Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think abolishing private schools would cost the tax payer a lot of money?!

215 replies

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 08:26

I am not against the idea at all but there's a few things I don't understand.

How do the dc currently in private schools fit into schools in areas where all the schools are already full?
Would private schools be open to foreign dc only seeing as a lot of students at the private schools are not from the U.K. and use private schools because their company often pays for their fees or would foreign dc also be forced into state schools?
What about boarding schools for forces parents? Are there enough state boarding schools?

Do grammar schools also need deconstructing as well in order for all education to be 'fair'? I live in a grammar area and you can forget buying a house in one of the school catchment areas unless you're already a lot wealthier. Is that not a similar problem? One school has 2% of pupils eligible for pupil premium for example.

Just wondering how it would work. Do state teachers want this to happen? Many move over to private schools so I suppose if many private schools shut down it would stop some choice in where to work.

Would state schools attempt to reach the standard of facilities that private schools have or would we accept that it is better that all British dc have the 'same' even if it's worse vs some having better facilities simply down to money.
Just Monday morning day dreaming about this really!

OP posts:
mummymeister · 05/12/2022 09:54

If I actually believed that the removal of charitable status and charging VAT on private schools plus the abolition of the house of lords would not only be labour party policy but actually this time enacted then I would vote for them. I have never in 60+ years voted Labour but this would get my vote. the priviledge ceiling has been in place way, way too long. the removal of grammar schools was a massive mistake and the perpetuation of these other 2 systems just reinforces the whole thing. Now if they also said they would abolish the monarchy as well then I would not only vote for them but go out and actively campaign!!

cyclamenqueen · 05/12/2022 09:51

georgedawes · 05/12/2022 08:32

Not even that, just that they should pay vat is Labour's policy.

Private schools already pay VAT but they don’t charge VAT on fees. Labours policy is to make parents pay VAT on fees . This has nothing to do with charitable status

MarshaBradyo · 05/12/2022 09:51

ShinyHappyTits · 05/12/2022 09:43

I am terrified of this happening. I teach performing arts in private schools and if the fees go up by 20% almost none will be able to afford my lessons. So I’ll be out of work.

By no means are all the parents rich, many of them are really stretching themselves to send their children to these schools, which really aren’t necessarily that fancy or exclusive. I’d guess fees would become unaffordable for at least 50% who would need to go into the state sector. The local schools would buckle, there isn’t the capacity because the moronic local authority has failed to monitor the demographic changes adequately and provide enough school places. It’s all very well saying ‘yes but it would mean state schools improve’ and this might even happen over time but what will happen for at least the first generation is that the quiet, studious kids will get lost, even more so in the vastly bigger year groups.

I have several pupils who have absolutely been drowned in the state sector and have picked up on this-they are terrified of having to go back. All three of my schools operate a bursary system so less wealthy families have opportunities. One of my students’ mum is a cleaner, for example. All of them offer local state schools use of their facilities. So there would be that loss also as they wouldn’t be obliged to do so if their charitable status were removed. A much, much better idea would be to force the private establishments to increase their bursary offering, widen access to their facilities and extracurricular activities and offer holiday schemes. Careers advice and University interview/personal statement coaching. Make them earn their charitable status.

This is a policy driven by class envy from people who were quite happy to use the private/grammar system themselves. Not every school is Eton or Rodean, many are small, family run establishments that would go under (and are already struggling due to heating and food bills skyrocketing) This policy would deprive people of choice in a sector that contributes many billions to the public purse and relieves the pressure on the state system. And what about the people who can’t afford a house in the catchment of the decent schools? The local school to us has just been rated Outstanding and house prices have jumped by 60k+ in that catchment, which has shrunk to 200 meters. We might well have to send our DC to the local private school as the other one near us is an absolute sink-we don’t stand a hope of doing that if the fees go up by 20%. Also worth mentioning that parents have already been taxed, often 40% but aren’t burdening the state system.

This is a poorly thought out vote catcher with no real plan for the consequences and no fucking way am I voting for it.

I agree with you and sadly there are many who like it as in pp

But at least they'll get the warm feeling inside that "the rich got screwed", I'm sure it'll be a great comfort to them.

It will indeed bring enormous pleasure.

It’ll bring very little benefit, likely detrimental but a policy capitalising on envy etc

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 09:50

I certainly don't think charging vat on private schools will work Labour getting in and thanks to those confirming about their desire to abolish private schools I did think that was the case but clearly have no idea what's going on. That's why I'm wondering how this will help make things more fair for all. I went to state school and my sister went to a private school. We suited our respective schools and my parents had different needs for us as well as different needs requiring my sister to go to a private school and me not to.

I genuinely cannot see the good that can come of pricing out the less wealthy current private school students out of these schools or abolishing them entirely.

I also can't envision the impact on current standards of schooling when these students join the state sector. I keep seeing people squabbling about how 'wealthy dc should never have an advantage' vs a real discussion as to this is how it will help.

I'm more interested in the impact on the state sector. I am not seeing the positives. I cannot see how the fee payers will suddenly pour their money into state schools. Unless attending state schools will be means tested or something. But as I said, I can't see it. Maybe someone else knows more than me hence my thread.

OP posts:
Saddogmum73 · 05/12/2022 09:49

If they remove charitable status from private schools then they should also change the rules for faith schools. A reduction in private schools is not going to change educational provision across the country to a level which we all think is good. We will end up with a two tier state provision, and that what will be done to ‘even’ it up?
However, I for one will continue to pay for my child to attend private school because our local comprehensive is terrible but we can’t afford to move to an area with an outstanding state school.

Zampa · 05/12/2022 09:46

Alexandernevermind · 05/12/2022 08:42

The policy is going to make Labour unelectable - again, and goodness knows we need a change in government. Education is essential and should not be subject to VAT, the fact that it is luxury education is irrelevant, its still education. Not all private schools are Eton, some are small, SEN friendly with generous scholarships and are a life line for rural communities.

@Andante57 @Crispyturtle

Here - page 1.

62% of voters support Labour's policy according to Redfield pollsters.

Fairyliz · 05/12/2022 09:44

MintJulia · 05/12/2022 08:36

It would be interesting for someone impartial to do the sums for ...

a) removing charitable status and hence making them pay VAT
b) 10% of private school pupils returning to the state sector
c) private schools charity activities coming to a halt - so no more bursaries, providing swimming pools for state primaries etc.

We've only ever seen the views of lobbyists from one party or the other, none of which can be trusted.

It would be good to have some real information from an accountant.

@MintJulia
That would indeed be wonderful to have an impartial review. However it seems that politics is not about facts and figures but simply about slagging off the other side.

Another76543 · 05/12/2022 09:43

mathsgirl12 · 05/12/2022 09:36

According to the government's own webpage, education and training are exempt from VAT. I'm not sure how you can single private schools out as needing to pay VAT but not other forms of education and training.

Exactly. However, presumably all those calling for VAT school fees would also be happy to pay VAT on their private nursery fees and university tuition fees. I suspect in reality that these people are happy with the idea of VAT until it affects them, at which point they’ll claim that they should be exempt because “it’s different”.

ShinyHappyTits · 05/12/2022 09:43

I am terrified of this happening. I teach performing arts in private schools and if the fees go up by 20% almost none will be able to afford my lessons. So I’ll be out of work.

By no means are all the parents rich, many of them are really stretching themselves to send their children to these schools, which really aren’t necessarily that fancy or exclusive. I’d guess fees would become unaffordable for at least 50% who would need to go into the state sector. The local schools would buckle, there isn’t the capacity because the moronic local authority has failed to monitor the demographic changes adequately and provide enough school places. It’s all very well saying ‘yes but it would mean state schools improve’ and this might even happen over time but what will happen for at least the first generation is that the quiet, studious kids will get lost, even more so in the vastly bigger year groups.

I have several pupils who have absolutely been drowned in the state sector and have picked up on this-they are terrified of having to go back. All three of my schools operate a bursary system so less wealthy families have opportunities. One of my students’ mum is a cleaner, for example. All of them offer local state schools use of their facilities. So there would be that loss also as they wouldn’t be obliged to do so if their charitable status were removed. A much, much better idea would be to force the private establishments to increase their bursary offering, widen access to their facilities and extracurricular activities and offer holiday schemes. Careers advice and University interview/personal statement coaching. Make them earn their charitable status.

This is a policy driven by class envy from people who were quite happy to use the private/grammar system themselves. Not every school is Eton or Rodean, many are small, family run establishments that would go under (and are already struggling due to heating and food bills skyrocketing) This policy would deprive people of choice in a sector that contributes many billions to the public purse and relieves the pressure on the state system. And what about the people who can’t afford a house in the catchment of the decent schools? The local school to us has just been rated Outstanding and house prices have jumped by 60k+ in that catchment, which has shrunk to 200 meters. We might well have to send our DC to the local private school as the other one near us is an absolute sink-we don’t stand a hope of doing that if the fees go up by 20%. Also worth mentioning that parents have already been taxed, often 40% but aren’t burdening the state system.

This is a poorly thought out vote catcher with no real plan for the consequences and no fucking way am I voting for it.

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 09:40

Crispy turtle who has said putting VAT on private schools will make Labour unelectable?

Crispyturtle · 05/12/2022 09:38

I love the idea that abolishing VAT for private schools is going to make Labour unelectable, do you seriously think the vast majority of voters give a teeny tiny shit that Eton, Marlborough etc might have to pay some tax? Give over

mathsgirl12 · 05/12/2022 09:36

ZenNudist · 05/12/2022 09:03

No one is talking about abolishing them so you don't need to worry.

Re VAT on fees, Private schools are a business. If a business suddenly finds itself with less customers it will adjust its prices. I don't think this will need to happen.

The rich will still afford the fees.

Maybe some schools will eventually shut. It's not going to be an overnight thing.

People will do the best by their DC so may make more sacrifices to keep them in a school they have already started but maybe more people will choose state over private at primary and secondary entry points.

More funding will have to be allocated by the government and slowly the state system will improve in those areas.

Currently some hedge fund owned private schools can make a lot of money. I'm sure these will continue with more overseas students. A British education is one of our last globally recognised "products". That's going nowhere.

According to the government's own webpage, education and training are exempt from VAT. I'm not sure how you can single private schools out as needing to pay VAT but not other forms of education and training.

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 09:36

Labour will pledge to abolish private schools if it wins the next election, after the party’s annual conference voted for a proposal to “integrate” them into the state sector.

This was the first sentence in the article Another 76543 has linked in his/her post above.

Another76543 · 05/12/2022 09:30

For those saying that Labour don’t want to abolish private schools, this has indeed been suggested over the years and is still supported by many in the Labour Party.

www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/labour-public-private-school-abolish-eton-vote-conference-corbyn-education-policy-a9115766.html?amp

I’m not entirely sure how abolishing private schools, or even taxing them more, will improve the state system. “Outstanding” secondary schools would be inundated with applicants, making the catchment area tiny and pushing the house prices beyond the reach of the majority of parents. Parents who would have been able to secure a place at those schools would no longer be able to do so because the schools would be full of people who would otherwise have been in the private sector.

To make it a truly “fair” system, you would have to abolish the grammar system entirely (it’s now heavily used by those who can afford private tuition), and introduce a lottery system for state schools. I’m fairly sure that if the Labour politicians’ children were allocated a place at a failing secondary they’d rethink their policy.

Whilst they are at it, they should probably have a look at faith schools; schools which are heavily funded by the state which can openly discriminate in their admissions policy. That’s not “fair” either.

In reality, it’s not as simple as removing charitable status to impost VAT on fees anyway. Plenty of independent schools aren’t charities at the moment, but don’t have to charge VAT because of existing VAT legislation; the same legislation which means that private nurseries and universities don’t have to charge VAT either.

bumblybum · 05/12/2022 09:29

@L1ttledrummergirl I don't think Kier starmer hates strivers so by the looks of that thread it's not the same angle?

Should I not start a thread asking my own questions?

OP posts:
bumblybum · 05/12/2022 09:25

Some schools have already had to make huge cut backs @Zodfa due to the cost of living rise. For me this says that they know parents won't pay too much more. My friend has boys at a boarding school who wrote to the parents saying heating would be off a long as possible due to the cost of living crisis. They've already put the fees up by 10% as well. There's only so much you can absorb I imagine? And absorbing costs in the long term means lowering the standards which I suppose defeats the purpose of attending one?

What about the monopoly the state would have on teachers options? Is that an issue?
Could the state effectiv pay them less if there's less market available to move?

Two private schools have shut in my old area in the last decade due to not enough people being able to afford them. They're already shutting in many places. The pressure does show in these areas already. Private schools in my current area share their facilities with state schools due to the charitable status. Will these nice facilities then end for the state educated dc and what will the be replaced with? (Swimming pools being my main thought here because they're expensive to run)

And yes, I know that people leaving the private sector already head for the 'best' state schools leading to fewer lower income pupils attending them anyway. So hardly diversifying the population of all schools anyway. And as pp have said. Parents will just tutor their dc way up. Again the wealth divide then hasn't been solved anyway. I'm not sure how you can solve it. Perhaps by allowing lower income families better access to private schools instead?

OP posts:
Andante57 · 05/12/2022 09:22

But at least they'll get the warm feeling inside that "the rich got screwed", I'm sure it'll be a great comfort to them.

Setyoufree It will indeed bring enormous pleasure.

IncessantNameChanger · 05/12/2022 09:21

Whatever you did to private schools, that cash will never fully flow into state. If your as loaded as the private parents near me they will no issue paying for private tutors. So even if Labour wanted to abolish private schools those children would either be moved abroad or tutored. Or both. You can not dictate how wealthy people spend their cash

Andante57 · 05/12/2022 09:21

sevenbyseven · Today 08:37
It's not going to happen. But imagine how great it would be if all the money people pay in school fees went into the state sector. (Also not going to happen.)

Please explain how money from school fees would go into the state sector? Would you means test parents and if they can afford to pay fees then they would have to do so even though their children are at state school?

Setyoufree · 05/12/2022 09:20

It's a great way to make private schools even more elitist than they are - kiss goodbye to all the bursaries and sharing of facilities they do at the moment. The house price bump around the decent state school in my area is hundreds of thousands of pounds. If those people move their kids into the state school from private, kids further out will end up shipped to a worse school in a different town altogether. But at least they'll get the warm feeling inside that "the rich got screwed", I'm sure it'll be a great comfort to them.

Usual disclaimer - my kids are at state school.

Blossomtoes · 05/12/2022 09:15

Tipsyturvychocolatemonster · 05/12/2022 08:36

Didn’t Corbyn have this as part of their manifesto, they were going tp abolish private schools and basically claim them as public propery And run them as state schools?

Corbyn hasn’t led the Labour Party for some time, haven’t you noticed?

Zodfa · 05/12/2022 09:12

If a school can't cut its spending back 20% whilst remaining an attractive option that raises the possibility that it wasn't all that much better than the state schools to begin with.

ordinarilyordinary · 05/12/2022 09:12

I have experience of my children going to both state and private schools. The private school that two of my children attend very much pride themselves on their charitable status. They offer their facilities on a regular basis to local state schools. This is for Sports, plays and performances. They host many large inter-school events. They have plenty of bursaries, full charitable ones, music, art and sport. Lately they have been working with Disability Scotland and other groups to provide a large Sports platform and opportunities to groups that would not otherwise have it.

My child who goes to the local state school benefits occasionally from the regular educational events that three local private schools provide.

funinthesun19 · 05/12/2022 09:10

Well I hope they never do abolish private schools because it would mean less state school places for regular people who might have been lucky to send their child to a fantastic state school.

You just know the people with money (who would have sent their child to private) would swoop in and move to a house closer to the state school and that’s the opportunity gone for the lower income child who would have got the school place.

Swipe left for the next trending thread