Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be baffled by DH and his commute/working hours?

903 replies

GreatLates · 20/10/2022 16:00

DH started a new job - I used to do the same job in the same industry so I know how it all works. His employer requires him on site from 8.15-4.10 each day and he can do the rest from home as and when suits him as long as it's done. It's uncommon in the industry but DH's employer doesn't have meetings beyond 4.10 - this was something he bragged about when moving to this employer. We currently live two hours away from his site but we're moving (tomorrow, finally) to be about 15 minutes away from it. So, at the moment, DH leaves around 6am and should get home by 6.30 depending on traffic - and that's how it was for the first few weeks. But now, there's suddenly a million reasons why he's leaving early or coming home late. I also work full-time but I don't have set hours - DCs aren't school age so I have DS three days each week and DD every day and then start work when DH gets home. So, every time DH is late, I have to stay up even later working and/or lose time out of my weekend (I work 45 hours per week).

To take this week as an example, he told me last week that he had signed up for an extension to his shift for Monday this week which would mean he left an hour later but he'd get paid above his usual rate - which is fine. Then, over the weekend he said "oh, remember I can't collect DS from nursery on Tuesday because I'm doing the shift extension" and I said "you told me it was on Monday", "oh, yeah, yeah, it is, sorry". Then, later he said "I can't remember if I told you, I've signed up to a shift extension on Tuesday so I'll be home late" and I said again "you told me Monday" and, again, he said "oh, yeah, my bad, it is". So, Monday rolls around and he messages me to say he's just double-checked the rota and he's not staying late on Monday, he's staying late on Tuesday. It makes no difference to me which day it is so I said it's fine or whatever and said "so I'll see you at 6.30 then" and he didn't reply but he messaged me again at 4.30 to ask me to call our mortgage lender because they tried to phone him and he won't be finished by 5 (when they close). I asked why he's not finishing at 4.30 and he said he has a meeting (but he made a big thing when he took this job about how great it is that they never do meetings outside of the allotted time).

Then on Tuesday, I woke up at just gone 5.15 which is when we normally get up because DH has to leave at 6. I was feeding DD so I phoned DH at 5.37 (I have the call log) thinking he was downstairs getting ready (and I was going to pester him to make me a cup of tea) - but when he answered he was in the car driving so I said it doesn't matter and I didn't realise the time (thinking I must've got the time wrong if he'd already left). So, then, at 6.05, I realised I wasn't wrong on the time so I phoned him and I asked him where he was and he said he was at the petrol station near our house. I asked him why he'd left early and flatly refused to accept that he'd left early and said he let at 6... but I have the call log!

So, yesterday, I had a work meeting (which I only have on Wednesdays) starting from 6.30 so I needed him to be prompt - but he didn't arrive through the door until almost 8! No explanation from him for why he was late - and I had to try and do the meeting with DS bouncing around and DD on my lap.

Because we're completing on our sale tomorrow, DH and I packed up the car last night and DH was going to drive it down today and put the stuff into the storage unit we've rented near his work so everything we have left will fit in the car tomorrow. So, this morning, he left at 5 so he'd have time to unload the stuff into the unit. I just spoke to him now and he's said he won't be coming back as soon as he finishes because he needs to go to the unit to empty the car. He said it was never his intention to go before work and didn't realise that I thought he was going to - but then why did he leave an hour early?!

It honestly feels like he's trying to avoid spending time with me but a) when he's leaving early in the morning he would be sleeping and so would I, so even if he can't stand me, surely he'd rather be asleep? and b) the rest of his behaviour isn't indicating that. He says he loves me, he's very happy etc. At the end of the day, we're completing tomorrow so it's not going to be going on much longer but I am exhausted from having the kids on my own for additional hours and then having to do a full day of work myself! He's not usually like this (usually rushing home, mostly to see the kids) so the sudden change has concerned me - is he depressed? He seems fine in every other way. Any thoughts?

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 22/10/2022 10:22

Why are you not on maternity leave?

Mirrorcell · 22/10/2022 10:23

Id drop it with him. Let him drop his guard and then check his phone. Or put a voice recorder in the car. Yes you shouldn’t have to but his behaviour is unusual and he’s obviously up to something. Don’t rule out an online/phone affair.

Jaybird43 · 22/10/2022 10:32

Is this seriously real? Like how can OP repeatedly ask DH about his strange behaviour, he gives a really rubbish and unbelievable response, and then she drops it and then asks again when he does something else strange? Like surely you would demand to know / he shows his phone offers up a proper explanation?

MrsLargeEmbodied · 22/10/2022 10:34

perhaps he has some shady business opportunity on the side?

MrsLargeEmbodied · 22/10/2022 10:35

do you not have a joint bank account?

EmmaDilemma5 · 22/10/2022 10:35

Your lifestyle sounds very stressful.

Your husband is lying to you. And his inability to answer simple questions about why he's lying to you and taking stupid amounts of time unaccounted for is disrespectful.

You wouldn't be the first or last to accept a partner cheating on you. Which sadly, it seems he's doing.

But it's irrelevant really isn't it. He's lying, and you don't need to live with a liar.

WimbyAce · 22/10/2022 10:39

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

adviceplease93 · 22/10/2022 10:40

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

NotSorry · 22/10/2022 10:53

RampantIvy · 22/10/2022 10:22

Why are you not on maternity leave?

Just because her baby is 12 weeks olds, doesn’t mean she’s on maternity leave. I had to go back to work when my eldest was 6 weeks old as we needed the money as we were also moving house.

ReluctantCourier · 22/10/2022 10:54

@Endlesslysurprised84 it was about 3-6 weeks, that’s how blatant it was. Like most people, I didn’t start googling family law firms the first time he worked late or seemed a bit distant. It became very quickly apparent something wasn’t right. We had two young kids so I tried ti get babysitters/organise dates which if anything confirmed my suspicions as without the kids to distract it was quite clear how glued to his phone he was. I asked him repeatedly what was up and he distracted/evaded/gaslit. After giving him a chance to change the behaviour or come clean I got the evidence I needed and divorced him within a year, hanging into the house, dog and the kids live with me.

But yeah, do tell me how you’d do it better 🤔

Jeanstable · 22/10/2022 11:01

OP you need to open your eyes, I don’t know why you’re believing everything he’s saying.

SecretWorrier · 22/10/2022 11:10

@GreatLates See how it goes from here. Leave it a week to settle. Then how about one of those family tracker apps. Family 360 or something. You can say you want to feel safe if anything ever happens he would know where you are. That way he has to have it on his phone too.

Endlesslysurprised84 · 22/10/2022 11:24

ReluctantCourier · 22/10/2022 10:54

@Endlesslysurprised84 it was about 3-6 weeks, that’s how blatant it was. Like most people, I didn’t start googling family law firms the first time he worked late or seemed a bit distant. It became very quickly apparent something wasn’t right. We had two young kids so I tried ti get babysitters/organise dates which if anything confirmed my suspicions as without the kids to distract it was quite clear how glued to his phone he was. I asked him repeatedly what was up and he distracted/evaded/gaslit. After giving him a chance to change the behaviour or come clean I got the evidence I needed and divorced him within a year, hanging into the house, dog and the kids live with me.

But yeah, do tell me how you’d do it better 🤔

Good grief.

knittingaddict · 22/10/2022 11:29

Unbelievable.

Burgoo · 22/10/2022 11:32

@GreatLates

A few thoughts, I haven't caught up with the updates however...

  1. Tracking him sounds a little too much for me. If it were a man and he was saying he was tracking his female partner's phone he would be called controlling/coercive, and people would be saying "leave him". Let's not have double standards.
  2. Until you KNOW what he is doing, don't assume. People are jumping on the cheating hypothesis because it is a convenient and often common reason. There could be any number of reasons, OP needs to get to the bottom of it.
  3. "He is a terrible liar" and "he can't be having an affair". oh dear. I suppose he told the OP that too. The absolute best liars are the ones that blatantly lie about the little things to "show" that they are bad liars. Only to be very skilled with lying about the big stuff. It's easy to make it look like you are a bad liar; just look a bit shifty, say how guilty you feel for lying, say that you want to be honest etc.

From my ++ experience working with people who can be ++ dishonest, I'd sit him down and have a frank conversation with him about it. Though start by getting him relaxed - not a "can we talk tonight?" text - after dinner etc. Then ask the question "what are you doing during X,Y,Z times because what you say doesn't add up?" Check his body language. Anything out of his normal baseline I would jump on. If he seems to get edgy when specific topics are raised, push on the topic hard. Then back off a bit, give him an out. "It'd make sense if you were doing X, we can work together on it. It doesn't make you a bad person"... then reel him back in. If he has good, honest answers he won't struggle just saying it and sticking to the story. He will only move to fight/flight if he feels you are going toward something that will get him in the shit. I'd name it - "you seem to look really uncomfortable with this conversation, I notice A,B and C when I asked". If this doesn't work I would speak about a specific situation and get him to explain BACKWARDS from getting home back to being at work. Who, what, when, why, how, where? If he is lying there is a good chance he won't be able to recall events in reverse. Lies tend to come to use in a linear (forward) fashion. Recalling fictional events backwards is actually very hard and usually people leak stress cues. Move between the supportive/understanding partner and the needing to know spouse. This technique can work beautifully when done well.

Alternatively, don't interrogate him!
Hope this is helpful. good luck!

Hippyatheart58 · 22/10/2022 11:34

I personally would be looking at the Google map history if he has that on his phone. I get an email from Google each month highlighting where I been how many miles walked and driven. It now even breaks down everyday for me. I like it cause am trying to up my walking and this shows an improvement without the whole watch/app side of it. I have occasionally thought though if I was up to no good this certainly would prove

Hippyatheart58 · 22/10/2022 11:36

Grrr posted to soon!

Prove my guilt. I think enough is going on right now to justify a little snoop tbh.

bloomety · 22/10/2022 11:36

ImustLearn2Cook · 22/10/2022 00:28

@GreatLates You’ve given birth only 12 weeks ago, you are parenting a toddler and a newborn, you are working late into the night, you’ve just moved house. That is an awful lot on your plate. On top of all this your husband is not treating you with respect and is leaving you for hours on end with no explanation.

You are in no way to blame for the way he is treating you, it is all on him. Honestly, you have so much on your plate and there really is only so much one person can deal with.

I have no idea what he’s playing at so I can’t offer any suggestions there. However, just want to say look after yourself, be kind to yourself and do whatever you need to do to lighten the load a bit. 💐🌺🌸

what a lovely post. Yes it must be really stressful for the OP. You’ve just given birth, this should be a lovely family time, feeling secure and everyone getting to know the new baby. You’ve got a lot on your plate

LuckyLil · 22/10/2022 11:40

NotSorry · 22/10/2022 10:53

Just because her baby is 12 weeks olds, doesn’t mean she’s on maternity leave. I had to go back to work when my eldest was 6 weeks old as we needed the money as we were also moving house.

Yes, but she has repeatedly dodged that question. And as you and I both know, it's quite simple to explain.

babyyodaxmas · 22/10/2022 11:48

I'm thinking fuge state breaking bad, he is manufacturing crystal meth.

Quitelikeit · 22/10/2022 11:52

Op check his locations on his iPhone it’ll tell you where he’s been and at what time

TheLassWiADelicateAir · 22/10/2022 11:53

LuckyLil · 22/10/2022 11:40

Yes, but she has repeatedly dodged that question. And as you and I both know, it's quite simple to explain.

Why does she need to explain ? Not every woman takes maternity leave or full maternity leave. I had 3 months in total. It's a fact that she's not on maternity leave- why she isn't, is irrelevant.

Blueeyedgirl21 · 22/10/2022 11:54

I thought op might be the same poster who is doing the masters that she absolutely has to do right this instant whilst on Mat leave and being funded for it which the funding is being topped up by SMP so she doesn’t effectively have to take a wave drop for Mat leave. The hours and circumstances are so so similar but in that post the DH leaves at 6am to take the DS to nursery on his way to work and if I’m not mistaken that isn’t happening here?

Blueeyedgirl21 · 22/10/2022 11:55

Wage drop - wave drop lol

Bollindger · 22/10/2022 12:14

The morning thing makes me think maybe he is getting to the work location and having a nice breakfast with a book and quiet time,.
Maybe the same on the collection bit, he got himself a snack, hence why not worried about food when he came home.
Go out to his car and log his mileage, you know how far he should travel and you can see if any miles extra are being logged.