Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Disability And Abortion: The Hardest Choice CHANNEL 4

363 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 07:50

www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-11155443/DOMINIC-LAWSON-Doctors-stop-pushing-mothers-aborting-disabled-babies.html

I’m planning on watching this in the next few days, but I’m getting increasingly concerned about the amount of anti-choice activity going on under the guise of ‘disability equality’.

OP posts:
Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:56

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 13:53

That is not what has been declared.

An allowance has been made to the timeframe for medical reasons, including disability, as these can take time to be detected and the woman needs to be given tike to weigh up her options.

For example, Jane is 20wks pregnant and due her anomaly scan which csn be done anywhere between 18wks and 22wks. She's having it at 21wks. The baby is not in a good position and won't budge for the scan to be complete so she is invited back at 22wks.

The 22wk scan detects a potential issue. Jane sees the doctor to discuss her options and opts for further testing. A week later she has the tests, she is now 23wks. Four days later, at 23+4 she gets the results and it is confirmed that her baby has the issue suspected at the anomaly scan.

If the cut off was 24wks for all pregnancies, Jane has just three days in which to seek a second opinion if she wants it, access counselling services, speak to support groups, obtain information on the condition and prognosis, speak with her partner/family/friends/support network, and make a decision.

Should Jane be rushed into that? Or should she be allowed time and space to come to terms with the news and make an informed decision?

If she chooses to watch and wait to see if the issue remains stable or worsens, should she not be allowed time to do so?

There are less than 280 abortions s year carried out post-24wks and every single one of them is for medical reasons, that flexible time limit is absolutely needed for them.

The timeframe should not just be for medical reasons then. It should be for social reasons, or mental health reasons or Know what, I just don’t want to be pregnant anymore reasons.

@Annieisalright that’s fine, it’s your pov. A woman’s choice every single time, even if I think society would be poorer for eradicating all difference.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 13:56

gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 13:51

You are fine with making abortion legal for autism, partial deafness or visual impairments? Jeez, that's some Brave New World scenario. To any disabled people or parents reading this - I love the world with difference in it. This is the society I want, not some world where it is acceptable to screen out anyone who doesn't fit some narrow band of 'acceptable.'

I am fine with women being given all possible information about the pregnancy they are carrying and making an informed decision about whether or not to continue that pregnancy, yes

pointythings · 29/08/2022 13:54

@gnilliwdog I am the parent of an autistic adult. Would I be happy for autism screening to happen prenatally? (It's not possible because there isn't a single gene, but hypothetically) Yes, absolutely. Would I have aborted for autism? No, but I would not deny another woman the choice to do so.

It's all about the woman's choice and what she feels she is able to cope with when raising a child.

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 13:53

Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:35

No, as I said before, whatever limits there are should be equal. My line is “ a woman’s right to choose” and that should be as early as possible / as late as necessary. For every woman and every foetus. Not different limits because society has decreed that the life of someone with Down Syndrome is worth less than the life of someone without Down Syndrome.

That is not what has been declared.

An allowance has been made to the timeframe for medical reasons, including disability, as these can take time to be detected and the woman needs to be given tike to weigh up her options.

For example, Jane is 20wks pregnant and due her anomaly scan which csn be done anywhere between 18wks and 22wks. She's having it at 21wks. The baby is not in a good position and won't budge for the scan to be complete so she is invited back at 22wks.

The 22wk scan detects a potential issue. Jane sees the doctor to discuss her options and opts for further testing. A week later she has the tests, she is now 23wks. Four days later, at 23+4 she gets the results and it is confirmed that her baby has the issue suspected at the anomaly scan.

If the cut off was 24wks for all pregnancies, Jane has just three days in which to seek a second opinion if she wants it, access counselling services, speak to support groups, obtain information on the condition and prognosis, speak with her partner/family/friends/support network, and make a decision.

Should Jane be rushed into that? Or should she be allowed time and space to come to terms with the news and make an informed decision?

If she chooses to watch and wait to see if the issue remains stable or worsens, should she not be allowed time to do so?

There are less than 280 abortions s year carried out post-24wks and every single one of them is for medical reasons, that flexible time limit is absolutely needed for them.

Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:53

I would let the voices of people with DS and those of their families be heard, for a start. Stop force teaming them with pro lifers and referring to them in derogatory ways, as on this thread.

No one tells a pregnant teenager their life will be horrendous and not worth living if they give birth. We should stop telling women with markers for DS that, too.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 13:53

Do you have a disabled child @gnilliwdog ?

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 13:51

FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 13:41

I'd be fine with that level of screening and for every woman to be able to make an informed choice about whether to continue their pregnancy as they do now with the conditions that we do screen for.

Woman should have the choice at every stage.

Should I get pregnant, yes or no? With free, easy, unrestricted access to contraception to prevent it if the answer is no.

I'm pregnant, do I want to be, yes or no? With free, easy, unrestricted access to abortion services if the answer is no and antenatal care if the answer is yes.

Do I want the 10wk booking in bloods, yes or no? With information provided on why the tests are carried out and what the potential consequences of declining could be.

Do I want a 12wk scan, yes or no? With information provided on the pros and cons of having the scan.

If I take the 12wk scan do I want them to check the nuchal fold, yes or no? As above.

Do I want to 16wk screening bloods, yes or no? Again with information provided as above.

Do I want a 20wk anamoly scan, yes or no? With information provided as above.

If I have the scan and it picks up an issue do I want further testing, yes or no? With access to the appropriate medical staff and information with pros and cons presented impartially.

If a problem is detected so I want to continue ue the pregnancy, yes or no? With access to all relevant information, support services, and so on whether the decision is yes or no.

Women should be free to make their choice at every stage of pregnancy and it is their own business. At all stages they should have unhindered access to the relevant services needed no matter which direction their choice takes them.

You are fine with making abortion legal for autism, partial deafness or visual impairments? Jeez, that's some Brave New World scenario. To any disabled people or parents reading this - I love the world with difference in it. This is the society I want, not some world where it is acceptable to screen out anyone who doesn't fit some narrow band of 'acceptable.'

Annieisalright · 29/08/2022 13:51

Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:25

Are people ok with testing being rolled out for deafness, visual impairment, autism, growth anomalies? Because if it’s ok to abort due to Down Syndrome then surely it’s ok to eradicate those conditions too? If not, why not?
Either every foetus has the right to be carried to term or none have that right, is where I’m coming from.
I’m uneasy about the hijacking of the Don’t Screen Us Out campaign by pro lifers, but equally uneasy about the prevalent attitude that DS is something every woman would like to eradicate from society. That as soon as that test result comes through, you’d need to get on the abortion track asap.

Of course

I'd actively terminate in most if not all of those cases you listed

Why actively bring a child into this world where they will suffer to varying degrees based on something they're born with?

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 13:49

Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:48

It’s the woman’s right to choose in every single circumstance.

My concern is the disproportionate testing and subsequent pressure put on women to abort for Down Syndrome.

So what would you do about that, if anything?

OP posts:
Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:48

It’s the woman’s right to choose in every single circumstance.

My concern is the disproportionate testing and subsequent pressure put on women to abort for Down Syndrome.

LangClegsInSpace · 29/08/2022 13:47

Either every foetus has the right to be carried to term or none have that right.

No foetus has the right. Human rights begin at birth.

Crowter and friends tried this argument - that the current time limits are direct discrimination against disabled foetuses. This only works if foetuses have legal personhood and human rights. The judge ruled that they did not and Crowter et al were not given leave to appeal on this point.

I’m uneasy about the hijacking of the Don’t Screen Us Out campaign by pro lifers

It wasn't hijacked, it was started by pro lifers.

StaunchMomma · 29/08/2022 13:44

Honestly, I think you should watch it before commenting, really.

It didn't come across as anti-abortion at all, it was just a person with Downs and a person with spina bifida questioning what pregnant women are told about their conditions (as in, is it sometimes exaggerated) and why abortion is allowed up to term for all disabilities.

It didn't come across as judgemental at all. They sat down with women who had chosen to abort babies, some with their conditions, and were very supportive and empathetic to what they'd been through.

Give it a watch.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 13:42

Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:35

No, as I said before, whatever limits there are should be equal. My line is “ a woman’s right to choose” and that should be as early as possible / as late as necessary. For every woman and every foetus. Not different limits because society has decreed that the life of someone with Down Syndrome is worth less than the life of someone without Down Syndrome.

But abortion per se is judging which lives should be brought into the world and which shouldn’t. Whether that’s because the mum is a teenager, because she’s broke, because the dad is violent… should a fetus be discriminated against because its mum is a teenager? Why is that any better than terminating because the fetus is disabled?

OP posts:
FarmerRefuted · 29/08/2022 13:41

Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:25

Are people ok with testing being rolled out for deafness, visual impairment, autism, growth anomalies? Because if it’s ok to abort due to Down Syndrome then surely it’s ok to eradicate those conditions too? If not, why not?
Either every foetus has the right to be carried to term or none have that right, is where I’m coming from.
I’m uneasy about the hijacking of the Don’t Screen Us Out campaign by pro lifers, but equally uneasy about the prevalent attitude that DS is something every woman would like to eradicate from society. That as soon as that test result comes through, you’d need to get on the abortion track asap.

I'd be fine with that level of screening and for every woman to be able to make an informed choice about whether to continue their pregnancy as they do now with the conditions that we do screen for.

Woman should have the choice at every stage.

Should I get pregnant, yes or no? With free, easy, unrestricted access to contraception to prevent it if the answer is no.

I'm pregnant, do I want to be, yes or no? With free, easy, unrestricted access to abortion services if the answer is no and antenatal care if the answer is yes.

Do I want the 10wk booking in bloods, yes or no? With information provided on why the tests are carried out and what the potential consequences of declining could be.

Do I want a 12wk scan, yes or no? With information provided on the pros and cons of having the scan.

If I take the 12wk scan do I want them to check the nuchal fold, yes or no? As above.

Do I want to 16wk screening bloods, yes or no? Again with information provided as above.

Do I want a 20wk anamoly scan, yes or no? With information provided as above.

If I have the scan and it picks up an issue do I want further testing, yes or no? With access to the appropriate medical staff and information with pros and cons presented impartially.

If a problem is detected so I want to continue ue the pregnancy, yes or no? With access to all relevant information, support services, and so on whether the decision is yes or no.

Women should be free to make their choice at every stage of pregnancy and it is their own business. At all stages they should have unhindered access to the relevant services needed no matter which direction their choice takes them.

Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:35

No, as I said before, whatever limits there are should be equal. My line is “ a woman’s right to choose” and that should be as early as possible / as late as necessary. For every woman and every foetus. Not different limits because society has decreed that the life of someone with Down Syndrome is worth less than the life of someone without Down Syndrome.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 13:28

@Saucery but if either all of them do or none of them do, then you’re in favour of banning abortion completely?

OP posts:
Saucery · 29/08/2022 13:25

Are people ok with testing being rolled out for deafness, visual impairment, autism, growth anomalies? Because if it’s ok to abort due to Down Syndrome then surely it’s ok to eradicate those conditions too? If not, why not?
Either every foetus has the right to be carried to term or none have that right, is where I’m coming from.
I’m uneasy about the hijacking of the Don’t Screen Us Out campaign by pro lifers, but equally uneasy about the prevalent attitude that DS is something every woman would like to eradicate from society. That as soon as that test result comes through, you’d need to get on the abortion track asap.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 13:20

@LangClegsInSpace Dominic Lawson is in favour of scrapping prenatal testing altogether (how dare he) and has written numerous articles to this effect.

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 13:18

@Fivemoreminutesinbed she doesn’t seem to have a grasp of the facts at all, she never engages with the points in favour of this law and instead just reverts back to ‘but it’s unfair’.

Her son is very small and she seems to have thrown herself into the world of disability campaigning without much experience behind her of caring for a disabled child. At this age I expect it’s a very different ball game to having a teen/young adult.

OP posts:
LangClegsInSpace · 29/08/2022 13:17

YANBU.

The people behind the court case, trying to get the abortion time limit for disabilities reduced to 24 weeks, are the same people behind the 'Don't Screen Us Out' campaign, which attempted to prevent the roll-out of early trisomy testing on the NHS. And yes, they are linked with right wing evangelical anti-choice campaigns.

They are also behind the championing of the weirdly empty new Down Syndome Act and the resurrection of the long dormant APPG on Down's Syndrome. This is chaired by Lisa Cameron SNP MP who is very very friendly with SPUC. The group is also attended by Lord Shinkwin and Lord Alton, both of whom have in the past introduced private members bills trying to lower abortion time limits.

Thread about the links:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/4539125-more-institutional-capture-pro-lifers-this-time

Long thread about the current court case:

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/feminism/4289660-Late-term-abortion-high-court

I believe the appeal decision is due some time in October. They won't win but it may well prompt a new private members bill on abortion time limits.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 29/08/2022 13:15

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 13:14

Is that Maire? I’ve heard her being interviewed a few times, I take huge issue with a lot of what she says. She repeats the same phrases over and over, such as ‘my son isn’t valued the same as my healthy child’ when he is Hmm there are no rights her healthy son has that her son with DS doesn’t. She also talks a lot about ‘not knowing how to explain this to my son when he’s older’. Given her son won’t ever be needing a termination, and most NT adults don’t know about this law, it’s highly unlikely he will know anything about it unless she tells him.

I’ve also heard her asserting that her son is ‘happy and very healthy’ a few times. Which is disingenuous - yes he’s lovely and seemingly happy, but he’s got numerous ongoing health problems which she blogs about.

Yes it was.

Wouldloveanother · 29/08/2022 13:14

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 29/08/2022 13:04

I did dislike the mum who was given a choice to terminate the pregnancy of her DS boy but wants to deny that to others. Sorry. Nope.

Is that Maire? I’ve heard her being interviewed a few times, I take huge issue with a lot of what she says. She repeats the same phrases over and over, such as ‘my son isn’t valued the same as my healthy child’ when he is Hmm there are no rights her healthy son has that her son with DS doesn’t. She also talks a lot about ‘not knowing how to explain this to my son when he’s older’. Given her son won’t ever be needing a termination, and most NT adults don’t know about this law, it’s highly unlikely he will know anything about it unless she tells him.

I’ve also heard her asserting that her son is ‘happy and very healthy’ a few times. Which is disingenuous - yes he’s lovely and seemingly happy, but he’s got numerous ongoing health problems which she blogs about.

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 29/08/2022 13:09

'i’m not sure why anyone else’s levels of comfort, or indeed discomfort, should have an impact on any pregnancy other than their own. Your dislike of late termination doesn’t mean that it shouldn’t be an option for other women.'

I think people feel there should be limits to when it is morally acceptable and not everyone sees a late term foetus as a non-person. It's often said that women wouldn't abort for no reason at late term anyway, but as someone has already said, we don't make laws based on predictions of what people may or may not do. We outline what is morally acceptable to us as a society.

Fivemoreminutesinbed · 29/08/2022 13:04

I did dislike the mum who was given a choice to terminate the pregnancy of her DS boy but wants to deny that to others. Sorry. Nope.

whumpthereitis · 29/08/2022 13:02

NFLBingo · 29/08/2022 12:19

Also, whilst I understand the sentiment some have of allowing a termination up to birth, who do they think will be willing to remove a full-term pregnancy?
Many surgeons will not go above 18 weeks with termination companies and charities, which I can understand personally and current limits make me somewhat squeamish, but taking a fully formed and regular sized baby out for “any reason”, nah that’s crazy. Pretty much nobody is going to want to do that just because a pregnant person has decided it’s not longer for them.

Doctors, presumably. Much like the ones that do it now.