thaisweetchill · 10/01/2023 12:47

I hate cash, always have done. I hate taking £10 out of a cash point for something £5, that extra £5 I'll just waste on stuff I don't need or wouldn't have bought.

BradfordGirl · 10/01/2023 12:47

Spidey66 · 10/01/2023 12:43

Even the Big Issue sellers in our area has card readers!!!

I prefer cards/phone use. I actually think it makes budgetting easier as I check my account online daily and can see exactly where my money is going. ''Bloody hell! I spent £30 down the pub last night! I need to rein my spending in sharpish!''

I think that works for people budgeting with a decent budget.
When money is really tight cash works best. You take £10 out and when it has gone it has gone. I have seen friends do this on a night out. They know if they are drinking especially it is easy to lose track. But with cash, once it is spent it is spent.

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:47

ily0 · 10/01/2023 12:45

It’s really deliberate and sinister that suddenly in every supermarket there are only two self service tills out of ten that let you pay by cash, and so you have to spend 3x the amount of time queuing. If it was one store that did this then you could blame them but all of them doing this at the exact same time? It’s coordinated and deliberate.

Wow. The paranoia! It is deliberate, but it's not sinister, it's simply that they know that a far larger percentage of people WANT to pay with card rather than cash.

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:45

you're

ily0 · 10/01/2023 12:45

It’s really deliberate and sinister that suddenly in every supermarket there are only two self service tills out of ten that let you pay by cash, and so you have to spend 3x the amount of time queuing. If it was one store that did this then you could blame them but all of them doing this at the exact same time? It’s coordinated and deliberate.

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:45

skyeisthelimit · 10/01/2023 12:43

If you want to budget then get a card like Revolut and just transfer over your spending money each week/month. You can track your spending on an app and see how much money you have left to spend. It is easy to top up. I use one for my daughter.

A lot of small businesses round here prefer cash due to the charges they have to pay when cards are used. Some are actively begging for cash to be used to save them money. However, cash can also cause a problem if they have an excess of it, as some banks charge a huge commission fee to bank cash now. So the small shops can't win.

I'm an accountant and I see bank statements where people are paying for every single drink in a pub, £3.80 several times in a night, whereas years ago they would have paid for one drink and then had cashback to pay for the rest. These transactions can often cost 20p per transaction plus a % depending on the card merchant that they use.

On the other hand, some pubs prefer cards because staff don't have to hand over change so there is less room for theft and errors.

Covid made a lot of people switch to cards when they had used cash for years and they just haven't gone back.

Ultimately a cashless society will prevent a lot of fraud and tax evasion as people won't be able to work for cash in hand. Every single payment will be tracked one way or another.

I agree that bartering will make more of a comeback as people will swap services to avoid recording the sale.

Your an accountant and don't know that there are endless options for cards that don't charge transactions fees on everyday purchases? Who on earth is paying 20p plus a percentage fee on every pint in the pub?

NotAnotherBathBomb · 10/01/2023 12:45

pishkashalante · 10/01/2023 11:16

@katseyes7

People turn up with just their phone, then shout at the poor soul sitting on the till because their shopping's over the limit, and the system won't accept their payment. Is it really too much effort to have your card with you?

I caused a pin drop silence in Tesco once. The till staff member was telling a woman that her shopping was over the limit. The woman was saying that she needs everything. There was a stalemate until I suggested splitting the products into two transactions.

It genuinely hadn’t occurred to either of them. Do you not tell customers they can split items into two transactions?

The lovely cashier at my local pharmacy did this for me, I was using Apple Pay but the pharmacy has a policy of needing a PIN for transactions over £30

Itschristmastimeinthecity · 10/01/2023 12:44

closingloop · 10/01/2023 12:36

Nobody mentioned local bank transfers, I have no idea why you would, costs of moving money internationally are insane, I have no idea if any bank would only charge 2%.

I was talking about a simple card transaction, put card in the machine, a small charge is made each time by the bank. These small charges add up and the original value of the £20 'disappears'.

OK I understands you now. That's just the handling fee though! The value of the £20 doesn't "disappear".
So you think banks just look after your business cash for free?
You will always pay a handling fee, it's one of those things that has to be accounted for when opening a business.
I'm sorry but that argument doesn't hold enough weight.

bringmetheheadofpastaalfredo · 10/01/2023 12:44

PlaitBilledDuckyPuss · 10/01/2023 12:39

You're completely missing the point. Every time you hand over your bank details, you are creating a route into your money, you are handing over data - and we all know how easily data can be breached, how there are lists of card numbers for sale on the dark web.

No, it can't be avoided altogether. But there's a difference between paying by card in, say, Sainsburys; where you would hope there'd be good controls in place, and paying by card at some tiny outlet - a random food van, say, where you have no idea whether it's legitimate or not.

As for my phone tracking me - we are not all slaves to our phones. Mine spends most of its time sitting at home, with the blue tooth and mobile data switched off. I don't need to be online all day, thanks. If I had to pay for things with my phone I might no longer have that choice.

No, you're missing the point. It's so easy to manouvere, you don't need to give your details at all!
I ahve a revolut account, it has a physical card and a virtual card on my phone. On the latter, every time I pay with it using my phone, it generates a new, one time use, card number. Nobody gets my bank account details, or my card details. Nobody can clone it or use it.

By not learning how to use these things properly and safely, you are shooting yourself in the foot. It's so easy to protect yourself from all those things your so worried about but don't actually bother to deal with.

And don't kid yourself that The Man can't find you a track you a thousand times over anyway!

Spidey66 · 10/01/2023 12:43

Even the Big Issue sellers in our area has card readers!!!

I prefer cards/phone use. I actually think it makes budgetting easier as I check my account online daily and can see exactly where my money is going. ''Bloody hell! I spent £30 down the pub last night! I need to rein my spending in sharpish!''

skyeisthelimit · 10/01/2023 12:43

If you want to budget then get a card like Revolut and just transfer over your spending money each week/month. You can track your spending on an app and see how much money you have left to spend. It is easy to top up. I use one for my daughter.

A lot of small businesses round here prefer cash due to the charges they have to pay when cards are used. Some are actively begging for cash to be used to save them money. However, cash can also cause a problem if they have an excess of it, as some banks charge a huge commission fee to bank cash now. So the small shops can't win.

I'm an accountant and I see bank statements where people are paying for every single drink in a pub, £3.80 several times in a night, whereas years ago they would have paid for one drink and then had cashback to pay for the rest. These transactions can often cost 20p per transaction plus a % depending on the card merchant that they use.

On the other hand, some pubs prefer cards because staff don't have to hand over change so there is less room for theft and errors.

Covid made a lot of people switch to cards when they had used cash for years and they just haven't gone back.

Ultimately a cashless society will prevent a lot of fraud and tax evasion as people won't be able to work for cash in hand. Every single payment will be tracked one way or another.

I agree that bartering will make more of a comeback as people will swap services to avoid recording the sale.

Swipe left for the next trending thread