Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be baffled by DH and his commute/working hours?

903 replies

GreatLates · 20/10/2022 16:00

DH started a new job - I used to do the same job in the same industry so I know how it all works. His employer requires him on site from 8.15-4.10 each day and he can do the rest from home as and when suits him as long as it's done. It's uncommon in the industry but DH's employer doesn't have meetings beyond 4.10 - this was something he bragged about when moving to this employer. We currently live two hours away from his site but we're moving (tomorrow, finally) to be about 15 minutes away from it. So, at the moment, DH leaves around 6am and should get home by 6.30 depending on traffic - and that's how it was for the first few weeks. But now, there's suddenly a million reasons why he's leaving early or coming home late. I also work full-time but I don't have set hours - DCs aren't school age so I have DS three days each week and DD every day and then start work when DH gets home. So, every time DH is late, I have to stay up even later working and/or lose time out of my weekend (I work 45 hours per week).

To take this week as an example, he told me last week that he had signed up for an extension to his shift for Monday this week which would mean he left an hour later but he'd get paid above his usual rate - which is fine. Then, over the weekend he said "oh, remember I can't collect DS from nursery on Tuesday because I'm doing the shift extension" and I said "you told me it was on Monday", "oh, yeah, yeah, it is, sorry". Then, later he said "I can't remember if I told you, I've signed up to a shift extension on Tuesday so I'll be home late" and I said again "you told me Monday" and, again, he said "oh, yeah, my bad, it is". So, Monday rolls around and he messages me to say he's just double-checked the rota and he's not staying late on Monday, he's staying late on Tuesday. It makes no difference to me which day it is so I said it's fine or whatever and said "so I'll see you at 6.30 then" and he didn't reply but he messaged me again at 4.30 to ask me to call our mortgage lender because they tried to phone him and he won't be finished by 5 (when they close). I asked why he's not finishing at 4.30 and he said he has a meeting (but he made a big thing when he took this job about how great it is that they never do meetings outside of the allotted time).

Then on Tuesday, I woke up at just gone 5.15 which is when we normally get up because DH has to leave at 6. I was feeding DD so I phoned DH at 5.37 (I have the call log) thinking he was downstairs getting ready (and I was going to pester him to make me a cup of tea) - but when he answered he was in the car driving so I said it doesn't matter and I didn't realise the time (thinking I must've got the time wrong if he'd already left). So, then, at 6.05, I realised I wasn't wrong on the time so I phoned him and I asked him where he was and he said he was at the petrol station near our house. I asked him why he'd left early and flatly refused to accept that he'd left early and said he let at 6... but I have the call log!

So, yesterday, I had a work meeting (which I only have on Wednesdays) starting from 6.30 so I needed him to be prompt - but he didn't arrive through the door until almost 8! No explanation from him for why he was late - and I had to try and do the meeting with DS bouncing around and DD on my lap.

Because we're completing on our sale tomorrow, DH and I packed up the car last night and DH was going to drive it down today and put the stuff into the storage unit we've rented near his work so everything we have left will fit in the car tomorrow. So, this morning, he left at 5 so he'd have time to unload the stuff into the unit. I just spoke to him now and he's said he won't be coming back as soon as he finishes because he needs to go to the unit to empty the car. He said it was never his intention to go before work and didn't realise that I thought he was going to - but then why did he leave an hour early?!

It honestly feels like he's trying to avoid spending time with me but a) when he's leaving early in the morning he would be sleeping and so would I, so even if he can't stand me, surely he'd rather be asleep? and b) the rest of his behaviour isn't indicating that. He says he loves me, he's very happy etc. At the end of the day, we're completing tomorrow so it's not going to be going on much longer but I am exhausted from having the kids on my own for additional hours and then having to do a full day of work myself! He's not usually like this (usually rushing home, mostly to see the kids) so the sudden change has concerned me - is he depressed? He seems fine in every other way. Any thoughts?

OP posts:
Idratherbepaddleboarding · 20/10/2022 23:16

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Booklover3 · 20/10/2022 23:31

Im so sorry OP but with your update about him changing into nice clothes it’s not looking good. I hope he isn’t having an affair

RebeccaRose92 · 20/10/2022 23:33

OP I have no advice but my Dp has been the same last couple months. I’m suspicious.

StoppinBy · 20/10/2022 23:34

Do you have his work number? Calling that when he is late or really early would be a sure fire way to find out if he is actually where he says he is.

Bournetilly · 20/10/2022 23:43

Sounds like an affair

deeperthanallroses · 20/10/2022 23:52

Wearing nice clothes huh?
She's 12 weeks. The house move is what will give because it saves us hours of the day when DH doesn't have to commute.
it will only get easier if he uses that saved time for his family not for his affair.

JulesCobb · 20/10/2022 23:54

he doesnt have to be good at lying to be lying. He is obviously lying to you.

Ariela · 21/10/2022 00:15

He's either

  • having an affair
  • Driving in early to avoid the rush hour traffic, and napping. Then napping around the corner before he comes home
  • Lost his job, is too worried to tell you and has been driving over early to look for work, and has just been for an interview
All will be revealed once you've moved and he's not home 15 mins after his shift
PickAnyName · 21/10/2022 00:15

EarringsandLipstick · 20/10/2022 16:25

Unfortunately, walks like a duck, quacks like a duck ...

This. If it's not another woman, is he gambling?

He sounds like he is up to something he shouldn't be.

StarCourt · 21/10/2022 00:29

How did your word go Op?

akabluebell · 21/10/2022 00:38

Iwonder08 · 20/10/2022 20:13

Honestly, who has affairs at 6 am? He has a new job, maybe he wants to put in more hours at the beginning? Maybe he picked up a new hobby and doesn't want to say anything yet? Is it possible he is too stressed with the new job and house move happening at the same time and just needs some time to himself?
I would attempt a non-accusatory chat first before any of the spy things people suggested

Mine did. I was the OW and he used to come by at 5ish a.m. after he'd worked the night shift.

MrsElijahMikaelson1 · 21/10/2022 00:38

Sounds like an affair to me💐

Puppers · 21/10/2022 00:44

You don't sound controlling at all. Parents can't just go AWOL, leaving the children's other parent to pick up all their slack for hours and hours every week without explanation or agreement. He's unilaterally making you entirely responsible for his children and preventing the main breadwinner in the family from doing their job properly.

The facts are:

  • He is lying about where he is and what time he is out of the house (and further, he's gaslighting you by doubling down on these lies when confronted).
  • He has turned up at home very late and in "nice" clothes, having changed out of his work clothes at some point.
  • He is lying about being in meetings after he has finished work.
  • He has drastically changed his behaviour and no longer rushes home to see his children.

His lie about working late on Monday...no Tuesday...no actually, Monday...seems as though whatever he was actually planning to do had not been confirmed yet and he was pretending to be confused about his work schedule whilst making sure his "working late" alibi seemed plausible because presumably you would have been suspicious if he announced overtime on the day of.

Easy for a stranger online to say perhaps, but if it quacks like a duck and walks like a duck...

He's definitely up to no good. If he was really doing overtime he'd just tell the truth and you know he's definitely lying. So why? What is he covering up? A woman makes sense. And if it's a town that you both have ties to, it wouldn't necessarily need to be someone at work. It could be someone he knows who lives in the area. The other thing that would add up with some of the details (although not really the outfit change) would be gambling or drugs. But you seem sure that you'd see a financial trail.

PyongyangKipperbang · 21/10/2022 01:15

I wouldnt say it is an affair right now but it sounds like he is on the cop.

Be careful, this could get very messy very quickly.

I suggest you start the conversation with "I know what is going on, but I would prefer you to tell me yourself" and see what he comes out with. IME a good non commital blindside like that will elicit a lot of very crap attempts at lying....and you will know straight away what he is up to.

ICancelledTheCheque · 21/10/2022 02:55

When I was seeing someone at work, we would meet up before and after work. So entirely possible that it’s an affair.

emptythelitterbox · 21/10/2022 04:01

I've RTT and I think you'll know more after next week and you're done moving.
If he's still leaving early and returning late, obviously he is up to something.

You mentioned all male workplace.
I've often been the only women working with a group of men well except for a couple admin types. The men would often avoid going home by fannying about online, playing video games with workmates, and other nonsense. No affair but they wanted to avoid any home or childcare duties.

So that would be my first guess. You mentioned he loved parenting. People change, for no real reason. I used to love the actual parenting part and domestic things. Now, it would be very difficult to deal with a toddler or infant for more than a couple of hours lol.

Regardless of what he's doing, it's quite unfair to you and the family.

groovergirl · 21/10/2022 04:07

OP, you both sound absolutely exhausted. 💐If I were the boss of your household, I'd organise some in-home afternoon childcare, plus a cleaner. No way should you be struggling on alone, with no free time at all.

As to what your DH is up to, I think this PP has it nailed: A new job, a house move, two little ones, and those early starts and the commute ... He might just be a bit fried. Yep.* *I know the usual MN "advice" is that your DH is having an affair, but I reckon it's more likely he's using that long commute to listen to music and, perhaps at the end of it, play games on his phone. Maybe even take a nap in his car, as I sometimes did!

I'm a woman working FT in transport infrastructure and can assure you that certain "male" industries have much longer working hours than is standard. If there's something that must be done urgently, you have to stay back and do it without complaint. And that can happen every day. Want to keep your job? Then shut up and do it.

When I was married but before DC, I had a different job that also required long hours. This didn't bother me as a single; I'd play music, dance around and chill. But as a newlywed, I'd dread the barrage of criticism so would lie out on the lawn, gazing at the stars and steeling myself to go in and face the uproar. It was a horrid way to "live" and was a big factor in my decision to divorce.

OP, this will be unpopular advice on MN, but if you value your marriage, I'd suggest you call in outside help and give your DH a bit of chill time. Give him space in the day and, very importantly, get free time for yourself. BUT! Do not pay for it all yourself! You need to go halves if paying for childcare and housework.

Good luck with your move.

expat101 · 21/10/2022 04:38

Is it possible he actually hasn't got/or doesn't have the job anymore you think he was going for?

BuryingAcorns · 21/10/2022 06:57

Some people experience very high anxiety in a new job. It can stop you sleeping, make you want to get to work early to set up, make you leave later as you need to finish stuff that would take half the time when you know the ropes.

Have you sat down with him and asked how it is going? Does he feel he's settling in and getting the hang of it? And then ask about the extended hours.

PlainJaneSuperBrain99 · 21/10/2022 07:02

Well, I was thinking that he's struggling in his new job and being pushed in to working extra hours to fulfill his basic duties, but is too embarrassed to tell you because you've done that job and are clearly very highly competent. You say his job is easy - maybe he's not finding it so easy but your assertion that it is makes him feel ridiculous and unable to confess he's struggling to you?

But then you said about the changing clothes, and I thought "a-ha. Here is that terrible lying that op mentioned." His saying he changed in to swanky clothes to put boxes in to storage is so transparently a lie that I now think affair too.

Softplayhooray · 21/10/2022 07:12

Follow the money or find the woman, I think it's one or the other. I hope I'm wrong though OP and that it's something silly! Whatever it is, he's out of order for lying to you.

babyyodaxmas · 21/10/2022 07:14

I couldn't live with having to be through the door at a certain time, it's too much pressure. I couldn't live with waiting for my partner to walk in and counting off the minutes he's late so I could get my work done.

Thisis how it is for millions of working parents for years. I am actually completely baffled as to how your world works that it's not like this for you. Unless you are the sole breadwinner with a SAHP. My DCs are 16&18 and it is just easing off now, in that there are nights when no needs to be through the door at 4:30/5.

babyyodaxmas · 21/10/2022 07:15

To OP it does sound fishy unfortunately, the smart clothes tip the balance for me.

GreatLates · 21/10/2022 07:27

I asked about the clothes again in a why-would-you-risk-nice-clothes kind of way. He said it’s because the clothes he’s wearing are new and fit him the best and so were more comfortable…. My intention is to drop it until after the move (today’s the day!!) and see if it improves or changes at all.

OP posts:
EverydayIsPJday · 21/10/2022 07:31

@GreatLates get on with the move today but my advice is to your keep eyes and ears open. If you are asking lots of questions he will know you are suspicious and either try to cover up or start the gas lighting. Take note of anything wierd just in case it helps you down the line...really sorry OP I hope it's nothing.