Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Vegetarians eat fish

217 replies

KateLumley · 26/10/2022 20:06

AIBI to be annoyed that some people still think vegetarians eat fish. Because their friend is 'vegetarian' and eats fish so it must be true.

OP posts:
TheOnlyBeeInYourBonnet · 27/10/2022 05:53

SnoozyLucy7 · 27/10/2022 04:22

But by eating fish, which is the flesh of an animal, you are eating meat so you are not vegetarian.

Are you having trouble reading?

I said I'm pescatarian. But I will ask for vegetarian food if given the option to specify a preference.

Or do think as a fish eater I should be banned from ordering vegetables?

startfresh · 27/10/2022 06:43

@inappropriateraspberry

But surely if the person is saying they are veggie, then they are happy to choose from the veggie options, and aren't going to complain that they weren't offered fish dishes.
I'm pescatarian, usually say I'm a vegetarian as it's easier. I wouldn't then expect to be asked if I ate fish or not, and would take the vegetarian option.

Yes and that's great, however you're in the minorities. A lot of pescatarians will specifically state they are veggie then will ask about fish options. That's the whole point.

If they didn't ask about fish and just said they were veggie and had a veggie option, absolutely fine.

And EXACTLY MY POINT you wouldn't EXPECT to be asked if you eat fish, but we are. On a regular basis.

inappropriateraspberry · 27/10/2022 07:16

I have never been asked if I eat fish after informing someone I'm vegetarian. I have been asked lots of times if I'm vegan, or if I eat ham though!

NorthStarRising · 27/10/2022 07:20

That is a recent thing and the definition has widened over the decades. I was an old-school vegetarian and it simply meant.... not....eating.....meat.

I suppose it depends on your personal bubble. I’ve been vegetarian since 1972 and to me, mine and the circles I moved in, that meant no dead animal products and a lot of label-reading. To avoid gelatine and animal fats and rennet.
It’s not a recent thing in my experience, but it might be in yours.

pigsDOfly · 27/10/2022 08:00

TimeToSellAKidney · 26/10/2022 20:56

DH is a lactose-intolerant pescatarian.
It's often easier to check the "vegan" box on dietary requirements requests (work events etc) that try to explain what he can/can't have.

Your DH's situation is completely different from the step-mum's situation, unless she also has other issues like your DH, but the poster just said she, step-mum, doesn't eat meat but eats fish and describes herself as a vegan

I also tick the vegetarian/vegan box on certain occasions, for instance a catered Christmas lunch, when the only choice on offer is between some sort of meat or a vegan alternative, usually nut roast.

That doesn't make me a vegan/vegetarian and I'm sure your DH doesn't describe himself as a vegan either in a general way.

Thurst · 27/10/2022 08:26

I think this thread is a great example of why it’s easier to say vegetarian than pescatarian or any other label. Even on here People on here can’t agree what it means. If someone asks me round for dinner and I say ‘ I eat fish but not shell fish or squid, I don’t eat gelatine but I do eat cheese without checking to labels. I drink any wine but don’t eat meat stock and I’m not bothered about things being next to each other in-the oven or BBQ’ I sound like hard work. So I usually say vegetarian then eat what I’m given.
The hypocrisy of eating some animal products and not others is the same hypocrisy we all live with in varies areas of our lives. We drive cars but care about the environment we love children but buy clothes from high street shops that are all exploitative. If you looked into the morality of most things you’d never leave the house.
I eat how I eat and I’m happy with that. I never tell anyone else they should eat differently.
The reason I eat fish is because when I was pregnant I felt like eating fish would make my diet healthier. My main objection to eating meat is that animals like pigs are very sophisticated with complex social interactions and they are very intelligent, the idea of eating a pig makes me feel guilty. Fish less so. I suppose you couldn’t make the same argument about chicken but have no desire to eat chicken.

ReneBumsWombats · 27/10/2022 09:03

Of course vegetarians don't eat rennet or gelatine. I knew some people weren't aware of what foods contain these products, but I didn't know anyone under the age of about 500 didn't realise anything that is made from an animal carcass isn't vegetarian. Vegetarians do not eat any part of an animal's body.

Veganism goes further and means you do not consume anything that comes from an animal's body or anything that was produced by an animal. So no eggs, milk or honey either.

Recognising where animal products can creep in unexpectedly can be difficult if you're not used to it, but the definitions and concepts are really not that complicated.

TimeToSellAKidney · 27/10/2022 09:07

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 26/10/2022 21:49

Out of curiosity, what is the ethos behind people who are pescatarian or 'vegetarian but eat fish'? Is it just a preference thing, in that they don't like the texture or taste of meat from land animals but do like the taste of fish and/or seafood meat?

I'm not trying to be goady, but I presume the decision doesn't come from an ethical stance?

I'm a happy confirmed meat (from land and sea animals) eater, but it seriously irritates me on behalf of vegetarians when others take their label which is understood shorthand for 'doesn't eat meat' and then apply it to themselves, even though they quite freely and happily do eat meat. Meat surely uncontroversially being understood as 'the flesh from dead animals'.

To me, it's like describing yourself as fiercely committed and staunchly faithful to your spouse, even though you do quite happily have the odd affair whenever you feel like it.

For DH he's pescatarian due to health. He has IBS and we've gradually eliminated a number of foods that cause reactions, including red meat & poultry (and legumes, onions, asparagus, stone fruits... there's a whole list).

Topseyt123 · 27/10/2022 09:10

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 27/10/2022 02:17

Just messaging with a vegetarian friend who has been a lifelong vegetarian along with her mum and sister. It never occurred to her not to eat gelatine either. She was like huh? Wtf, it's not meat!

Seems like some take a rather extremist definition, whereas most vegetarians just don't eat flesh, that's all.

Your friend is plain wrong, as are you yet here you are trying to argue black is white.

Vegetarians do not eat meat or any meat products that have been extracted after the animal has been killed. Gelatin is one of those products, as is calf rennet that is in many hard cheeses such as parmesan. They can eat dairy (being careful with some cheeses obviously), eggs and honey.

If your friend wants to be a true vegetarian then she should do her research properly. She is hardly being the font of all knowledge on the subject of vegetarianism and might like to rethink her habits if she is serious about it. This information is much more easily available now in the internet age than it was years ago.

FourNaanJeremy · 27/10/2022 09:12

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 27/10/2022 02:08

That is a recent thing and the definition has widened over the decades. I was an old-school vegetarian and it simply meant.... not....eating.....meat.

NO ONE thought about gelatin or by-products or any of that extremist bs back then. We simply, did...not....eat.....flesh.

That....is.....all.

No amount of posting the modern definitions from extremist sites will change that.

But you ate fish, which is meat. So you never were a vegetarian, by the ancient definition of the word.
HTH.

TimeToSellAKidney · 27/10/2022 09:14

pigsDOfly · 27/10/2022 08:00

Your DH's situation is completely different from the step-mum's situation, unless she also has other issues like your DH, but the poster just said she, step-mum, doesn't eat meat but eats fish and describes herself as a vegan

I also tick the vegetarian/vegan box on certain occasions, for instance a catered Christmas lunch, when the only choice on offer is between some sort of meat or a vegan alternative, usually nut roast.

That doesn't make me a vegan/vegetarian and I'm sure your DH doesn't describe himself as a vegan either in a general way.

I understand that.
I was thinking that maybe it was a description of ease i.e. when describing her diet to others who might be catering for her / making her a cup of tea, rather than "I don't eat red meat, poultry, milk, cheese, eggs, cream etc, but I do eat some fish occasionally".

lifeturnsonadime · 27/10/2022 09:22

My daughter is a strict vegetarian.

No meat products including gelatine, no honey. We have to check every label which is largely OK here but going abroad where there are different symbols/ interpretations can be a challenge.

People seem to understand Vegan better in that sense so when out ordering vegan is easier than ordering vegetarian so that's what she tends to do, especially abroad.

It is surprising what isn't vegetarian. I picked up some filled spinach and ricotta pasta which contained parmesan so she wouldn't eat it. Can be quite frustrating at times.

Vegetarian really doesn't mean no red meat!

I have a niece who is vegetarian who eats chicken!

Topseyt123 · 27/10/2022 09:29

lifeturnsonadime · 27/10/2022 09:22

My daughter is a strict vegetarian.

No meat products including gelatine, no honey. We have to check every label which is largely OK here but going abroad where there are different symbols/ interpretations can be a challenge.

People seem to understand Vegan better in that sense so when out ordering vegan is easier than ordering vegetarian so that's what she tends to do, especially abroad.

It is surprising what isn't vegetarian. I picked up some filled spinach and ricotta pasta which contained parmesan so she wouldn't eat it. Can be quite frustrating at times.

Vegetarian really doesn't mean no red meat!

I have a niece who is vegetarian who eats chicken!

Very frustrating, I agree. I was at a hotel in Spain recently and found chicken nuggets in the vegetarian section of the breakfast buffet, and very definitely individually labelled as "vegetal", which is Spanish for vegetable products/vegetarian.

They did amend the labelling and move the serving dish when I pointed this out (very politely) to the head waiter.

MyneighbourisTotoro · 27/10/2022 09:41

YANBU, it’s annoys me OP, vegetarians don’t eat meat or animals, fish are a type of animal, therefore vegetarians don’t eat fish!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 09:55

Some do some don't. The best people are the people who manage their personal eating choices with quiet grace.

But how is that possible when people quietly used (what should be) obvious descriptions for their personal eating choices and others just ignore them or decide to arbitrarily redefine them. It often boils down to "That's nice for you, dear, but I don't care' so shut up and I will decide what you will eat."

Thanks, TimeToSellAKidney - makes very good sense to me.

I never understand why so many people are determined to take on a label that clearly doesn't apply to them and then get angry when people query it. Not even talking about positive/negative labels - just relating to personal food preferences. I wasn't born in France, my parents and grandparents weren't French and I've never lived there, so would it not seem a little strange and clearly incorrect if I were to insist angrily that I AM French, just because I like croissants and David Guetta's music?

Being vegetarian or vegan isn't a moral choice with which you would proudly identify if you don't eat a vegetarian or vegan diet - so why would it mean anything to you, that you want to claim it?

MyneighbourisTotoro · 27/10/2022 10:01

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 27/10/2022 01:59

Gelatin isn't meat though. Vegans worry about by-products. Vegetarians don't care unless it's actual meat, killing the animal or not is irrelevant, they simply don't eat flesh. I have never in my life met a vegetarian that has even thought about something like gelatin. Actually it's only on this site that I've even heard about worrying about gelatin. It sounds bizarre to me.

I refused to eat gelatine, it’s made from animal parts and being a vegetarian for me not only means not eating any types of meat it also means not eating animals because I’m opposed eating something that was killed, so therefore gelatine is a big no no!

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 10:15

There are definitely parallels between a lot of perspectives this issue and the widespread desire to overturn single-sex spaces:

"How dare you suggest that I'm not a vegetarian, just because I like to eat food that has come from animals who have to be killed to provide it."

"How dare you claim that a woman can't have a penis - I have a penis and I am a woman, so that clearly disproves your suggestion."

sashh · 27/10/2022 10:43

Can I just throw in something for consideration. Some people are vegetarian only in some situations. If you are Jewish or Muslim you may well be 'vegetarian when out'.

Fish is halal and kosher. Although how or where it is prepared can make it not so.

Also for some Christians there are days that are 'fasting' or 'abstinence' or both. Abstinence means no meat, but can include fish.

So what word do you use for someone who eats kosher at home but vegi at other people's houses / cafes.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 27/10/2022 10:45

TigerDroveAgain · 26/10/2022 20:46

off topic slightly but I shared a house years ago with a very aggressive vegetarian (I'm not using your pan because it has had dead animals in it) but who snarfed down prawns etc on the basis they were 'sea vegetables'. Also had a vegetarian friend who ate bucketloads of prawns because'they have no central nervous system'

That’s brilliant. I suppose caviar would pass as well ( and eggs?). Cockroaches should be okay, too.

ReneBumsWombats · 27/10/2022 10:46

sashh · 27/10/2022 10:43

Can I just throw in something for consideration. Some people are vegetarian only in some situations. If you are Jewish or Muslim you may well be 'vegetarian when out'.

Fish is halal and kosher. Although how or where it is prepared can make it not so.

Also for some Christians there are days that are 'fasting' or 'abstinence' or both. Abstinence means no meat, but can include fish.

So what word do you use for someone who eats kosher at home but vegi at other people's houses / cafes.

Kosher/halal observant. Such people will need to know that "vegetarian" means vegetarian when they're out and need to avoid anything made of an animal's body. Just as those who aren't vegetarian but need the veggie/vegan option when stating dietary requirements for other reasons (eg the lactose intolerant person who eats only white meat and needs a safe option) need the word to mean what it means.

WeBuiltThisBuffetOnSausageRoll · 27/10/2022 10:50

But surely that's kind of what has been mentioned - that you can ask for a vegan/vegetarian/whatever meal without any issues, without claiming it as a label for yourself.

If the only meat you eat on Fridays is fish, why tie yourself in knots trying to find a label that doesn't really apply, when you can just clearly state to anybody who needs to know that you only eat fish meat on Fridays? Or even say "I eat/am pescetarian on Fridays" - rather than simply telling somebody that you are pescetarian and then having them confused when they invite you over on a Tuesday and you'll happily eat chicken.

Greenginghamdress · 27/10/2022 10:52

I'm technically a pescatarian but I eat fish sometimes. I'll have prawn cocktail for Christmas and the occasional tuna sandwich, but I try to eat it infrequently. I say vegetarian as when I have said pescatarian many people ask me what that is or make a joke about it.

Vegetarians do not eat gelatine. That's absurd to say they do. It's made of the spinal cord of animals! It may not be flesh per se, but it is from the bones and tissue of animals...how is that different to flesh!
Unfortunately gelatine is present in a lot of sweets and desserts and I've been caught out a few times and eaten it accidentally. I try my best to avoid it even though by definition I'm not a full vegetarian.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 27/10/2022 10:55

ChocolateCakeYum · 26/10/2022 20:18

I think they’ve probably never heard of the word pescatarian.

As a pescatarian I I often describe myself as a vegetarian for simplicity's sake... maybe I am part of the problem by adding to the misinformation.

inappropriateraspberry · 27/10/2022 10:58

I'm sure I saw an episode of Jimmy's Farm or similar, they soaked bits of pig to get the gelatine out of it. The children weren't impressed that that was what went in their sweets and marshmallows!

FourNaanJeremy · 27/10/2022 11:02

sashh · 27/10/2022 10:43

Can I just throw in something for consideration. Some people are vegetarian only in some situations. If you are Jewish or Muslim you may well be 'vegetarian when out'.

Fish is halal and kosher. Although how or where it is prepared can make it not so.

Also for some Christians there are days that are 'fasting' or 'abstinence' or both. Abstinence means no meat, but can include fish.

So what word do you use for someone who eats kosher at home but vegi at other people's houses / cafes.

That’s called ‘choosing the vegetarian option’ which everyone is at liberty to do. It doesn’t make them a vegetarian. In the same way that I sometimes choose vegan options when out eating if it is the only suitable option for me on the menu (I’m vegetarian - vegan options seem to be replacing vegetarian options in some restaurants) - it doesn’t mean I’m occasionally vegan. You either are or you aren’t.