Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MIL reaction to our proposal to begin fostering children. AIBU to find this upsetting?

562 replies

Happypomegranate · 27/12/2022 22:41

We FaceTimed our in-laws on Xmas day and mentioned our intention to apply to become foster carers. This is something we have both wanted to do for years, but have been previously unable due to work commitments and living in a small flat. We’ve been very fortunate and we now live in a big house and we are financially secure enough that I don’t have to work. I still do a little bit of part time care work but can give this up to focus on fostering. MIL initially said she thought our DD was too young which is a fair point to make. We have a toddler and will not be having anymore biological children. I said we would discuss with the LA but we could wait until DD was in school if necessary but that we just wanted to get the ball rolling as we know how long these things can take. But it later became apparent that she was very against the idea of us fostering at any point in the future and I don’t believe my DD’s age has anything to do with it. She used language such as ‘it will be someone you don’t know’, ‘there could be problems’, and ‘troubled children’. We have done our research and we are aware that the children may have additional needs, mental health and/or behavioural problems, but every child in need of a foster placement is different and I feel it’s not right to stereotype. As for children that may come with challenges, I feel it would be our job as the foster parents to try and work through the challenges with the children. I don’t understand why she doesn’t want us to support vulnerable children, it’s just bizarre to me. It hurts because I had an extremely abusive childhood, struggled with mental health in my early adulthood and I’ve worked really hard to get to a place where I am happy, stable and resilient. I feel I could have a lot to give as a foster carer. My DH is lovely and a great dad, and I believe he’d be a fantastic foster carer but he had a drastically different upbringing from me. Think well to-do, independent school, etc. We are an unlikely but very happy pair. I thought she would be supportive but she’s actively against it and I’m not sure why it bothers me so much because it’s ultimately my and my husbands decision to apply, not hers. AIBU to be upset?

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 17:45

Nobody is ‘using it against you.’ Because it isn’t about you. At all. It’s about the children and what’s best for them. It doesn’t matter if it makes you feel sad. It doesn’t matter if it offends you. It’s all about how it will or could impact the child. Not you. Your traumatic past matters only in so far as it could possibly impact the children. Whether or not that makes you unhappy isn’t their problem.

ClaretBarret · 28/12/2022 17:43

Happypomegranate · 28/12/2022 17:41

Oh no. Imagine taking abuse that happened to someone as a kid and using it against them when they go on to apply to support vulnerable children. I have been through it all to become a success in my own right. I was always open to waiting until DD is older. My problem was MIL’s outright objection to the idea and nothing to do with having to wait. I’ve been breaking barriers and tearing down walls my entire life, and I will continue to do so. Checking out now. Wish me luck.

We will wish any child who might be placed with you luck.

You have such a low chance of being approved though which is a good thing imo.

Look into secondary trauma, it’s something social workers are really hot on and with a trauma background yourself it will be even more of an uphill struggle to get approved

Happypomegranate · 28/12/2022 17:41

Oh no. Imagine taking abuse that happened to someone as a kid and using it against them when they go on to apply to support vulnerable children. I have been through it all to become a success in my own right. I was always open to waiting until DD is older. My problem was MIL’s outright objection to the idea and nothing to do with having to wait. I’ve been breaking barriers and tearing down walls my entire life, and I will continue to do so. Checking out now. Wish me luck.

OP posts:
Kanaloa · 28/12/2022 17:38

jamoncrumpets · 28/12/2022 17:22

My DD grew up with one of these bogeyman kids everyone on here seems so petrified of. Her big brother is autistic, has ADHD, SPD, learning disability, Tourette's. He's all she's ever known as he was nearly four when she was born and she loves him dearly. He loves her too. In fact I'd wager she's emotionally much more switched on than a lot of her peers because of him, and when I visited her class for a parent session recently I saw her playing so nicely with the kids who clearly had ADHD/SEN, including them and encouraging them.

If anything having a child with so many 'issues' has been a very positive experience for her. She know now that everybody has something to bring to the universe, no matter what.

And I know you'll come on now and tell me how having am autistic sibling messed you up for life, and I'm sorry that was YOUR experience. But we work hard with both of our children every day to give them the best we can.

That’s wonderful. Have you considered that it may be an entirely different situation for a toddler to experience a succession of entirely different traumatised people with vastly different issues in and out of her life?

My kids have a sibling with SEN who has his own challenges. Not at all comparable to if I suddenly decided to foster various traumatised children who may have suffered extreme abuse a short time after finishing my own trauma therapy.

Stripedbag101 · 28/12/2022 17:35

jamoncrumpets · 28/12/2022 17:22

My DD grew up with one of these bogeyman kids everyone on here seems so petrified of. Her big brother is autistic, has ADHD, SPD, learning disability, Tourette's. He's all she's ever known as he was nearly four when she was born and she loves him dearly. He loves her too. In fact I'd wager she's emotionally much more switched on than a lot of her peers because of him, and when I visited her class for a parent session recently I saw her playing so nicely with the kids who clearly had ADHD/SEN, including them and encouraging them.

If anything having a child with so many 'issues' has been a very positive experience for her. She know now that everybody has something to bring to the universe, no matter what.

And I know you'll come on now and tell me how having am autistic sibling messed you up for life, and I'm sorry that was YOUR experience. But we work hard with both of our children every day to give them the best we can.

it must be incredibly challenging and rewarding to foster this boy. All people are doing is trying to inject some realism into this.

Children like your foster son who have been separated from their birth parents for whatever reason will be impacted by that separation. They will bring a range of additional challenges into your home that foster parents have to be prepared for.

it sounds like you fostered this little bit before you had children of your own - and it sounds like a long term placement that is working well. That is amazing.

does the boy have contact with his family? Is reunification possible? I am sure that will be upsetting for your daughter.

endlesswinter · 28/12/2022 17:29

@jamoncrumpets I think you misunderstood the kind of issues that people are talking about here.
They aren't SEN, autism or Tourette's.

theparkisrising · 28/12/2022 17:28

Sorry, posted too soon. The little ones were extremely needy, wanting continuous attention, plus often we had to take them to contact with their birth parents every day, which meant a drive of 40 mins to contact centre. Wait for an hour and another 40 min drive back. It's relentless. We loved it as our children were grown up so we could make it our full time, 24/7 job. But I wouldn't have done it with my own children at home

Readabookgroucho · 28/12/2022 17:27

‘Some children needing fostering may be ‘troubled’, whereas others may not fit that label at all.’

your inexperience is showing, OP. These children are ALL ‘troubled’ for want of a better word. They’ve been separated from their parents. That’s traumatic for any child. Whether it’s because of illness, abuse, neglect or whatever

Readabookgroucho · 28/12/2022 17:24

Your DD is too young, the only person I know who was allowed to foster when her children were young ( and we’re talking the youngest being 6/7) was a VERY experienced social worker, who’s DH was a GP. They had a large house, and both came from happy, stable backgrounds.
Not to say you wouldn’t be able to but with your back ground they’ll want your child to be much older.
Have you considered taking a mother and baby? They look for supportive temp homes for young mothers who need early support, and having experience there will help.
As will any kind of volunteering with children, or in a school, or work in those areas.

jamoncrumpets · 28/12/2022 17:22

My DD grew up with one of these bogeyman kids everyone on here seems so petrified of. Her big brother is autistic, has ADHD, SPD, learning disability, Tourette's. He's all she's ever known as he was nearly four when she was born and she loves him dearly. He loves her too. In fact I'd wager she's emotionally much more switched on than a lot of her peers because of him, and when I visited her class for a parent session recently I saw her playing so nicely with the kids who clearly had ADHD/SEN, including them and encouraging them.

If anything having a child with so many 'issues' has been a very positive experience for her. She know now that everybody has something to bring to the universe, no matter what.

And I know you'll come on now and tell me how having am autistic sibling messed you up for life, and I'm sorry that was YOUR experience. But we work hard with both of our children every day to give them the best we can.

theparkisrising · 28/12/2022 17:21

We fostered for many years. We never had a child with us that didn't have challenges one way or the other. Never. The issues ranged from abusing our animals, abusing other children, setting fires, breaking things (every mirror in the house

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 17:19

FleasNavidad · 28/12/2022 17:11

Maybe fostering can work for families with young children, my point was really that you don't know the impact on your children yet. One is just a young teen and the other a mid-teen currently.

From your posts about struggles and difficulties faced over the years I suspect the negatives will far outweigh the positives for one or both of your biological children in the end. Something you might never even find out sadly as trauma is a tricky subject to unpick with your parents.

The OP is only recently getting extensive therapy for her own trauma, triggered by the addition of her daughter. Her MIL is entirely correct and I think that she should be put off from applying to protect her young child.

Thanks for the balance. I can't say what will emerge in the future with my own children. I expect and hope that they will continue to give a balanced view of the impact. Fostering was a formative experience for both of them and they continue to have positive relationships with several children that went on to be adopted. It is clearly not for everyone but, in the right circumstances, can be an amazing role with amazing outcomes.

FleasNavidad · 28/12/2022 17:11

Maybe fostering can work for families with young children, my point was really that you don't know the impact on your children yet. One is just a young teen and the other a mid-teen currently.

From your posts about struggles and difficulties faced over the years I suspect the negatives will far outweigh the positives for one or both of your biological children in the end. Something you might never even find out sadly as trauma is a tricky subject to unpick with your parents.

The OP is only recently getting extensive therapy for her own trauma, triggered by the addition of her daughter. Her MIL is entirely correct and I think that she should be put off from applying to protect her young child.

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 17:09

Stripedbag101 · 28/12/2022 16:35

Yes the calling from God really worried me - and the subsequent lying to get accepted.

the daughter probably feels pressured into saying fostering was the right thing to do. From @Petros9 posts even he was aware that divergent views would be an issue in his home: for example they avoided issues around their views on homosexuality by only
fostering young children.

I don’t think this was a home where children are allowed to be themselves, find their own voice and express their own views

Again, thanks for reading the AMA thread.

Looking after the vulnerable is a Biblical calling. If Christians didn't follow that call in pretty large numbers, we'd be even more short of carers. We didn't lie to get approved, but we did change the emphasis about our motivations.

My daughter doesn't say it was the right thing to do. She knows she had no choice in it and that it was difficult for her and her brother at times. She's got a balanced view of the pros and cons which she shares with anyone who is interested. I wouldn't criticise the way you have raised your children, even if I knew a lot more about their upbringing than you know about mine.

Sorry to be a little defensive.

Chickychoccyegg · 28/12/2022 17:06

I have a close family member who is a Foster carer, with a young dc of their own (now started school), yes she has had some troubled dc with her and some who have no issues, and have slotted into her family.
She is a very calm, kind person, and is a fantastic Foster carer, at the moment she has a small baby , she recently had a teenager for 18 months, who is back with their parents, if you feel strongly that you and your dh want to try it , then you should at least look into it.

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 16:57

FleasNavidad · 28/12/2022 16:29

@Petros9

Your daughter is only 14 yet you describe her as an older teen who is proud of what your family did. I know she's lost her mum a year ago and may seem proud and wise now but there's likely some bottled up stuff to be dealt with in the future.

She's known nothing other than sharing her home with foster children, all of them traumatised, and her parents not recognising that even the babies were so.

You're also saying the OP won't have much issue getting accepted but fully admit that you were turned down on your first application because you did it due to a calling from God that you weren't actually keen on! You didn't tell the truth on your second application so that they'd accept you.

Thanks for reading the AMA thread.

To clarify, I have an older son too. He does remember a pre-fostering time. Both children are quite balanced in their analysis of the impact of fostering on their lives. Our bereavement ended our fostering but it has not made any difference to the experience we had. I am not trying to say that there are no negatives, just to add some balance by highlighting that there are positives too. This thread is so full of negativity about fostering and its impact, as well as being unduly negative about the OP in my view.

In terms of traumatised babies, I would repeat what I said earlier in that there may have been underlying trauma but that the newborns we looked after were not complicated to care for. I am saying that fostering a baby, as the OP would probably do, is in most ways more straightforward than fostering an obviously traumatised older child. You make it sound as though we were ignorant of the circumstances when that is not a fair representation. I'm well aware of the difficulties that children in care face but I still think that fostering families are best placed to look after them. This thread would seek to put anyone off fostering and again I am trying to add some balance.

Finally, in terms of approval, I don't know whether the OP would be approved but I think she shouldn't be put off from applying. We did struggle with the calling and we had to count the cost. I would say the way we got round it in the end with social services was by minimising the religious part rather than by lying. Lots of fc are Christians and they do an amazing job.

So I think your summary of our experience is a little unfair overall. It's clearly not the popular view here, but fostering can work for families with young children, babies in care are not always difficult to look after and sometimes people should be encouraged to at least apply rather than being scared off by negative input.

Thanks.

PollyPut · 28/12/2022 16:47

I would think that MIL is hoping for a second grandchild - a lifelong sibling for her GD.

This is not what she was expecting. Your own DD is going to take a lot of your energy and she is rightly concerned about whether you will have enough time for her if you are taking on additional children.

Nordix · 28/12/2022 16:44

Stripedbag101 · 27/12/2022 23:37

OP I think this is you

www.mumsnet.com/talk/fostering/4705809-birth-child-is-two-is-she-too-young-to-start-fostering

if so, you were a foster child yourself so no doubt are upset by your MIL’s reaction.

BUT - you need to do a lot more research. A lot. Speak to people, volunteer, read books, speak to some more people. You are coming across as incredibly naive.

Interesting.

Everyone in that thread said your daughter was too young, too, OP. Including foster parents who fostered while their children were young, and said they would do it differently knowing what they know now.

Lots of foster carers and adjacent professionals are giving up their time to share advice and experiences, and you are ignoring all of them. This doesn’t bode well at all. To be a foster carer you have to be open to listen to the experience of others and learn new things. There’s a lot of training. Sometimes the hardest thing is accepting what you don’t know.

You won’t get very far in the process with your current attitude, and I mean that kindly.

If so many experienced people are advising you against, why are you so keen to inflict the situation on your own child, and on foster children, regardless?

In ten years, your child would be older, you’d have more life experience as a parent, you’d be further along with your own therapy, and have a quiet home + more to offer to foster children.

Even outside of the context of fostering - ask any parent of a teen+ if they knew what parenting was about when their first child was 2, and they’d give a wry chuckle. You have a lot of life experience still to accrue.

Stripedbag101 · 28/12/2022 16:35

FleasNavidad · 28/12/2022 16:29

@Petros9

Your daughter is only 14 yet you describe her as an older teen who is proud of what your family did. I know she's lost her mum a year ago and may seem proud and wise now but there's likely some bottled up stuff to be dealt with in the future.

She's known nothing other than sharing her home with foster children, all of them traumatised, and her parents not recognising that even the babies were so.

You're also saying the OP won't have much issue getting accepted but fully admit that you were turned down on your first application because you did it due to a calling from God that you weren't actually keen on! You didn't tell the truth on your second application so that they'd accept you.

Yes the calling from God really worried me - and the subsequent lying to get accepted.

the daughter probably feels pressured into saying fostering was the right thing to do. From @Petros9 posts even he was aware that divergent views would be an issue in his home: for example they avoided issues around their views on homosexuality by only
fostering young children.

I don’t think this was a home where children are allowed to be themselves, find their own voice and express their own views

2ndTimeRound90 · 28/12/2022 16:32

Happypomegranate · 28/12/2022 15:41

I am fully aware, probably more than the majority of posters on here even, of the realities of children from a care background. Furthermore who leaves their child unsupervised with their dog, never mind their foster child……? That’s so irresponsible of them.

Spoken as a parent of one child 🤣🤣

FleasNavidad · 28/12/2022 16:29

@Petros9

Your daughter is only 14 yet you describe her as an older teen who is proud of what your family did. I know she's lost her mum a year ago and may seem proud and wise now but there's likely some bottled up stuff to be dealt with in the future.

She's known nothing other than sharing her home with foster children, all of them traumatised, and her parents not recognising that even the babies were so.

You're also saying the OP won't have much issue getting accepted but fully admit that you were turned down on your first application because you did it due to a calling from God that you weren't actually keen on! You didn't tell the truth on your second application so that they'd accept you.

Stripedbag101 · 28/12/2022 16:28

Happypomegranate · 28/12/2022 15:41

I am fully aware, probably more than the majority of posters on here even, of the realities of children from a care background. Furthermore who leaves their child unsupervised with their dog, never mind their foster child……? That’s so irresponsible of them.

I am not sure you can be real.

are you honestly saying that on one hand you don’t believe Foster children can hurt your child (because you don’t buy into that narrative) but on the other hand you will never leave your child or family pet alone with the foster child?

either this is all a fantasy or you are very mixed up and really not a suitable person to give a stable and understanding home to a vulnerable child.

your personal experiences also do not make you more knowledgable than the social workers and experienced foster parents who have given advice on this thread . That is an incredibly immature viewpoint.

but express these views during your assessment. See how they are received.

Burgoo · 28/12/2022 16:24

I've worked with many foster children/teenagers over the years and was in the system and I can tell you, this is NOT easy. Many (possibly even most) are very troubled (and I use that term as politely as I can) and if you think its "just a bit of naughty behaviour" then you are going to be in for a shock. These individuals are always traumatised, neglected, treated terribly. They don't get taken away for "no reason".

That behaviour will leak into every area of your life. You may have to deal with traumatising self-injury, aggression, attachment problems, run-aways, verbal fights, passivity, eating disorders and any other number of problems. That is without the additional issues associated with drugs, gangs etc. This is the real lived experience of many foster families, it is NOT easy.

Even if the young person is an absolute dream and the model foster kid, the system damages them, often beyond repair. You must remember that if you are not adopting, they will eventually leave and each time they leave that is another attachment broken. I have huge respect for foster carers, social workers and these individual children/teenagers and at the same time I am not going to sugar coat it. Fostering/adoption is NEVER ideal and always traumatic - often for all involved.

ClaretBarret · 28/12/2022 16:24

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 16:22

The last part of this is not correct in my experience. Having a young child does not bar you from fostering, though it makes it likely that you would start with a baby (no bad thing as most of the horror stories on this thread involve troubled older foster children). Your own life experiences may not be a barrier either (sometimes can be a help) and the views of your relatives will be of limited relevance (though you will need a support network of some sort.)

This is from my experience of being approved as a fc with a 3 year old daughter, a wife on anti-depressants and sceptical parents. We fostered for 10 years and, alongside the way we raised our own children, it was our proudest achievement.

Having a toddler definitely will be a block for the OP, thankfully things have changed a lot since you went through the approval process. With the situation you describe you wouldn’t have been approved now.

Petros9 · 28/12/2022 16:22

ClaretBarret · 28/12/2022 15:48

This is one of those comments you’ll look back on a laugh at if you’re ever approved to foster.

Tbh it’s something you’ll laugh at when your child gets to 7, you think anyone monitors children 24/7?

you’ll have multiple children in your home, you won’t be watching them every minute of every day.

As said, you’re unlikely to be approved they will take into account your MILs views and your background plus young child means it’s pretty much a no.

The last part of this is not correct in my experience. Having a young child does not bar you from fostering, though it makes it likely that you would start with a baby (no bad thing as most of the horror stories on this thread involve troubled older foster children). Your own life experiences may not be a barrier either (sometimes can be a help) and the views of your relatives will be of limited relevance (though you will need a support network of some sort.)

This is from my experience of being approved as a fc with a 3 year old daughter, a wife on anti-depressants and sceptical parents. We fostered for 10 years and, alongside the way we raised our own children, it was our proudest achievement.

Swipe left for the next trending thread