Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability/abortion debate in UK

237 replies

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 21:53

www.itv.com/news/meridian/2022-11-04/teenager-with-downs-syndrome-meets-rishi-sunak-over-abortion-laws

This cause went to the High Court and was rejected, so why is Rishi meeting with her?

I’m getting irritated with this ‘pressure group’ who basically want to ensure more babies with disabilities are born by stealth, by taking choice away from women. I’m also dubious about how many of these disabled people are truly advocating for themselves and how many have been ‘encouraged’ to do so by pro life parents.

In some cases the parents had the screening but slipped through the net - so they didn’t make an active decision to parent a disabled child, but now expect others to do so, to affirm their circumstances presumably?

Prepared to be told AIBU, but I feel we should be able to discuss it as it’s potentially our rights they want to restrict.

OP posts:
LangClegsInSpace · 07/11/2022 23:38

This is the front line of the anti-abortion movement in the UK today.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4539125-more-institutional-capture-pro-lifers-this-time

The Crowter case was permitted to appeal on one ground - that having a different time limit for disability constitutes indirect discrimination against disabled people by encouraging the view that their lives are worth less.

The decision in that case is due any time now. Long thread here:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/feminism/4289660-Late-term-abortion-high-court

If that is now the argument then the most obvious targets are the benefit system and social care, which discriminate against and dehumanise disabled people day after day. But these people do not say a word about those things, It's only ever about abortion.

Also, I most definitely will not be listening to lectures about abortion law stigmatising disabled people from an org that still calls itself 'Mencap' Hmm

https://www.mencap.org.uk/crowter-case-statement

Disability/abortion debate in UK
Blocked · 07/11/2022 23:35

Luredbyapomegranate · 07/11/2022 22:47

I voted YANBU because I agree abortion rights are a concern. However, I think this is just a nice photo op for Caring Rushi. I can't imagine this is or ever will be of any interest to him.

Nail on head there. Sunak is a money man, we effectively have a team of two chancellors now instead of a PM and a chancellor. Sunak is not interested in challenging the status quo on anything unless it impacts the countries finances in some way.

Mandatorymongoose · 07/11/2022 23:33

@gogoldsparklyChocolate there have been a few cases where the court of protection have made decisions about if an abortion is to be performed or not (taking the choice away from the woman). They have generally been related to women with learning disabilities or severe mental health issues.

It would be under the mental capacity act usually that that choice was made. Although the mental health act may have some provision too.

The test for capacity is always the same, no matter the choice. You need to establish the person has an impairment of mind, then look at if they understand the specific decision to be made, if they can weigh up the pros and cons, if they can recall the information for long enough to make the decision and if they can communicate their choice. If they can't do ar least one of those then they lack capacity and the decision should be made in their best interests.

Best interests should consider what the person would want if they did have capacity. If there is any hope of the person regaining capacity and the decision can be put off until then then you should do that.

Few stories with different outcomes:

www.theguardian.com/world/2019/oct/11/woman-severe-learning-disabilities-abortion-judge-rules

www.theguardian.com/world/2019/jun/24/catholic-church-hits-out-at-court-over-abortion-ruling

www.theguardian.com/society/2001/oct/18/mentalhealth

Tommyrot · 07/11/2022 23:32

It's really about treating disabled and non-disabled people the same. If it is okay to have a late abortion if a child is disabled why is it not okay to have a late abortion if the child is not disabled? By treating them differently you are saying disabled people are worth less. The fact that some people don't want to look after a disabled child is not an argument for treating them differently. Not everyone wants to look after children who aren't disabled either but they aren't allowed to abort them late in pregnancy.

Sparklesocks · 07/11/2022 23:23

Endwalker · 07/11/2022 22:58

The vast majority of abortions in the UK take place before 10wks (over 80%) with most of rhe rest taking place before 13wks, only 1% take place between 20-24wks. The statistics suggest that women who simply don't want to be pregnant are taking care of it as early as possible.

The number of abortions that take place post-24wks is tiny, around 248 per year. Provision for post-24wks is essential as it gives women time to have further tests, to seek a second opinion, to talk it out with family/friends, to consider the situation, to see if the prognosis improves (e.g., where there is a development issue), and so on. The 248 women each year who make this decision should not be rushed into it, they should be allowed the time they need.

The parents involved in these campaigns had a choice, protected by law, about whether or not to continue their pregnancy. Its sickening that they're now seeking to remove that choice from other women.

You don't have to like someone's reasoning for having an abortion. Their reasons are literally none of your business anyway but you are under no obligation to agree with those reasons, however just because you don't like it doesn't mean they shouldn't be allowed to do it.

Thank you for this.

EL8888 · 07/11/2022 23:19

Bretontops · 07/11/2022 22:44

But those parents are the ones seeking to change my rights, so why shouldn’t I be able to air my views?

Well, exactly. It’s a 2 way street surely?

CherryBlossomWinter · 07/11/2022 23:11

Raddix · 07/11/2022 23:06

YANBU. The people with Downs (and their parents) who are campaigning for this are by definition only mildly affected. Because those who are severely affected by Downs aren’t campaigning - they are non verbal, housebound, unable to walk or toilet train, and the parents are exhausted from giving 24/7 care.

I don’t find it reasonable for those who are only mildly affected to tell others they must roll the dice and hope their disabled child will also only be mildly affected. I can tell you for sure that the parents of children with severe Downs aren’t going around suggesting it as an option to anyone else.

I agree with this, and am quite saddened by what I see as a ‘sanitisation of disability’ - only ‘acceptable’ milder forms are discussed, debated, centred or shown in our media - meaning those with less socially ‘acceptable’ disabilities are further isolated and hidden. And the centering is around acceptance only - and in this case an opportunity lost to tackle Rishi Sunak about quality of care and support for parents/those with disabilities. The debate is a massive deflection.

123ROLO · 07/11/2022 23:11

To me, it isn't about whether one child Is any less valuable than another, its about whether the mother is able or willing to care for a disabled child.

On the less extreme end of the spectrum, you could have a disabled child who is able to have and maintain a good quality of life and independent living just with a little support.

On the extreme end, you could have a disabled child that needs round the clock care, requires assistance with all aspects of living, has no likelihood of independent living, the mother's life will turn into one of a carer, or laden with guilt if she can't provide that care and chooses a care home, and she will grow old with the worry of who will care for them when gone.

Down syndrome often is only represented by the individuals who are independent, articulate and happy, while i imagine the majority are like this, I worked with young adults who have down syndrome who were non verbal, incontinent and had to be supervised at all times due to choking risk or aggressive behaviour, their life is full of value, but mostly, it was the mother who provided most of that care.

No mother should be forced into this role. I've worked in disability care in the past, I helped people live as independently as possible, I loved the people I worked with and they bought value to mine and others lives, just like anyone else. But if I was a mother, I cant comprehend how challenging that must be. Perhaps if it is sprung upon me then I'd find the means, but I wouldn't willingly walk into a role of both mother and carer.

To me, prolifers in this context are just saying to women "why are you bothered about potentially having to give up your career, lose your friendships, free time and hobbies? you should be happy to give up the rest of your life to be a carer that's your duty as a woman!"

I am genuinely happy there are women out there willing and able to do this, and I don't doubt for one second that those parents aren't happy with their child, and have zero regrets about them being born. That's great, there are some seriously strong mothers out there, but I don't think I could do it, and it definitely shouldn't be forced upon mother's.

SarahAndQuack · 07/11/2022 23:07

LBB2020 · 07/11/2022 23:00

No @SarahAndQuack that is not what I’m saying. I’m saying the limit should be the same regardless of reason for wanting an abortion (so really the 24 week limit should be removed and it should be until term/birth for any reason)

I apologise! Thanks for explaining.

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 23:06

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 23:02

There is no debate. Some things, like my bodily autonomy, are not up for debate. Pretending there’s a debate to be had suggests that, well, that there’s a debate to be had – about my body. And that is, frankly, weird.

Do you know by chance where I could find information about autonomy and abortion?

Is there ever a time when a woman can have that decision taken away (to abort or not abort) - if so does a capacity assessment have to take place with her knowledge ? How is capacity assessed ? It’s something I’ve been looking into and can’t find much about it you hear so much about autonomy but how is that right protected ?

Raddix · 07/11/2022 23:06

YANBU. The people with Downs (and their parents) who are campaigning for this are by definition only mildly affected. Because those who are severely affected by Downs aren’t campaigning - they are non verbal, housebound, unable to walk or toilet train, and the parents are exhausted from giving 24/7 care.

I don’t find it reasonable for those who are only mildly affected to tell others they must roll the dice and hope their disabled child will also only be mildly affected. I can tell you for sure that the parents of children with severe Downs aren’t going around suggesting it as an option to anyone else.

LaBellina · 07/11/2022 23:04

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 23:02

There is no debate. Some things, like my bodily autonomy, are not up for debate. Pretending there’s a debate to be had suggests that, well, that there’s a debate to be had – about my body. And that is, frankly, weird.

this

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 23:04

@Untitledsquatboulder See @Endwalker’s very good post a little above – the vast vast majority of women abort far earlier than anything you could screen for.

Untitledsquatboulder · 07/11/2022 23:02

@stuntbubbles how so? If termination on the basis of sex is OK, then why not under other characteristics? What makes them so special?

Personally I'm fine with the laws around termination where they are, I neither wish to see them expanded or retracted.

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 23:02

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 23:01

Or valid questions being ignored because it makes people scared that if they engage in a debate they will lose their rights so they’d rather just avoid the discussion totally. It doesn’t make you less pro choice to consider these things

There is no debate. Some things, like my bodily autonomy, are not up for debate. Pretending there’s a debate to be had suggests that, well, that there’s a debate to be had – about my body. And that is, frankly, weird.

TheSnugglyDuckling · 07/11/2022 23:01

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 22:09

You should be allowed to abort for any reason at all.

100%

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 23:01

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 22:54

Not wildly interesting, no. Just strawman nonsense designed by forced birthers to create debate where there is none.

Or valid questions being ignored because it makes people scared that if they engage in a debate they will lose their rights so they’d rather just avoid the discussion totally. It doesn’t make you less pro choice to consider these things

LBB2020 · 07/11/2022 23:00

No @SarahAndQuack that is not what I’m saying. I’m saying the limit should be the same regardless of reason for wanting an abortion (so really the 24 week limit should be removed and it should be until term/birth for any reason)

KitchiHuritAngeni · 07/11/2022 22:59

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:54

I just feel as if any of my daughters ever came to me saying they were pregnant and aborting I’d say ‘right ok let sort it out I’ll support you however you need ‘ no questions asked . I can only think of one scenario where I wouldn’t and that would be if they said ‘oh I don’t want this baby as I don’t want a boy/girl - if it was the other gender I’d keep it’ I would absolutely tell them precisely how wrong that it

That's fine, tell your daughter that if it were to happen.

You don't get to tell other women that they are doing a disservice to other due to their own choices about their own lives.

The alternative would be to force someone who doesn't want a particular sex of child, and who feels so strongly about that that they wanted an abortion, to give birth to a child they don't want.

Endwalker · 07/11/2022 22:58

The vast majority of abortions in the UK take place before 10wks (over 80%) with most of rhe rest taking place before 13wks, only 1% take place between 20-24wks. The statistics suggest that women who simply don't want to be pregnant are taking care of it as early as possible.

The number of abortions that take place post-24wks is tiny, around 248 per year. Provision for post-24wks is essential as it gives women time to have further tests, to seek a second opinion, to talk it out with family/friends, to consider the situation, to see if the prognosis improves (e.g., where there is a development issue), and so on. The 248 women each year who make this decision should not be rushed into it, they should be allowed the time they need.

The parents involved in these campaigns had a choice, protected by law, about whether or not to continue their pregnancy. Its sickening that they're now seeking to remove that choice from other women.

You don't have to like someone's reasoning for having an abortion. Their reasons are literally none of your business anyway but you are under no obligation to agree with those reasons, however just because you don't like it doesn't mean they shouldn't be allowed to do it.

AllCatsAreBeautiful · 07/11/2022 22:58

ClocksGoingBackwards · 07/11/2022 22:36

I’m all for women’s rights to reproductive autonomy, but you have to have a heart of stone and be very closed minded if you can’t at least see where this lady is coming from. She’s not trying to take rights away, she’s making the point that her life is still well worth living even if she has a disability.

She very literally is “trying to take rights away”! She’s campaigning for abortion restrictions!

CPandme · 07/11/2022 22:55

I have a number of disabilities. The main ones are cerebral palsy, autism and a genetic condition. If there was screening I think it should be available even if it means I might not have been born due to screening and ivf or abortion at any time during the pregnancy.

These are such variable conditions that I have no right to expect any woman to carry a child knowing that they may have a severely disabled child and then adult needing care.

As with all MH services there should be therapy available if there are disabled people who feel that they are less valuable due to being disabled and unfortunately often there isn’t . I have certainly had suicidal thoughts/wished my parents had a “normal” child/adult. They would not have had to fight for me or see me through medical treatment and not be worried about my future. I could be more support as they age. Testing if available could have saved them that and I have relatively mild disability.

LaBellina · 07/11/2022 22:55

Millie and her family need to stay in their lane. Another woman’s right to abortion has absolutely nothing to do with them. How shameless and all about ‘me, me, me’ are you when you want to abolish a basic human right because ‘it hurts your dignity’.
🤮

The only dignity that’s being hurt is that of those who’s right to body autonomy you’re trying to end.

goldsparklyChocolate · 07/11/2022 22:54

KitchiHuritAngeni · 07/11/2022 22:49

One woman having an abortion isn't doing anyone else a disservice though.

If she made the same choice as someone else but for different reason then that's fine and noone else's business.

Not all abortions come with a traumatic backstory or heartbreaking reason.

"I don't wish to continue this pregnancy" is all that's needed. You may not like it but we need to trust women to choose for ourselves.

I just feel as if any of my daughters ever came to me saying they were pregnant and aborting I’d say ‘right ok let sort it out I’ll support you however you need ‘ no questions asked . I can only think of one scenario where I wouldn’t and that would be if they said ‘oh I don’t want this baby as I don’t want a boy/girl - if it was the other gender I’d keep it’ I would absolutely tell them precisely how wrong that it

stuntbubbles · 07/11/2022 22:54

Untitledsquatboulder · 07/11/2022 22:52

Well it's interesting isn't it? If we are OK w termination for whatever reason, what might we be able to screen for and select for in future? Sexual orientation? Good looks? Skin tone?

Not wildly interesting, no. Just strawman nonsense designed by forced birthers to create debate where there is none.