Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not fully understand the outrage of the gender recognition reform?

419 replies

iamop · 22/12/2022 23:36

Leaving my views at the door on this subject....I am just hoping to gain some clarification on one main point for my own information.

Opponents of the gender reform bill claim that this will effect single sex spaces. I was appalled hearing this but I've done some reading. And it would seem (unless I'm getting this wrong) that due to the equality act 2010, a man claiming to be a female or vice versa can already use single sex spaces due to gender identity being a protected characteristic under this act. And as the equality act is a UK wide legislation implemented under labour, this has nothing to do with the Scottish gov. So am I correct in saying, that actually the gender reform bill won't actually affect single sex spaces any more so than the equality act already does?

I completely disagree with rapists etc being able to change genders and therefore force their victims and the courts to call them by a different pronoun. I think the age of 16 to be able to do this is bonkers, and I think the SNP have lost my vote moving forward.

I was just looking for some clarification to my main point above to be explained by people smarter than myself

Thanks

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Waitwhat23 · 24/12/2022 15:32

My comment about the MOJ was meant very much as a criticism of the decision made.

LangClegsInSpace · 24/12/2022 15:24

GentlySobbing · 23/12/2022 21:29

The EHRC guidance posted below is new, and published after the appointment of Akua Reindorf's appointment as an EHRC commissioner. Reindorf is not a gender adherent, and her appointment led to a notable change in EHRC policy (on a side note she has today been appointed a KC, so huge congratulations due to her).

The EHRC's previous advice contained a little table which set out how service providers should treat people who have undergone gender reassignment without a GRC, and those that have. The advice was that excluding a male with a GRC from a women's single sex service was a very high bar to reach, and was higher than the bar for excluding those without a GRC. So technically legally possible (as per Sch 3 of the EA), but unlikely to happen in practice. Possession of a GRC therefore, under that guidance, led to a change in ability to be admitted to women's spaces.

This advice then filtered down to policy makers, meaning that it is a common position that GRC holders cannot be excluded from single sex spaces. This is the relevant clause of the Ministry of Justice's policy (upheld last year at judicial review) for the treatment of GRC holders:

‘4.64 The Gender Recognition Act 2004 section 9 says that when a full GRC is issued to a person, the person’s gender becomes, for all purposes, their acquired gender. This means that transgender women prisoners with GRCs must be treated in the same way as biological women for all purposes. Transgender women with GRCs must be placed in the women’s estate/AP unless there are exceptional circumstances, as would be the case for biological women.'

So the EHRC's current guidance on what service providers can legally do is not having an effect on what service providers are actually doing. Possibly because it is still very new, but more likely because it gives service providers a nice clean line for policy making ("GRC = in. Bish bash bosh").

The other issue with the recent guidance is that it's non-statutary and it contradicts the older statutory code, which has a higher status in law.

A while back, EHRC said they also intend to produce new statutory code but I haven't heard anything else about that. Presumably there will be a consultation at some point.

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 15:06

The MOJ judicial review basically said that women's safety, dignity and well being is simply less important than transwomen prisoners having the opportunity to socialise with women.

I really wish posters would own their political agendas. It is very clear to anyone who has read widely about this, anyone who has listened to female prisioners in the UK and USA or listened to Rhona Hotchkiss who has been prioritised and who has been told to suck any distress or harm they feel or encounter.

Let us not forget the rate of sexually abused women or women victims of male violence who are in these prisons. And we have had rapes, we have also had Scottish women make statements that some males have been upfront about getting into the female estate for sex.

Regardless of whether a male believes wholeheartedly they are a woman or whether they are intact or not. When there is the potential for women to be harmed in any way, not males should be in with them.

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 14:59

Thank you FOJN I am away from my desktop and it is very hard to find and post links where I am.

Waitwhat23 · 24/12/2022 14:58

HMP Downview. It was heartily disliked by trans prisoners. It also took away space in the female estate which (I believe) had been previously earmarked to improve the facilities for female prisoners.

The MOJ judicial review basically said that women's safety, dignity and well being is simply less important than transwomen prisoners having the opportunity to socialise with women.

Resources, services and spaces for women are simply seen as something to be exploited by people who see women as service humans and human shields.

FOJN · 24/12/2022 14:57

A new facility was built and was rejected by the trans lobby groups. I can go find the name of the facility if you like.

www.prisonphone.co.uk/blog/hmp-downview-the-first-prison-with-a-wing-dedicated-to-transgender-inmates/

Of course it's never been about safety, it's always been about access to women either to abuse us or in settings outside prison to use us as props to validate someone's gender feels.

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 14:48

aseriesofstillimages · 24/12/2022 12:43

You say that a trans woman who has committed sexual offences against women shouldn’t be placed in a women’s prison, and I agree.

On the other hand, I think that a trans woman who transitioned 20 years ago, has had full gender reassignment surgery, has been a victim of sexual violence at the hands of men, and is in prison for financial fraud, should clearly be in a women’s prison.

The are many cases in between that are less clear cut. The important thing is careful risk assessment.

And your approach neglects the very important fact that women can generally tell who is male and who is not.

Therefore ‘your’ approach simply says to women who have been traumatised by male violence against women and girls that you couldn’t give a shit about their needs and would prioritise a male over them.

A male who has no penis is still a male! And it is likely to cause a female distress. Obviously not you. But you don’t count as you are not one of those in prison being forced to share. What a fucking privileged position you have?

There are already vulnerable male prisoner estates. Why do you choose to ignore this? A new facility was built and was rejected by the trans lobby groups. I can go find the name of the facility if you like.

Just own your opinion. You choose male prioritisation over female. I believe you always have done on the FWR board.

LangClegsInSpace · 24/12/2022 14:46

AWaferThinMint · 23/12/2022 10:40

I'm just baffled how declaring a "gender" now means you can change your actual sex in laws self ID as whatever you like but muddling reality in law will not go well. (Ex legal bod). It makes no sense to me.

I'd be interested to see the definitions section of the bill. How are they defining the terms they've enshrined in law?

I'm a long way behind so this may already have been answered. In the current GRA we have:

“the acquired gender” is to be construed in accordance with section 1(2),

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/7/section/25

Section 1(2) says:

In this Act “the acquired gender”, in relation to a person by whom an application under subsection (1) is or has been made, means—

(a)in the case of an application under paragraph (a) of that subsection, the gender in which the person is living, or

(b)in the case of an application under paragraph (b) of that subsection, the gender to which the person has changed under the law of the country or territory concerned.

www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2004/7/section/1

No further definitions of gender, sex, man or woman are provided.

FOJN · 24/12/2022 14:35

Defenders of the GRR claim that self-ID has passed in other countries with no problems for women but this is lies- there have been plenty of documented harms in those countries.

I post the following links fairly regularly because they are such a good resource for news about how gender ideology is affecting women and children around the world.

www.womenarehuman.com/

reduxx.info/

And this is how proponents of self ID claim it's causing no harm in other countries:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4700477-no-evidence-to-suggest-abuse-of-self-id

Helleofabore · 24/12/2022 14:29

I may be totally wrong and that is also okay. If you want to talk about my thoughts please feel free to DM me.

Please understand readers, it is not standard practice to ask people to DM them to ‘talk about’ thoughts. Please be very careful with this. It is unusual behaviour to take discussion ‘off board’.

Also a sure sign that posters have a political agenda and cannot support their opinions with evidence. At all. It all hinges on emotional manipulation. There is absolutely nothing else.

YouSetTheTone · 24/12/2022 14:27

I haven’t read the whole thread, apologies. But has ONE SINGLE person managed to successfully show that this legislation isn’t harmful to women and girls?

Defenders of the GRR claim that self-ID has passed in other countries with no problems for women but this is lies- there have been plenty of documented harms in those countries.

Jaxhog · 24/12/2022 14:22

"This could easily be fixed by making clear that sex and gender are distinct and currently there is only a legal reason to discriminate on sex not gender so even with a grc you would not be allowed into single sex spaces

Further problem I think is the reinforcement of stereotypes in children."

Absolutely correct - and it isn't just children who will get indoctrinated about gender stereotypes. As someone old enough to remember just how biased Uk society used to be e.g. having to get my DH's signature on my tax return and being turned down for a management job because 'the men wouldn't like it' (really!), I find the return to outdated stereotypes quite depressing. It feels like the last 50 years were wasted effort in trying to achieve female equality.

TonTonMacoute · 24/12/2022 14:21

There are trans women who oppose this legislation, who are happy to be trans women and to accept they will never be anything other than biologically male.

Debbie Hayton wrote an article about autogynephilia (gratification from perceiving oneself as a woman) and she considers that many (if not most) trans women are autogynephiliac and genuine, ‘born in the wrong body’ trans women are a minority. She admitted that she couldn’t honestly say that she wasn’t autogynephiliac herself.

Back in the 60s my grandmother was good friends with Roberta Cowell, Britain’s first transsexual M2F. She absolutely felt that she was female and had the full surgical transition, which was illegal at that time. The surgeon who performed the operation was her friend who was a trans man. It’s an amazing story.

It is not necessary to obliterate women’s sex-based rights and protections to ensure trans people can live as they wish. Women are already being persecuted, hounded, even threatened with prison for airing their opinions, these politicians want to expose them to even more harm at the behest of a tiny very vocal minority. The fact that the main fuss centres around trans women (ie men) speaks volumes.

Skyellaskerry · 24/12/2022 14:19

2bazookas · 24/12/2022 13:41

It's got fuck all to do with gender dysphoria.

It's all about Independence. The SNP has created a raging-boil of corrupt legislation to force a head on collision with Westminster . Westminster will lance the GRA boil to avoid social chaos. SNP hope this will promote a political division that results in a Referendum and a Yes vote.

In fact they've shot themselves in the foot. Already, women in Scotland are outraged at how the GRA has been shoved hrough. We ain;t seen nothing yet. Self-ID (full set of new ID) is set to become a social, legal, financial nightmare for the whole of Scotland and far beyond. Ultimately the death knell of politicians who supported it.

Butterfingers Keir just dropped his woke ball down the sewer. Probably just handed Sunak the next election.

Good points, not surprised about KS though, especially given the support from Scottish labour for the bill. Not that long ago on Mumsnet there was a Q&A with him and Bridget Phillipson and so many questions submitted were on this, hope he saw them but doubt it. Labour is not listening, they are not reading the room, and they will lose support. And the Tories are hearing and will make political gain from it, especially as they’ve not got much to go on elsewhere, and despite all this happening in their watch these last 12 years.

FOJN · 24/12/2022 14:16

Hopefully this sort of progressive authoritarianism gets rolled back in 2023 but Sunak is weak and Starmer looks like he will sign up to it

Starmer is fully committed to enacting the same legislation if Labour win the next election. He's been full on TWAW since he became party leader. Many lefty women feel politically homeless.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4704243-telegraph-keir-starmer-pro-trans-laws-are-needed-across-uk

Looks like Sunak may well support action to block the Scottish GRR which will go down like a cup of cold sick with the SNP and start a war which may end up with the break up of the union.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4703411-secretary-of-state-for-scotland-looking-at-using-westminster-powers-to-overule-gender-recognition-bill

The whole thing is a shit show of badly thought out legislation.

Get yourself over to the petitions board, there are a couple of relevant petitions to sign and share.

verystablegenius · 24/12/2022 14:08

ManAboutTown · 24/12/2022 14:07

Only just picked up on this thread and haven't read the whole thing but extremely gratifying to see that the vast majority of views here coincide with my own

Women and, particularly, girls are entitled to their private areas, sports teams and so on. And as for the demonisation of lesbians - words fail me

Hopefully this sort of progressive authoritarianism gets rolled back in 2023 but Sunak is weak and Starmer looks like he will sign up to it

I agree, I worry for my daughter

Userg1234 · 24/12/2022 14:07

I am male. It is ridiculous that I could claim to be female if I get arrested and must then be held as a female prisioner. With no checks, no protection for my female cell mate.
at a local school there is a 16 year old but who turns up in a dress when he feels like it...fair play for breaking down clothing taboos and if when he is older and fully matured physically and mentally I would agree he should be able to undergo surgery to become a women. But I wouldn't want him in the girls changing room

ManAboutTown · 24/12/2022 14:07

Only just picked up on this thread and haven't read the whole thing but extremely gratifying to see that the vast majority of views here coincide with my own

Women and, particularly, girls are entitled to their private areas, sports teams and so on. And as for the demonisation of lesbians - words fail me

Hopefully this sort of progressive authoritarianism gets rolled back in 2023 but Sunak is weak and Starmer looks like he will sign up to it

FOJN · 24/12/2022 14:02

It's got fuck all to do with gender dysphoria.

Neither has being trans these days, in fact activists would call you transphobic for suggesting it does.

2bazookas · 24/12/2022 13:57

ChaToilLeam · 23/12/2022 12:19

This is grim for Scotland. I think Sturgeon may have overplayed her hand though. While the whip ensured that it was supported by the majority of MPs (shame on them all) it is not popular with the electorate in general. I know many independence supporters who no longer support the SNP and would welcome Westminster intervention on this. Which will surely now come.

I completely agree.
This piece of legislation will be the final nail in the SNP coffin.
I voted "Yes" last time. I'll never vote SNP again.

verystablegenius · 24/12/2022 13:52

We don’t and we can’t

Thanks. It does seem that many of these issues are ultimately manageable through better research and monitoring

OneTC · 24/12/2022 13:47

The fact is FEELING vulnerable doesn't mean you ARE vulnerable. I think we need to move away from this idea that "if I feel something it is valid" to a more objective, measured "knowledge".

The irony

SamphirethePogoingStickerist · 24/12/2022 13:42

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 13:18

Fair enough. Do we know what percentage of transwomen are sex offenders?

We don't and can't. Firstly we have no idea how many transwomen there are in the UK - see the Stonewall definition for some idea of the problem.

Then the sex of offenders are recorded according to declaration - see various media reports, court appearances and ONS statements about not being able to supply stats by sex now gender has entered the mix. For example men with a GRC committing sex crimes are arrested, tried, sentenced and imprisoned as females.

And then see again the issues around who is imprisoned as a women because they make a statement, no GRC required.

This is already happening, as though Self ID already exists. You can start to see it in the ONS data now, if you choose to assume that some male crimes are recorded as female ones rather than women are suddenly committing increasing numbers of sex crimes. But we cannot know, as some data is just not recorded.

2bazookas · 24/12/2022 13:41

Blueberrywitch · 23/12/2022 08:33

It blows my mind that the most stereotypical “sensible and practical” nation of Scots, the birthplace of the enlightenment, has passed this insanity.

It's got fuck all to do with gender dysphoria.

It's all about Independence. The SNP has created a raging-boil of corrupt legislation to force a head on collision with Westminster . Westminster will lance the GRA boil to avoid social chaos. SNP hope this will promote a political division that results in a Referendum and a Yes vote.

In fact they've shot themselves in the foot. Already, women in Scotland are outraged at how the GRA has been shoved hrough. We ain;t seen nothing yet. Self-ID (full set of new ID) is set to become a social, legal, financial nightmare for the whole of Scotland and far beyond. Ultimately the death knell of politicians who supported it.

Butterfingers Keir just dropped his woke ball down the sewer. Probably just handed Sunak the next election.

FOJN · 24/12/2022 13:39

HappinessAlley · 24/12/2022 13:18

Fair enough. Do we know what percentage of transwomen are sex offenders?

We have no idea how many transwomen there are but of the prison population we know that 50 - 60% of transwomen in prison have at least one conviction for sexual offences. In the general male prison population 15 - 20% are sex offenders. Approx 2% of the female prison population are sex offenders.

Do you think it's possible that sexual predators are pretending to be trans? The problem with self ID is that they are trans if they say so and there is nothing you can do to prove otherwise. The risk assessment tool used for male sex offenders isn't used for transwomen for some inexplicable reason which is how a male sex offender ended up in a female prison where they raped and sexually assaulted 4 women within a matter of days.

Swipe left for the next trending thread