Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be bloody pissed off that school are annoyed that my son can't breathe?

239 replies

Mrsweasleysclock · 17/10/2022 15:25

DS suffers from asthma. It has been a struggle to get it under control and this time of year always comes with a flare up. He has been breathless and coughing with chest tightness for a week now, hasn't been in school in this time. We've had to take him to the hospital twice, once by ambulance as he couldn't catch his breath for an hour so called 999. I have kept in touch with the school everyday giving them updates.

This morning I get a letter about his poor attendance and threatening further action if his attendance doesn't improve.

I am fuming. I understand they have attendance standards to keep but surely if you were concerned you could have had a chat with me any time when I was in dropping/collecting DD. Or even act like you care about his health rather than making it seem like I just haven't bloody bothered to bring him to school.

So mumsnet, talk me down because I feel like going to war over this with the school.

Yabu: the school have procedures to follow

Yanbu: they could have discussed his health/attendance informally first before going down the formal route of sending a letter threatening action.

OP posts:
Skodacool · 19/10/2022 08:02

girlmom21 · 17/10/2022 15:30

YABU. They're not annoyed at your sons health condition. They're communicating about his attendance. They're not the same thing.

WTAF kind of reasoning is that?!

NannaKaren · 19/10/2022 07:20

go to war on them - how dare they send the ‘automatic’ letter when your DS has a medical condition !!!!

Untitledsquatboulder · 18/10/2022 23:11

In what way is that a defence @Mynan ?

  1. Sending a letter to a child that you know is struggling with a serious health condition is not going to approve their attendance. So utterly pointless.
  1. The cost of someone checking letters is not comparable to the cost of either a new roof or a part time teacher. Divert 10 min a week of the time spent sending the letters. If you add up the cost of sending a letter to the wrong parent and dealing with the fallout, it's cheaper to check.
  1. See above.

Teachers are not leaving teaching because parents are challenging administrative errors.

ilovesushi · 18/10/2022 23:06

Montelukast was a game changer for my DS. We were told it would be 50/50 whether it worked for him. Took a few days to kick in, then massive massive improvement. Hope it works for your DS!

Mynan · 18/10/2022 22:40

I worked in schools for many years and I understand why people get upset by these letters getting sent out, but can I say a few things in schools’ defence?

  1. Schools have targets to meet for attendance. Low overall attendance figures are a flag which can cause issues for schools, not least of which is triggering an Ofsted Inspection. A low attendance figure can mean failing an Ofsted inspection and that can cause a while world of pain for the school, it’s staff and the children.
  2. School budgets are stripped to the bone. Once the daily running costs are deducted (fuel bills, council tax, the outrageous % the MAT take, what’s left has to pay for staff and resources. If you are choosing how to spend your last £20k in the budget (assuming you have £20k left, most schools are running deficits) and your choice is to hire an administrator to read and check letters, a new roof for the leaky science block or an additional part time teacher or TA in the classroom, which would you choose? You can only pick one and you need all of them.
  3. one of the biggest drains on leadership and admin time is dealing with parental complaints. That’s not to suggest parents shouldn’t complain if you feel it’s justified, but just bear this in mind if you are reacting in the heat of the moment.

finally, from a parent point of view, you are not going to end up in court or fined for a student absence if you have a justifiable reason for them being off. It’s OK to ignore letters from the school and don’t take it personally. Generally, school staff do care about their children and families, they just don’t have time or enough staff to run the way they should. It’s the most stressful thing to have to deal with day in and day out, knowing that you can only ever do a half arsed job even if you’re working 100+ hours a week. School staff and NHS staff are leaving because they are burnt out through caring about people and working too hard. Please think about that before going in all guns blazing because you got an automated letter.

Mynan · 18/10/2022 22:37

I worked in schools for many years and I understand why people get upset by these letters getting sent out, but can I say a few things in schools’ defence?

  1. Schools have targets to meet for attendance. Low overall attendance figures are a flag which can cause issues for schools, not least of which is triggering an Ofsted Inspection. A low attendance figure can mean failing an Ofsted inspection and that can cause a while world of pain for the school, it’s staff and the children.
  2. School budgets are stripped to the bone. Once the daily running costs are deducted (fuel bills, council tax, the outrageous % the MAT take, what’s left has to pay for staff and resources. If you are choosing how to spend your last £20k in the budget (assuming you have £20k left, most schools are running deficits) and your choice is to hire an administrator to read and check letters, a new roof for the leaky science block or an additional part time teacher or TA in the classroom, which would you choose? You can only pick one and you need all of them.
  3. one of the biggest drains on leadership and admin time is dealing with parental complaints. That’s not to suggest parents shouldn’t complain if you feel it’s justified, but just bear this in mind if you are reacting in the heat of the moment.

finally, from a parent point of view, you are not going to end up in court or fined for a student absence if you have a justifiable reason for them being off. It’s OK to ignore letters from the school and don’t take it personally. Generally, school staff do care about their children and families, they just don’t have time or enough staff to run the way they should. It’s the most stressful thing to have to deal with day in and day out, knowing that you can only ever do a half arsed job even if you’re working 100+ hours a week. School staff and NHS staff are leaving because they are burnt out through caring about people and working too hard. Please think about that before going in all guns blazing because you got an automated letter.

wordler · 18/10/2022 21:22

alltheevennumbers · 18/10/2022 17:18

DfE set the regulations (legislation) and the guidance, not schools or Local Authorities.

Do the Local Authorities have any leeway in how they implement the legislation -or is everyone across England and Wales getting exactly the same letter in exactly the same circumstances?

If the local authorities are composing their own letters then they should be the ones to lobby about it rather than the individual schools?

Ineedsleepandcoffee · 18/10/2022 21:05

There may be standard letters that schools are required to send out but they can still communicate in a sympathetic way alongside. When my daughter had letters for low attendance she also had a hand written note from her guidance teacher acknowledging her health concerns.

RockyReef · 18/10/2022 20:58

Solidarity here from a fellow asthma-mum! My son had a total of 3 days off for actual illness last school year, and then 6 days off for covid (3 when he actually had covid but wasn't ill despite having very severe asthma, and 3 while he waited for results of the then required PCR test after a family.member tested positive - son turned out to be negative). We had a letter about his attendance and I really lost my shit about it. He was only off because the law required him to be kept off school in 2/3rds of his absences. I think the whole system of school absences, the way they are poorly recorded, policed and either over or under enforced depending on where you live, is utterly ridiculous and not fit for purpose. You have my sympathies and yes to answer your question, I would be going to war over this with the LEA (it's unlikely the letter actually came from the school), but copy the school in to all emails / letters so they can see how it is affecting your family. It's discrimination against a child with an illness - can you imagine a workplace behaving so unreasonably?

gardenflowergirl · 18/10/2022 20:03

There are processes that schools have to go through for safeguarding and letters will go out one attendance falls to a specific percentage. This is to protect vulnerable children. If the education welfare officer come round to see you, don't worry, your child has legitimate reasons for the absence, but the ewo can enable you to get more support for your child, like home tuition when your child is too ill to go into school. It's a process and could be supportive for you. I used to work for a local authority supporting children out of school for medical reasons.

marktayloruk · 18/10/2022 20:00

YANBU. They are!

pollymere · 18/10/2022 19:41

Mine had an illness that required months off school. The school had to send us these letters but were really kind and apologetic when explaining they are duty bound at County level to send them, otherwise they get sanctioned and fined. It can also make a school lose its Ofsted status. Ignore them but do talk with the school about Care Plans in case an attack happens at school.

SarahJane796 · 18/10/2022 19:29

Schools have a duty to inform you of the attendance of your child. They also have a duty to enquire if the attendance is low due to safeguarding - obviously not the case here.
There is also the case of some parents don’t do what the OP is doing, but keep children off when they could go to school. Having the sniffles is not the same as severe asthma, of course, but unless medical notes are given then you can’t judge the severity of the situation.
Complaints often come from parents whose children are behind or do not achieve gcse grades due to absence. So parents have to be told how many lessons they’ve missed.
letters should be informative though not rude or accusatory.

Mollymoostoo · 18/10/2022 19:28

ZeroFuchsGiven · 17/10/2022 15:26

It will be an automatic letter once his attendance hit a certain %

This. However, the absences need to be verified. Can you take medical evidence to show what is happening? The EWO will also be checking absences and pressure from the local authority menas schools have to take a no tolerance approach. It is hard to not take it personally but for your own well being, don't.

LongLostTeacher · 18/10/2022 19:07

YANBU

This happened to me with my daughter. We were so worried about her and were aware that she off too much, but she was literally in hospital so of course she couldn’t also be at school.

I sent a reply that reiterated the situation (as it already been explained) and asked in a slightly pointed manner for any advice on managing DD’s condition to allow her to attend school.

It was made slightly worse because I worked at the same school, so the members of staff sending the letter, ie the head and admin staff, knew the situation and how worried we were. Yes, it was “automated,” but the the head apologised and said it should have been caught and not sent to me due to the situation with DD’s condition.

Lawandsawdus · 18/10/2022 18:51

the letters should be targeted and some should just have a permanent or temporary block flag (terminal illness or bereavement). I suspect cuts in councils as well as schools haven’t helped.

I do know some of why they are sent though. Years ago I worked in local government as an education solicitor including prosecuting parents for low attendance. it was seriously low attendance (about 50- 60%).
They would do truancy sweeps and find children with flu out shopping with parents. (We didn’t see the ones with depression where the illness is compatible or even may help with being outside.)

A large number would say they were aware it was bad/the consequences and that’s what you’d say the headteacher wrote 4letters then welfare team had a meeting.. a letter from solicitor. All the letters would ask about issues like bullying as parents would say for the first time in court their child was being bullied.

It did actually work sometimes, though not always.

Islandgirl68 · 18/10/2022 18:07

That I'd ridiculous your son is not well. Not much you can do about it. I hhink it is disgraceful to send letters like that when a child is genuinely ill. Health comes before their stats.

alltheevennumbers · 18/10/2022 17:18

DfE set the regulations (legislation) and the guidance, not schools or Local Authorities.

wordler · 18/10/2022 17:08

Do Local Authorities set their own policies and procedures individually? So you could have a different approach to this issue depending on where you live?

Is the national guidance just guidance or does it tell LAs exactly what they have to do?

ICrunchCrispsNotNumbers · 18/10/2022 16:39

@Mrsweasleysclock you're very welcome. I'm glad that the school are open to meeting with you.

I agree with you about potentially sending children to school under those circumstances. I think schools should consider the impact of this before sending these kinds of letters.

Mrsweasleysclock · 18/10/2022 16:35

ICrunchCrispsNotNumbers · 18/10/2022 16:28

@Mrsweasleysclock I'm so sorry. This is ridiculous. Your poor son has got enough to cope with. It's a bit different, but I've been though the same. I had really bad problems with my back when I was at college, and I received the same attendance letters as you described, despite keeping my tutor fully informed. It's so rude and unhelpful.

I'd just have a word with school about how these letters are impacting your son. I hope he feels better soon ❤️

Thank you. I did speak to school and I said I'm happy to have a meeting. They more or less said to ignore the letter.

I'm relieved, but it's such a horrible feeling to receive the letter in the first place. I feel bad for any parents that it would scare into sending very unwell children to school for fear of consequences.

OP posts:
ICrunchCrispsNotNumbers · 18/10/2022 16:28

@Mrsweasleysclock I'm so sorry. This is ridiculous. Your poor son has got enough to cope with. It's a bit different, but I've been though the same. I had really bad problems with my back when I was at college, and I received the same attendance letters as you described, despite keeping my tutor fully informed. It's so rude and unhelpful.

I'd just have a word with school about how these letters are impacting your son. I hope he feels better soon ❤️

Mrsweasleysclock · 18/10/2022 15:51

Schulte · 18/10/2022 13:40

Has he been given a course of oral steroids OP? The montelukast may take a few days to start working.

Yes he had a 5 day course of prednisolone. Finished with little to no relief.

OP posts:
Schulte · 18/10/2022 14:55

www.mumsnet.com/talk/childrens_health/4658023-asthma-support-thread

Does this link work? If not, it’s in childrens’ health.

containsnuts · 18/10/2022 13:58

Schulte · 18/10/2022 13:46

BTW I started an asthma parents’ support thread last year but it didn’t really take off… shall I try again? Somewhere for us to come and moan and share our worries and tips?

I'll follow!