Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it’s reasonable to return the Elgin Marbles to Athens?

359 replies

Digita · 02/09/2022 01:47

Learned I have to start a new thread rather than resurrect an existing one if I want to discuss this. Original zombie thread (learned new term!) FYI: www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/776736-to-think-it-outrageous-that-Britain-refuses-to-give-back

Old thread still relevant imo because 13 years later and the Elgin (Parthenon) marbles have still not been returned to Athens. Still a topic that reoccurs in the news cycle. Most recent article was within last month.

Athens asked for marbles back nicely and waited patiently. Even through Brexit negotiations, apparently.

I think it’s reasonable to return the Parthenon marbles. Athens have asked for them and also shown they are capable of taking care of their own heritage too. Doesn’t seem fair to require Athenians to get flights to London if they want to see the Parthenon marbles that were dedicated to their city’s patron deity.

Even if the claims that Elgin ‘bought’ them from the occupying Ottomans are true, it could be counter-argued that the marbles are priceless and shouldn’t have had a material value on them. In fact, who decided the price? Doesn’t sound like the Greeks had a say at the time…

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VickyEadieofThigh · 24/01/2024 22:18

KenAdams · 24/01/2024 22:08

Sorry to resurrect this thread but what are peoples thoughts on this? Do we think they might also "loan" the Elgin Marbles?

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/entertainment-arts-68066877

A loan has apparently been offered before. The Greeks have refused it, insisting that they will only accept permanent return of thr sculptures.

DonnaBanana · 24/01/2024 22:09

The Ottoman Empire was in charge at the time so yes let’s give them back. To Turkey.

Digita · 05/09/2022 08:57

darmaka · 05/09/2022 08:35

More the reason why stolen / taken artefacts should be returned to their owners / countries of origin. We are alone now after Brexit and ardently exactly loved by the world after invading every country but 22 in the world.
In future we would be better off making friends rather than enemies.

I see that. A diplomatic strategy for the future.

“We are alone now after Brexit and ardently exactly loved by the world after invading every country but 22 in the world. In future we would be better off making friends rather than enemies.”

I’m not sure everyone understands that vulnerability of being alone after Brexit- it seemed pp like @apintortwo didn’t or couldn’t grasp the bigger picture.

But I can see how if the empire felt they owned all but 22 countries in the world, it would also have been a harder mental leap to imagine how that could all be lost. And the Britain would one day be on its own.

If you want to see someone’s character give them power… see how they treat people then.

OP posts:
darmaka · 05/09/2022 08:35

More the reason why stolen / taken artefacts should be returned to their owners / countries of origin. We are alone now after Brexit and ardently exactly loved by the world after invading every country but 22 in the world.
In future we would be better off making friends rather than enemies.

Digita · 05/09/2022 08:26

darmaka · 05/09/2022 08:01

Where is your proof? - Majority were all stolen or taken during Colonial times. Do you come from such a country where you know for sure they were rescued? If they were rescued and taken without permission they should be given back to there owners.
Let's see if you can allow anyone into your garden to rescue something that you are supposedly not looking after . . . then keep it safe for them and only return it if YOU can be sure they will look after it. What a load of ...
Why do you think the UK has the authority to decide whether someone else's property will be safe if returned?

I see both sides.

Either way, upper hand is with the one who has the artefacts. However they were acquired.

Possession is nine tenths of the law.

Legal phrase meaning that ownership is easier to maintain if a person has possession of something and difficult to enforce if a person does not.

But it’s not the whole law.

Possession doesn’t mean lawful ownership, as in the case of the kohinoor.

Maybe the kohinoor was good to show off in Victorian times and the British Empire as a show of power in subjugating and humiliating an Indian Royal (from when he was a child separated from his mum through to his death - buried in England according to Christian rites but refused a bible quote on his gravestone, so arguably an improper burial too).

But times have moved on. Kohinoor is a clearer problem now than before because the possessor is also supposed to be the UK’s representative for the Law. Leading by example… a diamond on the crown with dubious legality and clear immortality. See the problem there now?

OP posts:
darmaka · 05/09/2022 08:01

MysteriesOfTheOrganism · 02/09/2022 06:31

Where artefacts have clearly been stolen then there's a good case for returning them - provided they will be safe and well cared for. When they have been bought - no. Many of the artefects in British (and other European) possession were rescued from desctruction from people who did not value "old junk" from ancient times. If you bought something at a boot sale that years later turned out to be valuable, what would you say if the original owner asked for it back? The narrative that it was ALL looting by colonial oppressors is simply not true.

Where is your proof? - Majority were all stolen or taken during Colonial times. Do you come from such a country where you know for sure they were rescued? If they were rescued and taken without permission they should be given back to there owners.
Let's see if you can allow anyone into your garden to rescue something that you are supposedly not looking after . . . then keep it safe for them and only return it if YOU can be sure they will look after it. What a load of ...
Why do you think the UK has the authority to decide whether someone else's property will be safe if returned?

Digita · 04/09/2022 11:38

@Saz12 ”Our taking of the kohinoor & ruling of the Punjab were hugely unethical. It shouldn’t have happened.”

Though the two are connected in strategy; that’s why it seems to have happened, even if it was unethical.

The kohinoor was a symbol of the punjab’s strength (from what I’ve read, it was a fabulously formidable kingdom; that’s why Britain wanted the Punjab and its riches). Holding the Punjab down and taking their kohinoor symbol became part of that power struggles for dominance over what had been a formidable kingdom. There was a real fear of an uprising because the punjabis had a reputation for being good fighters.

Fraser Harrison writes about how the pressure to subjugate and humiliate Duleep Singh (who was a child!) came from how successful his father was in creating a powerful modern empire in the kingdom.

Hugely unethical, but highly strategic. Where’s the balance?

OP posts:
Digita · 03/09/2022 15:12

BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 14:42

Anyway, for all you know the tradition of respecting Athena still continued alongside other heritages? Maybe that’s how she retain her city status namesake

To use your parlance, perhaps losing the marbles is the punishment for a city that desecrated the temple of their namesake, turning it into a Christian church and destroying all that they could easily reach and losing (honestly probably destroying) the statue of Athena. Why don’t you look at it that way 😆

That’s one angle. Glad you’re playing along now…

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 03/09/2022 15:06

But that doesn't mean that Celtic artefacts, sold during colonial rule, would be rightfully considered the property of anyone but the Irish.

TheKeatingFive · 03/09/2022 15:02

I don’t know why you insist on using Ireland as an example as they weren’t traditionally ruled from London by fellow Celts.

Not strictly true, Scots, Welsh and Anglo Irish were amply featured in the ruling classes.

BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 15:00

Connections to their ancient heritage and culture remain. Ireland as a country of Gaelic warlords has ceased to exist for centuries, it doesn't mean the Irish don't have rights to their Celtic past

I don’t know why you insist on using Ireland as an example as they weren’t traditionally ruled from London by fellow Celts.

TheKeatingFive · 03/09/2022 14:43

Athens as an independent city-state ceased under like, Alexander the Great.

So? Connections to their ancient heritage and culture remain. Ireland as a country of Gaelic warlords has ceased to exist for centuries, it doesn't mean the Irish don't have rights to their Celtic past.

and neither particularly appreciated their pagan heritage.

How are you in any position to speak for the hundreds of thousands of Greeks across time ? Regardless, it's their heritage, not the Brits.

BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 14:42

Anyway, for all you know the tradition of respecting Athena still continued alongside other heritages? Maybe that’s how she retain her city status namesake

To use your parlance, perhaps losing the marbles is the punishment for a city that desecrated the temple of their namesake, turning it into a Christian church and destroying all that they could easily reach and losing (honestly probably destroying) the statue of Athena. Why don’t you look at it that way 😆

BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 14:37

TheKeatingFive · 03/09/2022 14:18

who have been ruled from Constantinople/Istanbul since Roman/Byzantine times.

but not at the time of the construction of the Parthenon

So it’s not correct to say that the Sultan had no jurisdiction

Not over cultural history that predated his arrival - like the Irish example above

Athens as an independent city-state ceased under like, Alexander the Great. Come on. It is relevant that it was ruled by fellow Greeks from Constantinople (and later Istanbul). Christian Greeks and Muslim Turks are both inheritors of Byzantine culture, and neither particularly appreciated their pagan heritage.

Only a bunch of North Europeans cared about it at that time, for whatever reason.

Digita · 03/09/2022 14:34

BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 14:21

It’s so weird you are talking about a pagan heritage that the people of Athens had long abandoned.

Athens is still associated with the goddess Athena. Whether she had been abandoned by the people or not. Quite impressive given the number of occupations there were of the city and for how long too. The city name could have changed, but it seems like it didn’t. Athena held on.

Anyway, for all you know the tradition of respecting Athena still continued alongside other heritages? Maybe that’s how she retain her city status namesake.

My point is that she’s relevant to the Parthenon marbles because in terms of their origin story they were dedicated to her, Athena. Marbles Taken from city she’s associated with through both name and ancient history.

Wisdom is knowing you don’t know.

OP posts:
BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 14:21

It’s so weird you are talking about a pagan heritage that the people of Athens had long abandoned.

Digita · 03/09/2022 14:20

BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 14:01

She was turfed out of her own temple by Christian Greeks. They didn’t care about their pagan heritage, it was less than worthless to them. She has as much to do with the Parthenon as Jesus Christ does, tbh, as functioned as a Christian church for 1000 years

As I said. Goddesses generally have a harder time surviving the patriarchy than gods.

The city didn’t turf Athena out, she’s still the namesake. A woman god holding on to her own name is of more value. Athena survives through the city name - people ask where Athens comes from and her ancient historical story survives through that tradition.

Maybe adds more credence to the possibility that what Athena’s actually not happy about is how Parthenon marbles dedicated to her (a goddess) are now named after a mortal man called Lord Elgin.

Depends on the origins but I read a bit in the classics where there’s a power dynamic issue between goddesses and mortal men (it’s as though the mortal man dominates and that’s degrading for some goddesses). But gods with mortal women is different because the god dominates.
Hence why such a fuss was made over the arranged marriage between Thetis (a goddess/immortal) marrying a mortal man Peleus. It was a sensitive arranged marriage and degrading for Thetis to be subservient to a mortal man. Thetis wasn’t happy and that was part the reason extra effort was made to exclude Eris (goddess of discord). Organisers were trying to manage that wedding and keep the peace.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 03/09/2022 14:18

who have been ruled from Constantinople/Istanbul since Roman/Byzantine times.

but not at the time of the construction of the Parthenon

So it’s not correct to say that the Sultan had no jurisdiction

Not over cultural history that predated his arrival - like the Irish example above

BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 14:16

We're talking of the people of Athens

who have been ruled from Constantinople/Istanbul since Roman/Byzantine times. So it’s not correct to say that the Sultan had no jurisdiction

TheKeatingFive · 03/09/2022 14:10

I’m just saying it’s ridiculous to suggest he stole them from a military garrison.

of course it isn't, he was bribing people all over the place.

TheKeatingFive · 03/09/2022 14:10

You could not say this about the Greeks and Turks. The people in Istanbul are largely the same since Byzantine times.

We're talking of the people of Athens.

And you don’t have any more proof that the Elgin marbles were a theft any more than BM has proof that he paid for them. I don’t know, neither do you

We both know that they didn't start off in his possession so the burden of proof would be on proving the transaction

BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 14:07

TheKeatingFive · 03/09/2022 14:01

You don’t agree, that’s fine. But the Ottomans were in fact the successor state to the Byzantines, Athens was ruled from Istanbul/Constantinople since Byzantine times

Doesn't mean they have rights over Greek cultural artefacts, see my Irish/Celtic analogy above.

I doubt they’d let Elgin hack off the marbles without express permission, being a military fort and all.

He was never able to evidence this 'permission'

You may not accept the documentation, but it’s pretty outlandish to suggest someone like him could steal it from a military garrison.

In a war situation a few hundred years ago? Are you kidding? It is well documented he paid many bribes.

Celts and English do not appear to be ethnically the same people. You could not say this about the Greeks and Turks. The people in Istanbul are largely the same since Byzantine times. Just because they are now Muslim doesn’t mean they don’t inherit Byzantine heritage. They absolutely do.

And you don’t have any more proof that the Elgin marbles were a theft any more than BM has proof that he paid for them. I don’t know, neither do you.

I’m just saying it’s ridiculous to suggest he stole them from a military garrison.

BananaSpeel · 03/09/2022 14:01

Digita · 03/09/2022 13:52

@BananaSpeel ”Athena was turfed out long ago.”

And the city of Athens is named after… Athena.

Not turfed out.

She was turfed out of her own temple by Christian Greeks. They didn’t care about their pagan heritage, it was less than worthless to them. She has as much to do with the Parthenon as Jesus Christ does, tbh, as functioned as a Christian church for 1000 years

Digita · 03/09/2022 14:01

Digita · 03/09/2022 13:59

That doesn’t change the fact that the Parthenon marbles were dedicated to her, Athens. No one else. City that housed them retained her namesake. The Parthenon marbles were never dedicated to Elgin.

Goddesses have a harder time holding their place compared to gods and staying afloat in patriarchal history. Athena’s done well to hold on to Athens, as a clear indication of the historical stamp that’s her turf.

FAO @BananaSpeel

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread