Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask about a trial involving multiple counts with same jury

79 replies

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 05:37

I've a specific case in mind, though the last thread on it was deleted here, so I'm not going to mention it specifically.

My question is about multiple counts against different victims (some against same victim).

Each charge holds different evidence. Each case, holds different evidence. In fact, a lot of the cases allege different methods of alleged criminality against different alleged victims (sorry, I'm trying to choose my words carefully here).

My question is this one. Are the jury asked to consider each count separately or are they asked to consider for example that while the weight of evidence for 2 counts out of 10 isn't strong enough with EMPHASIS ON "FOR EXAMPLE", that you should still reasonably conclude that those two counts are also to be considered to be proven?

I'm sorry if that post or question seems garbled.

I can try to clarify if the question doesn't seem clear.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:51

toastofthetown · 26/10/2022 08:50

You said in the OP you didn’t want to discuss a specific case specifically but you very clearly do. Mumsnet take a very careful approach to threads on live trials as they can very quickly turn to contempt of court. Maybe you’d be better posting on Reddit or somewhere else which does allow live cases to be discussed.

I'm not discussing details of the case.

OP posts:
toastofthetown · 26/10/2022 08:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

You said in the OP you didn’t want to discuss a specific case specifically but you very clearly do. Mumsnet take a very careful approach to threads on live trials as they can very quickly turn to contempt of court. Maybe you’d be better posting on Reddit or somewhere else which does allow live cases to be discussed.

sheepandcaravan · 26/10/2022 08:42

Scotland here OP.

We have a doctrine called Moorov which might interest you to read about.

Not exactly the same but explanations about how corroboration can occur by linking different offences by time and circumstance.

It's often, for example, used with sexual assault cases.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:40

Intuition plays a lot in medicine. Not so much in a court of law.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:38

I guess it's the difference between doctors and lawyers.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:37

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Quveas · 26/10/2022 08:31

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:34

It must be a truly horrendous case to be involved in. A truly horrendous case for the parents and medical professionals too. I've discussed it briefly with a friend who is a doctor. The medical evidence so far presented is not unambiguous. There is intuition and there are obvious conclusions but God, this case? It's beyond belief in some ways.

Nobody knows what the evidence is. They know selected snippets of evidence as presented third hand by the media. There are never "obvious conclusions" and intuition plays no part in anything.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:28

CredibilityProblem · 26/10/2022 08:23

This is how I understand it with a hypothetical example. Any actual criminal lawyers on the thread feel free to correct me.

Jane works in a warehouse. Various valuable items have gone missing at times when only she was there. She is charged with five counts of theft.

For thefts 1 and 2, the CCTV shows that Jane was literally the only person in the warehouse at the time the items went missing. Only she could have taken them. For theft 3, the police have caught her selling the item on eBay in a sting operation. At the time of theft 4, only Jane was working in the warehouse but the CCTV had an intermittent fault and doesn't cover ten minutes of the day. At the time of theft 5 only Jane was in the warehouse but the CCTV was faulty for the entire day, and in addition, the back door of the warehouse had a faulty catch and swung open, leaving it accessible to the general public from the street while Jane was away in a team meeting.

The jury obviously convict in cases 1-3. In case 5, the alternative explanation, that a passing member of the public carried out the theft, is so reasonable that they acquit. They shouldn't just decide that Jane is a thief and therefore she's guilty of this particular theft.

The interesting case is case 4, where there's an alternative explanation, of a passing member of the public who just happened to break in by means unknown, at exactly the same time that the CCTV went down. If the jury were trying this case on its own, and there were no other reasons to think that Jane were a thief, then they might decide that this alternative explanation is just about reasonable enough to acquit.

But combined with the fact that they've got evidence beyond reasonable doubt that Jane has a pattern of behaviour of theft from her employer, then the coincidental burglar is a leap of faith too far. As I understand it, they are allowed to take the evidence from cases 1-3 into account in deciding whether it's reasonable to accept the defence's tenuous explanation in case 4.

So If you were charging the five cases separately they'd convict on 1-3 only. Trying them together, they can reasonably convict on 1-4.

That makes sense to me. I like analogies. I find it hard to talk about theories.

OP posts:
CredibilityProblem · 26/10/2022 08:23

This is how I understand it with a hypothetical example. Any actual criminal lawyers on the thread feel free to correct me.

Jane works in a warehouse. Various valuable items have gone missing at times when only she was there. She is charged with five counts of theft.

For thefts 1 and 2, the CCTV shows that Jane was literally the only person in the warehouse at the time the items went missing. Only she could have taken them. For theft 3, the police have caught her selling the item on eBay in a sting operation. At the time of theft 4, only Jane was working in the warehouse but the CCTV had an intermittent fault and doesn't cover ten minutes of the day. At the time of theft 5 only Jane was in the warehouse but the CCTV was faulty for the entire day, and in addition, the back door of the warehouse had a faulty catch and swung open, leaving it accessible to the general public from the street while Jane was away in a team meeting.

The jury obviously convict in cases 1-3. In case 5, the alternative explanation, that a passing member of the public carried out the theft, is so reasonable that they acquit. They shouldn't just decide that Jane is a thief and therefore she's guilty of this particular theft.

The interesting case is case 4, where there's an alternative explanation, of a passing member of the public who just happened to break in by means unknown, at exactly the same time that the CCTV went down. If the jury were trying this case on its own, and there were no other reasons to think that Jane were a thief, then they might decide that this alternative explanation is just about reasonable enough to acquit.

But combined with the fact that they've got evidence beyond reasonable doubt that Jane has a pattern of behaviour of theft from her employer, then the coincidental burglar is a leap of faith too far. As I understand it, they are allowed to take the evidence from cases 1-3 into account in deciding whether it's reasonable to accept the defence's tenuous explanation in case 4.

So If you were charging the five cases separately they'd convict on 1-3 only. Trying them together, they can reasonably convict on 1-4.

reachforthebloodymary · 26/10/2022 08:20

my friend was involved in a trial, while the fucker was found not guilty for her, due to her, he was found guilty on other counts against a different victim.

It was a while a go and I think she was told, that the chances were high he would be found not guilty but her testinomy would help convict him on some of the other counts

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:16

I suppose that I'm a little bit upset by this trial and we haven't even got to the Defence's case yet. It must be hell for everyone involved.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:14

WeAreTheHeroes · 26/10/2022 08:12

The jury has to be sure of the facts for each count in order to find the defendant guilty. I've been on a jury in a case where there were 11 counts on the indictment. The defendant was found not guilty of some counts and guilty of others. You can't just say, "well they've done x so they've probably done y too" and find them guilty of everything. That's not fair, not is it justice.

I suppose I'm thinking of it working in reverse. If they were accused of doing X, Y and Z and the jury were clear that there was no evidence of them doing X or Y, then does that mean that they believe that maybe there's a chance that they didn't do Z either?

OP posts:
WeAreTheHeroes · 26/10/2022 08:12

The jury has to be sure of the facts for each count in order to find the defendant guilty. I've been on a jury in a case where there were 11 counts on the indictment. The defendant was found not guilty of some counts and guilty of others. You can't just say, "well they've done x so they've probably done y too" and find them guilty of everything. That's not fair, not is it justice.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:09

Shebelievedshecouldbutshecba · 26/10/2022 08:06

I was on a jury with multiple victims, multiple counts. We found one count guilty, one not guilty and on all the others we were a hung jury so it went to a retrial. I often wonder what happened at the retrial, and what happened after our original guilty verdict on the one count, whether the perpetrator went to jail or not. There was a press blackout on the case.

That must have been difficult.

OP posts:
TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:07

DisplayPurposesOnly · 26/10/2022 08:04

Why then, are 22 counts and 17 alleged victims in the same trial?

You're going round in circles now. Each needs a separate charge and verdict, but need to be considered collectively as well as separately, because they are linked.

Also as PP says - a court case is expensive and is a lot to arrange! The case I was a juror for took eight working days; that was just three charges, not particularly complicated evidence.

It's doesn't have a straight-forward answer I think but you have answered it. I'd feel sad involved in this case from any end of it. I'm not sure that I'd ever quite recover. It's a lot to ask of a jury.

OP posts:
Shebelievedshecouldbutshecba · 26/10/2022 08:06

I was on a jury with multiple victims, multiple counts. We found one count guilty, one not guilty and on all the others we were a hung jury so it went to a retrial. I often wonder what happened at the retrial, and what happened after our original guilty verdict on the one count, whether the perpetrator went to jail or not. There was a press blackout on the case.

sashh · 26/10/2022 08:06

As far as I am aware then each charge has to be considered individually.

If I remember correctly Rolf Harris wasn't found guilty of all charges.

If it is the same case I'm thinking about I know what you mean, it seems similar to the Beverly Allit case but not as clear cut.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 08:05

DisplayPurposesOnly · 26/10/2022 08:04

Why then, are 22 counts and 17 alleged victims in the same trial?

You're going round in circles now. Each needs a separate charge and verdict, but need to be considered collectively as well as separately, because they are linked.

Also as PP says - a court case is expensive and is a lot to arrange! The case I was a juror for took eight working days; that was just three charges, not particularly complicated evidence.

How many victims? Or three charges relating to one victim?

OP posts:
DisplayPurposesOnly · 26/10/2022 08:04

Why then, are 22 counts and 17 alleged victims in the same trial?

You're going round in circles now. Each needs a separate charge and verdict, but need to be considered collectively as well as separately, because they are linked.

Also as PP says - a court case is expensive and is a lot to arrange! The case I was a juror for took eight working days; that was just three charges, not particularly complicated evidence.

Sandinmyknickers · 26/10/2022 08:00

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:53

Why then, are 22 counts and 17 alleged victims in the same trial?

In my trial we had counts of murder to consider as well as counts of conspiracy to cause grievous bodily harm etc. We convicted of murder but still had to go through the steps of the other charges (even though in theory, if we were saying they were guilty of murder then it followed logically that they were guilty of yhe lesser ones too)

lentilly · 26/10/2022 07:59

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:53

Why then, are 22 counts and 17 alleged victims in the same trial?

Because some of the evidence will relate to each case or a fair few of them. So instead of going over it 22 times they just go over it once.

TheNosehasit · 26/10/2022 07:58

I just find it hard to bear this trial I suppose. I'm one of those people who tends to read things that upset me as I feel that those people deserve to have their story heard, no matter how hard I find it to read about it.

It's just a legal question really.

OP posts:
Sandinmyknickers · 26/10/2022 07:58

Thought of maybe an example (but not an expert on the case so may be wrong)..but think fo the moors murders and the poor victims whose bodies still javent been found. If you tried that case without the others, with no body, probably wouldn't get a conviction. But combined with the others, you get a conviction for that victim. The case on its own is weak but combined together it is strong

lentilly · 26/10/2022 07:57

The judge will give them guidance. So if this, then this, if not then that. You don't have to say guilty to all counts and some of them are either or.

Fayrazzled · 26/10/2022 07:55

I totally see what you are saying TheNosehasit and it must be extraordinarily difficult for her families going through the court proceedings. I suppose the alternative is your child being left off the count sheet altogether because the CPS decides the evidence isn’t strong enough? And I guess there must be parents who have lost babies at that unit who will always be wondering.

Swipe left for the next trending thread