Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ASD/ADHD Do not know what to do for best - medicate or carry on?

58 replies

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 21:53

DC10 has a diagnosis - high functioning autism (unable to focus so not highly academic) and mild ADHD inattentive type without hyperactivity. He enjoys sport and the practical lessons.

He tolerates school - does not really like it and has some trouble making good friends but is friendly with a couple of boys. He has poor impulse control so sometimes behaves in a silly way (calling out in class or acting the clown). It's not very often but enough to alienate himself from a lot of his classmates.

He struggles academically - bright but his inability to focus means he rarely shows his true ability.

Psychiatrist wrote his report and ASD/ADHD diagnosis and we had a phone call to ask questions.

We asked about trialling medication to help with focus and came away feeling psych was against medicating - recommended reading up on methylphenidate which he referred to as amphetamine.

We have read and researched and see there are possible side effects but also worry we are not doing the right thing if we don't try it.

Our child is struggling with school work and socially. Much of the time seems stressed and anxious. Self confidence affected too. We have tried counselling, one to one tuition, extra support in school (sat at front of class, one to one help, lots of positive reinforcement) but feel his inability to focus is very much a hindrance in so many areas of his life.

Has anyone else struggled with this decision and felt psychiatrist was not supportive of medicating?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Yolande7 · 01/12/2022 21:58

You might want to check out this book:
https://www.amazon.co.uk/Straight-about-Psychiatric-Medications-Fourth/dp/1462519857/ref=sr_1_1?crid=22LHEATO9C7P8&keywords=kids+medication+psychiatric&qid=1669931704&sprefix=kids+medication+psychiatric%2Caps%2C65&sr=8-1 Straight Talk about Psychiatric Medications for Kids Paperback – Illustrated, 16 May 2016by Timothy E. Wilens (Author), Paul G. Hammerness (Author)

Dr Russell Barkeley's youtube videos are also helpful, in case you have not come across them.

It sounds like your son is negatively affected in several ways. If meds can help, I would try them.

flossymuldoon · 01/12/2022 20:41

My DS13 has just started on Concerta XL.

We had a private assessment as we were reaching crisis point as a family, and I estimated that we would have another 9-12 month wait for diagnosis and then I believe there would have been a wait to see whoever it is who prescribes in the first instance.

He was being excluded on a once or twice weekly basis, with constant calls from school about serious incidents. He couldn’t keep still and couldn’t control his impulses. The constant outbursts and meltdowns were absolutely exhausting and It was heartbreaking to see him struggle so much. I was dead set against medicating him so it took a lot of soul searching before I came to the conclusion that I was doing him a disservice but not trying them. I’ve heard so many people say they were life changing.

They opted to start him with the slow release on the smallest dose (18mg). So far it’s looking promising. While his week at school has been far from perfect, it’s now Thursday and there have been no exclusions or serious incidents.

He is calmer, there have been very few outbursts at home and no meltdowns. He seems much more relaxed and happier that things are better at school. We’ve been sitting and having some lovely conversations, which I now realise we weren’t really able to do so much before the meds.

He says that for the first half of the day he can feel they are making a difference but then he can feel it all building up again so i suspect that they will probably up his dose at his review appointment next week.

His appetite is affected a little bit but not worryingly so. He’s eating less during the day but still eating.

I am still not at the point where I can exhale fully, but it feels like we are heading in the right direction!

Ameanstreakamilewide · 01/12/2022 18:25

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 23:11

We don't have any medication prescribed as yet. If we go ahead we need to do a few things first. Explain to DC and ask if he wants to try medication. At his age he will need to be on board with this.

Inform school, inform GP. We have not shared the diagnosis yet, only just received it.

Go back to psychiatrist for health check prior to prescribing. I don't think it's a straight forward process from here.

I've just had a formal diagnosis for my son (he's 11) and the school were cc'd a copy of the report.

So you might not need to inform the school, per se.

Phineyj · 01/12/2022 17:34

Thanks for starting this thread, OP. We're in a similar position (although thinking of going private due to woeful waiting times) and the information has been really helpful.

LimitIsUp · 01/12/2022 17:34

By the way, she takes supplements of magnesium complex, omega 3 and Ashwagandha for anxiety - since you mention your dc struggles with this

LimitIsUp · 01/12/2022 17:16

My 20 year old has just started on methylphenidate - late diagnosis. I only wish we had known her diagnosis when younger and started her on meds back then - would have saved a tonne of angst

User15643289 · 01/12/2022 07:49

I'm so glad I found this thread.

My son doesn't have a diagnosis yet but we expect he will have a diagnosis of ASD (he's high functioning and school don't see it but I do) and ADHD. School do see this but have only just started accepting that I might be onto something when I suggest he has ADHD. He struggles in the same way as many of the children mentioned here.

I don't mean to derail the thread but if anyone has any Facebook group recommendations for support or meeting other parents I'd be really grateful to hear them.

SEND2022 · 01/12/2022 07:09

Make sure the school are aware of diagnosis.

We opted against medicating my 8 year old. For us the downsides of meds were too significant to ignore.

sunnydayhereandnow · 01/12/2022 06:56

It sounds like you're worried that the drug is an amphetamine, so it sounds like a dangerous recreational drug. Remember that prescription drugs are very tightly controlled, and are in totally different formulations and doses than what people misuse dangerously - it's not the same thing. Ritalin (methylphenidate) is very, very widely prescribed and used by kids with ADHD. I don't have personal experience but like others here, I've seen friends whose lives were transformed (for the better) by taking it, including at least one kid who is not neurotypical and sounds like your son.

Hercisback · 01/12/2022 06:39

I know this wasn't your original point, however does he have an EHCP?

I'd tell school because what is manageable in primary can quickly become unmanageable in secondary. A diagnosis is a flag to secondary which otherwise wouldn't be there without an EHCP.

RavenclawsPrincess · 30/11/2022 23:25

DS will need to go through a process called titration. This may be done by the psychiatrist or a specialist titration nurse. He will have to have a baseline health check, which depending on the requirements of the psychiatrist or service, may include weight, blood pressure, heart rate, possibly an ECG or blood tests if there are any pre-existing conditions of concern or history in the family (eg heart disease)

You may need to record and report things like weight, blood pressure and pulse rate and report those along with any effects, positive and/or negative, back to the professional on a weekly basis. This may include asking teachers for feedback from school. DS will start on the lowest dose for his age/height/weight and they will increase the dose possibly weekly or fortnightly until they find a dose that offers optimal positive effects with minimal or no side effects.

If you go ahead it is worth asking your psychiatrist or titration nurse who to contact and how if you have concerns about side effects in between appointments. Some people have few/none of course, but tolerance varies between people and can vary between doses quite widely.

mumwon · 30/11/2022 23:24

Not our family but one of the children I looked after: in this child's case the parents gave him the medication on school days so not weekends or holidays. You may find as he matures he may not need it aka you might be able to wean him off.
Another friend swore by not eliminating certain preservatives and artificial colouring it might be worth a try

NeverDropYourMooncup · 30/11/2022 23:20

That's the thing with ADHD, the central nervous system stimulants don't affect somebody with it in the same way they do everybody else.

I know so many kids who you can tell as soon as they explode into a room sideways that they haven't taken their medication yet (we keep secure spares at work for those children - a quick call home to doublecheck whether they've taken it later than usually would or have forgotten altogether and then, when the parent inevitably says 'Hang on, I'll check - (sigh) no, it's still on the kitchen counter' and within a very short time, they're back to being able to learn and enjoy their day again.

Most take methylphenidate, a small number take lisdexamfetamine because methylphenidate didn't work well for them - and another smaller number whose parents have chosen to take the non medication path who really do struggle, particularly in the wall of noise, smells, visual distractions and expectations of secondary.

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 23:11

We don't have any medication prescribed as yet. If we go ahead we need to do a few things first. Explain to DC and ask if he wants to try medication. At his age he will need to be on board with this.

Inform school, inform GP. We have not shared the diagnosis yet, only just received it.

Go back to psychiatrist for health check prior to prescribing. I don't think it's a straight forward process from here.

OP posts:
ZellyFitzgerald · 30/11/2022 23:09

Your son sounds exactly like mine!

My son (age 11) is a different child now he's taking Concerta.

Like your son he is very bright but unable to concentrate.

He's so much happier now he's on medication and we really notice when he doesn't take it and he's gone from being at the bottom of the class (despite being clearly very intelligent) to the top.

We had to go through a few different medications to find one that suited him but we are very happy we decided to try medication.

lollipoprainbow · 30/11/2022 23:08

This all sounds positive and what I want for my dd. Can I ask how you managed to get your child medication ? Was it the GP route. ?

Starlightstarbright1 · 30/11/2022 23:07

My ds has asd and adhd..

He is medicated from end of year 5.. i noticed he was happier as more able to stay in the moment. ,academically more able to focus, massive improvement.

He says doesn't get in as much trouble.

momamama · 30/11/2022 23:02

I resisted adhd meds for a long time. The moment I realised I had no other options she was a changed child overnight. She says she feels like a totally different person, like the clouds have lifted. She's on minimum dose and she's 10.

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 23:01

FlemCandango · 30/11/2022 22:56

DD was diagnosed with autism aged 8 and then ADHD at 11. She has struggled with emotional regulation, attention, anxiety and focus ( on things she is not interested in) all her life. She started on ritalin and now takes medikinet XL every school day morning and a smaller dose at lunch. She is 16 and in 6th form. Doing her A levels. She led the decision to medicate we were unsure but it was the right decision. There are some issues with appetite but she has a real drive to do well at school so being unable to focus really distressed her. She did really well in her GCSEs and without the meds she would have struggled.

An interesting point to note is that the affect the stimulants have on an ADHD brain are different to a non ADHD brain. So either they work and it is right or they don't. DD only takes them when she needs to and takes breaks at weekends over holidays. It works for her.

This last point resonates, thank you

OP posts:
FlemCandango · 30/11/2022 22:56

DD was diagnosed with autism aged 8 and then ADHD at 11. She has struggled with emotional regulation, attention, anxiety and focus ( on things she is not interested in) all her life. She started on ritalin and now takes medikinet XL every school day morning and a smaller dose at lunch. She is 16 and in 6th form. Doing her A levels. She led the decision to medicate we were unsure but it was the right decision. There are some issues with appetite but she has a real drive to do well at school so being unable to focus really distressed her. She did really well in her GCSEs and without the meds she would have struggled.

An interesting point to note is that the affect the stimulants have on an ADHD brain are different to a non ADHD brain. So either they work and it is right or they don't. DD only takes them when she needs to and takes breaks at weekends over holidays. It works for her.

antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:56

Thank you @RavenclawsPrincess . Now worried our psychiatrist kept referring to methylphenidate as an amphetamine.

OP posts:
antarctictoc · 30/11/2022 22:53

School are able to manage and support occasional impulse behaviours - he is not in trouble every day at school. It's his focus and social interactions, academic work that is hindered. School do not seem concerned about academics because he is working within ability range of the year group albeit very near the bottom.

Diagnosis did include a QB Check which I think is the same as a QT test. We were not given results - report says 'results consistent wit diagnosis of ADHD'.

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 30/11/2022 22:50

Id say meds have been incredibly useful for my asd son. He has extremely poor impulse control without them which is not a good thing in high school when there are so many kids messing about or doing things they shouldn't.
Expect them not to eat much during the day. So heavy calorie breakfast and dinner then supper before bed to get calories in.

RavenclawsPrincess · 30/11/2022 22:49

@antarctictoc medication options for ADHD are wider than methylphenidate/Ritalin. The info you’ve been given here isn’t quite right, as methylphenidate is not amphetamine.

Methylphenidate is usually the first line medication option, particularly for children with ADHD, and is often better tolerated by children than adults, and it’s also one of the cheaper options. It is one of a class of drugs called central nervous system stimulants, and does not contain amphetamine. Methylphenidate can come in immediate release or timed release form (brand names such as Concerta, Medikinet) There are other stimulants that do contain amphetamine, such as Elvanse (lisdexamfetamine, which has been modified for timed release) and Dextroamphetamine (immediate release). In my experience, adults tolerate the amphetamine based medications better.

Other options for ADHD medication may include non-stimulants, such as Atomoxetine (Strattera) and guanfacine, if your child does not tolerate stimulants. Guanfacine is often used for children with both autism and ADHD where there are co-occurring issues with anxiety.

Hope that helps understand the options better :)

SunsetGirl · 30/11/2022 22:48

I have ADHD, was diagnosed at 17, took methylphenidate, and it was the best thing I ever did. I only took it for a year or so, but it really did help me rewire my brain, in a way. I'm still scatty and struggle with executive function, but my emotional balance became WAY better, and I learned what being "normal" was like. Plus I improved by a whole grade!