Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My girls hate their SM

154 replies

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 08:04

I am a rubbish parent just dropped off 2 DDs at breakfast club the youngest in tears. They are at there dads this weekend and they hate there SM.
I had a good thing with there dad when we seperated still parented well went out for dinners. Then he met his new wife and she stopped everything. My DDs see there dad two weekends a month and he picks them up from school two nights a week he's a good dad just a rubbish husband. What can I say to my DDs that makes them feel better I can't believe he chooses his new wife over his kids.The girls are 13 and 15.

OP posts:
beachcitygirl · 21/10/2022 09:41

Hmmm

A bit of both here & we don't know enough to go on.

OP you need to "allow" your kids to like stepmum.

But

I'd be having a round the table chat with my daughters.
Do they have their own space in dads home?
Do they get to spend alone time with dad or is stepmum there every minute.
Does she do anything unkind or rude
Does she obviously prioritise her kids & make them feel second best.

If none of the above is the problem then YOU are the problem.

Worthyornot · 21/10/2022 09:42

HeddaGarbled · 21/10/2022 08:11

He sees them every other weekend and two nights a week. In what way is he choosing his new wife over his kids? Stop stirring.

This. It's pretty normal to not want to play happy families and go for dinners if you have moved on and remarried. You are definitely stirring Here by saying you can't believe he has done this. They probably get some of the issue from you.

Novum · 21/10/2022 09:42

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 08:42

She would not want him to come to my house alone and I don't want him in my house. They want to see there dad just not her.

But that simply isn't going to happen, and crying won't change it. They need to get used to the fact that she is in their dad's life and, if they want a relationship with him, they need to accept that.

hardtochangename · 21/10/2022 09:43

Your DDs are used to things being different and now have to grow up a bit more and adjust to new arrangements. You can help them with that. Family dinners might be understandable for special occasions but as a regular event that seems to be perpetuating a falsity. Your ex has a new life and has a home with a new wife, she's going to be there when your DDs go round. What is she doing exactly that's so terrible?

mam0918 · 21/10/2022 09:43

She stopped everything... What is everything? And when?

You say hes a good dad but shit husband, it doesnt sound like a good father to put your girlfriend before his kids (and I doubt he met and instantly married this woman) so he chose to marry someone who was effecting his family.

It doesnt sound at all like hes a 'bad husband' just a 'selfish father' to put her demands above the happiness of his kids who he had a great relationship with before.

Im all for kids not having a say in their parents relationships but you also cant just suddenly completely change the stable working co-parent dynamic you built because you found someone new.

Badger1970 · 21/10/2022 09:45

Given their ages, no court would enforce contact. I wouldn't make them go if it's making them unhappy. I don't see an issue with them messaging him that they don't want to stay over as they don't feel comfortable. And hard as it is, it's for them and him to sort out - I'd stay well out of it.

I didn't see my Dad for many years because of my SM. I never hated her, but she didn't want to be around my sister and I and we didn't want to be around her.
She died young, so we got a relationship back with him but I won't lie that it didn't hurt like hell at the time.

Worthyornot · 21/10/2022 09:47

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 08:33

I am talking to them Zero and trying to find out if there a bigger problem. Im not goading them to dislike her but I don't like her and maybe they pick up on it.

Well off course this is why. It's you who has given them this idea. The fact you don't know why they don't like her tells you that already! They don't have a specific reason because they are going on what you are feeling. And if they only know her for a short time, it's normal for her not to have that bond with them. They are already much older children so she's not going to be in any Motherly role.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 21/10/2022 09:48

ITookABathWithAinsleyHarriott · 21/10/2022 09:34

@youngestisapsycho I suspect it’s because there is no real reason they dislike her.

My DH’s ex was fine with me until we got engaged and bought a home together (5 years into dating so definitely not rushed). She then tried to alienate my SDs from me who were 11 & 15 at the time and I’d previously had a lovely relationship with them.

I had them saying things like “
Mum said it’s unfair we don’t have the biggest bedroom”
”Mum said dad doesn’t take us out as much anymore”
”Mum said dad wouldn’t let her have the key to the house to use the washing machine because hers is broken”.

They don’t have the biggest bedroom because my DD is a full time resident of the house and all her worldly possessions need room to store them. SDs stay a max of 8 nights a month.

Dad was in a shit tonne of debt when I met him, mostly pertaining to the ridiculous sums of money he was spending on the other household so their mum could choose not to work. I told him I wouldn’t marry him or buy a home with him whilst he was in debt so he tightened his belt and sorted out his finances. This has also brought long term stability to his children.

No, we were not willing to allow their mum to have a key to our house and free reign of our appliances. We did however offer to pick up the kids washing and drop it back clean.

Because of this, his ex tried poison her kids against me with sly comments and twisting things to fit her own agenda.

At 11 & 15 (now 13 & 17) they were old enough to be told the truth from our perspective and luckily we were able to reserve a lot of the damage.

We are now married and his ex still tries to feed into any perceived drama by encouraging the girls to dislike me. She can’t see that the only people she is hurting by doing this are her own children.

I really hope for your daughters’ sakes that your ex can sit them down and have a mature conversation about things and then hopefully they’ll realise how bizarre your reaction to their SM is.

I could have written this myself. DH’s ex cannot accept he has moved on (even though she left him), and has fed this into SC, who were previously happy and loved coming to us.

It’s not really me it affects, it’s SC. And DH. But mostly SC.

OP, don’t do this to your children.

Worthyornot · 21/10/2022 09:48

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 09:00

Mrs Keats she stopped our family dinners together. He does see them on his own its when they go to his house and she's there that they don't like it.

Well pretty normal for her to want to do that!! Why should she be fine with her husband going off to dinners with his ex wife and playing happy families?? This is sometimes done, but only if everyone else is happy.

TeaAndJaffacakes · 21/10/2022 09:49

Maybe the problem is actually with their dad? Is he talking about his wife and kids as though they are a family and should act like a nuclear family when the girls are with him and this is grating on the girls and their teenage interpretation is that SM is the problem rather than their DDad’s expectations?

SmileyClare · 21/10/2022 09:50

Encourage some positive conversation towards their stepmum.

It’s fine for your dds to moan about her or feel threatened by her relationship with their dad. As their parent, you need to be more rational and help dds accept their situation.

At the moment I think your daughters feel they have to choose a side: their mum or their stepmother.

Rewis · 21/10/2022 09:50

Does she stop the kids and dad from having a day out together and insist of always being there? Or is the problem that she exits in the same house in general?

Worthyornot · 21/10/2022 09:52

It's slowly unraveling that it's you who is the issue here/at least encouraging the issue. Pretty obvious the dc have picked up on your dislike and carrying it out. Your disbelief at stopping family dinners is quite telling.

Dishwashersaurous · 21/10/2022 09:52

Family dinners with separated parents is so strange and werid for the children.

No wonder your children are confused, you were acting like you weren't separated. They probably held onto a belief that you might get back together.

Now that's clearly not going to happen.

You need to not engage with this conversation at all. You don't talk about the wife at all.

Mariposista · 21/10/2022 09:53

Unless this woman has given them a reason to dislike her, they need to grow up a bit. Is it HER they dislike or the principle of her?

Beamur · 21/10/2022 09:55

She didn’t stop the meals. He did
This is normal. Going out for birthdays etc is fine. But carrying on 'family dinners' actually perpetuates the myth of this family unit and is part of the problems you are having now.
Dad has moved on. He has remarried and shares a home with his wife.
You need to let this go for the sake of your girls too. Make sure nothing actually unpleasant is happening at the other house.
Don't expect SM to love them. To be kind, pleasant and make them welcome, that's fine.
Dad should spend time with the girls and it sounds like he does.
This is the reality of divorce.

Algor1thm · 21/10/2022 09:56

Their issue is that they go to his house and his wife is there. Presumably it's not his house, it's their house. I'm afraid it's not reasonable to expect her not to be there. Doesn't mean their feelings aren't valid, but they have to sit with them. It wouldn't be reasonable to expect things to be any different.

My dad is remarried and I really don't like his wife. But I don't expect her not to be in her own house 🤷🏼‍♀️ I just rarely go there. As kids they may not have that choice. But maybe help them to explore if they really dislike her as a person or just what she represents. Has she actually done anything other than 'take their dad away'?

TheOrigRights · 21/10/2022 09:57

I've only read the OP's posts.

If their Dad wants to maintain a relationship with his daughters then it's up to him to enable it, and at the ages they are I don't think it's simply a case of them having to suck it up and see their Dad when he can fit them in around his new family, but to prioritise them.

Unless they are being really bratty and cruel towards his new wife then he will just need to accept that they don't want a relationship with their SM - they can be respectful but not see her.

They are his children and it's up to him to manage this. He doesn't have to pander to them, but make time to do what they want to do on their terms.
If he doesn't do this then the reality is that the relationship will breakdown.

Aphidsandhoneybees · 21/10/2022 09:59

As long as the new wife is not abusive there’s not a lot you can do about it, other than have a word with your exdh if you can. It’s up to him to handle the situ whilst they’re with him. As you’ve said yourself your own attitude might be contributing to your DDs’ “hate” of this woman. They may have overheard you talking about how she won’t let you have family meals together anymore and they might be viewing her as the person/ reason why you’re no longer together, even though she’s not. Your job is to make sure they come to terms with the way things are as smoothly as possible. I know it’s painful to see them upset but that doesn’t make you a rubbish parent. You’ve said yourself he’s a good dad, try not to worry whilst they’re there, I know it’s hard, but try and have that conversation with your exdh, whilst your DC’s are not around.

WickedStepmomNOT · 21/10/2022 10:01

Parentingbynumbers98 · Today 08:42

She would not want him to come to my house alone and I don't want him in my house. They want to see there dad just not her.

This I think is what my DSD thinks also, and I try to be understanding. I was not OW, and we met and married long after DH and exw split up, but she clearly doesn't like me around. I made her a nice comfy room at ours to make her fel welcome, and I do plan to go out on one day of her weekends - she's here EOW - but it is my home too. Come the cold weather, Im not doing long walks any more and theres a limit to movies and museums. Nor am i staying in my room!

I never called DH by his name when I talk to her, I always say 'your dad' to reinforce the bond, but its slowly slowly eggshell time. As my name says Im not the wicked stepmother but my god its difficult!

MacroTwigg · 21/10/2022 10:01

Parentingbynumbers98 · 21/10/2022 08:23

No drip feed he is a decent dad. I don't really know why they hate her so much. She is not me and doesn't love them and they feel it. They want dad to themselves they are a bit young for there age. He does see them on there own as she goes out sometimes or he takes them to the cinema.

They sound like they're acting a bit bratty then. Because they're having to share their dad with his wife now.

whumpthereitis · 21/10/2022 10:02

So far the only thing you’ve said ‘against’ the stepmother is that she doesn’t love them. Which isn’t actually a fault on her part at all, why would she love two children that aren’t hers and are hostile towards her?

If she was an actual ‘evil stepmother’ i don’t doubt you’d be more than happy to give a detailed list of her sins, so it seems the issue is that she exists at all.

of course the dynamic between you changed when he met someone else. That’s entirely normal. You’re separated, and no longer an intact family, so why the expectation that you will continue to act like one. The likelihood is that the cosy dinners would have stopped no matter who he met.

It does come across that instead of supporting your daughters and helping them adapt to the new dynamic, you’re encouraging their ill feelings as they match your own.

JennyNotFromTheBlock · 21/10/2022 10:05

Wait.... you had family dinners with your ex-husband?!?? That is so incredibly messed up and so wrong on many levels. Why on earth did you do that? Common sense would have told you when he entered his next relationship these 'family' dinners with your ex husband would have to stop. So why did you even allow that in the first place? Wow you've really stuffed this up. I agree, you're the common denominator/problem here. Having your ex husband to 'family' dinners was so inappropriate. So inappropriate on many levels. What were you even thinking?? smh

Put yourself in their (SM) shoes. Imagine when you were married to your ex-husband, if he had kids with a previous woman, and he went swanning off regularly to have intimate family dinners with his ex-wife and children. Be honest, even if you can't be honest on here, be honest in your own head; how would you feel?

You (and your ex) gave your girls false hope that you were still a family, then, suddenly, of course those dinners had to stop, because it's wholely and absolutely inappropriate women you become a family with another woman. You both have absolutely fucked with the minds of those girls, and they believe it's all their SM's fault, (instead of your fault), because you let them believe that.

You've made a mess of this. Forget talking to your ex, you have a lot of explaining to do to your girls and a lot of apologising to them to do. You've set them up for this disappointment by making them think you were still a couple.

CarefreeMe · 21/10/2022 10:06

I can't believe he chooses his new wife over his kids.

Why do you say he chooses his new wife over his kids?
What does he do?

There doesn’t sound like any major issues and hopefully it’s just a case of them just wanting their dads attention.

Could you speak to him and tell him how they are feeling?
You could suggest that when they go over he makes sure he spends time alone with them.

I remember wanting to spend time with just my dad and he would only see us when his new wife was there too.
There was nothing wrong with her but I barely knew her and so I just wanted time with my dad sometimes.

Spending the day out with just him and his DDs would be a good compromise but unfortunately this is out of your hands.

ThisIsHardcore · 21/10/2022 10:08

OP, I think you're the problem here, not your ex husband or his wife or your daughters.

For whatever reason, you're unhappy that your ex husband has moved on. That is your problem, so don't turn in into your daughters' problem too.

You presumably enjoyed acting as if you were still a nuclear family when you were still getting together to have dinner etc. Perhaps your ex husband was secretly hating every minute of it and was just doing it for his daughters' sakes. Perhaps he was glad not to have to go through the whole charade any longer. Perhaps his wife told him he couldn't do it any more and he was upset about it.

Nobody knows what the reason is - but your job is to reassure your DDs that their dad loves them, and to encourage them to see that him choosing to be in a relationship with their SM is not him "choosing her over them". It sounds as if you're encouraging them to see it as a great betrayal of them. You are doing your daughters no favours at all by doing this.