Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kids still feeling the effects of lockdowns…

910 replies

sloanedanger · 23/11/2022 20:27

I just got caught reading a really interesting thread on Twitter started by a teacher:

“Is anyone else thinking we are starting to see the impact of 2 years of disruption and time at home, due to COVID 19, in schools? Extreme behaviours? Some pupils very emotional and struggling to regulate? Low attendance compared to normal? Winter bugs hitting hard?”

A lot of the comments say Y3 is the worst, others saying Years 7 and 8.

My DS is in Year 2 and often struggles with emotions and self regulation at school. It’s made me think, perhaps there’s a reason why linked to the pandemic. Lockdown was hard, DP and I were home with very young DC, trying to work, poor mental health, emotions high. Very little patience.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SirMingeALot · 26/11/2022 11:26

Also worry about the rewriting history on here. School closures were necessary, but went on too long. If we have another pandemic with similar r and death rates to the early stages of this one (remember bodies lining corridors awaiting ventilators in northern italy) locking down asap and then releasing once we know more is still going to be the best way forward

Your first paragraph was bang on napody, but this is speculative. We don't know nearly enough yet to ascertain whether lockdown as we had was the least worst course of action, and any future pandemic response will also need to take into account public attitudes and responses (which is how we ended up with a lockdown in the UK really, the government didn't want to initially).

Because in order for a lockdown to be possible and for any of the potential benefits to be reaped, you also need a lot of other factors in play: the desire and ability to fund it, a population who'll comply in high enough numbers to reduce contacts, and enough people who are willing to work outside the home in the jobs that are necessary to keep both society and lockdown functioning. That is, not just things like NHS, carers and food distribution but also those who delivered the sevrices that kept the population pacified. Amazon warehouse staff, Deliveroo drivers, takeaways etc.

We did have those in place in 2020-21 but whether that would still be the case in a future pandemic that looks like this one we just don't know. It obviously wouldn't be the case in the near to medium term, but in say 2048 or whatever that's harder to call.

napody · 26/11/2022 11:21

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 11:14

Also worry about the rewriting history on here. School closures were necessary, but went on too long. If we have another pandemic with similar r and death rates to the early stages of this one (remember bodies lining corridors awaiting ventilators in northern italy) locking down asap and then releasing once we know more is still going to be the best way forward. But this time there'll be all these layers of ignorance to deal with.

I agree. We needed to close schools but there should have been quicker lock downs and more priority to schools reopening rather than everything else.

Yes, and prioritising the measures to make that happen more safely, as noblegiraffe was constantly calling for on here. We've just spunked £30bn as a country on the gambling whims of a couple of eejits. Imagine the good that could have done for better ventilation in schools.

MarshaBradyo · 26/11/2022 11:18

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 11:07

It doesn't matter what people on this thread say. The evidence is on MN that discussions were had regarding lockdowns and schools shutting so obviously people weren't silenced or squashed on either said. If they were there would have been no discussions.

They may have happened but attempts to shut voices down was a constant.

Many have said they avoided posting due to aggression. Probably the right tack but at times it felt too important to be silenced over.

napody · 26/11/2022 11:16

Delatron · 25/11/2022 17:26

Yeah I think if you’re going to close schools and have such an impact on children’s education and future then you would want this to translate in to a big drop in the death rate for it to be worth it. Not just a reduction in the number of mild cases amongst young children.

Do you not remember how sharply the deaths dropped in January 2021?

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 11:14

Also worry about the rewriting history on here. School closures were necessary, but went on too long. If we have another pandemic with similar r and death rates to the early stages of this one (remember bodies lining corridors awaiting ventilators in northern italy) locking down asap and then releasing once we know more is still going to be the best way forward. But this time there'll be all these layers of ignorance to deal with.

I agree. We needed to close schools but there should have been quicker lock downs and more priority to schools reopening rather than everything else.

napody · 26/11/2022 11:13

SusanBland · 26/11/2022 01:37

The main problems in school are happening because despite the children missing big chunks of learning, the targets they're supposed to reach have remained the same, as if it never happened. So you have all these children who have understandably fallen behind a little (in some cases a lot) yet teachers are under enormous pressure to get them to meet age related expectations with no leeway whatsoever from school management/LEA/OFSTED. Therefore the kids and the teachers feel like they're constantly failing trying to reach unachievable targets. This in turn affects behaviour.

Y3 have definitely been the worst hit in primary in my experience.

Completely agree with this- it's what happens when a whole country doesn't trust teachers.
Makes a mockery of comparisons of learning loss with Sweden too... or any other country where teachers are trusted to teach the children in front of them what they need.

napody · 26/11/2022 11:09

CarefreeMe · 23/11/2022 22:32

IME the majority of young people didn’t struggle in lockdowns and the majority actually thrived.

The issue was/is being impacted by returning in such a sudden way and for many that was way too overwhelming and they’re still feeling the effects from it now.

In an ideal world (apart from not locking down) the reintroduction would have been much slower and with their MH at the forefront.

Instead the focus was on their grades and missed education, as well as the need for childcare.

I disagree that it was the majority, but there is research emerging that shows that the mental health of a significant minority of young people, particularly secondary age, improved during lockdowns. But many, particularly as pps have pointed out in overcrowded housing or with abusive family members, suffered hugely, and younger children particularly so with socialisation and language development.
I agree that the pressure to 'catch up' on return was a big problem... but the unrelenting focus on attainment data over all else has been going on in schools for many years, so not surprising. I worry that we are blowing our chance to learn real lessons from this.

Also worry about the rewriting history on here. School closures were necessary, but went on too long. If we have another pandemic with similar r and death rates to the early stages of this one (remember bodies lining corridors awaiting ventilators in northern italy) locking down asap and then releasing once we know more is still going to be the best way forward. But this time there'll be all these layers of ignorance to deal with.

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 11:08

said side

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 11:07

MarshaBradyo · 26/11/2022 10:10

Disagree and many have said same on here.

It doesn't matter what people on this thread say. The evidence is on MN that discussions were had regarding lockdowns and schools shutting so obviously people weren't silenced or squashed on either said. If they were there would have been no discussions.

user1496146479 · 26/11/2022 10:22

trumpet50 · 23/11/2022 23:22

What we are seeing is what happens when parents aren't able to outsource all their parenting to the state. Children weren't at home alone, they were with their families. Abusive situations aside there is no reason why they shouldn't have developed good social skills and managed quite well. If parents didn't prioritise their children's development and wellbeing during lockdown then that is on them. If parent's were anxious and shared that anxiety with their young children, if they didn't engage with them socially, if they allowed their child to become withdrawn and isolated then those are failures of parenting not an inevitable outcome of lockdown.

@trumpet50
Biscuit

MarshaBradyo · 26/11/2022 10:10

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 10:06

People weren't "squashed" vehemently at all. There has always been debate about whether school should have shut. I don't think things are any different now.

Disagree and many have said same on here.

Blackcatinanalley · 26/11/2022 10:08

One thing I’ve noticed is that when posters have got upset about the schools being closed and what their children went through there have been defensive replies along the lines of it not being the fault or the responsibility of the teachers.

That is 100% correct and it is right to point this out.

Equally though how safe or otherwise schools were or are is not the fault of or responsibility of the parents.

orchid220 · 26/11/2022 10:06

MarshaBradyo · 26/11/2022 10:01

I agree it’s good to ask although some were trying to highlight this before hindsight stage. It’s a shame that it was squashed so vehemently.

People weren't "squashed" vehemently at all. There has always been debate about whether school should have shut. I don't think things are any different now.

Blackcatinanalley · 26/11/2022 10:03

Yes, it was.

MarshaBradyo · 26/11/2022 10:01

Blackcatinanalley · 26/11/2022 09:29

While it’s very easy to be wise in hindsight I do think that we can learn from it and I think that it is all right to ask questions and to discuss.

I agree it’s good to ask although some were trying to highlight this before hindsight stage. It’s a shame that it was squashed so vehemently.

Dinoteeth · 26/11/2022 09:57

@MeetPi
Scotland Preschools were closed Mar-Aug 2020, Dec-Mar 2021.

Glasgow / Central Scotland Home Visitors weren't allowed Mar 20 - May 21, except about 6-8 weeks in summer 20 and Christmas day.

Softplays were also closed.

So unless people already had a social circle to meet in the park. Young children were very isolated. From both other children and extended family.
Also remember during the lockdowns parents were also work and homeschooling older children.

Children might not know they missed out but that is a huge chunk of development time in Children who are less than 5 years old.

BlueRidge · 26/11/2022 09:40

momlette · 25/11/2022 23:27

Shame on those “ professionals “ who campaigned so vociferously on here for closures. Hang your heads in utter shame. I hope you will be held to account

Oh fgs. What dramatic language. What on earth do you mean, anyway?

Blackcatinanalley · 26/11/2022 09:29

While it’s very easy to be wise in hindsight I do think that we can learn from it and I think that it is all right to ask questions and to discuss.

MarshaBradyo · 26/11/2022 09:07

Sir mentioned SALT increase but for babies isolating mothers (usually) and babies / toddlers will have a negative impact. The extra stress in families due to isolation will have repercussions.

Now I think if it the BMA did report concern re increase in injury as early as July first year. I’m sure this data fed through but imo the second closure (which yes to pp it was third lockdown) was a mistake again. And summer most certainly was hospital graphs were pretty flat.

SirMingeALot · 26/11/2022 09:01

The impact of lockdowns on those who were babies and very young children at the time is unlikely to be something we'll fully understand for a while.

This is from ROI, and their lockdowns were a bit different to ours, but an interesting read.

adc.bmj.com/content/early/2022/09/19/archdischild-2021-323441

The data is parentally reported, I guess we will have to wait until that cohort are all in school to get more than that. There has been an increase in the UK of school pupils needing SALT support but obviously these children couldn't have been babies in 2020-1.

Blackcatinanalley · 26/11/2022 08:54

Ah that takes me back @MeetPi . All preschool children needed was a puddlesuit. Twelve hours a day could be spent jumping in puddles. Toddler groups, preschool or nursery, farms, soft play - all an indulgence and they didn’t have them fifty years ago (yes, actually they did.)

It is true a child doesn’t ‘need’ a session at a toddler class, but speech in particular (and with it, social skills) do need some integration. To give some examples, part of it is the ability to watch lips move, observe facial expressions, have chances to observe reciprocal speech interaction - screens can never replace that and a child won't learn language from a screen. It's this really complex process which relies largely on a multitude and a variety of human interactions. Toddler groups aren’t all of that but they are part of that.

I was probably fine as I only had one baby, but I do recognise that WFH with other kids was going to make one on one nursery rhyme singing a bit difficult. Then you take away the groups, the shopping trips, the visits to family, the school run, and you replace that with one walk a day then back home, like the start of lockdown. Then you factor in confidence - a child who has been encouraged to "give the man in the shop the money and say thank you" is going to gain confidence in actually using speech. So it's not something you could pin on one thing - the shops, the groups, the lack of visits to granny - it's the cumulative effect of everything going at once, over a long chunk of vital time in their development.

Parent blame is a new thing and it isn’t limited to on here. I think people get defensive. I do remember at the start of lockdown how surreal and dystopian it all seemed and how frightening it was.

What was wrong was shutting the playgrounds, and keeping them shut. It was wrong that pubs went back before schools. The bubble system was absolute insanity. The key worker list was wrong and unfair.

TwitTw00 · 26/11/2022 06:29

noblegiraffe · 25/11/2022 11:19

Oh mate. I’m not rewriting history, and you can tell because it’s all there on MN. This from 1st Dec 2020.

www.mumsnet.com/talk/coronavirus/4095400-noblegiraffe-wants-SAFER-schools-not-closed-schools-Do-you

From the OP of that thread “I don't want schools to close. I want them to be made safer so that they stay open longer to more pupils.”

And we now know what happened. The suggested mitigation measures were not implemented, covid continued to increase in schools and in Jan 2021 they had to close again.

Do you know how fucking annoying it was to have been saying over and over that something needed to be done to stop covid spread in schools, to be on the receiving end of a shit tonne of abuse for it, to see the concerns ignored, and to see schools close for another two months as a result?

Slow fucking handclap for all those people.

And I posted upthread the new DfE research where they admit that implementing masks in schools would have saved thousands of days of pupil absence.

If you wanted schools open, if you wanted more kids in school, you should have bloody listened.

And now people are still trying to argue I was wrong. Despite how it played out. Hmm

Well said. Wish we had upvotes on MN if only for this post.

MeetPi · 26/11/2022 06:21

@Delatron

I have seen in real life and on here many who thought they were ‘vulnerable’ to Covid caught it and were fine. Including FIL who hid himself away claiming he would die if he caught it then had a mild cold with it. Sadly his health deteriorated significantly due to him being too scared to even go for a walk outside. Such fear mongering.

It is a bit of a lottery, though. Ive written about my ECV sibling on here who currently has Covid, and is not doing well. He just doesn't have an immune system at all. He's had one round of anti-virals, but the Covid has come back even worse. He's trying another round, but I just don't know.

And then my FIL, also with cancer, who was very ill for a day or two but then picked up well with anti-virals. (They're a miracle.)

Please don't call it fear-mongering.

MeetPi · 26/11/2022 06:12

Delatron · 25/11/2022 13:31

Children missing pre-school and seeing friends and family. Toddler groups. Mother and baby meetings. None of these happened. That will have had a profound impact on those young children. Plus the lack of immunity that they have now to many common childhood illnesses.

How long, really, was pre-school cancelled for? If it was only for a couple of months, I don't think the impact would be "profound". Children learn self-care and playing in the vicinity of others at pre-school. The concept alone only became more common in the last thirty years or so. As for toddler and mother and baby groups, these are great, but not essential for everyone, and the socialisation they provide can be found elsewhere. (Siblings/cousins/neighbours/at the park.) And of course, the children themselves won't know they have missed out on this apparently crucial step - unless parents harp on it. Babies and toddlers, in the main, won't experience any lasting profound effects from missing nursery/preschool for a few months.

Dinoteeth · 26/11/2022 04:16

HeraldicBlazoning · 25/11/2022 19:57

It was bonkers like many other bonkers SNP half though out ideas.

my personal favourite was the proposal to saw 6 inches off the bottom of fire doors for ventilation.

So many open mouth and spout nonsense SNP moments. People will look back and laugh.