Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Told I was 'phobic' for not using pronouns!

684 replies

NewStartIn50s · 08/12/2022 17:48

Asked for my preferred pronouns and I said ' I don't use them', pushed on what I use to refer to myself and I said I don't use on emails or when I introduce myself or at all. Apparently, if I use them I am showing inclusivity to others and being accepting. I'm not quite a dinosaur yet but why are these things forced on us. I don't have a beard (yet) and I think you can tell what I am/but does it really matter if you can't.

So AIBU

YANBU - don't have to use pronouns if you don't want to

YABU - you should state what your preferred pronouns are

OP posts:
nolongersurprised · 08/12/2022 20:58

Dreamwhisper · 08/12/2022 20:56

You've completely missed the point of my post, please read it again.

It wasn’t written very clearly, all I could really work out was that “also” seemed to be doing some very heavy lifting.

Undaunted77 · 08/12/2022 20:58

smile enigmatically and say I’m not ready to out myself

thepenismightier · 08/12/2022 20:57

orzoisorange · 08/12/2022 18:05

Because it gives unwarranted endorsement to a load of bollocks?

Ha! Very well said.

Dreamwhisper · 08/12/2022 20:56

nolongersurprised · 08/12/2022 20:48

If you use the pretty universally accepted fact that "men can't become women" to assert your views when called out, but what you've also been doing is denigrating and shaming trans people for existing though, that would be bigoted, no?

It’s true that men can’t become women, it’s not shaming or denigrating transwomen to acknowledge this. Be Kind is one thing, but having to reject reality discomfits me.

Acknowledging biological reality isn’t a segue into denigrating and shaming transpeople. Not parroting TWAW isn’t political, it’s ok not to believe something that isn’t true.

I find it very immature when the “bigot” and “far right” insults come out when people refuse to capitulate to gender woo. Adults are allowed to have a range of beliefs, we’re not 10 and having to pick some sort of side in the playground. Transwomen are not women, they are transwomen. This isn’t political, it’s not literal violence not to believe it and it’s not kind to pretend that people can change sex.

You've completely missed the point of my post, please read it again.

SammyScrounge · 08/12/2022 20:56

Shoxfordian · 08/12/2022 17:53

How hard would it be to just say she/her? 🙄

I hate looking absurd

Cailleachian · 08/12/2022 20:54

This is both direct sex discrimination and gender assignment discrimination.

Would they demand to know which race people identified as at the start of every meeting? Or their religion? Why do they require that you identify with a gender, make it public and have it enforced in every meeting.

I would say see a union, but....ya know.

Happyher · 08/12/2022 20:54

Just say ‘isn’t it obvious?’

electricdreaming · 08/12/2022 20:51

RichardMarxisinnocent · 08/12/2022 20:18

I can’t believe there’s some people on here saying they never use pronouns. You’ve never referred to someone as she/her/he/him/they?
If course I use those pronouns to refer to other people. But if someone asks me what pronouns I use, they're not asking me what I use about others, they're asking about what I use for myself. And the only pronouns I use about myself are I and me, I never use she/her/he/him/they/them about myself (and I don't care which of them people use about me)

That’s fair enough. I don’t think “what pronouns do you use” is the best wording. Maybe the question should be “what pronouns would you prefer” and then those who have a preference can say so, and those who don’t can say they don’t mind and are happy to be referred to by any pronouns.

DoorKeyPad · 08/12/2022 20:50

I’d tell them it is private and them forcing you is forcing you to our yourself when you are not ready and that’s harassment

LimeTwists · 08/12/2022 20:49

I say ‘I’m a woman.’ I am not interested in playing their silly games with pronouns because doing so would confirm that I accept that we can just pick and choose our sex (because he / she has always referred to immutable biological sex, no matter how much ideologists try to replace it with the woolly concept of ‘gender’). It would also confirm that I believe that ‘gender’ is not just a godawful set of regressive sexist stereotypes and that if we don’t fit them it means our gendered souls were somehow ‘allocated’ by a midwife to the wrong bodies.

‘Transphobic’ used to mean hatred or fear of trans people. Now it apparently means asking any sort of question at all or showing signs of scepticism of any part of gender ideology.

You are not transphobic. You are a woman and a logical, sensible person who can clearly see reality. So can all of the people who have no problems at all in looking at you and seeing you are a she / her, which we have done successfully as human beings for thousands of years until a group of people decided we could pick our sexes after birth.

What to say when asked which pronouns you use

GCautist · 08/12/2022 20:49

Just make up random noises and expect them to be used in the right context without further explanation as you don’t owe anyone the emotional energy of educating them

nolongersurprised · 08/12/2022 20:48

If you use the pretty universally accepted fact that "men can't become women" to assert your views when called out, but what you've also been doing is denigrating and shaming trans people for existing though, that would be bigoted, no?

It’s true that men can’t become women, it’s not shaming or denigrating transwomen to acknowledge this. Be Kind is one thing, but having to reject reality discomfits me.

Acknowledging biological reality isn’t a segue into denigrating and shaming transpeople. Not parroting TWAW isn’t political, it’s ok not to believe something that isn’t true.

I find it very immature when the “bigot” and “far right” insults come out when people refuse to capitulate to gender woo. Adults are allowed to have a range of beliefs, we’re not 10 and having to pick some sort of side in the playground. Transwomen are not women, they are transwomen. This isn’t political, it’s not literal violence not to believe it and it’s not kind to pretend that people can change sex.

HatThatWearsYou · 08/12/2022 20:47

Compelled speech and TWAW ideology (which really does exist) leads to this:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4175263--No-Trans-Olympian-List-of-women-and-girls-disadvantaged-in-sport-resource-thread

and

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3348290-It-will-never-happen-resource-thread

Being open minded is great, being so open minded brains fall out not so much.

Women and children are being harmed by the ideology of which preferred pronouns are the thin end of the wedge. Women are excluded by the ideology and told that it's important for them to "be kind and inclusive", all the while being compelled, threatened with job loss, being attacked for speaking out about reasonable concerns and ostracised or even being arrested on spurious claims.

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 08/12/2022 20:46

waterlego · 08/12/2022 20:42

Absolutely. So almost all women, I imagine 😂

Whereas my husband puts the baby to bed and does the washing up before he sits down.
Good thing he doesn't Id as female at work though because money is tight and we could do without the pay cut lol!

waterlego · 08/12/2022 20:42

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 08/12/2022 20:39

Surely Iding as a male behind closed doors is just taking your bra off, climbing into sweats and avoiding the housework?

Absolutely. So almost all women, I imagine 😂

TillyTheTeddy · 08/12/2022 20:39

CountZacular · 08/12/2022 20:31

Male manager*.

I don’t own a male.

😂😂😂

YouScumbagYouMaggotHeresKevinTheCarrot · 08/12/2022 20:39

Surely Iding as a male behind closed doors is just taking your bra off, climbing into sweats and avoiding the housework?

LigPatin · 08/12/2022 20:39

People who put their pronouns in their signatures (social media, email etc) are generally the same people who put filters over their facebook photo to show their support for the NHS/Red Cross/[insert political/social movement here]

ie. the type to jump on the bandwagon for show, but rarely contributing to the actual cause

waterlego · 08/12/2022 20:37

@HipTightOnions, I don’t understand that either. I tend to think the idea of ‘living as’ a man/woman is nonsense, but the only way I can make any sense of it at all is to assume people are referring to stereotypes, so ‘living as a woman’ would involve using a woman’s name and wearing clothes designed for or more typically associated with women. Maybe showing an interest in things commonly assumed to be popular with women, such as dancing, shopping, gossiping, drinking cocktails etc. (Obviously goes without saying that a great many women here on MN and elsewhere are not interested in such things).

So what does that look like behind closed doors? Just doing those things when you’re at home so the only person to witness it is yourself and whoever you live with? Meaningless, IMO.

ScrawlyEmbroidery · 08/12/2022 20:36

I have no issue with people's gender preferences, but I am failing to see why it is of utmost importance to be brought up in every situation, even when it isn't relevant.
By the inclusivity argument, then surely I should sign off my emails with Vegan / Agnostic / Pro-Choice etc etc

AgathaMystery · 08/12/2022 20:36

Tinseltosser · 08/12/2022 20:35

Wrong of me maybe but I instantly think less of the intelligence of anyone with pronouns in their bios/email signatures. I know many who’ve said the same.

I mean, you can instantly tell they are the type to knee jerk react to anything asked of them if they think it may make them look kind/good, and not think too deeply past that even when faced with evidence of problems with the approach.

The kind who never really question going with the flow and so ignore any uncomfortable facts that don’t fit the narrative they currently follow, either through laziness (‘I don’t need to worry about this, someone higher up has already decided so it must be fine’s or through dogmatic ignorance (‘That fact/opinion makes me have to think about my beliefs, I feel vulnerable to being swayed. I’ll react with anger to chase it away or stick my fingers in my ears’).

This is exactly how I feel.

Waitwhat23 · 08/12/2022 20:36

For those who say 'it's not compulsory - no one is making you', I imagine the staff at the Scottish Government who are told that they will be 'encouraged' and 'educated' to add pronouns despite the majority stating that they did not wish to add them in a poll feel rather restricted in declining to add pronouns, for fear of their employment prospects -

www.holyrood.com/news/view,majority-of-scottish-government-civil-servants-say-theyll-never-add-pronouns-to-their-email-signatures

If my workplace ever asks, my answer will be no. I don't agree with compelled speech.

Tinseltosser · 08/12/2022 20:35

Wrong of me maybe but I instantly think less of the intelligence of anyone with pronouns in their bios/email signatures. I know many who’ve said the same.

I mean, you can instantly tell they are the type to knee jerk react to anything asked of them if they think it may make them look kind/good, and not think too deeply past that even when faced with evidence of problems with the approach.

The kind who never really question going with the flow and so ignore any uncomfortable facts that don’t fit the narrative they currently follow, either through laziness (‘I don’t need to worry about this, someone higher up has already decided so it must be fine’s or through dogmatic ignorance (‘That fact/opinion makes me have to think about my beliefs, I feel vulnerable to being swayed. I’ll react with anger to chase it away or stick my fingers in my ears’).

ILoveeCakes · 08/12/2022 20:34

Can you state your pronouns to be "Do-Re-Mi"?

When questioned, start singing:

Doe. A deer. A female deer.
Ray. A drop of golden sun.
Me. A name I call myself..........

catmum88 · 08/12/2022 20:33

Surely if they are trying to be inclusive to everyone, you have the right not to specify pronouns? This all seems to work one way!