Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vegetarians eat fish

217 replies

KateLumley · 26/10/2022 20:06

AIBI to be annoyed that some people still think vegetarians eat fish. Because their friend is 'vegetarian' and eats fish so it must be true.

OP posts:
WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 17:40

Because lots of vegetarians do OP.
Even vegans eat creatures - millions of small creatures are destroyed every time a plant is harvested.
It’s a question of where you draw your line in the sand.

I can't stand the particularly smug brand of vegans who will insist that no animals ever die for their food and claim the exclusive moral high ground as they see it, that they are perfect and everybody else is simply terrible; but surely there's a clear difference in intent between somebody eating plants that were harvested to the detriment of field mice and somebody actually deciding to cook a haddock and cheerfully shovelling it straight into their mouth?

FourNaanJeremy · 27/10/2022 17:43

Itstarts · 27/10/2022 17:10

One of my best friends is a pescatarian. She quite often says she's vegetarian because of all the blank stares or "whats that?" responses she's had over the years.

Perhaps she could just say ‘pescatarian means I eat fish but no other meat’ instead of perpetuating the myth that vegetarians eat fish. I really couldn’t care less what anyone else eats, but I really wish people would just accurately describe their own diet instead of describing another one, redefining it and confusing people on the meaning just because they’re lazy.

Same goes for people who claim to be gluten intolerant but then eat gluten products when they fancy it. It makes life a lot harder for people with coeliacs disease, as no one takes it particularly seriously.

Borisisabanana · 27/10/2022 17:43

I know several vegans who will “make an exception for cake”.

Butchyrestingface · 27/10/2022 17:48

Borisisabanana · 27/10/2022 17:43

I know several vegans who will “make an exception for cake”.

Then they're not vegetarians.

It's a bit like sex. Even if you only do it once in a blue moon with the lights off, even if you think of raw tofu and steamed lentils the whole time, it means you are not a virgin.

ReneBumsWombats · 27/10/2022 18:01

Butchyrestingface · 27/10/2022 17:48

Then they're not vegetarians.

It's a bit like sex. Even if you only do it once in a blue moon with the lights off, even if you think of raw tofu and steamed lentils the whole time, it means you are not a virgin.

even if you think of raw tofu and steamed lentils the whole time

Stop, you're getting me all hot and bothered.

Borisisabanana · 27/10/2022 18:45

Butchyrestingface · 27/10/2022 17:48

Then they're not vegetarians.

It's a bit like sex. Even if you only do it once in a blue moon with the lights off, even if you think of raw tofu and steamed lentils the whole time, it means you are not a virgin.

😆

PinkStarAtNight · 27/10/2022 21:23

Applesandcarrots · 27/10/2022 14:51

Which one had it please? Never checked for this on tiramisu and we have gelatine issue here!

It was either Aldi or Lidl, I can't remember which one.

I'm happy to hear its not a universal thing! I had unhappily added tiramisu to the list of things I can't have. I'll look out for ones without gelatine!

RachelGreep87 · 27/10/2022 21:31

Some do, some don't. Live and let live

startfresh · 27/10/2022 21:42

Leftbutcameback · 27/10/2022 11:16

As a PP said pesto is the most annoying thing as a pescatarian / veggie. The only ones that are ok are usually really expensive organic ones, and making my own was a disaster! I'm sure if they made a standard veggie version it would sell well.

@Leftbutcameback

Same price and size as standard.

www.tesco.com/groceries/en-GB/products/297372421

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 21:46

Same goes for people who claim to be gluten intolerant but then eat gluten products when they fancy it. It makes life a lot harder for people with coeliacs disease, as no one takes it particularly seriously.

For some reason, it always seems to be the people who've decided they 'might give gluten-free a bit of a go' who make a huge fuss about it - and then still instantly ignore their own proclamations when they see a deliciously-looking cake with gluten in, with a mumbled "Ah, it should be OK".

The people who are actually gluten-intolerant will just say it once, matter-of-factly: underline that they cannot have gluten - and then leave it at that. And then, when there are delicious gluteny goods on offer later, they won't eat them - because they are the real deal.

I think the idea of 'just let people choose their own labels, live and let live' sounds nice in theory; but it just then muddies the water and can put others in danger or other compromising positions as a result.

If enough people tell you that they're gluten-intolerant, but do sometimes still eat gluten; or that they're vegetarians, but do sometimes eat meat/parts of dead animals, it just gives the message that it's not really any kind of big deal and thus maybe do your best if you can be bothered, but don't put yourself out or take it too seriously at all.

slashlover · 27/10/2022 21:52

That is a recent thing and the definition has widened over the decades. I was an old-school vegetarian and it simply meant.... not....eating.....meat.

Vegetarian since 1991, do not eat gelatine, carmine/cochineal/E120, rennet etc.

EmotionalSupportLynel · 27/10/2022 22:06

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 27/10/2022 02:17

Just messaging with a vegetarian friend who has been a lifelong vegetarian along with her mum and sister. It never occurred to her not to eat gelatine either. She was like huh? Wtf, it's not meat!

Seems like some take a rather extremist definition, whereas most vegetarians just don't eat flesh, that's all.

I've been a vegetarian for 34 years. In all that time I have always avoided products with gelatin etc, so jelly, some sweets, marshmallows.

Because I am vegetarian.

And because the definition of that has not 'changed over the years' at all.

ReneBumsWombats · 27/10/2022 22:07

The only thing that hasn't changed is people causing confusion and misinformation by not using the terms correctly and then arguing with vegetarians/vegans about it.

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 27/10/2022 22:09

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 21:46

Same goes for people who claim to be gluten intolerant but then eat gluten products when they fancy it. It makes life a lot harder for people with coeliacs disease, as no one takes it particularly seriously.

For some reason, it always seems to be the people who've decided they 'might give gluten-free a bit of a go' who make a huge fuss about it - and then still instantly ignore their own proclamations when they see a deliciously-looking cake with gluten in, with a mumbled "Ah, it should be OK".

The people who are actually gluten-intolerant will just say it once, matter-of-factly: underline that they cannot have gluten - and then leave it at that. And then, when there are delicious gluteny goods on offer later, they won't eat them - because they are the real deal.

I think the idea of 'just let people choose their own labels, live and let live' sounds nice in theory; but it just then muddies the water and can put others in danger or other compromising positions as a result.

If enough people tell you that they're gluten-intolerant, but do sometimes still eat gluten; or that they're vegetarians, but do sometimes eat meat/parts of dead animals, it just gives the message that it's not really any kind of big deal and thus maybe do your best if you can be bothered, but don't put yourself out or take it too seriously at all.

I am gluten intolerant. I can have awful stomach pain after one biscuit, or a bit of fish in breadcrumbs, but no effect with a particular brand of pasta. I only learn through trial and error. So if I see an amazing cake and my self-control is weak that day I might well be heard to mumble, "It'll be alright ..."

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 27/10/2022 22:11

Should add, but I might regret it!

Dahlietta · 27/10/2022 22:13

Could be worse. My mother-in-law thinks that vegetarians eat chicken!

Longtimelurkerfinallyposts · 28/10/2022 00:13

Just coming back to add to the chorus pointing out that vegetarians have always avoided animal rennet and gelatine (and cochineal made from beetles etc). And the Vegetarian Society has existed for a long time, and always tried to educate people about these issues.
It's shocking that -even now, when vegan/ plant-based cuisine is so trendy- many in the catering industry still don't seem to know what counts as 'vegetarian' and what definitely doesn't.
The gelatine issue is important for lots of people - eg Hindus don't want to eat beef gelatine made from cows, Muslims and Kosher-eating Jews don't want pork gelatine made from pigs... - and I'm glad that there are now more gelatine-free sweets and marshmallows available in mainstream supermarkets for children, but disturbed by how many people don't get it.

lljkk · 28/10/2022 04:39

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 17:34

The word pescatarian didn't exist in the 1980s. So if you ate fish but not other animal flesh, vegetarian was the best word you could find. That's why we used it but also ate fish.

Did you just state that you were vegetarian or did you say "I'm a vegetarian, but I do eat fish"? as a 'less wrong' description. Surely the word 'fish' still existed then?! That would have been better than using an entirely wrong label without giving any other clues, wouldn't it?

All I can say is that 1982-2000 , when I described my self as a "vegetarian" who sometimes ate fish, Nobody Cared. Not a single person complained or objected or commented. I worked in a very busy vegetarian food store for > 4 years so obviously lots of customers & fellow staff were self-identified vegetarians: nobody cared about dietary-self-mis-labelling. Obsession with other people strictly conforming to labels: I did not encounter it. The closest was when I met some strictly Jewish guys in hostel in 1991 who said to check British bread carefully because it often had lard in it. Obviously their dietary concern was religious.

I never worried about tiny % ingredients when I was "vegetarian" either. Partly thinking that lots of things could have insect body parts hidden in them & I wasn't going to try to control that. I tried to choose veg-rennet-cheeses, but I didn't fret about trace ingredients in cheese if eating in a restaurant. Sometimes with other "vegetarians" we would discuss whether to be strict about the wine or beer: most who called themselves vegetarian had decided not to worry about trace animal ingredients in the alcohol. Nobody told each other they were wrong to call selves "vegetarian" but not be strict on the wine & cheese.

My old boss has called himself vegan for 45+ years but admitted to having some cream in a hotel one time "because it looked so good."

I want to add that the SeeFood diet is much easier than being a vegetarian. I find it amazing I ever had the energy to be so strict about my diet when it wasn't necessary.

amicissimma · 28/10/2022 17:07

I know about a dozen long-term vegetarians. Every single one eats fish. None of them make a big deal about what they eat - just state their preference if we're, say, ordering a takeaway.

They've all been vegetarians for at least 25 years. Maybe the insistence on stipulating that they don't eat fish is a thing for more recent vegetarians.

ReneBumsWombats · 28/10/2022 17:11

amicissimma · 28/10/2022 17:07

I know about a dozen long-term vegetarians. Every single one eats fish. None of them make a big deal about what they eat - just state their preference if we're, say, ordering a takeaway.

They've all been vegetarians for at least 25 years. Maybe the insistence on stipulating that they don't eat fish is a thing for more recent vegetarians.

Every single one is not a vegetarian.

Phrenologistsfinger · 28/10/2022 17:15

If you eat fish then you are not a vegetarian. Nor are you a vegan. You are a pescatarian. The end.

Phrenologistsfinger · 28/10/2022 17:16

amicissimma · 28/10/2022 17:07

I know about a dozen long-term vegetarians. Every single one eats fish. None of them make a big deal about what they eat - just state their preference if we're, say, ordering a takeaway.

They've all been vegetarians for at least 25 years. Maybe the insistence on stipulating that they don't eat fish is a thing for more recent vegetarians.

I’ve been vegetarian for 40 years! And vegan for 10. Vegetarians have never eaten fish, not 25 years ago and not 30 years ago. Your friends are using the term incorrectly.

caringcarer · 28/10/2022 17:28

My dh gets very annoyed when we eat out and a fish dish is included as a vegetarian option. He always makes a point of telling waiter/waitress fish are living beings so not vegetarian.

suzyscat · 28/10/2022 17:44

YABU because plenty of people do and it's hard to keep up the lacto ovo vegetarian, pescatarian, vegan lingo.

One shouldn't assume a vegetarian eats fish so YANBU there, but it's not rude to ask if they do.

tkmethrthis · 28/10/2022 17:46

One shouldn't assume a vegetarian eats fish so YANBU there, but it's not rude to ask if they do.

It is though because vegetarians, by definition, don't eat fish.

If you were in the hospitality industry and asked me that I would be concerned that you would not either understand or adhere to my dietary requirements.